Hell Is the Absence of God
|"Hell Is the Absence of God"|
|Published in||Starlight #3|
|Publication date||July 2001|
"Hell Is the Absence of God" is a 2001 fantasy novelette by American writer Ted Chiang, first published in Starlight #3, and subsequently reprinted in Year's Best Fantasy 2, and in Fantasy: The Best of 2001, as well as in Chiang's 2002 anthology, Stories of Your Life and Others.
"Hell Is" won the 2002 Hugo Award for Best Novelette, the Nebula Award for Best Novelette, and the Locus Award for Best Novelette. It was also a finalist for the 2002 Theodore Sturgeon Award. The novelette has also been translated into Japanese, Italian, Spanish, French, German and Romanian.
This theological novelette is set in a world where the existence of God, souls, Heaven, and Hell are obvious and indisputable, and where miracles and angelic visitations are commonplace—albeit not necessarily benevolent. The story focuses primarily on Neil Fisk, a widower whose wife, Sarah, is killed by the collateral damage of an angel's visitation. Sarah's soul was seen ascending to Heaven, leading the non-devout Neil to desperately find the love and devotion needed to please God and enter Heaven to reunite with Sarah.
The story also follows Janice Reilly, a woman born without legs who is made able-bodied in an angelic visitation. Janice, a motivational and spiritual speaker, is met with a lukewarm response during a meeting after her visitation when she suggests that her gift is a test of her devotion to God rather than a blessing. This greatly angers Neil, who was present.
The reader is then introduced to Ethan Mead, who cannot discern the meaning of an angelic encounter he experienced. This begins to take a toll on his marriage, but Ethan desperately seeks help with his predicament. He eventually meets Janice, who has decided to organize a pilgrimage to one of the few holy sites on Earth where visitations are frequent. Wanting to return her blessing, her story makes the news, convincing Neil that the only way to enter Heaven is by witnessing Heaven's light.
In the past, many people who have witnessed Heaven's light, which appears when an angel enters and exits the mortal world, ascend to Heaven no matter the amount or severity of their sins. Sure enough, an angel appears and flies over the holy site. The many pilgrims present desperately attempt to witness Heaven's light by following the angel. Neil is following in a truck but crashes and is left mortally wounded. Janice and Ethan attempt to help him, but as the angel leaves Earth, Heaven's light strikes Neil and Janice.
Both are left blind and Neil dies. Much to Ethan's shock, he witnesses Neil's soul descend to Hell. Janice goes on a speaking tour where she describes her experience and the beauty of Heaven. Ethan becomes a minister after deciding that the purpose of his first visitation was to lead him to meet Neil and reveal to the world that exposure to Heaven's light does not guarantee entrance into Heaven.
In Hell, Neil, having finally gained the love and devotion to God that he desperately sought, accepts that he will never reunite with Sarah and will spend eternity in the absence of God.
Commenting on "Hell Is the Absence of God" in the "Story Notes" section of Stories of Your Life and Others, Chiang said that after seeing the film The Prophecy, he wanted to write a story about angels, but could not think of a scenario that would work. It was only when he started imagining angels as being "phenomena of terrifying power, whose visitations resembled natural disasters" that he was able to proceed. Chiang wrote that the Book of Job also contributed to ideas for his story, as it raised the question: why did God restore Job to prosperity when the Book's lesson was that "virtue isn't always rewarded"?
In interviews Chiang has explicitly stated that "Hell Is the Absence of God" is "straight fantasy", because it takes place in a universe "in which the scientific method doesn't work". He said it is about "innocent suffering", and the way people devoted to God deal with it. He also said that the novelette examines the role of faith in religion, and suggests that if God undeniably existed, then faith would no longer be applicable.
Robert J. Sawyer and David G. Hartwell described "Hell Is the Absence of God" as the "best single SF story of 2002". Conversely, John C. Wright called it "trite antichristian propaganda". Elf Sternberg has compared the novelette to C. S. Lewis's The Great Divorce, saying that although Lewis is a supporter of God, Chiang is "far more ambivalent".
