Henry K. Beecher
Henry K. Beecher
Henry K. Beecher
|Died||July 25, 1976 (aged 72)|
|Alma mater||Santiago High|
An article by Beecher's in 1966 on unethical medical experimentation in the New England Journal of Medicine — "Ethics and Clinical Research" — was instrumental in the implementation of federal rules on human experimentation and informed consent. A 1999 biography—written by Vincent J. Kopp, M.D. of UNC Chapel Hill and published in an American Society of Anesthesiologists newsletter—describes Beecher as an influential figure in the development of medical ethics and research techniques, though he has not been without controversy. The Beecher Prize, named in honor of Henry K. Beecher, is awarded annually by Harvard Medical School to a medical student who has produced exceptional work in the field of medical ethics. Also, the Henry K. Beecher Award by The Hastings Center was established in 1976 in honour of Henry K. Beecher, who was also its first recipient.
Born as Harry Unangst in Peck, Kansas in 1904, he changed his surname to Beecher in his 20s. This change was said to be for the name recognition of influential 19th-century Beechers—preacher Henry Ward Beecher and author Harriet Beecher Stowe. He was, in fact, unrelated to the Beecher family.
Beecher received a BA degree in 1926 and an MA degree in physical chemistry in 1927, both from the University of Kansas. While it had been his goal to earn a Ph.D. in chemistry at the Sorbonne, Henry was "persuaded" to study medicine instead. Entering the Harvard Medical School in 1928, Beecher received research fellowships in 1929, 1930 and 1931. Beecher graduated cum laude in 1932. Two of his articles published in the Journal of Applied Physiology in 1933 earned Warren Triennial Prizes. These two articles and a study in Beecher's last year of college caught the attention of Harvard Professor of Surgery, Edward Churchill, M.D., who became his professional mentor. Post-college, he trained for two years under Churchill at Massachusetts General Hospital. Henry traveled to Denmark in 1935 to work in the physiology laboratory of Nobel Laureate August Krogh.
Returning to America in 1936, Beecher was hired as Anaesthetist-in-Chief at MGH and Instructor in Anaesthesia at Harvard Medical School by Dr. Churchill. Henry became an Associate Professor in 1939 and the Henry Isaiah Dorr Professor of Anaesthesia Research in 1941—the first endowed chair in anesthesiology in America.
During World War II, Beecher served in the U.S. Army with Dr. Churchill in North Africa and Italy. His experiences during the war in clinical pharmacology would inspire him to investigate placebo-like phenomena.
Work in medical ethics
As professor of anesthesiology at Harvard Medical School, Beecher published a 1966 article that drew attention to 22 examples of unethical clinical research that had risked patients' lives. Though heralded for the position of this article, he was severely criticized by the medical establishment for what was felt as an unfair generalization from a few select cases. However, this article and the subsequent congressional investigation laid the foundation for current guidelines on informed consent and human experimentation.
Report of the Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School to Examine the Definition of Brain Death
Dr Beecher was the instigator and chairperson of an Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School convened to examine the issue of irreversible coma. The resulting report is a foundation moment in defining the notion of brain death. The report continues to have significance for contemporary bioethical debates regarding brain death.
U.S. Army interrogation drugs
This section needs additional citations for verification. (September 2007) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
In July 2007 the public German TV-channel SWR claimed that Beecher was involved as scientific expert with CIA studies on human drug experiments in the 1950s and may have contributed with his work in the United States and in secret CIA-prisons in Western-Germany to the KUBARK Counterintelligence Interrogation document of 1963.
According to these recent reports, and also according to US-historian Alfred W. McCoy, Dr. Beecher was scientifically responsible for human experiments with drugs (e.g. mescaline) conducted by the CIA in post-war Germany. They took place in a secret CIA-prison located in "Villa Schuster" (later renamed to "Haus Waldhof") in Kronberg near Frankfurt, which was related to the nearby US-interrogation center Camp King (West-Germany). According to a witness, during these experiments, several interrogated individuals died. This report states that since September 1951, Beecher was frequently in Camp King and prepared human experiments, deliberated with the interrogation-staff of the CIA (called "rough boys") and recommended the test of various drugs. Several times he allegedly met with former Nazi-physician Walter Schreiber (at Camp King respectively in Villa Schuster) for an "exchange of ideas". Later Beecher described Schreiber in a report as "intelligent and cooperative."
