Hans Urs von Balthasar
Hans Urs von Balthasar
|Ordination||26 July 1939
by Michael von Faulhaber
12 August 1905|
|Died||26 June 1988
Hans Urs von Balthasar (12 August 1905 – 26 June 1988) was a Swiss theologian and Catholic priest who was to be created a cardinal of the Catholic Church but died before the ceremony. He is considered one of the most important Roman Catholic theologians of the 20th century.
Balthasar was born in Lucerne, Switzerland on 12 August 1905, to a wealthy family. He was educated first by Benedictine monks at the abbey school at Engelberg in central Switzerland. Before finishing his secondary education, however, Balthasar was moved by his parents to the Stella Matutina College run by the Society of Jesus in Feldkirch, Austria. In 1923 he enrolled in the university of Zurich. His studies in philosophy and German literature led him to study subsequently in Vienna and Berlin and culminated in his doctoral work on German literature and idealism.
In 1929, having submitted his thesis, he entered the Society of Jesus, better known as the Jesuits (in Germany, since the Jesuits were banned in Switzerland until 1973). For three years he studied philosophy at Pullach, near Munich, and came into contact with Erich Przywara, whose work on analogia entis (the analogy of being) was very influential on him. In 1932, he moved to Fourvières, the Jesuit school at Lyon, for his four years of theological study. Here he encountered Jean Daniélou, Gaston Fessard, and Henri de Lubac. Daniélou and de Lubac were both to become notorious from the 1940s onwards as members of the nouvelle théologie, a set of thinkers raising deep questions about the neoscholastic doctrine of grace and nature, with its suggestion that human nature could be conceived of in isolation from its relation to the vision of God. Both Daniélou and de Lubac, as part of their re-assessment of neoscholastic thought, were increasingly turning to studies of patristic thinkers. Balthasar received from his time here an enduring love of the church fathers, which was later to lead to his studies of Origen of Alexandria, (1938), Maximus the Confessor, Kosmische Liturgie (1941), and Gregory of Nyssa, Présence et pensée, (1942).
Having finished his seven years of training, Balthasar was ordained a priest in 1936. He then worked briefly in Munich, on the Jesuit journal Stimmen der Zeit. In 1940, with the Nazi regime encroaching on the freedom of Catholic journalists, he left Germany and began work in Basel as a student chaplain.
While he Basel he met Adrienne von Speyr. She was a twice-married Protestant medical doctor in chronically poor health, who through her mystical experiences would have a huge impact on Balthasar's later thought. In 1940 he received her into the Church. In 1945, they founded a religious society, the Community of Saint John (Johannesgemeinschaft), for men and women. This became more widely known three years later when Balthasar produced a theology for secular institutes in his work Der Laie und der Ordenstand, the first book to be published by the Johannes Verlag, a publishing house established  with the help of a friend.
Because the Jesuits did not see running the institute as compatible with belonging to the society, von Balthasar had to choose between remaining a Jesuit and his involvement with the institute. In 1950 he left the Society of Jesus, feeling that God had called him to continue his work with this secular institute, a form of consecrated life that sought to work for the sanctification of the world. He accordingly remained without a role in the Church until in 1956 he was incardinated into the Diocese of Chur as a secular priest.
Balthasar was not invited to take part in any capacity in the Second Vatican Council. In later years, though, his reputation as a theologian grew. In 1969, Pope Paul VI appointed him to the International Theological Commission.
From the low point of being banned from teaching as a result of this move, his reputation eventually rose to the extent that Pope John Paul II named him to be a cardinal in 1988. He died, however, in his home in Basel on 26 June 1988, two days before the ceremony which would have granted him that position. His remains were interred in the Hofkirche cemetery in Lucerne.
Along with Karl Rahner and Bernard Lonergan, Balthasar sought to offer an intellectual, faithful response to Western modernism, which has brought the world to no longer being well-disposed towards Christianity. While Rahner offered a progressive, accommodating position on modernity and Lonergan worked out a philosophy of history that sought to critically appropriate modernity, Balthasar resisted the reductionism and human focus of modernity, wanting Christianity to challenge modern sensibilities.
