Human Nature (Madonna song)
|Single by Madonna|
|from the album Bedtime Stories|
|Released||June 6, 1995|
|Madonna singles chronology|
"Human Nature" is a song recorded by American singer Madonna for her sixth studio album Bedtime Stories (1994). It was written as an answer song to her critics, who had panned her provocative image of the previous two years and Madonna's release of sexually explicit works. Written and produced by Madonna and Dave Hall, with additional writing from Shawn McKenzie, Kevin McKenzie and Milo Deering, "Human Nature" includes a looping sample from Main Source's 1994 track "What You Need". The track was released on June 6, 1995, by Maverick Records as the fourth and final single from Bedtime Stories.
Musically it is an R&B track where the sound of drums and the sample is heard looping throughout, with Madonna sarcastically asking rhetorical questions based on her real-life actions over the last two years. The song received mostly positive reviews from music critics who have later noted its anthemic and empowering nature. "Human Nature" became a moderate hit in the United States, peaking at number 46 on the Billboard Hot 100 and at number two on the Hot Dance Club Play chart. In the United Kingdom, the single entered the chart and peaked at number eight and it also charted within the top ten in Italy.
The accompanying music video was directed by Jean-Baptiste Mondino, and features Madonna and her dancers dressed in latex and leather, while executing highly choreographed dance routines. Inspired by S&M imagery, the video later influenced the work of singers Rihanna and Christina Aguilera. Madonna has performed "Human Nature" on three of her concert tours, most recently on her 2012 The MDNA Tour, where it was the subject of controversy when the singer exposed her nipples during a show in Istanbul.
- 1 Background and release
- 2 Recording and composition
- 3 Critical response
- 4 Chart performance
- 5 Music video
- 6 Live performances
- 7 Track listings and formats
- 8 Credits and personnel
- 9 Charts
- 10 Notes
- 11 References
- 12 External links
Background and release
In 1992, Madonna released the coffee table book Sex and her fifth studio album Erotica, both being of explicit sexual content. She also starred in the erotic thriller Body of Evidence the next year. Madonna promoted Erotica with The Girlie Show World Tour, which was met with protests and boycott threats due to its explicit content. In March 1994, Madonna's appearance on Late Show with David Letterman was highly criticized for her controversial behavior and usage of profanity. The release of her sexually explicit film, album and book, and the aggressive appearance on Letterman all made critics question Madonna as a sexual renegade. She faced strong negative publicity from critics and fans, who commented that "she had gone too far" and that her career was over.
Madonna wanted to tone down her explicit image. Her first attempt was to release the tender ballad "I'll Remember" (1994) from the soundtrack of the film With Honors. Musically she wanted to move in a new musical direction and started exploring new-jack R&B styles with a generally mainstream, radio-friendly sound. She incorporated it in her sixth studio album, Bedtime Stories, released in October 1994. Journalist Mary von Aue from Vice magazine noted that Madonna and her publicist Liz Rosenberg started promoting Bedtime Stories as an apology album with the promotional videos promising that there would be "no sexual references on the album".
However, the singer was still seething about how the media had treated her unfairly over the last two years. When she started working with producer Dave Hall on the album, she wrote an answer song for the media. Titled "Human Nature", it directly addressed the media and the press who had criticized her for dealing with taboo issues with her previous record and tried to punish her for that. "I'm saying in the song that I'm giving my back to them. I'm not sorry", Madonna explained. Described by Billboard as "Madonna taking on her critics more directly than ever with a logical, defiant attack on slut-shaming", the song was also about closing the book on the previous two years of her life. "Human Nature" eventually became the fourth and final single released from Bedtime Stories on June 6, 1995, by Maverick Records.