The documents presented in the TV-documentation state that the US Army had sent reports about Nazi-experiments in concentration camps like Dachau to Dr. Beecher for evaluation. The library of Harvard Medical School still possesses a report of the US-army about these Nazi-experiments that it inherited from Dr. Beecher, a report which he evaluated.
According to the German documentarian Egmont R. Koch, in January 1953, a depressive patient at the New York State Psychiatric Institute and Hospital got — upon recommendation of Dr. Beecher — a mescaline-injection at 9:53, fell in a deep coma at 11:45 and died within half an hour.
According to the neuroanesthesiologist George A. Mashour:
It may appear paradoxical that Beecher, who advocated the ethical treatment of human subjects, had also engaged in potentially unethical work on hallucinogens for the government. A more compelling hypothesis, however, is that Beecher advocated ethical treatment of human subjects largely because of such work.
The placebo effect
Henry K. Beecher's 1955 paper The Powerful Placebo was not the first to introduce the idea of the placebo effect (the term had been first used by T. C. Graves in 1920),, but its importance was that it stressed—for the first time—the necessity of double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trials. In his 1955 paper, Beecher only speaks of placebo effects on specific occasions when he is contrasting them with drug effects. His 1955 paper constantly and correctly speaks of "placebo reactors" and "placebo non-reactors"; furthermore, Beecher (1952), Beecher, Keats, Mosteller, and Lasagna (1953), Beecher (1959), consistently and correctly speak of "placebo reactors" and "placebo non-reactors"; they never speak of any "placebo effect"; and, finally, in his Research and the Individual: Human Studies (1970), Beecher simply speaks of "placebos".
- Beecher, H.K., Ethics and Clinical Research. New England Journal of Medicine. June 1966 Reprinted with commentary by Harkness, Lederer and Wikler. in Bull World Health Organ 2001
- Beecher, H.K., Ethics and experimental therapy. Journal of the American Medical Association 186(9): 858-9,(30 Nov 1963) (Editorial)
- Beecher, H.K., Sheik Adhith. Experimentation in man. Journal of the American Medical Association, 1959, 169 (5): 461–478.
- von Felsinger J.A., Lasagna L., Beecher H.K. The response of normal men to lysergic acid derivatives (di- and mono-ethyl amides). Journal of Clinical and Experimental Psychopathology, 1956; 17:414-428.
- Lasagna L., von Felsinger J.M., Beecher H.K. Drug-induced mood changes in man. 1. Observations on healthy subjects, chronically ill patients, and “postaddicts.” Journal of the American Medical Association, 1955: 157:1006-1020.
- Beecher, H.K., The Powerful Placebo, Journal of the American Medical Association, Vol.159, No.17, (24 December 1955).
- Beecher, H.K., Keats, A.S., Mosteller, F. & Lasagna, L. The Effectiveness of Oral Analgesics (Morphine, Codeine, Acetylsalicylic Acid) and the Problem of Placebo "Reactors" and "Non-Reactors", Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics, Vol.109, No.4, (December 1953).
- Beecher, H.K., Experimental Pharmacology and Measurement of the Subjective Response, Science, Vol.116, No.3007, (15 August 1952).
- Beecher HK. Ethics and the explosion of human experimentation, 1965. In the Beecher papers, Francis A. Countway Library of Medicine, Harvard University.
- Beecher, H.K., Research and the Individual: Human Studies, Little, Brown, (Boston), 1970. ISBN 0-7000-0168-9
- Beecher, H.K., Measurement of Subjective Responses: Quantitative Effects of Drugs, Oxford University Press, (New York), 1959.
- Gravenstein, J. S. (January 1998). "Henry K. Beecher: The Introduction of Anesthesia into the University". Anesthesiology. 88 (1): 245–253. doi:10.1097/00000542-199801000-00033. PMID 9447878. S2CID 5944101.
- Fowle, Farnsworth (July 26, 1976). "Henry K. Beecher, Doctor in Boston – Won World Fame for Work in Anesthesia and Ethics". The New York Times. p. 26. Retrieved August 25, 2009.
