Jump to content

Hugh Lawson White

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Hugh White
President pro tempore of the United States Senate
In office
December 3, 1832 – December 15, 1833
Preceded byLittleton Tazewell
Succeeded byGeorge Poindexter
United States Senator
from Tennessee
In office
October 28, 1825 – January 13, 1840
Preceded byAndrew Jackson
Succeeded byAlexander O. Anderson
Personal details
Hugh Lawson White

(1773-10-30)October 30, 1773
Rowan County, North Carolina, British America (now Iredell County)
DiedApril 10, 1840(1840-04-10) (aged 66)
Knoxville, Tennessee, U.S.
Resting placeFirst Presbyterian Church Cemetery
Political partyDemocratic-Republican (Before 1825)
Democratic (1825–1836)
Whig (1836–1840)
Spouse(s)Elizabeth Carrick (1798–1831
Anne Peyton (1832–1840)
RelativesJames White (Father)
Samuel Carrick (Father-in-law)
Charles McClung (Brother-in-law)
John Overton (Brother-in-law)
John Williams (Brother-in-law)

Hugh Lawson White (October 30, 1773 – April 10, 1840) was an American politician during the first third of the 19th century. After filling in several posts particularly in Tennessee's judiciary and state legislature since 1801, thereunder as a Tennessee Supreme Court justice, he was chosen to succeed former presidential candidate Andrew Jackson in the United States Senate in 1825. He became a member of the new Democratic Party, supporting Jackson's policies and his future presidential administration. However, he left the Democrats in 1836 and was a Whig candidate in that year's presidential election.[1]

An ardent strict constructionist and lifelong states' rights advocate, White was one of President Jackson's most trusted allies in Congress in the late 1820s and early 1830s.[2]: 246  White fought against the national bank, tariffs, and the use of federal funds for internal improvements,[2]: 31, 76–77  and led efforts in the Senate to pass the Indian Removal Act of 1830.[2]: 153  In 1833, at the height of the Nullification Crisis, White, as the Senate's president pro tempore, coordinated negotiations over the Tariff of 1833.[2]: 239 

Suspicious of the growing power of the presidency, White began to distance himself from Jackson in the mid-1830s, and realigned himself with Henry Clay and the burgeoning Whig Party.[2]: 251–2  He was eventually forced out of the Senate when Jackson's allies, led by James K. Polk, gained control of the Tennessee state legislature and demanded his resignation.[2]: 409–410 


Early life[edit]

Lloyd Branson's "Sheep-shearing scene," showing Hugh Lawson White (left), his future father-in-law Samuel Carrick (middle), and future wife, Elizabeth

White was born in what is now Iredell County, North Carolina (but then part of Rowan County), the eldest son of James White and Mary Lawson White.[1] James, a Revolutionary War veteran, moved his family to the Tennessee frontier in the 1780s, and played an active role in the failed State of Franklin.[3] In 1786, he constructed White's Fort, which would eventually develop into Knoxville, Tennessee.[3] Young Hugh was a sentinel at the fort and helped manage its small gristmill.[2]: 8 

In 1791, White's Fort was chosen as the capital of the newly created Southwest Territory, and James White's friend, William Blount, was appointed governor of the territory. Hugh Lawson White worked as Blount's personal secretary,[1] and was tutored by early Knoxville minister and educator, Samuel Carrick.[1] In 1793, he fought in the territorial militia under John Sevier during the Cherokee–American wars.[1] Historian J. G. M. Ramsey credited Hugh Lawson White's company with the killing of the Chickamauga Cherokee war chief, King Fisher,[4] and White's granddaughter and biographer, Nancy Scott, stated that White fired the fatal shot.[2]: 11n 

White studied law in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, under James Hopkins, and was admitted to the bar in 1796.[1] Two years later, he married Elizabeth Carrick, the daughter of his mentor, Samuel.[1]

The judiciary and early political career[edit]