He was interested in some religious renewal movements that flourished in the middle of the 20th century, such as Opus Dei, on which he wrote in disapproving terms.
Balthasar is very eclectic in his approach, sources, and interests and remains difficult to categorize. An example of his eclecticism was his long study and conversation with the influential Reformed Swiss theologian, Karl Barth, of whose work he wrote the first Catholic analysis and response. Although Balthasar's major points of analysis on Karl Barth's work have been disputed, his The Theology of Karl Barth: Exposition and Interpretation (1951) remains a classic work for its sensitivity and insight; Karl Barth himself agreed with its analysis of his own theological enterprise, calling it the best book on his own theology.
Writings and thought
Balthasar's first major work, the three volume Apokalypse der deutschen Seele (1937–39) (Apocalypse of the German Soul) was an expansion of his dissertation and a study in German literature, theology and philosophy. Published in Germany and Austria during the Third Reich, some have argued that the work contains anti-Semitism.
In Balthasar's book Mysterium Paschale he explored the meaning of Holy Saturday, where Jesus Christ dies and descends to the dead, to be resurrected by God the Father and His own power. Balthasar extrapolates from it the idea that God can endure and conquer godlessness, abandonment, and death.
Balthasar was well known for his 16-volume systematics (Trilogy), published from 1961-1985, which is divided into three parts: The Glory of the Lord, the first 7-volume work on 'theological aesthetics' (a theology based upon contemplation of the good, the beautiful, and the true). One of the often quoted passages from the entire Trilogy comes from the First Volume (Seeing the Form) of The Glory of the Lord:
Before the beautiful—no, not really before but within the beautiful—the whole person quivers. He not only 'finds' the beautiful moving; rather, he experiences himself as being moved and possessed by it.
In Theo-Drama: Theological Dramatic Theory—the following 5-volume work on 'theodramatics'—the action of God and the human response, especially in the events of Good Friday, Holy Saturday, and Easter Sunday are examined. Balthasar's soteriology, christology, and eschatology, are here developed. The final group of volumes are titled: Theo-Logic. These three volumes describing the relation of the nature of Jesus Christ (christology) to reality itself (ontology, or the study of being). He completes the third part of his trilogy with a brief Epilogue.
A distinctive thought in Balthasar's work is that our first experience after birth is the face of love of our mothers, where the I encounters for the first time the Thou, and the Thou smiles in a relationship of love and sustenance.
Balthasar also wrote of the lives of saints and Church fathers. Saints appear as an example of the lived Christian life throughout his writings. Instead of merely systematic analysis of theology, Balthasar described his theology as a "kneeling theology" deeply connected to contemplative prayer and as a "sitting theology" intensely connected to faith seeking understanding guided by the heart and mind of the Catholic Church.
Balthasar was very concerned that his writings address spiritual and practical issues. He insisted that his theology never be divorced from the mystical experiences of his long-time friend and convert, the physician Adrienne von Speyr.
Balthasar published varied works spanning many decades, fields of study (e.g., literature and literary analysis, lives of the saints, and the Church Fathers), and languages. His most controversial theological assertions were that Christ deposited his divine knowledge with the Father before the incarnation (kenotic doctrine), the possibility that all people may be saved, that Christ literally was "made sin", and the idea that Christ experienced in Sheol after his death on the cross a state of abandonment from the Father worse than hell.
At Balthasar's funeral, then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, later to become Pope Benedict XVI, said, speaking of Balthasar's work in general, "What the pope intended to express by this mark of distinction [i.e., elevation to the cardinalate], and of honor, remains valid, no longer only private individuals but the Church itself, in its official responsibility, tells us that he is right in what he teaches of the faith."
Balthasar expressed some sympathy with a "hope" for salvation for non-Christians, and even believes that it is possible that all human beings will be saved (but warns against asserting it). Universal salvation, if it happens, would be the result of Christ's "utter abandonment".