Recording and composition
"Human Nature" was written and produced by Madonna and Hall, with additional writing credits from Shawn McKenzie, Kevin McKenzie and Milo Deering. The song was recorded and mixed by Frederick Jorio and P. Dennis Mitchell with Robert Kiss working as an assistant engineer during the sessions and Joey Moskowitz doing the programming. Musically, "Human Nature" is a R&B song with a hip-hop influenced beat. It also includes a looping sample from the song "What You Need" performed by hip-hop group Main Source along with the sound of slamming doors. "Human Nature" begins in a trip hop style with the sound of bass and drums and Madonna whispering "express yourself, don't repress yourself". Throughout the song, the music continues looping around the same chord sequence and Madonna utters whispered phrases to counterpoint the actual lyrics. Her vocals utilized the 1990s soul style of music with a nasal, thin sound. The chorus ends with the line "I'm not your bitch, Don't hang your shit on me" which was often censored by the radio stations from airplay. Unlike the other tracks on the album, "Human Nature" does not employ the pentatonic melody and is devoid of the melancholy nature of Bedtime Stories, as observed by Jon Pareles of The New York Times. Composed in the time signature of common time, "Human Nature" has a key of C major while progressing in 88 beats per minute. Madonna's "nasal" vocals range from F3 to E7 and the song follows a repetitive sequence of Fmaj7–E7–Am7–Fmaj7–E7–Am7 as its chord progression.
A 29 second sample from "Human Nature" which features the heavy bass and the looping drum sounds. It also aurally shows the part where Madonna asserts the main chorus, employing a 90s soul style of music with a nasal, thin sound.
|Problems playing this file? See media help.|
Rikky Rooksby, author of The Complete Guide to the Music of Madonna felt that the lyrics, along with being an answer-song, could also be interpreted as a rebellious one, where Madonna looks back on a relationship where she was not allowed to speak her mind. The song's lyrics contain sarcastic backing vocals with Madonna asking rhetorical questions based on her real-life actions, such as "Did I say something wrong? Oops, I didn't know I couldn't talk about sex. I must have been crazy," as well as the line "What was I thinking?" Madonna explained that the lyrics were about "about basically saying don't put me in a box, don't pin me down, don't tell me what I can and can't say. It's about breaking out of the restraints." With the Los Angeles Times she further clarified that there was a defensiveness with the lyrics for "Human Nature":
It's my definitive statement in regards to the incredible pay-back I've received for having the nerve to talk about the things that I did in the past few years with my Sex book and my record. It's getting it off my chest. It is defensive, absolutely. But it's also sarcastic, tongue-in-cheek. And I'm not sorry. I do not apologize for any of it.
"Human Nature" also received nine official remixes clocking a total of 53 minutes and 26 seconds. Most of the remixes turned the R&B sounding song into a house one. The radio edit omitted the line ""I'm not your bitch/Don't hang your shit on me" but AllMusic's Jose F. Promis felt that the removal made the version repetitive and made it "lack the punchline". The "Runway Club Mix" is stripped down while the "I'm Not Your Bitch Mix" replaced the verse and the chorus with whispered comments like "I have no regrets", "I'm not your bitch", "Deal with it" and "I'm HIV negative" which are added over a much deeper house groove. The hip hop mixes include one clean and one adult rated version. According to Promis, the "Love is the Nature Mix" was the best remix created, describing it as containing "swirling instruments", which converted the song into a dance track.
"Human Nature" received mostly positive reviews from music critics. Sal Cinquemani of Slant Magazine gave the song a positive review, stating that "for years, Madonna spoke in metaphors, fantasies and blatant shock tactics, but the performer indignantly struck back at her critics on 'Human Nature'. She didn't just hold up a mirror, she became the mirror". Barbara O'Dair from Rolling Stone also gave a positive review of the song, commenting that "Madonna does a drive-by on her critics, complete with a keening synth line straight outta Dre", adding that "Madonna's message is still 'Express yourself, don't repress yourself.' This time, however, it comes not with a bang but a whisper". Scott Kearnan of The Boston Globe included the track at number 11 on his list of "30 Ultimate Madonna Singles", stating that the line "Absolutely no regrets" was a "Madonna mantra if ever there was one".
Larry Flick from Billboard was also positive, and expected "radio to hungrily come to the table and dine on this wickedly catchy jeep/pop jam in which La M unapologetically snaps at her more close-minded critics". He complimented her vocals which were "playfully snide and aggressive, holding strong against a forceful hip-hop groove and a host of ear-pleasing funk guitar links and synth hoops". Author Chris Wade wrote in his book, The Music of Madonna, that "Human Nature" lifted the sadness emanated from the first few tracks from the album. "There's a great beat to this, a brilliant vocal where Madonna answers herself with whispers and an unforgettable chorus," Wade added. Matthew Rettenmund wrote in his Encyclopedia Madonnica that "inspite of the chart performance", the song has become a modern "self-empowerment anthem".
