This article possibly contains original research. (September 2017)
Homoeroticism is sexual attraction between members of the same sex, either male–male or female–female. The concept differs from the concept of homosexuality: it refers specifically to the desire itself, which can be temporary, whereas "homosexuality" implies a more permanent state of identity or sexual orientation. It is a much older concept than the 19th-century idea of homosexuality, and is depicted or manifested throughout the history of the visual arts and literature. It can also be found in performative forms; from theatre to the theatricality of uniformed movements (e.g., the Wandervogel and Gemeinschaft der Eigenen). According to the Oxford English Dictionary, it is "pertaining to or characterized by a tendency for erotic emotions to be centered on a person of the same sex; or pertaining to a homo-erotic person."
This is a relatively recent dichotomy that has been studied in the earliest times of ancient poetry to modern drama by modern scholars. Thus, scholars have analyzed the historical context in many homoerotic representations such as classical mythology, Renaissance literature, paintings and vase-paintings of ancient Greece and Ancient Roman pottery.
Though homoeroticism can differ from the interpersonal homoerotic — as a set of artistic and performative traditions, in which such feelings can be embodied in culture and thus expressed into the wider society — some authors have cited the influence of personal experiences in ancient authors such as Catullus, Tibullus and Propertius in their homoerotic poetry.
Arguments over classifications and labeling
The term "homoerotic" carries with it the weight of modern classifications of love and desire that may not have existed in previous eras. Homosexuality as known today was not fully codified until the mid-20th century, though this process began much earlier:
Following in the tradition of Michel Foucault, scholars such as Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick and David Halperin have argued that various Victorian public discourses, notably the psychiatric and the legal, fostered a designation or invention of the "homosexual" as a distinct category of individuals, a category solidified by the publications of sexologists such as Richard von Krafft-Ebing (1840–1902) and Havelock Ellis (1859–1939), sexologists who provided an almost-pathological interpretation of the phenomenon in rather Essentialist terms, an interpretation that led, before 1910, to hundreds of articles on the subject in The Netherlands, Germany, and elsewhere. One result of this burgeoning discourse was that the "homosexual" was often portrayed as a corrupter of the innocent, with a predisposition towards both depravity and paederasty—a necessary portrayal if Late-Victorian and Edwardian sexologists were to account for the continuing existence of the "paederast" in a world that had suddenly become bountiful in "homosexuals." (Kaylor, Secreted Desires, p. 33)
Despite an ever-changing and evolving set of modern classifications, members of the same sex often formed intimate associations (many of which were erotic as well as emotional) on their own terms, most notably in the "romantic friendships" documented in the letters and papers of 18th- and 19th-century men and women (see Rictor Norton, ed., My Dear Boy: Gay Love Letters through the Centuries, Gay Sunshine Press, 1998). These romantic friendships, which may or may not have included genital sex, were characterized by passionate emotional attachments and what modern thinkers would consider homoerotic overtones.
For Sigmund Freud, "rather than being a matter only for a minority of men who identify as homosexual or gay, homoeroticism is a part of the very formation of all men as human subjects and social actors." Freud's point of view is embedded in his psychoanalytic studies on Narcissism and Oedipus complex.
Notable examples in the visual arts
Male-male examples, in the visual fine arts, range through history: Ancient Greek vase art; Roman wine goblets (The Warren Cup). Several Italian Renaissance artists are thought to have been homosexual, and homoerotic appreciation of the male body has been identified by critics in works by Leonardo da Vinci and Michelangelo. More explicit sexual imagery occurring in the Mannerist and Tenebrist styles of the 16th and 17th centuries, especially in artists such as Agnolo Bronzino, Michel Sweerts, Carlo Saraceni and Caravaggio, whose works were sometimes severely criticized by the Catholic Church.
Many 19th century history paintings of classical characters such as Hyacinth, Ganymede and Narcissus can also be interpreted as homoerotic; the work of 19th-century artists (such as Frédéric Bazille, Hippolyte Flandrin, Théodore Géricault, Thomas Eakins, Eugène Jansson, Henry Scott Tuke, Aubrey Beardsley and Magnus Enckell); through to the modern work of fine artists such as Paul Cadmus and Gilbert & George. Fine art photographers such as Karl Hammer, Wilhelm von Gloeden, David Hockney, Will McBride, Robert Mapplethorpe, Pierre et Gilles, Bernard Faucon, Anthony Goicolea have also made a strong contribution, Mapplethorpe and McBride being notably in breaking down barriers of gallery censorship and braving legal challenges. James Bidgood and Arthur Tress were also important pioneers in the 1960s, radically moving homoerotic photography away from simple documentary and into areas that were more akin to fine art surrealism.