In 1801, White was appointed judge of the Superior Court of Tennessee, then the state's highest court.[1] In 1807, he resigned after being elected to the state legislature.[1] He left the state legislature in 1809, following his appointment to the state's Court of Errors and Appeals (which replaced the Superior Court as the highest court).[1] He resigned this position in 1815 when he was elected to the state senate.[1] He served in the state senate until 1817. As a state legislator, White helped reform the state's land laws,[2]: 19  and engineered the passage of an anti-dueling measure.[5]

In 1812, White was named president of the Knoxville branch of the Bank of Tennessee.[1] White was described as a very cautious banker,[2]: 14–9  and his bank was one of the few in the state to survive the Panic of 1819.[6]

In 1821, President James Monroe appointed White to a commission to settle claims against Spain, following the Adams-Onís Treaty in which that nation sold Florida to the United States.[1]

United States Senate[edit]

Portrait of White by Emanuel Leutze

In 1825, the Tennessee state legislature chose White to replace Andrew Jackson in the United States Senate (Jackson had resigned following his failed run for the presidency in 1824).[1] White spearheaded the Southern states' opposition to sending delegates to 1826 Congress of Panama, which was a general gathering of various nations in the Western Hemisphere, many of which had declared their independence from Spain and abolished slavery.[2]: 40–6  White argued that if the U.S. attended the congress, it would violate the commitment to neutrality put forth by President Washington decades earlier, and stated that the nation should not get involved in foreign treaties merely for the sake of "gratifying national vanity."[2]: 39 

Following Jackson's election to the presidency in 1828, White became one of the Jackson Administration's key congressional allies.[2]: 246  White was chairman of the Senate Committee on Indian Affairs, which drew up the Indian Removal Act of 1830, a major initiative of Jackson.[2]: 153–4  The act called for the relocation of the remaining Native American tribes in the southeastern United States to territories west of the Mississippi River and would culminate in the so-called Trail of Tears.

In an 1836 speech, White described himself as a "strict constructionist,"[2]: 209  arguing that the federal government could not pass any laws outside its powers specifically stated in the Constitution. Like many Jacksonians, he was a staunch states' rights, advocate.[2]: 76–7  He opposed the national bank,[2]: 19  and rejected federal funding for internal improvements (which he believed only the states had the power to fund).[2]: 76–7  He also supported Jackson's call for the elimination of the Electoral College.[2]: 348  A slaveowner himself,[7] he and opposed federal intervention into the issue of slavery.[2]: 199 

Like most Southern senators, White opposed the Tariff of 1828, which placed a high tax on goods imported from overseas to protect growing northern industries. White argued that while the federal government had the power to impose tariffs, it should only do so when it benefited the nation as a whole, and not merely one section (i.e., the North) at the expense of another (i.e., the agrarian South, which relied on trade with England).[2]: 76–7  During the resulting Nullification Crisis in late 1832 and early 1833, as the Senate's president pro tempore (the leader of the Senate in the absence of the Vice President), White coordinated negotiations in the interim between the resignation of Vice President John C. Calhoun (December 28, 1832) and the swearing in of Vice President Martin Van Buren (March 4, 1833).[2]: 239  Vice President Calhoun's resignation put White next in line to assume the presidency should that office have become vacant.[8]

1836 presidential election[edit]

Toward the end of Jackson's first term, a rift developed between White and Jackson. In 1831, as Jackson reshuffled his cabinet in the aftermath of the Petticoat affair, White was offered the office of Secretary of War but turned it down.[2]: 251  During the Nullification Crisis in February 1833, White angered Jackson by appointing Delaware senator and Clay ally John M. Clayton to the select committee to consider the Clay compromise.[2]: 239  In later speeches, White stated that the Jackson Administration had drifted away from the party's core states' rights principles, and argued that the executive was gaining too much power.[2]: 352 

At the end of Jackson's second term, the Tennessee state legislature endorsed White for the presidency in 1835. This angered Jackson, as he had chosen Martin Van Buren as his successor. White stated that no sitting president should choose a successor, arguing that doing so was akin to having a monarchy.[2]: 352  In 1836, White left Jackson's party entirely, and decided to run for president as a candidate for the Whig Party led by Henry Clay, which had mainly formed from opposition to Jackson but also continued the nationalist agenda of the National Republican Party, although this very contradicting position in regard to White's ideals was not yet determined at that time, as the party was still regionally factionalized.[1]