Charles Aaron from Spin described the song as "slinking through [Hall's] low-ridin', gum-smackin' groove, Maddy's hard-bitten ingenue expresses no regrets, but this time you feel for her." Aaron highlighted the lyrics "Would it sound better if I were a man?" as subversive and coy. Author Lucy O'Brien described in her book, Madonna: Like an Icon, that "Human Nature" was one of the "quirkiest" tracks on Bedtime Stories, "throbbing with with a tightly restrained but devastating anger". For Barry Walters from Moscow-Pullman Daily News, the song had the catchiest chorus among all the other tracks from the album. Jim Farber from Entertainment Weekly gave the song a negative review, noting that Madonna's "on far surer ground thrashing through such neurotic (if not uncommon) views of relationships than she is trashing the media. In striking back at her critics, Madonna simply sounds self-righteous and smug. 'I didn't know I couldn't talk about sex,' she sneers in 'Human Nature'. 'Did I say something true?' Yes. But tooting your own horn about it just sounds petty". Rooksby said that the repetition of the sample was "wearing" and it "did not suggest that the world of the singer was very appealing".
"Human Nature" debuted at number 86 on the US Billboard Hot 100, for the week ending June 24, 1995, with 7,400 units sold. It reached its peak position three weeks later, at number 46. "Human Nature" became Madonna's second consecutive single not to enter the top 40 in the United States, following her previous single "Bedtime Story", which had reached a peak of number 42. Fred Bronson from Billboard reported that although the song had moved up the chart with a positive bullet point, the song being a risky choice for radio, it stalled progress and failed to become Madonna's 33rd top 40 hit. "Human Nature" was a success on the dance chart, peaking at number two on Hot Dance Club Play. It also peaked at number 35 on Hot 100 Singles Sales, number 58 on Hot 100 Airplay, and number 57 on Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs. In Canada, "Human Nature" debuted at number 90 on the RPM Singles Chart on July 10, 1995. It reached a peak of number 64 on the chart and was present for a total of seven weeks only.
In the United Kingdom, "Human Nature" entered the chart at its peak position of number eight, but rapidly descended down the charts, being present for a total of six weeks only. According to the Official Charts Company, it has sold a total of 80,685 copies as of August 2008. In Australia, the single peaked within the top 20, at number 17, on the ARIA Charts. On the Irish Singles Chart the song peaked just outside the top 20, at number 21. It was not as successful in New Zealand, peaking at number 37, making it Madonna's poorest performing single to stay on the chart for a sole week. The song reached the top 20 in Finland and Switzerland, peaking at number 11 and number 17 respectively, while in Germany it reached a peak of number 50.
The accompanying music video for "Human Nature" was directed by Jean-Baptiste Mondino, who had previously directed Madonna's videos for "Open Your Heart" and "Justify My Love". It was shot over two days, May 6 to 7, 1995 at Raleigh Studios in Hollywood, California and was created under Palomar Productions' Anita Wetterstedt. The video was choreographed by Jamie King, who later directed Madonna's concert tours. "She wanted me to dance in her 'Human Nature' video. I didn't want to do it, but she begged", he stated. King was one of the dancers in the S&M attires hanging down from a swinging trapeze in the video. Her dancer Luca Tommassini was the choreography assistant. Madonna's main inspiration behind the video was the work of artist Eric Stanton who did S&M inspired drawings. The singer enlisted Mondino to direct the video and wanted to be about the fun aspects of Stanton's work and more dance-oriented than her previous videos from Bedtime Stories. For Mondino, the main problem was that he did not prefer too much dancing in the videos, because that resulted in extra editing.
I remember most of the video you had shot with the crane, some Steadicam, plus some panning. So you have about five different cameras shooting a performance, and after they edit like crazy. It gives you a lot of freedom, but I feel very frustrated because I like to see somebody dancing. I hate when there's too much editing. I like the steadiness of the performance because then you can really enjoy the movement of the body. You see the skill.