In Asia, male eroticism also has its roots in traditional Japanese shunga (erotic art), this tradition influenced contemporary Japanese artists, such as Tamotsu Yatō (photography artist), Sadao Hasegawa (painter) and Gengoroh Tagame (manga artist).
Female-female examples are most historically noticeable in the narrative arts: the lyrics of Sappho; The Songs of Bilitis; novels such as those of Christa Winsloe, Colette, Radclyffe Hall, and Jane Rule, and films such as Mädchen in Uniform. More recently, lesbian homoeroticism has flowered in photography and the writing of authors such as Patrick Califia and Jeanette Winterson.
Female homoerotic art by lesbian artists has often been less culturally prominent than the presentation of lesbian eroticism by non-lesbians and for a primarily non-lesbian audience. In the West, this can be seen as long ago as the 1872 novel Carmilla, and is also seen in cinema in such popular films as Emmanuelle, The Hunger, Showgirls, and most of all in pornography. In the East, especially Japan, lesbianism is the subject of the manga subgenre yuri.
In many texts in the English-speaking world, lesbians have been presented as intensely sexual but also predatory and dangerous (the characters are often vampires) and the primacy of heterosexuality is usually re-asserted at the story's end. This shows the difference between homoeroticism as a product of the wider culture and homosexual art produced by gay men and women.
Notable examples in writing
There is also a strong tradition of homoeroticism in poetry.
The most prominent example in the Western canon is that of the sonnets by William Shakespeare. Though some critics have made assertions, some in efforts to preserve Shakespeare's literary credibility, to its being non-erotic in nature, no critic has disputed that the majority of Shakespeare's sonnets concern explicitly male-male love poetry. The only other Renaissance artist writing in English to do this was the poet Richard Barnfield, who in The Affectionate Shepherd and Cynthia wrote fairly explicitly homoerotic poetry. Barnfield's poems, furthermore, are now widely accepted as a major influence upon Shakespeare's.
Elisar von Kupffer's Lieblingminne und Freundesliebe in der Weltlitteratur (1900) and Edward Carpenter's Ioläus: An Anthology of Friendship (1902) were the first known notable attempts at homoerotic anthologies since The Greek Anthology. Since then, many anthologies have been published.
In the female-female tradition, there are poets such as Sappho, "Michael Field", and Maureen Duffy. Emily Dickinson addressed a number of poems and letters with homoerotic overtones to her sister-in-law Susan Huntington Gilbert.
Letters can also be potent conveyors of homoerotic feelings; the letters between Virginia Woolf and Vita Sackville-West, two well-known members of the Bloomsbury Group, are full of homoerotic overtones characterized by this excerpt from Vita's letter to Virginia: "I am reduced to a thing that wants Virginia [...] It is incredible to me how essential you have become [...] I shan't make you love me any the more by giving myself away like this --But oh my dear, I can't be clever and stand-offish with you: I love you too much for that." (January 21, 1926)
Although the idea is spread by some Christian circles that non-heteronormative orientation is a "sin," some theologians, sexologists and historians have concluded that the very founder of Christianity, Jesus of Nazareth, had a non-heteronormative behavioral pattern. Some theological historians claim that Jesus had a homoerotic behavior, including some apostles such as John the Apostle, Simon Peter, etc.
Some speculate that cousin that Jesus, John the Baptist's had a homosocial or homoerotic behavior. In the Gospel of John (3: 22–36), John the Baptist speaks of himself as the “friend of the bridegroom,” implying that the bridegroom of Christ (Matthew 9:15) is coming to meet his bride, though nothing specific to identify the bride. Jesus was a rabbi, a teacher, and all the rabbis at that time were married; there is no reference to a possible marriage.
Some theologians and scholars claim that the biblical character Lazarus also had non-heterosexual behavior and other figures such as Jacob, David and Jonathan and other canonized saints such as Francis of Assisi, Saint Sebastian, etc.
