I'm Going to Tell You a Secret
|I'm Going to Tell You a Secret|
|Directed by||Jonas Åkerlund|
|Country of origin||United States|
|Running time||121 minutes|
|Budget||$1 million ($1.27 in 2016 dollars)|
|Original release||October 21, 2005|
I'm Going to Tell You a Secret is a 2005 American documentary film that follows singer-songwriter Madonna on her 2004 Re-Invention World Tour. Directed by Jonas Åkerlund, the film premiered on MTV on October 21, 2005, and was released on DVD on June 20, 2006, by Warner Bros. Records. The documentary was originally called The Re-Invented Process, referencing the tour and the Steven Klein exhibition titled X-STaTIC Pro=CeSS. It starts with imagery from the exhibition and Madonna auditioning dancers for the tour, continues with her entourage travelling through different cities and performing, the singer's introspection on her life, her marriage, her religion, and her children, and ends with Madonna's visit to Israel in the midst of protests.
The documentary was inspired by Madonna's need to show her artistic side on the tour and her devotion towards the Jewish mysticism Kabbalah. Unlike her 1991 documentary Truth or Dare, which portrayed Hollywood glamour, I'm Going to Tell You a Secret clarified from its beginning that it was about the singer's personal views on life and spirituality. Like Truth or Dare, the performance scenes were shot in color, while the rest of the film was in black-and-white. Besides Madonna, her dancers and her tour entourage, Åkerlund also shot her family, her working process and her day-to-day life. Madonna and her then-husband Guy Ritchie's local pub in Mayfair, London was used for some sequences. The film features appearances from Madonna's father, stepmother and filmmaker Michael Moore.
Before releasing the documentary, Madonna invited a select group of friends and co-workers to watch a rough three-hour cut of the film at a local theater in Notting Hill. The film was trimmed after negative feedback regarding excessive details about Kabbalah. For the promotion and premiere of the film, Madonna appeared at Q&A sessions with the press and also gave a speech to film students at New York's Hunter College. Critical response to I'm Going to Tell You a Secret was mixed, with reviewers complimenting the live performances and the scenes involving her children and family, but criticizing the self-indulgent and preachy nature. I'm Going to Tell You a Secret was released in a two-disc format, a CD with 14 songs from the show and a DVD with the documentary film. It received a positive response from critics but was a moderate success commercially.
The documentary begins with scenes from the X-STaTIC Pro=CeSS, with Madonna featured as a queen sitting beside a coyote. The intro is followed by the singer recording vocals with music director Stuart Price and auditioning dancers for the Re-Invention World Tour.
After the first show of the tour at The Forum in Inglewood, California, Madonna attends a party with her dancers celebrating the success of the opening night. The tour moves to New York City with more rehearsal footage and Madonna asking her dancers to register for voting in the upcoming elections. Guy Ritchie jokes around with Madonna as she gets ready for the performance at Madison Square Garden, while Michael Moore appears in an interview segment, recalling how Madonna thanked him during the concert for his documentary.
In Chicago, Madonna's father Tony Ciccone is interviewed in his vineyard; he recalls Madonna's childhood. Ciccone and his wife Joan come to visit the singer at her concert in United Center. The entourage moves to Miami where Ritchie is shown angling with their son Rocco, plays with her daughter Lourdes, and Madonna reflects on relationships and her husband. By the time the tour reaches London, Madonna gets irritated with the journeys. Kabbalah comes into the picture with explanations of the mystical practice from Madonna and her teacher Eitan. At Slane Castle, Dublin, Madonna and her dancers were in danger of being electrocuted due to constant rain, but she nevertheless continued the performances.
In Paris, Madonna takes her dancers for a classical piano recital by Katia and Marielle Labèque. After the performance at Palais Omnisports de Paris-Bercy, the tour reaches its final stop at Lisbon. The dancers are shown enjoying the beach and talking about their future plans. With a final performance of "Holiday", the Re-Invention World Tour ends. At an after party, Madonna recites a poem for her assistant Angie.
The final segment of the documentary shows Madonna arriving at Tel Aviv, Israel, amidst protests of her visit. She gives a speech at a benefit for her charity foundation, Spirituality For Kids. She speaks of compassion, peace and giving children all the benefits that they deserve. Then Madonna visits Rachel's Tomb on the outskirts of Bethlehem and offers her prayers. The documentary ends then, with a parting shot of an Israeli child and a Palestinian child walking down a road together as Madonna's voice over tells that the audience has learnt her "secret".