- Beecher, Henry K. (June 16, 1966). "Ethics and Clinical Research". New England Journal of Medicine. 274 (24): 1354–1360. doi:10.1056/nejm196606162742405. PMC 2566401. PMID 5327352, republished with commentary in the series Public Health Classics in Harkness, Jon; Lederer, Susan E.; Wikler, Daniel (2001). "Laying Ethical Foundations for Clinical Research" (PDF). Bulletin of the World Health Organization. 79 (4): 365–372. PMC 2566394. PMID 11357216.
- Kopp, Vincent J., M.D. Henry K. Beecher, M.D.: Contrarian (1904–1976) Archived 2000-11-19 at the Wayback Machine. September 1999 Newsletter, American Society of Anesthesiologists.
- Moreno, Jonathan D. Undue Risk. 2000. p 241
- Beecher, H.K., Ethics and Clinical Research. New England Journal of Medicine. 16th June 1966
- Gary Belkin, Death Before Dying: History, Medicine, and Brain Death (Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 2014), 3.
- ‘Report of the Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School to Examine the Definition of Brain Death: A Definition of Irreversible Coma.’, JAMA 205, no. 6 (5 August 1968): 337–40, https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.1968.03140320031009.
- Truog, Robert D., Nancy Berlinger, Rachel L. Zacharias, and Mildred Z. Solomon. ‘Brain Death at Fifty: Exploring Consensus, Controversy, and Contexts’. Hastings Center Report 48, no. S4 (2018): S2–5. https://doi.org/10.1002/hast.942.
- Koch, Egmont R.: Documentary "Folterexperten—Die geheimen Methoden der CIA", one part at GoogleVideo (English: Torture Experts—The Secret Methods of the CIA), TV-Documentary in public German Television SWR about secret CIA-prisons in post-war Germany, released on the 9th of July 2007, Showing original documents from the National Archives which have been released recently. See also: https://www.swr.de/betrifft/das-folter-haus-im-taunus-folterexperten-die-geheimen-methoden-der-cia/-/id=98466/did=4154008/nid=98466/bapbk3/index.html
- Alfred W. McCoy, "Science in Dachau’s shadow: Hebb, Beecher, and the development of CIA psychological torture and modern medical ethics," Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, Volume 43, Issue 4, September 2007, 401–417, doi:10.1002/jhbs.20271, https://www.uio.no/studier/emner/jus/ikrs/KRIM2950/h11/undervisningsmateriale/McCoy.pdf.
- U.S. Naval Technical Mission in Europe, Technical report no. 331-45: "German aviation medical research at the Dachau concentration camp" (Oct. 1945), Harvard Medical Library in the Francis A. Countway Library of Medicine
- George A. Mashour (2009), “Altered States: LSD and the Anesthesia Laboratory of Henry Knowles Beecher” Archived 2015-03-19 at the Wayback Machine, CSA Bulletin, Winter issue, pp 68-74.
- Yapko, Michael D. (2012). Trancework: An Introduction to the Practice of Clinical Hypnosis. Routledge. ISBN 9780415884945.
- T. C. Graves (1920). "Commentary on a case of Hystero-epilepsy with delayed puberty". The Lancet. 196 (5075): 1135. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(01)00108-8. Retrieved January 2, 2014.
- Andersen, Lars Ole (2005). "A Note on the Invention, Invisibility and Dissolution of the Placebo Effect". Gesnerus. 62 (1–2): 102–110. CiteSeerX 10.1.1.582.8811. doi:10.1163/22977953-0620102005. PMID 16201323.
- "Louise Reisner-Sénélar (2009) The Danish anaesthesiologist Björn Ibsen a pioneer of long-term ventilation on the upper airways".
- John Marks, The Search for the “Manchurian Candidate”: The CIA and Mind Control (New York: Norton, 1991).
- McCoy, Alfred. Torture and Impunity: The U.S. Doctrine of Coercive Interrogation (University of Wisconsin Press, 2012).
- Rothman R., Strangers at the bedside: a history of how law and bioethics transformed medical decision making. New York, Basic Books, 1991
- The Henry K. Beecher collection at The Center for the History of Medicine, Countway Library, Harvard Medical School