Most notable are positive portrayals of homoerotic feelings in relationships, made at feature length and for theatrical exhibition, and made by those who are same-sex oriented. Successful examples would be: Mädchen in Uniform, Germany (1931); The Leather Boys, UK (1964); Scorpio Rising, U.S. (1964); Death in Venice, Italy (1971); The Naked Civil Servant, UK (1975); Sebastiane, UK (1976); Outrageous!, Canada (1977); My Beautiful Laundrette, UK (1985); Maurice, UK (1987); Summer Vacation 1999, Japan, (1988); Mulholland Drive, U.S. (2001); Brokeback Mountain, U.S. (2005); Black Swan, U.S. (2010); Carol, UK/U.S. (2015) and most recently Moonlight U.S. (2016), and Call Me by Your Name, U.S./Italy (2017). Also of note is the 1999 feature-length BBC adaptation of Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit.
Key introductory books
Classical and medieval literature:
- Murray & Roscoe. Islamic Homosexualities: Culture, History, and Literature (1997)
- J. W. Wright. Homoeroticism in Classical Arabic Literature (1997)
- Rictor Norton. The Homosexual Literary Tradition (1974) (Greek, Roman & Elizabethan England)
Literature after 1850:
- David Leavitt. Pages Passed from Hand to Hand : The Hidden Tradition of Homosexual Literature in English from 1748 to 1914 (1998)
- Timothy d'Arch Smith. Love In Earnest; some notes on the lives and writings of English 'Uranian' poets from 1889 to 1930 (1970)
- Michael Matthew Kaylor, Secreted Desires: The Major Uranians: Hopkins, Pater and Wilde (2006), a 500-page scholarly volume that considers the major Victorian writers of Uranian poetry and prose (the author has made this volume available in a free, open-access, PDF version).
- Mark Lilly. Gay Men's Literature in the Twentieth Century (1993)
- Patricia Juliana Smith. Lesbian Panic: Homoeroticism in Modern British Women's Fiction (1997)
- Gregory Woods. Articulate Flesh – male homoeroticism and modern poetry (1989) (USA poets)
- Vita Sackville-West. Louise DeSalvo, Mitchell A. Leaska, editors. Vita Sackville-West The Letters of Vita Sackville-West to Virginia Woolf (1985)
- Virginia Woolf. Congenial Spirits: The Selected Letters of Virginia Woolf Joanne Trautmann Banks, editor (Harcourt Brace, 1991)
- Joe Dowson. Past Thoughts and Precognition: Eroticism Through My Eyes (Self Published, co-author by D.Cameron, 2013)
- Jonathan Weinberg. Male Desire: The Homoerotic in American Art (2005)
- James M. Saslow. Pictures and Passions: A History of Homosexuality in the Visual Arts (1999)
- Allen Ellenzweig. The Homoerotic Photograph: Male Images, Delacroix to Mapplethorpe (1992)
- Thomas Waugh. Hard to Imagine: Gay Male Eroticism in Photography and Film from Their Beginnings to Stonewall (1996)
- Emmanuel Cooper. The Sexual Perspective: Homosexuality and Art in the Last 100 Years in the West (1994)
- Claude J. Summers (editor). The Queer Encyclopedia of the Visual Arts (2004)
- Harmony Hammond. Lesbian Art in America: A Contemporary History (2000) (Post-1968 only)
- Laura Doan. Fashioning Sapphism: The Origins of a Modern English Lesbian Culture (2001) (Post-WW I in England)
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Homoeroticism.|
- glbtg: an encyclopaedia of gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender and queer culture Archived September 1, 2007, at the Wayback Machine
- Younger, 2005, p.80.
- Quoted by Flood, 2007, p. 307.
- Flood, 2007, p.307.
- Younger, 2005, p.38.
- According to Flood, 2007, p.308.
- Quoted by Kontje, 2002, p. 327.
- John Berger, Caravaggio, Studio International, p. 1983, Volume 196 Number 998.
- Daugherty, Leo (2001). "The Question of Topical Allusion in Richard Barnfield's Pastoral Verse". In Boris, Kenneth; Klawitter, George (eds.). The Affectionate Shepherd: Celebrating Richard Barnfield. Pennsylvania: Susquehanna University Press. p. 45.
- Hunt, Mary E. "Mollenkott, Virginia Ramey". Encyclopedia of the Bible Online. Retrieved 2021-12-23.