Background of tour
The Re-Invention World Tour was the sixth concert tour by Madonna. It supported her ninth studio album American Life, and visited North America and Europe. Madonna was inspired to create the tour, after taking part in an art installation called X-STaTIC PRo=CeSS, directed by photographer Steven Klein. A number of songs were rehearsed for the tour, with twenty-four of them making the final setlist. The tour was divided into five segments: French Baroque-Marie Antionette Revival, Military-Army, Circus-Cabaret, Acoustic and Scottish-Tribal. The costumes were developed by designer Arianne Phillips based on the concept of re-invention. The opening segment displayed performances with dance in general. Military segment displayed performances with the theme of warfare. Circus displayed light-hearted performances while the Acoustic segment performances were melancholy. The final Scottish segment had Madonna and her performers display energetic dance routines.
The tour garnered positive reception from contemporary critics. However, fellow singer Elton John accused Madonna of lip-synching on the tour. Madonna's representatives denied the allegations and John later apologized. The Re-Invention World Tour was a commercial success. Tickets were completely sold as soon as dates and venues for the tour were announced, prompting the organizers to add more dates. After conclusion, it was named the highest-grossing concert tour of 2004, earning $125 million ($158.50 million in 2016 dollars) from 56 shows with an audience 900,000. It won the honor of Top Tour at the 2004 Billboard Touring Awards.
Concept and development
The tour was chronicled in the documentary titled I'm Going to Tell You a Secret. Originally called The Re-Invented Process in reference to the tour and the exhibition X-STaTIC Pro=CeSS, the documentary was filmed during Madonna's visit to North America and Europe from May 24 to September 14, 2004. It was directed by Jonas Åkerlund, whose previous endeavors included music videos, commercials and the cult film, Spun (2003). The documentary emerged from Madonna's urge to show her artistic side on the tour and her devotion towards the Jewish mysticism Kabbalah. Unlike her 1991 documentary, Truth or Dare, which portrayed Hollywood glamour, I'm Going to Tell You a Secret clarified from its beginning that it was about the singer's views on life and spirituality. "It's a different me, I have a husband, I have a family, my whole life has changed. It would be pretty strange if I was behaving the same way I did 12 years ago — that would be a little freaky. No more Evian bottles!", Madonna told MTV, with the last bit referring to a scene of her performing fellatio on an Evian bottle in Truth or Dare.
Like Truth or Dare, the performance scenes were shot in color, while the rest of the documentary was in black-and-white. Besides Madonna, her dancers and her tour entourage, Åkerlund also shot her family, her working process and her day-to-day life. Locations shot included Madonna and her husband Guy Ritchie's local pub in Mayfair, London. There was also an appearance from filmmaker Michael Moore, her father Tony Ciccone and stepmother Joan Ciccone. In some scenes, Ritchie was shown missing some of Madonna's concerts and going out for drinks, which drove the singer to tears. In December 2005, Madonna told Rolling Stone:
[My relationship with Guy] came off as peculiar [in the documentary]. Not a typical relationship. A lot of macho men see the movie and like Guy's character, because he doesn't give me any special treatment. I think we come off as a couple that has that has a genuine and deep connection. He is always there for me, but he's not impressed. I feel like we are sort of The Honeymooners, only I'm the Jackie Gleason character. Obviously, he irritates me on a significant basis, as everyone's significant other does.
Referring to the incidents in the pub, Madonna explained her view on relationships where a man has to travel with his wife, while giving an example of her friend, actress Gwyneth Paltrow. She said that it was easier for Paltrow to tour with her then-husband Chris Martin, who is the lead singer of the alternative rock band, Coldplay. Madonna also recalled her troubled relationship with her father and how he had e-mailed the singer with his approval, after watching the documentary. Kabbalah featured prominently towards the end and the singer wanted to embark on a spiritual pilgrimage to Israel. However, ultra-orthodox Jews protested her trip, saying that Madonna disgraced Judaism with her portrayal of wearing phylacteries over her arm—a Jewish custom usually reserved for men—in the music video of her 2002 single "Die Another Day", before escaping from an electric chair on which Hebrew letters spell out one of the 72 sacred names of God. Although Israeli securities had advised the singer against the trip, she nevertheless visited graves of Jewish sages in northern Israel as well as shrines such as Rachel's Tomb on the edge of Bethlehem, traditional burial place of the biblical matriarch Rachel.