In a review of Chiang's Stories of Your Life and Others in The Guardian, English fantasy author China Miéville called "Hell Is the Absence of God" the showpiece of Chiang's collection. He wrote that despite the story's religious underpinnings, there is no "moralistic Sturm und Drang", and Chiang "does not descend to the finger-wagging one might expect from a liberal intellectual".
|Nebula Award for Best Novelette||2002||Won|||
|Locus Award for Best Novelette||2002||Won|||
|Hugo Award for Best Novelette||2002||Won|||
|Theodore Sturgeon Award||2002||Finalist|||
|July 2001||Starlight 3||Patrick Nielsen Hayden||English||Anthology|
|June 2002||Fantasy: The Best of 2001||Robert Silverberg, Karen Haber||English||Anthology|
|July 2002||Stories of Your Life and Others||Ted Chiang||English||Collection|
|July 2002||Year's Best Fantasy 2||David G. Hartwell, Kathryn Cramer||English||Anthology|
|April 2003||I premi Hugo 2002||Gianfranco Viviani||Italian||Anthology|
|March 2004||Nebula Awards Showcase 2004||Vonda N. McIntyre||English||Anthology|
|July 2004||The Locus Awards: Thirty Years of the Best in Science Fiction and Fantasy||Charles N. Brown, Jonathan Strahan||English||Anthology|
|April 2006||La tour de Babylone||Ted Chiang||French||Collection|
|June 2006||Feeling Very Strange: The Slipstream Anthology||James Patrick Kelly, John Kessel||English||Anthology|
|February 2008||Sci-Fi Magazin||Ted Chiang||Romanian||Magazine|
|December 2011||Die Hölle ist die Abwesenheit Gottes||Ted Chiang||German||Collection|
|2011||Împărțirea la zero||Ted Chiang||Romanian||Collection|
- "Hell Is the Absence of God". Internet Speculative Fiction Database. Retrieved December 29, 2018.
- Împărțirea la zero, Nemira, 2011
- Chiang 2015a, p. 189.
- Chiang 2015b, p. 225.
- Ted Chiang interviewed at Infinity Plus
- Locus, July 2011, Issue 606 (vol. 67, no.1), "Scientific Method: Interview with Ted Chiang"
- Anders, Lou (July 2002). "A Conversation With Ted Chiang". SF Site. Retrieved May 25, 2017.
- Grant, Gavin J. "Ted Chiang: Interviewed by Gavin J. Grant". IndieBound. Archived from the original on April 7, 2017. Retrieved May 25, 2017.
- Robert J. Sawyer, FictionWise Recommender at Fictionwise (via archive.org)
- John C. Wright's review of Stories of Your Life and Others; by John C. Wright; originally published at Amazon.com, February 13, 2003; archived at SciFiWright.com, November 16, 2009; retrieved September 1, 2015
- Oh, what the harsh light of reason hath wrought Archived 2008-05-17 at the Wayback Machine: Elf Sternberg's Livejournal for January 11, 2006
- Miéville, China (April 24, 2004). "Stories of Your Life". The Guardian. Retrieved May 25, 2017.
- 2004 Awards (in Japanese)
- "2003 Nebula Awards". The Locus Index to SF Awards. Locus. Archived from the original on February 17, 2004.
- "News Log, July 2002". Locus Online. Locus.
- "2002 Hugo Awards". World Science Fiction Society. Archived from the original on 2011-05-07.
- Honors for Starlight 3 stories at Patrick Nielsen Hayden's official site
- Sci-Fi Magazin nr.5, cititorsf.ro
- Chiang, Ted (2015a) . "Hell Is the Absence of God". Stories of Your Life and Others (e-book ed.). Picador. p. 164. ISBN 978-1-4472-8198-6.
- Chiang, Ted (2015b) . "Story Notes". Stories of Your Life and Others (e-book ed.). Picador. p. 223. ISBN 978-1-4472-8198-6.