So Mondino came up with the concept of boxes and had Madonna and the dancers perform choreography inside it. The director was satisfied since the small space of the boxes meant there was not much movement, and he could create the desired graphic S&M imagery and choreography. According to Dustin Robertson, editor of the video, Mondino and Madonna both had opposite work ethics. While Mondino was "cool and laid-back", Madonna was a "stickler for details" and the former had "a wonderful way of handling her, while she demanded a strong handler to pull out the best she's got to give".
Release and reception
The music video premiered on May 19, 1995, through MTV. It features Madonna, her dancers, and her chihuahua Chiquita in black leather and latex outfits. The S&M inspired outfits were to symbolize the "breaking out of the restraints" as the lyrics described. Her hair, which appears brown in the video was actually blonde at the time. She had leather strips painstakingly braided into her hair to blend with her dark roots. The frizzy afro she sports halfway through the video was actually a hairpiece. During the middle of the video, Madonna and her dancers appear in a series of boxes, trying to break free. Another sequence shows the singer being thrown around within a series of ropes managed by her dancers. As the video concludes there is a shot of Madonna sitting in a chair, looking straight into the camera as she says the line "Absolutely no regrets!". Then there is a brief shot of her standing next to the chair as she boxes into the air.
Rettenmund complimented the video saying "God Bless [Mondino]... One of Madonna's worst performing singles was nonetheless given one of her best videos... Simply staged, it is equal parts funny and sexy... If its possible for one video to sum up Madonna's Madonna-ness, 'Human Nature' is that video". Louis Virtel from The Backlot ranked the video at number 22 on a list for "Madonna's 55 Best Videos", and called it "tongue-in-cheek, pleather-heavy". He went on to say that "It's rare that Madonna gets a chance to be both harsh and hilarious in a music video", and in this one, "Madonna basically does whatever the hell she wants. Brandish a chihuahua? Mock and celebrate kinkiness? Sneer at the camera like a bored third-grader? She does it all, and even in black cornrows, she's a vision of coolness and sexual superiority". Carol Vernallis, writer of Experiencing Music Video: Aesthetics and Cultural Context noted that the concept of black outfit against a white background "works well, but the snare drum, which corresponds to nothing in the imagery, seems to float above the soundtrack".
Roger Beebe, one of the authors of the book Medium Cool: Music Videos from Soundies to Cellphones noted that the video was an example of the viewer's impulse being intensified regarding "what will happen next?" by placing its primary performers against a stark background. In 2011, singer Rihanna's music video for the song "S&M" was compared to "Human Nature"'s music video with James Montgomery from MTV News saying that the video for "S&M" was not a new concept and was done in the video for "Human Nature". Montgomery also noted that singer Christina Aguilera's music video for 2010 single "Not Myself Tonight" was heavily inspired by that of "Human Nature", including scenes portraying Aguilera in "leather get-ups, her dominatrix attitude and the sultry chair-related activities she engages in throughout". The music video further inspired the dancing and the video of the song "Kambaqt Ishq", from the 2001 Bollywood film, Pyaar Tune Kya Kiya.
Madonna has performed "Human Nature" three times on tour. During the 2001 Drowned World Tour, she performed the song while slow-riding on a mechanical bull, which was considered by Rob Mancini from MTV News as "magical". During the performance, the singer was dressed as a cowgirl. For John McAlley from Entertainment Weekly, Madonna "prompts the oddly natural sight of lap-dancing a mechanical bull". Similar review was shared by Alexis Petridis from The Guardian, who noted that the media had heavily reported on the tour making all the details available from much before the London show that he reviewed. Nevertheless, Madonna riding the bull and performing "Human Nature" was one of the "most startling moments" of the tour according to him. The performance of the song on August 26, 2001, at The Palace of Auburn Hills was recorded and released in the live video album, Drowned World Tour 2001.