Production and release
Moore had initially offered to direct the documentary, though Madonna enlisted Åkerlund as director since Moore was busy with his own project, Fahrenheit 9/11. Moore later said that he could help around with the editing and advised Madonna to shoot "as much content as possible". I'm Going to Tell You a Secret was an important film for Madonna, who was determined to show her matured persona through the documentary. She had a meagre budget of one million ($1.27 million in 2016 dollars) for production. The singer had to spend time in the editing room with Åkerlund, analyzing all the shots and creating the final version. Side-by-side Madonna had also started working on her tenth studio album, Confessions on a Dance Floor, juggling time between editing the film and recording. Madonna had to fly to Stockholm for the editing and described pruning the 350-hour footage into a two-hour documentary as "exhaustive". She recalled her thoughts during that time:
I was sitting there in the theater at the back, showing it to people for the first time. I mean, it was like a puddle of sweat around my feet. It was like, 'Oh my God, oh my God, I hope I did the right thing. Oh, that scene is too long. Oh, that's too short. Are they going to get this part? Are they going to like this? Oh, they're going to think it's boring!' Just worrying the whole way, biting my fingernails off.
Before releasing the film, Madonna invited a group of friends and co-workers to watch a rough three-hour cut of the film at a local theater in Notting Hill, and noted their feedback. General consensus was that there was too much of Kabbalah in the film, hence she decided to prune those segments considerably. The documentary premiered on MTV in the United States, on October 21, 2005, at 10:00 PM. She also showed it to the film students at New York's Hunter College and appeared for a Q&A session. This promotion was a part of mtvU's Stand In series, in which celebrities filled in for college professors.
In the United Kingdom, the documentary premiered on Channel 4 on December 14, 2005. I'm Going to Tell You a Secret was not released commercially and was only viewed on MTV and Channel 4. Åkerlund told BlackBook that he wished more people had the chance to see the documentary because according to him, it is "a really strong piece of art, if you ask me..... it had a lot of my blood, sweat and tears in it."
I'm Going to Tell You a Secret received mixed reviews from critics. O'Brien noted how the film revealed a "strange isolation at the cost of stardom" from Madonna. She complimented the scenes featuring her father, and the scenes where Madonna was not self-conscious, like when she interacts with her children, talks about her "fat Italian thighs" and also the performance in rain at Dublin. O'Brien criticized other portions of the film, which she said was "affected" by conscious behavior in front of the camera, like backstage parties, poem and piano recitals. Author J. Randy Taraborrelli wrote in his book Madonna: An Intimate Biography that the film allowed a much closer look at the singer's family. He was particularly impressed by the scenes featuring Lourdes, believing that she "revealed herself to be sophisticated beyond her years". Kathryn Flett from The Observer newspaper described it as "Fascinating, [it has] tiny flashes of insight into her relationship with [Ritchie], which occasionally involve her being just as girlie and ever so slightly insecure as the rest of us." Rupert Smith from The Guardian reported that the director "squeezed every last drop of spectacle from a highly stage-managed performance", but commented that "she gave away far more in 1991's In Bed with Madonna; this time she gave only the illusion of candour". However, he complimented saying "Even the easy-to-mock pre-show prayers brought a tear to the eye. We don't need to be told that 'there's more to life than fame and fortune – something deeper, more profound', or that 'the material world' is a bad thing. But it's good to see an entertainer who, 20 years into her career, is still trying to change the world".
Barry Walters from Rolling Stone mentioned that I'm Going to Tell You a Secret "lacks the dishy delights of the diva's 1991 Truth or Dare doc. Instead, a more worldly Madge struggles to become a less sound-bite-reliant, more sincere person." Darryl Sterdan from Jam! gave it three out of five stars, saying that "it still sucks to sit through all that video and see almost as much of her limo as her show... For a start, how about giving us a [movie] that isn't derivative and self-indulgent?" Colin Jacobson from the DVD Movie Guide website opined that I'm Going to Tell You a Secret would find a divided audience and how one reacted to the documentary was a reflection of how one viewed Madonna. "Fans like me will be able to essentially ignore the self-serving moments and enjoy the tour elements. We'll also like the glimpse behind the curtain at Madonna on the road," he added. This view was shared by a reviewer from Lexington Herald-Leader who confessed that he did not enjoy the documentary except the live performances, since he saw Madonna only as an "entertainer" and not as a "preacher".