In the 1836 presidential election, the Whig Party, unable to agree on a candidate, ran four candidates against Van Buren: White, William Henry Harrison, Daniel Webster, and Willie Person Mangum. Jackson actively campaigned against White in Tennessee, and accused him of being a federalist who was opposed to states' rights.[2]: 356  In spite of this, White won Tennessee, as well as Georgia, giving him 26 electoral votes, the third highest total behind Van Buren's 170 and Harrison's 73.[9]

Later career[edit]

By 1837, the relationship between White and Jackson had turned hostile. Jackson was outraged when he learned that White had accused his administration of committing outright fraud, and stated in a letter to Adam Huntsman that White had a "lax code of morals."[2]: 306  Jackson's allies such as James K. Polk, Felix Grundy, and John Catron, also turned against White and blamed him for the dispute with Jackson.[2]: 262  White stood by his accusations and blasted Jackson for making "useless expenditures" of public money,[2]: 347  and increasing the power of the presidency.[2]: 348 

By the late 1830s, Jackson's allies had gained control of the Tennessee state legislature. After White refused their demand that he vote for the Subtreasury Bill, he was forced to resign on January 13, 1840.[1] Following a large banquet in Washington, White returned to his native Knoxville. His entry into the city was marked by the firing of cannons and the ringing of church bells, as he paraded through the streets on horseback.[2]: 410 

Shortly after his return, White fell ill, and he died on April 10, 1840. A large funeral procession led his casket and riderless horse through the streets of Knoxville.[2]: 421–2  He is interred with his family in the First Presbyterian Church Cemetery.[10]

Personality and style[edit]

White believed strongly in the principles of strict constructionism and a limited federal government and voted against fellow Jacksonians if he felt their initiatives ran counter to these principles.[11] His independent nature and his stern rectitude earned him the appellation "The Cato of the United States."[12] His congressional colleague, Henry Wise, later wrote that White's "patriotism and firmness" as the Senate's president pro tempore was key to resolving the Nullification Crisis.[2]: 239 

White believed that being on the public payroll obligated him to attend every Senate meeting, no matter the issue.[2]: 239–240   Felix Grundy recalled that White once departed Knoxville in the middle of a driving snowstorm to ensure he made it to Washington in time for the Senate's fall session.[2]: 241  Senator John Milton Niles later wrote that White was often "the only listener to a dull speech."[2]: 240  White prided himself on being the most punctual member of the Senate and was usually the first senator to arrive at the Capitol on days when the Senate was in session.[2]: 241  Senator Ephraim H. Foster once told a story about waking up well before sunrise one morning, determined to beat White to the Capitol at least once in his career, and arriving only to find White in the committee room analyzing some papers.[2]: 241 

Family and legacy[edit]

White's pocket watch on display at the Center for East Tennessee History

White's father, James White (1747–1820), was the founder of Knoxville, Tennessee. His brothers-in-law included surveyor Charles McClung (1761–1835), who platted Knoxville in 1791, Judge John Overton (1766–1833), the co-founder of Memphis, Tennessee, and Senator John Williams (1778–1837).[1] White and his first wife, Elizabeth Carrick, had 12 children, two of whom died in infancy.[2]: 413  Between 1825 and 1831, eight of their surviving ten children died of tuberculosis.[2]: 414–419  Their lone surviving son, Samuel (1825–1860), served as mayor of Knoxville in 1857.[13]

White's farm lay just west of Second Creek in Knoxville. In the late 19th century, this became a land development area known as "White's Addition."[14] The area is now part of the University of Tennessee campus and the Fort Sanders neighborhood.[14] White County, Arkansas was also named in his honor.[15]