Madonna performed the song again on her 2008–09 Sticky & Sweet Tour, while playing an electric guitar and adding vocoder voice effects on the background harmonies. The singer was dressed in a black leotard and fishnet tights. She also wore a white hat and black leather boots. During the performance a video backdrop portrayed American singer Britney Spears trapped in an elevator and trying to get out, while kicking the walls. At the end of the performance, the doors opened to reveal Spears saying the phrase "It's Britney, bitch", from her song "Gimme More" (2007). Madonna explained that she intended the video to stand as an analogy of Spears' career, saying "Didn't that explain what I thought? 'I'm not your bitch, don't hang your shit on me". On November 6, 2008 in the Los Angeles show at Dodger Stadium, Spears joined Madonna onstage halfway through the performance. Aidin Vaziri from Gibson.com was positive in his review, saying that the best moment of the tour was when Madonna picked up her black Les Paul guitar and emulated musician Slash while performing the song. Paul Schrodt from Slant Magazine was negative in his review of the performance, saying that by the time the performance of "Human Nature" had started, "it's the same as all her shows: A remixed mind-fuck". The performance was included on the Sticky & Sweet Tour live CD and DVD release, recorded during Madonna's four shows in Buenos Aires, Argentina, in December 2008.
In 2012, Madonna performed the song on The MDNA Tour as part of the third segment of the show. She performed the song while her dancers moved mirrors around her, as she removed articles of clothing. At her concert in Istanbul on June 7, 2012, Madonna briefly exposed her right breast to the audience, before covering it up again. This prompted criticism about her age, with Sophie Wilkinson from Heat World asking, "at 54, is she too old to be getting a boob out?" The striptease towards the end of the song continued in other cities where the tour visited, and most of the times the singer had messages written across her back talking about social issues. Amy Odell from The Huffington Post said that criticizing the gesture based on her age sends "a very archaic message", adding that "Women who are 53 still have breasts and... sex drives!". The performance of the song at the November 19–20, 2012, shows in Miami, at the American Airlines Arena were recorded and released in Madonna's fourth live album, MDNA World Tour. In April 2015, Madonna performed "Human Nature" along with her 2005 song "Hung Up" as a medley at the Coachella Festival during Drake's act, sporting thigh-high boots and a tank top that read "Big as Madonna". She then went on to kiss Drake; the activity went viral on the Internet due to Drake's reaction to the kiss.
Track listings and formats
Credits and personnel
- Madonna – lead vocals, songwriter, producer
- Dave Hall – songwriter, producer
- Shawn McKenzie – songwriter
- Kevin McKenzie – songwriter
- Milo Deering – songwriter
- Frederick Jorio – mixing
- P. Dennis Mitchell – mixing
- Robert Kiss – assistant engineer
- Joey Moskowitz – programming
- Paolo Riversi – cover art photographer, designer
- Michael Penn – designer
Credits and personnel adapted from Bedtime Stories album liner notes.
- Feldman 2000, p. 255
- "Top 10 Disastrous Letterman Interviews: Don't F___ with Madonna". Time. February 12, 2009. Retrieved February 14, 2014.
- Smith, Neil (May 24, 2004). "Show-stealer Madonna on tour". BBC News. Retrieved March 24, 2016.
- Tucker, Ken (April 15, 1994). "Madonna's shocking David Letterman interview". Entertainment Weekly. Retrieved March 24, 2016.
- Taraborrelli 2008, pp. 232–235
- Farber, Jim (October 28, 1994). "Album Review: 'Bedtime Stories' (1994)". Entertainment Weekly. Retrieved February 14, 2014.
- Von Aue, Mary (October 20, 2014). "Why Madonna's Unapologetic 'Bedtime Stories' Is Her Most Important Album". Vice. Retrieved January 29, 2016.
- Taraborrelli 2008, p. 239
- Palomino, Erika (November 21, 1994). "Madonna desiste do sexo e volta ao romantismo". Folha de S. Paulo (in Portuguese). Retrieved March 27, 2016.
- Lynch, Joe (October 6, 2014). "Madonna's 'Bedtime Stories' Turns 20: Babyface & Donna De Lory Look Back". Billboard. Retrieved October 10, 2014.
- Mayo, Simon. "Archive Interview from 1994 by Simon Mayo". BBC Radio 1. Archived from the original on September 30, 2004. Retrieved March 26, 2016.
- O'Brien 2008, p. 517
- ‹See Tfm› Bedtime Stories (LP, Vinyl, CD). Madonna. Maverick Records. WEA Records Pvt. Ltd. 1994. 9362-45767-2.