While reviewing Madonna: The Confessions Tour Live TV debut in 2007, Ginia Bellafante from The New York Times recalled the scenes of Madonna hugging her assistants and dancers and her wishing to be nicer to people she had met. She said that probably Madonna knew that many in her audience missed the "Madonna of so many Madonnas ago, the one who refused refinement and probably thought Oxford was just an insurance company." Stephen Thomas Erlewine from AllMusic believed that the documentary served its purpose well. "It will convince anybody who is on the fence about going out to see the 2006 tour to go ahead and buy those expensive tickets already," he added.
Stephen M. Deusner from Pitchfork panned the release, saying that "[Madonna's] life as portrayed in this documentary is cloistered and withdrawn, marked by hours of quiet Kabbalah study but very little self-reflection. Whether intentionally or not, Åkerlund reveals Madonna's supreme lack of self-awareness, from her embarrassing attempts at poetry to the condescending tone she takes with her dancers to her incredibly irresponsible visit to Rachel's Tomb despite the warnings of her host country and her security team." He ended the review noting that Madonna did not need to prove anything further, since her songs "have become a shared language among people who have very little common ground. Her music has been changing the world for more than two decades now, but sadly she seems unaware of this, her one true 'secret' to pop cultural unity."
I'm Going to Tell You a Secret was released in a two-disc format, a CD with 14 songs from the show and a DVD with the documentary film. The documentary and the album were also released as digital download to the iTunes Store. The live CD consisted of two pre-recorded tracks, "The Beast Within" and "Hollywood" while extras on the DVD included 12 deleted scenes from the documentary. The release received positive response from critics and was nominated for a Grammy Award at the 2007 show in the category of Best Long Form Music Video, but ended up losing the award to Wings for Wheels: The Making of Born to Run by Bruce Springsteen. It was a moderate success commercially, reaching the top-ten of the music charts in Belgium, Canada, France, Germany, Italy and Switzerland, while the DVD topped the video charts in Australia, Spain and the United States.
- Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Community Development Project. "Consumer Price Index (estimate) 1800–". Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis. Retrieved January 2, 2017.
- O'Brien 2008, p. 437
- Greig, Geordie (December 2005). "Madonna All Loved Up". Tatler. Archived from the original on December 4, 2005. Retrieved July 4, 2013.
- O'Brien 2008, p. 440
- "Madonna Reinvented For The Very Last Time". Vogue. August 2005. Retrieved July 1, 2013.
- O'Brien 2008, p. 441
- O'Brien 2008, p. 442
- Garfield, Simon (November 20, 2005). "Looks good on the dancefloor". The Observer. Retrieved July 1, 2013.
- Timmerman 2007, p. 23
- Lieberman, Rhonda (May 1, 2003). "Weighty Madonna: Rhonda Lieberman on "X-STaTIC PRo=CeSS"". Slant Magazine. Retrieved October 29, 2009.
- Reporter, BBC (March 13, 2004). "Scots piper gets Madonna call-up". BBC News. British Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved October 29, 2009.
- Greene, Mark (November 9, 2004). "Madonna Ultimately". London Institute for Contemporary Christianity. Archived from the original on June 14, 2011. Retrieved October 29, 2009.
- Timmerman 2007, p. 30
- Cinquemani, Sal (August 9, 2004). "Madonna: Live @ Madison Square Garden". Slant Magazine. Retrieved October 30, 2009.
- Freydkin, Donna (May 25, 2004). "The many faces of Madonna". USA Today. Retrieved October 29, 2009.
- Segal, David (June 15, 2004). "Prime Madonna". The Washington Post. Katharine Weymouth. Retrieved October 29, 2009.
- Smith, Elizabeth (May 24, 2004). "Liz Smith review of the Re-Invention Tour". The New York Times. Arthur Ochs Sulzberger, Jr. Retrieved October 29, 2009.
- Hand, John (August 13, 2004). "Madonna's loyal following". BBC News. BBC. Retrieved October 30, 2009.
- Cosgrove-Mather, Booty (October 4, 2004). "Elton John: Stop Faking, Madonna". CBS News. CBS Corporation. Archived from the original on November 4, 2012. Retrieved October 30, 2009.
- Reporter, Business Wire (March 30, 2004). "Madonna's Re-invention Tour Sells out around the World; New Dates Are Added.". Business Wire. Associated Press. Retrieved October 30, 2009.