Support for Medjugorje
Along with the French theologian René Laurentin, Balthasar was one of the most influential supporters of the reported Marian apparitions in Medjugorje, Bosnia-Herzegovina, which are currently being studied by an international Vatican Commission. In an interview with the Jesuit author Fr. Robert Faricy, Balthasar stated: "Medjugorje's theology rings true. I am convinced of its truth. And everything about Medjugorje is authentic in a Catholic sense. What is happening there is so evident, so convincing." Balthasar was highly critical of Bishop Pavao Zanic's opposition to the apparitions and visionaries of Medjugorje, linking the former bishop of Mostar's actions to the atheist government of Yugoslavia. In a personal letter in 1985, Balthasar wrote discouragingly of steps that Zanic was taking against Medjugorje: "Priests removed, the children forbidden to come to the church, the ban on preaching etc., etc. Zanic is out to destroy (annihiler) the whole thing. He gives the impression of one working with the atheistic government. People should be informed about all this...The work of the commission set up by Zanic is scandalous."
Shortly before Balthasar's death, Zanic's commission was dissolved and the jurisdiction over Medjugorje was taken away from him (by request of the Bishop himself) by Joseph Ratzinger then the Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, who was a longtime friend and former student of Balthasar. In Germany, Balthasar personally met with one of the Medjugorje visionaries, Marija Pavlovic.
Balthasar's major writings have been translated into English, and the journal he co-founded with Henri de Lubac, Walter Kasper, and Joseph Ratzinger, Communio, currently appears in twelve languages. In delivering his eulogy, Ratzinger, quoting de Lubac, called Balthasar, "perhaps the most cultured man of our time," a tribute to Balthasar's immense erudition.
Bibliography: The most comprehensive bibliography (174 pages, including translations up to 1990) now available of all of von Balthasar's writings is Hans Urs von Balthasar: Bibliographie 1925-1990, ed. Cornelia Capol, (Einsiedeln: Johannes Verlag, 1990)
- Between Friends: The Hans Urs von Balthasar and Gustav Siewerth Correspondence (1954-1963): A Bilingual Edition, ed. and trans. Andrzej Wierciński (Germany, Konstanz: Verlag Gustav Siewerth Gesellschaft, 2005).
- Bernanos: an Ecclesial Existence, tr. Eramso Leiv`a-Merikakis (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1996). [originally Bernanos, (Köln: Hegner, 1954)]
- The Christian and Anxiety
- Christian Meditation (San Francisco, 1989)
- The Christian State of Life, tr. Sr Mary Frances McCarthy (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1983) [first published 1977].
- Cosmic Liturgy: the Universe According to Maximus the Confessor, tr. Brian E. Daley, SJ (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 2003).
- Credo: Meditations on the Apostles' Creed
- Dare We Hope ‘That All May Be Saved’? With a Short Discourse on Hell, tr. David Kipp and Lothar Krauth (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1988)
- Does Jesus Know Us?
- Engagement with God
- First Glance at Adrienne von Speyr, tr. Antje Lawry and Sr Sergia Englund, OCD (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1981). [originally Erster Blick auf Adrienne von Speyr, (Einsiedeln: Johannes, 1968)]
- The God Question and Modern Man, tr. Hilda Graef, introduction by John Macquarrie, (New York: Seabury Press, 1967) [original title: Die Gottesfrage des heutigen Menschen, 1956]
- The Grain of Wheat: Aphorisms
- Heart of the World, tr. Erasmo S. Leiv`a (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1979). [original Das Herz der Welt, (Zürich: Arche, 1945)]
- In the Fullness of Faith: On the Centrality of the Distinctively Catholic
- The Laity in the Life of the Counsels: The Church's Mission in the World
- Light of the Word: Brief Reflections on the Sunday Readings
- Love Alone: the Way of Revelation, tr. not named (New York: Herder & Herder, 1969).
- Mary for Today, tr. Robert Nowell (Slough: St Paul Publications, 1987).
- Mary, The Church at the Source (with Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger)
- The Moment of Christian Witness, tr. R. Beckley (New York, 1968; San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1994) [first published 1966]
- My Work in Retrospect, tr. not named (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1992).