- Lynch, Joe (July 14, 2016). "Madonna's 'Human Nature': Saluting the Unapologetic Anthem That Should Have Been a Smash Hit". Billboard. Retrieved July 14, 2016.
- O'Brien 2008, p. 289
- Rooksby 2004, p. 48
- Pareles, Jon (October 25, 1994). "Pop Music; Madonna's Return To Innocence". The New York Times. Retrieved February 28, 2016.
- "Madonna 'Human Nature' Sheet Music – Digital download". Musicnotes.com. Retrieved June 25, 2016.
- Considine, J.D. (October 25, 1994). "Madonna's latest lets her talent do most of the talking the 'Secret' of Success". The Baltimore Sun. Retrieved February 28, 2016.
- Johnston, Maura (February 24, 2015). "Express Yourself: The Making of Madonna's 20 Greatest Music Videos". Rolling Stone. Retrieved May 27, 2016.
- Garratt, Sheryl (October 23, 1994). "The Madonna Complex : You don't have to tell her it's been a rocky couple of years". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved June 25, 2016.
- Promis, Jose F. "Human Nature – Madonna". AllMusic. Retrieved June 27, 2016.
- Gracie, Bianca (October 24, 2014). "Madonna's 'Bedtime Stories" Turns 20: Backtracking". Idolator. Retrieved June 9, 2016.
- Cinquemani, Sal (March 9, 2003). "Album Review: Madonna 'Bedtime Stories'". Slant Magazine. Retrieved June 26, 2016.
- O'Dair, Barbara (December 5, 1994). "Madonna: Bedtime Stores". Rolling Stone. Retrieved June 26, 2016.
- Kearnan, Scott (September 9, 2013). "30 Ultimate Madonna Singles". Boston Globe. Retrieved March 10, 2014.
- Flick, Larry (June 3, 1995). "Single Reviews". Billboard. 107 (22): 83. ISSN 0006-2510. Retrieved March 27, 2016.
- Wade 2016, pp. 79–80
- Rettenmund 2016, p. 234
- Aaron, Charles (October 1995). "Singles Review". Spin. 11 (7): 122. ISSN 0886-3032. Retrieved June 22, 2016.
- Waters, Barry (October 27, 1994). "Madonna Looks for Love in All the Song Places". Moscow-Pullman Daily News. p. 3C. Retrieved February 28, 2016.
- "Billboard Hot 100 Singles". Billboard. 107 (25): 86. June 24, 1995. ISSN 0006-2510. Retrieved February 28, 2016.
- Sandiford-Waller, Theda (November 16, 1996). "Hot 100 Singles Spotlight". Billboard. 108 (46): 95. ISSN 0006-2510. Retrieved February 28, 2016.
- "Madonna – Chart history" Billboard Hot 100 for Madonna. Retrieved July 18, 2015.
- Bronson, Fred (July 15, 1995). "Madonna Takes the 35th With 'Nature'". Billboard. 107 (28): 98. ISSN 0006-2510. Retrieved February 28, 2016.
- "Madonna – Chart history" Billboard Hot Dance Club Songs for Madonna. Retrieved July 18, 2015.
- "Hot 100 Singles Sales". Billboard. 107 (33): 90. August 19, 1995. ISSN 0006-2510. Retrieved February 28, 2016.
- "Madonna – Chart history". Billboard Radio Songs for Madonna. Retrieved February 28, 2016.
- "Madonna – Chart history" Billboard Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs for Madonna. Retrieved July 18, 2015.
- "Top RPM Singles: Issue 9016" (PDF). RPM. Library and Archives Canada. Retrieved June 26, 2016.
- "Top RPM Singles: Issue 2729." RPM. Library and Archives Canada. Retrieved April 3, 2013.
- "Top RPM Singles: Issue 9844" (PDF). RPM. Library and Archives Canada. Retrieved June 26, 2016.
- "Madonna: Artist Chart History" Official Charts Company. Retrieved July 18, 2015.
- Jones, Alan (August 19, 2008). "The Immaculate Guide To 50 Years Of Madonna". Music Week. Archived from the original on August 21, 2008. Retrieved June 11, 2011.