- Susman, Gary (June 1, 2004). "Madonna may have 2004's top-grossing tour". Entertainment Weekly. Retrieved October 30, 2009.
- Susman, Gary (December 14, 2004). "Mother of 'Re-Invention'". Entertainment Weekly. Retrieved October 30, 2009.
- Trust, Gary (November 4, 2004). "Madonna Tour Gets Top 'Backstage Pass' Honor". Billboard. Nielsen Business Media, Inc. Retrieved July 13, 2008.
- "Re – Invention named Top Tour in Billboard awards". Madonna.com. November 5, 2004. Retrieved October 30, 2009.
- Rush, George (May 25, 2005). "Madonna Film 'Truth Or Who Cares'?". Daily News. New York. Retrieved October 30, 2009.
- Vineyard, Jennifer (October 18, 2005). "Madonna's All Grown Up In New Doc: 'No More Evian Bottles!'". MTV News. Viacom. Retrieved July 2, 2013.
- Scheiffeld, Rob (December 1, 2005). "Madonna: How She Got Her Groove Back". Rolling Stone. 988 (51). ISSN 0035-791X. Retrieved July 1, 2013.
- "Is Israel ready for Madonna?". The Sydney Morning Herald. September 16, 2004. Retrieved June 29, 2013.
- Todd, Matthew (November 22, 2005). "Madonna: Confessions of an Icon". Attitude. Attitude Media Ltd (133): 43. ISSN 1057-1248.
- "Documentary a nail-biter for Madonna". Daily Times. Media Times Ltd. October 24, 2005. Archived from the original on February 16, 2006. Retrieved July 10, 2013.
- Eye, Red (October 19, 2005). "Moral of the story". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved July 10, 2013.
- "Stand In: Madonna". mtvU. Viacom. Archived from the original on March 17, 2009. Retrieved August 18, 2014.
- Haramis, Nick (July 9, 2009). "Jonas Åkerlund Directs Madonna's New Video, Female Bodybuilders". BlackBook. Retrieved July 10, 2013.
- O'Brien 2008, p. 439
- Taraborrelli 2008, p. 418
- Flett, Kathryn (December 4, 2005). "Television: I'm Going To Tell You A Secret". The Observer. London. Retrieved August 11, 2010.
- Smith, Rupert (December 2, 2005). "Last night's TV". The Guardian. London. Retrieved July 4, 2013.
- Walters, Barry (June 12, 2006). "Madonna: I'm Going to Tell You a Secret". Rolling Stone. Archived from the original on April 18, 2009. Retrieved August 11, 2010.
- Sterdan, Darryl (June 29, 2006). "Album Review: I'm Going to Tell You a Secret". Jam!. Canadian Online Explorer. Retrieved July 10, 2013.
- Jacobson, Colin (March 13, 2007). "Madonna: I'm Going To Tell You A Secret (2006)". DVD Movie Guide. Retrieved July 10, 2013.
- "The Mother Of Re-Invention, Madonna's Changes, Choices Speak To A Generation". Lexington Herald-Leader. November 17, 2005. Retrieved July 10, 2013.
- Bellafonte, Ginia (November 24, 2006). "Madonna: The Confessions Tour Live". The New York Times. Arthur Ochs Sulzberger, Jr. Retrieved July 10, 2013.
- Erlewine, Stephen Thomas (June 20, 2006). "I'm Going to Tell You a Secret > Madonna". AllMusic. Rovi Corporation. Retrieved August 8, 2012.
- Deusner, Stephen M. (July 7, 2006). "Madonna: I'm Going to Tell You a Secret". Pitchfork Media. Retrieved August 8, 2012.
- Carter, Kelly (December 8, 2006). "Local Grammy Nominees". Detroit Free Press. Retrieved August 11, 2010.
- "Madonna – I'm Going To Tell You A Secret" (in French). Ultratop. Hung Medien. Retrieved July 10, 2013.
- "Eurocharts – Single Sales". Billboard. New York. 118 (27): 4, 65–66. July 8, 2006. ISSN 0006-2510.
- O'Brien, Lucy (2008), Madonna: Like an Icon, Bantam Press, ISBN 9780552153614
- Taraborrelli, Randy J. (2008), Madonna: An Intimate Biography, Simon & Schuster, ISBN 9780330454469
- Timmerman, Dirk (2007), Madonna Live! Secret Re-inventions and Confessions on Tour, Maklu Publications Inc, ISBN 9085950023