- Mysterium Paschale, tr. Aidan Nichols, OP (Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1990; second corrected edition, Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 1993). [first published 1970)
- The Office of Peter and the Structure of the Church, tr. Andree Emery (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1986).
- Origen: Spirit and Fire, An Anthology of His Writings, edited by Hans Urs von Balthasar, tr. Robert J. Daly, SJ (Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press, 1984)
- Our Task: a Report and a Plan, tr. John Saward (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1994)
- Paul Struggles with His Congregation: The Pastoral Message of the Letters to the Corinthians
- Prayer, trans AV Littledale, (New York: Paulist Press, 1967)
- Presence and Thought: an Essay on the Religious Philosophy of Gregory of Nyssa, tr. Mark Sebanc (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1988).
- Principles of Christian Morality
- Razing the Bastions: On the Church in this Age
- Romano Guardini: Reform From the Source
- The Scandal of the Incarnation: Irenaeus Against the Heresies
- A Short Primer for Unsettled Laymen, tr. Sr Mary Theresilde Skerry, HSAS (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1985).
- Test Everything: Hold Fast to What Is Good
- A Theological Anthropology, tr. not named (New York: Sheed & Ward, 1967).
- The Theology of Henri De Lubac
- A Theology of History, tr. not named (New York: Sheed & Ward, 1963). [first published 1959]
- The Theology of Karl Barth: Exposition and Interpretation, tr. Edward T. Oakes, SJ, (New York, 1971; San Francisco, 1992) [originally Karl Barth. Darstellung und Deutung seiner Theologie, (Köln: Hegner, 1951)]
- The Threefold Garland
- To the Heart of the Mystery of Redemption
- Tragedy Under Grace: Reinhold Schneider on the Experience of the West
- Truth is Symphonic: Aspects of Christian Pluralism, tr. Graham Harrison (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1987)
- Two Sisters in the Spirit: Th´er`ese of Lisieux and Elizabeth of the Trinity, tr. Donald Nichols, Anne Elizabeth Englund, and Dennis Martin (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1992).
- Unless You Become Like This Child
- You Crown the Year With Your Goodness: Sermons Throughout the Liturgical Year
- You Have Words of Eternal Life: Scripture Meditations
- ‘The Fathers, the Scholastics and Ourselves’, Communio: International Catholic Review 24 (1997): 347–96, translation of ‘Patristik, Scholastik und Wir’, Theologie der Zeit (= Beiheft zu Seelsorge) 3 (1939): 65–104.
Collections of articles
- Elucidations, tr. John Riches (London: SPCK, 1975, reprint San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1998). [first published 1971]
- New Elucidations, tr. Sr Mary Theresilde Skerry, HSAS (San Francisco: IgnatiusPress, 1986).
Explorations in Theology
• Explorations in Theology: Word Made Flesh, vol 1 • Explorations in Theology: Spouse of the Word, vol 2 • Explorations in Theology: Creator Spirit, vol 3 • Explorations in Theology: Spirit and Institution, vol 4
The Glory of the Lord: A Theological Aesthetics, 7 vols, (Edinburgh, 1982–91; first published 1961–9).
• Volume I: Seeing the Form • Volume II: Clerical Styles • Volume III: Lay Styles • Volume IV: The Realm of Metaphysics in Antiquity • Volume V: The Realm of Metaphysics in the Modern Age • Volume VI: Theology: The Old Covenant • Volume VII: Theology: The New Covenant
• Volume I: The Truth of the World • Volume II: Truth of God • Volume III: The Spirit of the Truth
Theo-Drama, 5 vols. (San Francisco, 1988–98; first published 1973–83).