- "Australian-charts.com – Madonna – Human Nature". ARIA Top 50 Singles. Retrieved July 18, 2015.
- "The Irish Charts – Search Results – Human Nature". Irish Singles Chart. Retrieved April 3, 2013.
- "Charts.org.nz – Madonna – Human Nature". Top 40 Singles. Retrieved July 18, 2015.
- Nyman 2005, p. 109
- "Swisscharts.com – Madonna – Human Nature". Swiss Singles Chart. Retrieved 5 April 2015.
- "Musicline.de – Madonna Single-Chartverfolgung" (in German). Media Control Charts. PhonoNet GmbH. Retrieved April 3, 2013.
- Attwood, Brett (June 17, 1995). "'Videos In The Dark' Host Aims High". Billboard. p. 39. ISSN 0006-2510. Retrieved February 28, 2016.
- "Helping Madonna Hit Her Marks". The New York Times. June 20, 2004. Retrieved February 28, 2016.
- Lenihan, Jean (January 22, 2012). "Jamie King collaborates with the 'Immortal' Michael Jackson". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved February 28, 2016.
- ‹See Tfm› "Inlay credits". The Video Collection 93:99 (VHS, DVD, CD). Madonna. Warner Bros. 1999. 9362-49729-6.
- "The Oprah Winfrey Show". The Oprah Winfrey Show. Season 12. Episode 378. December 13, 1996. 45 minutes in. ABC.
- Virtel, Louis (August 18, 2014). "Madonna's 55 Best Videos, In Honor of Her 55th Birthday". AfterEllen.com and TheBacklot.com. Retrieved February 28, 2016.
- Vernallis 2004, p. 293
- Beebe & Middleton 2007, p. 146
- Montgomery, James (February 2, 2011). "Rihanna's 'S&M' Video: Always The Punished, Occasionally The Punisher". MTV News. Retrieved February 28, 2016.
- Montgomery, James (April 30, 2010). "Christina Aguilera's 'Not Myself Tonight' Video: A Pop-Culture Cheat Sheet". MTV News. Retrieved February 28, 2016.
- Badkar, Mamta; Das, Sohiny (June 6, 2009). "Boot-ilicious". Verve. Retrieved June 24, 2016.
- Mancini, Rob (July 23, 2001). "Madonna – All Five Of Her – Invades Philadelphia With Tour". MTV News. Retrieved November 1, 2015.
- McAlley, John (June 22, 2001). "Madonna lauches her "World" tour". Entertainment Weekly. Retrieved November 1, 2015.
- Petridis, Alexis (July 5, 2001). "Madonna: Earl's Court Exhibition Centre, London". The Guardian. Retrieved November 1, 2015.
- Trust, Gary (October 9, 2001). "Madonna's 'Drowned' Comes To Home Video". Billboard. Retrieved October 24, 2015.
- Singh, Anita (November 7, 2008). "Britney and Madonna duet on stage". The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved June 22, 2016.
- Vaziri, Aidin (October 29, 2008). "Madonna Makes Like Slash on Sticky and Sweet Tour". Gibson.com. Retrieved June 26, 2016.
- Kreps, Daniel (June 10, 2008). "Britney Spears' Madonna Tour Video Revealed". Rolling Stone. ISSN 0035-791X.
- Dinh, James (October 21, 2009). "Madonna: Britney Spears' 'Human Nature' Cameo Was Comment On Her Career". MTV News. Retrieved November 1, 2015.
- Carter, Kelley L. (November 9, 2008). "Britney, Justin back up Madonna at L.A. concert". USA Today. Retrieved February 24, 2010.
- Schrodt, Paul (October 29, 2008). "Madonna (Chicago, IL – October 27, 2008)". Slant Magazine. Retrieved June 26, 2016.
- Madonna (2010). Sticky & Sweet Tour (CD/DVD). Warner Bros. Live Nation. Semtex Films. 9362-49728-4.
- Cinquemani, Sal (September 7, 2012). "Madonna: New York, NY – September 6, 2012". Slant Magazine. Retrieved June 26, 2016.