  1. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q Mary Rothrock, The French Broad-Holston Country: A History of Knox County, Tennessee (Knoxville, Tenn.: East Tennessee Historical Society, 1972), pp. 501-502.
  2. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z aa ab ac ad ae af ag ah ai aj ak al am an ao Nancy Scott, A Memoir of Hugh Lawson White (Philadelphia: J.B. Lippincott and Company, 1856).
  3. ^ a b William MacArthur, Lucile Deaderick (ed.), "Knoxville's History: An Interpretation," Heart of the Valley: A History of Knoxville, Tennessee (Knoxville, Tenn.: East Tennessee Historical Society, 1976), p. 13.
  4. ^ J.G.M. Ramsey, The Annals of Tennessee to the End of the Eighteenth Century (Johnson City, Tenn.: Overmountain Press, 1999), p. 586.
  5. ^ John Wooldridge, George Mellen, William Rule (ed.), Standard History of Knoxville, Tennessee (Chicago: Lewis Publishing Company, 1900; reprinted by Kessinger Books, 2010), p. 480.
  6. ^ John Finger, Tennessee Frontiers: Three Regions in Transition (Bloomington, Ind.: Indiana University Press, 2001), p. 184.
  7. ^ "Congress slaveowners", The Washington Post, January 13, 2022, retrieved July 7, 2022
  8. ^ Feerick, John D.; Freund, Paul A. (1965). From Failing Hands: The Story of Presidential Succession. New York City: Fordham University Press. p. 86. LCCN 65-14917. As a result of Calhoun's resignation, Hugh L. White of Tennessee, as President pro tempore, was placed first in the line of succession and Andrew Stevenson of Virginia, as Speaker, second.
  9. ^ Election of 1836, The American Presidency Project website, University of California, Santa Barbara. Accessed September 13, 2011.
  10. ^ Graveyard Inscriptions, U-Z Archived March 20, 2012, at the Wayback Machine, First Presbyterian Church, Knoxville (website). Retrieved: September 9, 2011.
  11. ^ Jonathan Atkins, "Hugh Lawson White," Tennessee Encyclopedia of History and Culture, 2009. Retrieved: September 9, 2011.
  12. ^ Herbert Treadwell Wade, The New International Encyclopedia, Vol. 20 (1905), p. 480.
  13. ^ Mayors of Knoxville Archived September 28, 2011, at the Wayback Machine, City of Knoxville website. Retrieved: September 8, 2011.
  14. ^ a b Don Akchin and Lisa Akchin, National Register of Historic Places Nomination Form for Fort Sanders Historic District, March 4, 1980.
  15. ^ Our Rich History Archived August 23, 2011, at the Wayback Machine, White County, Arkansas website. Retrieved: September 9, 2011.

Further reading[edit]

  • Atkins, Jonathan M. (1992). "The Presidential Candidacy of Hugh Lawson White in Tennessee, 1832-1836". The Journal of Southern History. 58 (1): 27–56. doi:10.2307/2210474. JSTOR 2210474.
  • McCormick, Richard P. (1984). "Was There a "Whig Strategy" in 1836?". Journal of the Early Republic. 4 (1): 47–70. doi:10.2307/3122854. JSTOR 3122854.
  • Murphy, James Edward (1971). "Jackson and the Tennessee Opposition". Tennessee Historical Quarterly. 30 (1): 50–69. JSTOR 42623203.

External links[edit]

U.S. Senate
Preceded by U.S. Senator (Class 2) from Tennessee
Served alongside: John Eaton, Felix Grundy, Ephraim H. Foster, Felix Grundy
Succeeded by
Preceded by Chair of the Senate Indian Affairs Committee
Succeeded by
Preceded by Chair of the Senate Indian Affairs Committee
Succeeded by
Political offices
Preceded by President pro tempore of the United States Senate
Succeeded by
Party political offices
New political party Whig nominee for President of the United States
Succeeded by
Preceded by Nullifier nominee for President of the United States

Party dissolved
Notes and references
1. The Whig Party ran regional candidates in 1836. White ran in the Southern states, William Henry Harrison ran in the Northern states, and Daniel Webster ran in Massachusetts.