• Volume I: Prolegomena • Volume II: Dramatis Personae • Volume III: Dramatis Personae • Volume IV: The Action • Volume V: The Last Act
- Oakes (2004) pp.269ff
- The doctorate was entitled History of the Eschatological Problem in German Literature. It appeared, considerably rewritten, as Apokalypse der deutschen Seele, 3 vols, (Salzburg, 1937-9)
- While, as stated above, Jesuits were banned from running schools or parishes, student chaplaincy did not fall under the ban on Jesuits. This was because the anti-clerical laws of the 1840s which had banned the Jesuits had not envisaged this type of institution.F Kerr, Twentieth Century Catholic Theologians: From Neoscholasticism to Nuptial Mystery, (Malden, MA; Oxford: Blackwell, 2007), p122
- Aidan Nichols, The word has been abroad: a guide through Balthasar's aesthetics, Introduction to Hans Urs von Balthasar 1, (1998), p.xviii
- Leaving the Society meant that Balthasar was without a position, a pastorate, a place to live, or an income. Because he had left the Jesuit order, the Catholic Congregation for Seminaries and Universities had banned him from teaching. But he eventually found an ecclesiastical home under a sympathetic bishop and was able to live by a grueling schedule of lecture tours. "Hans Urs von Balthasar (1905-1988)" Radical Faith The Society of the Sacred Mission, accessed 1 February 2009
- On 29 May 1988 Pope John Paul II announced his intention to nominate von Balthasar as cardinal at the next consistory, held 28 June 1988; see Salvador Miranda, "Consistories for the creation of Cardinals: 20th Century (1903-2005)," accessed 9 May 2013. One is not a cardinal until the Pope formally announces the new cardinal in a consistory with the existing members of the college of cardinals; see Code of Canon Law (1983), canon 351.
- Oakes (2004) pp.262, 133
- Oakes (2004) p.2
- Colón-Emeric, Edgardo Antonio (31 May 2005). "Symphonic Truth: Von Balthasar and Christian Humanism". The Christian Century 122 (11): 30–. Retrieved 2 February 2009.[dead link]
- Paul Silas Peterson, "Anti-Modernism and Anti-Semitism in Hans Urs von Balthasar's Apokalypse der deutschen Seele", in Die neue Zeitschrift für systematische Theologie und Religionsphilosophie 52:3 (2010), 302-318.
- Oakes (2004) p.270
- Oakes (2004) p.236
- Oakes (2004) p.265
- Dietlind Langner, Marco A. Sorace, Peter Zimmerling (2008) Gottesfreundschaft: christliche Mystik im Zeitgespräch p.259 quotation:
Hans Urs von Balthasar selbst hat die Begegnung mit Adrienne von Speyr und ihrer „experimentellen Dogmatik"6 als das Movens seiner Theologie bezeichnet: „Das meiste, was ich schrieb, ist eine Übersetzung dessen, was auf unmittelbarere, weniger technische' Weise in dem gewaltigen Werk Adriennes von Speyr niedergelegt wurde.
- Hans Urs von Balthasar, ed. (1988). "Was dürfen wir hoffen; and, Kleiner Diskurs über die Hölle." (Dare We Hope That All Men Be Saved?). Ignatius Press. ISBN 0-89870-207-0.[page needed]
- Casta Meretrix: The Church as Harlot
- Allen, John L. Jr. (November 28, 2003). "The Word From Rome". National Catholic Reporter 3 (15).
- Oakes (2004) p.261 quotation: "Balthasar does not deny the possibility of salvation outside the boundaries of explicit Christianity - in fact he is probably more emphatic than Rahner in maintaining the legitimacy of Christian hope for universal salvation."
- Morwenna Ludlow Universal salvation: eschatology in the thought of Gregory of Nyssa p5 2000 - 304 页 "Von Balthasar hopes for universal salvation and warns against asserting it outright (e.g. Mysterium Paschale, 177–8, 262–6; Dare We Hope . . ., 148–57, 236–54)
- Alyssa Lyra Pitstick Light in darkness: Hans Urs von Balthasar and the Catholic 2007 p264 "Balthasar's theology of Christ's descent toward a doctrine of universal salvation,whether certain or as a hope. As Balthasar sees it, universal salvation (if actual) will be the result of the utter abandonment the Son undergoes."