- Rapoport, Chaim (2004). Judaism and homosexuality : an authentic Orthodox view. London: Vallentine Mitchell. ISBN 0-85303-452-4. OCLC 52509644.
- Jennings, Theodore W. (2010-08-26), "The "Gay" Jesus", The Blackwell Companion to Jesus, Oxford, UK: Wiley-Blackwell, pp. 443–457, retrieved 2021-12-23
- Ehrman, Bart D. (2003). Lost Christianities : the battle for Scripture and the faiths we never knew. New York: Oxford University Press. ISBN 0-19-518414-9. OCLC 57124976.
- Woggon, Harry A. (1981-06-01). "A biblical and historical study of homosexuality". Journal of Religion and Health. 20 (2): 156–163. doi:10.1007/BF01540819. ISSN 1573-6571.
- Loader, William R. G. (2005). Sexuality and the Jesus tradition. Grand Rapids, Mich.: W.B. Eerdmans Pub. ISBN 0-8028-2862-0. OCLC 57762402.
- Goss, Robert (1993). Jesus acted up: A gay and lesbian manifesto. ISBN-13: 978-0060633189. HarperSanFrancisco.
- J., Gagnon, Robert A. (2001). The Bible and homosexual practice : texts and hermeneutics. Abingdon Press. ISBN 0-687-02279-7. OCLC 611440807.
- Thatcher, Tom (2018-09-10). "The Beloved Disciple, the Fourth Evangelist, and the Authorship of the Fourth Gospel". Oxford Handbooks Online. doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198739982.013.5.
- Jennings, Theodore W., Jr. (2003). The man Jesus loved : homoerotic narratives from the New Testament. Cleveland: Pilgrim Press. ISBN 0-8298-1535-X. OCLC 51586948.
- Jennings, Theodore W., Jr. (2003). The man Jesus loved : homoerotic narratives from the New Testament. Cleveland: Pilgrim Press. ISBN 0-8298-1535-X. OCLC 51586948.
- Very, Jones, "Jacob wrestling with the Angel", Jones Very: The Complete Poems, University of Georgia Press, retrieved 2021-12-23
- "The Bible and Same-Sex Love", God, Sex, and Gender, Oxford, UK: Wiley-Blackwell, pp. 155–174, 2011-04-20, ISBN 978-1-4443-9638-6, retrieved 2021-12-23
- Ackerman, Susan (2005). When heroes love : the ambiguity of eros in the stories of Gilgamesh and David. New York. ISBN 978-0-231-50725-7. OCLC 213304831.
- Apczynski, John V. (2009), "What has Paris to do with Assisi? The Theological Creation of a Saint", Finding Saint Francis in Literature and Art, New York: Palgrave Macmillan US, pp. 79–93, ISBN 978-1-349-37123-5, retrieved 2021-12-23
- Woods, Gregory (1999), "The Art of Friendship in Roderick Hudson", Henry James and Homo-Erotic Desire, London: Palgrave Macmillan UK, pp. 69–77, ISBN 978-1-349-27123-8, retrieved 2021-12-23
- BURGER, Michael. The Shaping of Western Civilization: From Antiquity to the Enlightenment (University of Toronto Press, 2008), 308 pages. ISBN 1-55111-432-1, ISBN 978-1-55111-432-3
- YOUNGER, John Grimes. Sex in the ancient world from A to Z (Routledge, 2005), 217 pages. ISBN 0-415-24252-5, ISBN 978-0-415-24252-3
- FLOOD, Michael. International encyclopedia of men and masculinities (Routledge, 2007), 704 pages. ISBN 0-415-33343-1, ISBN 978-0-415-33343-6
- HEILBUT, Anthony. Thomas Mann: Eros and Literature (University of California Press, 1997), 638 pages. ISBN 0-520-20911-7, ISBN 978-0-520-20911-4
- KONTJE, Todd Curtis. A companion to German realism, 1848–1900 (Camden House, 2002), 412 pages. ISBN 1-57113-322-4, ISBN 978-1-57113-322-9
- FALCON, Felix Lance. Gay Art: a Historic Collection [and history], ed. and with an introd. & captions by Thomas Waugh (Arsenal Pulp Press, 2006), 255 p. ISBN 1-55152-205-5