- "Madonna Nipple: Singer Flashes Nipple At Istanbul Concert (NSFW VIDEO)". The Huffington Post. June 10, 2012. Retrieved November 1, 2015.
- Wilkinson, Sophie (June 9, 2012). "Madonna Flashes During Instanbul Gig". Heat World. Retrieved November 1, 2015.
- Vendenburgh, Barbara (October 22, 2012). "Madonna's 'MDNA' tour anything but variety act in Phoenix". The Arizona Republic. Retrieved June 27, 2016.
- Odell, Amy (June 2012). "Leave Madonna's 53-Year-Old Breast Alone". The Huffington Post. Retrieved July 23, 2012.
- Erlewine, Stephen Thomas (September 10, 2013). "MDNA World Tour – Madonna". AllMusic. Retrieved February 12, 2014.
- Horowitz, Steven J. (April 13, 2015). "Drake Sucks Face with Madonna During Hit-and-Miss Coachella Set". Billboard. Retrieved May 14, 2015.
- ‹See Tfm› "Human Nature" (UK Cassette single liner notes). Madonna. Maverick Records. 1995. 5439 17775 4.
- ‹See Tfm› "Human Nature" (UK 12" single liner notes). Madonna. Maverick Records. 1995. 9362 43583 0.
- ‹See Tfm› "Human Nature" (Germany CD maxi single liner notes). Madonna. Maverick Records. 1995. WO300CD.
- ‹See Tfm› "Human Nature" (Canada CD maxi single liner notes). Madonna. Maverick Records. 1995. CD 41880.
- ‹See Tfm› "Human Nature" (Australia CD maxi single liner notes). Madonna. Maverick Records. 1995. 9362-43556-2.
- ‹See Tfm› "Human Nature" (US CD single liner notes). Madonna. Maverick Records. 1995. 9 17882-2.
- ‹See Tfm› "Human Nature" (US Cassette single liner notes). Madonna. Maverick Records. 1995. 9-17882-4.
- ‹See Tfm› "Human Nature" (US 7" single liner notes). Madonna. Maverick Records. 1995. 7-17882.
- ‹See Tfm› "Human Nature" (US 12" maxi single liner notes). Madonna. Maverick Records. 1995. 9 41880-0.
- ‹See Tfm› "Human Nature" (Germany 12" single liner notes). Madonna. Maverick Records. 1995. 9362-43536-0.
- "Italiancharts.com – Madonna – Human Nature". Top Digital Download. Retrieved July 18, 2015.
- "Archive Chart: 1995-08-20". Scottish Singles Top 40. Retrieved June 12, 2015.
- "Madonna – Chart history" Billboard Pop Songs for Madonna. Retrieved July 18, 2015.
- "Madonna – Chart history" Billboard Rhythmic Songs for Madonna. Retrieved July 18, 2015.
- "The Year in Music 1995" (PDF). Billboard. p. YE-44. Retrieved June 26, 2016.
- Beebe, Roger; Middleton, Jason (2007). Medium Cool: Music Videos from Soundies to Cellphones. Duke University Press. ISBN 9780822341628.
- Feldman, Christopher (2000). Billboard Book of Number 2 Singles. Watson-Guptill. ISBN 0-8230-7695-4.
- Nyman, Jake (2005). Suomi soi 4: Suuri suomalainen listakirja [Finland list of Songs and chartings] (in Finnish). Helsinki: Tammi. ISBN 951-31-2503-3.
- O'Brien, Lucy (2008). Madonna: Like an Icon. Bantam Press. ISBN 978-0-552-15361-4.
- Rettenmund, Matthew (2016). Encyclopedia Madonnica 20. Boyculture Publications. ISBN 978-0-692-51557-0.
- Rooksby, Rikky (2004). The Complete Guide to the Music of Madonna. Omnibus Press. ISBN 0-7119-9883-3.
- Taraborrelli, Randy J. (2008). Madonna: An Intimate Biography. Simon & Schuster. ISBN 978-1416583462.
- Vernallis, Carol (2004). Experiencing Music Video: Aesthetics and Cultural Context. Columbia University Press. ISBN 9780231508452.
- Wade, Chris (2016). The Music of Madonna. Wisdom Twins Books. ISBN 978-1-326-53580-3.