I Should Be Proud

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
"I Should Be Proud"
Single by Martha and the Vandellas
from the album Natural Resources
A-side "I Should Be Proud"
B-side "Love, Guess Who"
Released 1970 (1970)
Genre Soul
Writer(s) Henry Cosby
Pam Sawyer
Joe Hinton
Martha and the Vandellas singles chronology
"Taking My Love (And Leaving Me)"
"I Should Be Proud"
"I Gotta Let You Go"

"I Should Be Proud" is a 1970 protest song written by Henry Cosby, Pam Sawyer and Joe Hinton and recorded by Motown girl group Martha and the Vandellas. Though not a big hit (peaking at #80 pop and #45 R&B),[1][2] the song was noted for being the first released Motown protest song (released in February of the year), just months before the releases of Edwin Starr's "War" and The Temptations' "Ball of Confusion".

The song had the narrator talk of how she was devastated on hearing the news that her loved one, who had been fighting in the Vietnam War, had been shot and killed in action. Instead of being proud that her loved one had "fought for her", as people around her were claiming, all she wanted was him and not his honors for fighting the war, exclaiming that the man, disguised as "Private Johnny C. Miller", had been "fightin' for the evils of society". On the MSNBC program, Headliners And Legends: Martha & The Vandellas, Reeves commented that this song was pulled off many radio stations' playlists due to its controversial "anti-war" message during the height of the Vietnam War. Lead singer Martha Reeves took the song personally, recounting that one of her brothers had died in a Vietnam War-related incident. It was the first release off the Vandellas' Natural Resources Motown LP.


See also[edit]


  1. ^ Whitburn, Joel (2004). Top R&B/Hip-Hop Singles: 1942-2004. Record Research. p. 378. 
  2. ^ I Should Be Proud at Allmusic