Insecticidal soap is based on potassium fatty acids and is used to control many plant pests. Because insecticidal soap works on only direct contact with the pests, it is sprayed on plants in a way so the entire plant is wetted. Soaps have a low mammalian toxicity and are therefore considered safe to be used around children and pets and may be used in organic farming.
Insecticidal soap should be based on long-chain fatty acids (10–18 carbon atoms), because shorter-chain fatty acids tend to be damaging for the plant (phytotoxicity). Short (8-carbon) fatty-acid chains occur for example in coconut oil and palm oil and soaps based on those oils. Recommended concentrations are typically in the range 1–2 percent. One manufacturer recommends a concentration of 0.06% to 0.25% (pure soap equivalent) for most agricultural applications.; another one recommends concentrations of 0.5 to 1% pure soap equivalent. In the European Union, fatty acid potassium salts are registered and allowed as insecticide at a 2% concentration.
Insecticidal soap is sold commercially for aphid control. Labels on these products may not always use the word soap, but they will list "potassium salts of fatty acids" or "potassium laurate" as the active ingredient. Certain types of household soaps (not synthetic detergents) are also suitable, but it may be difficult to tell the composition and water content from the label. Potassium-based soaps are typically soft or liquid.
Mechanism of action
- Soap, which enters via the insect's trachea, may disrupt cell membranes, resulting in the cell contents leaking from the damaged cells (cytolysis).
- Soap may dissolve the wax layer on the cuticle ("skin"), which leads to water loss by evaporation.
- Soap may block breathing openings or trachea, which leads to suffocation.
- Soap may interfere with growth hormones.
- Soap may affect insect metabolism.
Insecticidal soap works best on soft-bodied insects and arthropods such as aphids, adelgids, mealybugs, spider mites, thrips, jumping plant lice, scale insects, whiteflies, and sawfly larvae. It can also be used for caterpillars and leafhoppers, but these large-bodied insects can be more difficult to control with soaps alone. Many pollinators and predatory insects such as lady beetles, bumblebees, and hoverflies are relatively unaffected. However, soap will kill predatory mites that may help control spider mites. Also, the soft-bodied aphid-eating larvae of lady beetles, lacewing, and hoverflies may be affected negatively. According to one study a single soap application killed about 15% of lacewing and lady-beetle larvae, and about 65% of predatory mites (Amblyseius andersoni).
Green peach aphids are difficult to control since they reproduce quickly (one adult female can deposit up to four nymphs per day) because they tend to reside under the leaves and in leaf axils ("leaf armpits"), where they may not be wetted by a soap spray. Manufacturers indeed state that their insecticidal soaps are only suitable for controlling green peach aphids if used in combination with another insecticide, whereas the same soaps can control other aphids on their own. Among green peach aphids that are in contact with a 2% soap solution, around 95% of the adults and 98% of nymphs die within 48 hours. At 0.75% concentration, the mortality rates are reduced to 75% and 90%, respectively.
Since 2011, insecticidal soap has also been approved in the United States for use against powdery mildew. In the European pesticide registration, its use as an insecticide is listed for aphids, white fly, and spider mites. At different concentrations, it may also be used against algae and moss.
Insecticidal soap solution will only kill pests on contact; it has no residual action against aphids that arrive after it has dried. Therefore, the infested plants must be thoroughly wetted. Repeated applications may be necessary to adequately control high populations of pests.
Soap spray may damage plants, especially at higher concentrations or at temperatures above 32 °C (90 °F). Plant injury may not be apparent until two days after application. Some plant species are particularly sensitive to soap sprays. Highly sensitive plants include: horse chestnut, Japanese maple (Acer), Sorbus aucuparia (mountain ash), Cherimoya fruit, Lamprocapnos (bleeding heart), and sweet pea. Other sensitive plants are, for example: Portulaca, some tomato varieties, Crataegus (hawthorn), cherries, plum, Adiantum (maidenhair fern), Euphorbia milii (crown of thorns), Lantana camara, Tropaeolum (nasturtium), Gardenia jasminoides, Lilium longiflorum (Easter lily). Conifers under (drought) stress or with tender new growth are sensitive as well.
Damage may occur as yellow or brown spotting on the leaves, burned tips, or leaf scorch. Plants under drought stress, young transplants, unrooted cuttings and plants with soft young growth tend to be more sensitive. Sensitivity may be tested on a small portion of a plant or plot before a full-scale application.
One manufacturer recommends that applications are done with 7- to 14-day intervals, with a maximum of three applications, as repeated applications may aggravate phytotoxicity. In addition, water conditioning agents can increase phytotoxicity.
- “Soaps” and Detergents: Should They Be Used on Roses? R.A. Cloyd, American Rose Society (2018).
- Insect Control: Soaps and Detergents. W.S. Cranshaw, University of Colorado. March 2008.
- Aphids: Integrated Pest Management for Home Gardeners and Landscape Professionals. M.L. Flint, University of California Davis, July 2013.
- Insecticidal Soaps for Garden Pest Control. J. D. Ubl, Clemson University, July 2009.
- Pesticide product label for Super insecticidal soap concentrate. US Environmental protection agency, July 2011.
- According to the Super insecticidal soap concentrate label above: 0.5 pint of a 25% concentrate per 25 gallons = 0.06%.
- Pesticide product label for M-Pede insecticide miticide fungicide. US Environmental protection agency, July 2011.
- Fatty acids C7 to C20 Archived 2015-04-19 at the Wayback Machine. EU-database voor pesticides.
- Review report for the active substance Fatty Acids C7 to C20 Archived 2015-04-19 at the Wayback Machine. Europese Commissie (2013).
- Insecticidal Soaps - Modes of Action (video). L.L. Keeley (20 Aug 2013).
- Toxicity of biopesticides to green apple aphid, predatory insects and mite in an apple-tree orchard. L. Raudonis et al., Zemdirbyste-Agriculture, vol. 97, No. 1 (2010), p. 49–54.
- Toxicity effects of an insecticidal soap on the green peach aphid Archived 2015-04-02 at the Wayback Machine. E. Tremblay et al., Phytoprotection 90: 35-39 (2009).