- Klimek "Von Balthasar: Medjugorje 'a theater of holiness'"
- Michael O'Carroll "Medjugorje: Facts, Documents, Theology" 1989 p55
- Michael O'Carroll "Medjugorje: Facts, Documents, Theology" 1989 p56
- Wayne Weible "Medjugorje: The Message" 1991 p277
- Denis Nolan "Medjugorje and the Church" 2007 4th edition p50
- The influence is reflected in some of Schwager's titles, i.e.: Jesus in the Drama of Salvation. Toward a Biblical Doctrine of Redemption (German: Jesus im Heilsdrama. Entwurf einer biblischen Erlösungslehre), New York: Crossroad 1999, and: Banished from Eden: Original Sin and Evolutionary Theory in the Drama of Salvation (Duits: Erbsünde und Heilsdrama: Im Kontext von Evolution, Gentechnik und Apokalyptik), Londen: Gracewing 2006.
- Volumes 4 and 5 of The Glory of the Lord span all of Western philosophy, literature, and theology. Balthasar translated many authors, from Peguy to Ignatius of Loyla and Augustine to Calderon de la Barca and Claudel's "Satin Slipper". He was an incredible musician, with a particular affinity for Mozart.
- Edward T. Oakes, SJ, and David Moss, ed. (2004). The Cambridge Companion to Hans Urs von Balthasar. Cambridge University Press. pp. 2, 236, 261–2, 265, 269, 270ff. ISBN 0-521-89147-7.
- Peter Henrici, SJ, "Hans Urs von Balthasar: a Sketch of His Life", Communio: International Catholic Review 16/3 (fall, 1989): 306–50
- Rodney Howsare, Balthasar: a guide for the perplexed, (2009)
- Karen Kilby, Balthasar: A (Very) Critical Introduction, (2012)
- Aidan Nichols, The word has been abroad: a guide through Balthasar's aesthetics, Introduction to Hans Urs von Balthasar 1, (1998)
- Aidan Nichols, No bloodless myth: a guide through Balthasar's dramatics, Introduction to Hans Urs von Balthasar, (2000)
- Aidan Nichols, Say it is Pentecost: a guide through Balthasar's logic, Introduction to Hans Urs von Balthasar (2001)
- Aidan Nichols, Scattering the seed: a guide through Balthasar's early writings on philosophy and the arts", Introduction to Hans Urs von Balthasar, (2006)
- Aidan Nichols, Divine fruitfulness: a guide through Balthasar's theology beyond the trilogy, Introduction to Hans Urs von Balthasar, (2007)
- John O’Donnell, Hans Urs von Balthasar, Outstanding Christian Thinkers, (2000)
- Ben Quash, "Hans Urs von Balthasar", in David F. Ford, The Modern Theologians, (3rd edn, 2005)
- Lucy Gardner et al., Balthasar at the end of modernity, (1999)
- Mark A McIntosh, Christology from within: spirituality and the incarnation in Hans Urs von Balthasar, Studies in spirituality and theology; 3, (2000)
- Aidan Nichols, A key to Balthasar: Hans Urs von Balthasar on beauty, goodness and truth, (2011)
- J. Riches, ed, The Analogy of Beauty: The theology of Hans Urs von Balthasar (Edinburgh, 1986)
- Publications by and about Hans Urs von Balthasar in the catalogue Helveticat of the Swiss National Library
- IgnatiusInsight.com Hans Urs von Balthasar Author's Page: bio, books published by Ignatius Press, excerpts, and articles about von Balthasar
- Hans Urs von Balthasar profile and books on Goodreads
- Hans Urs von Balthasar - Internet Archive
- Works by or about Hans Urs von Balthasar in libraries (WorldCat catalog)
- The Casa Balthasar in Rome, Italy
- Quotations from Hans Urs von Balthasar
- Hans Urs von Balthasar Stiftung
- The Lubac-Balthasar-Speyr Association
- Johannes Verlag (publishing house founded by Hans Urs von Balthasar)
- The Inflated Reputation of Hans Urs von Balthasar, by Regis Scanlon O.F.M. Cap.
- Karen Kilby on Balthasar 1 on YouTubeand 2 on YouTube
- "Balthasar's Method of Divine Naming," Nova et Vetera 1 (2003): 245-68, available online, article by Bernhard Blankenhorn, O.P.