Islam in Spain

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Islam in Spain
Allah-green.svg
Statue of Averroes, an Islamic philosopher from Al-Andalus whose commentaries on Aristotle were a powerful influence on Scholasticism and Saint Thomas Aquinas[1]
Statue of Averroes, an Islamic philosopher from Al-Andalus whose commentaries on Aristotle were a powerful influence on Scholasticism and Saint Thomas Aquinas[1]
Total population
2,091,656 (4.45 %) in 2019
Regions with significant populations
In absolute frequencies: Catalonia, Andalusia, Community of Madrid, Valencian Community, Region of Murcia
Religions
Sunni Islam (majority), Shia Islam (minority)
Languages
Main: Spanish, Arabic, Berber and others

Islam was a widespread religion on the Iberian Peninsula, beginning with the Umayyad conquest of Hispania and ending (at least overtly) with its prohibition by the modern Spanish state in the mid-16th century and the expulsion of the Moriscos in the early 17th century, an ethnic and religious minority of around 500,000 people.[2] Although a significant proportion of Moriscos returned to Spain or avoided expulsion through various means, the practice of Islam had faded into obscurity by the 19th century.[3]

Nevertheless, throughout modern history there has always been a constant presence of Muslims in Spain, many of whom were former slaves (known as 'moros cortados') freed in the early 18th century.[citation needed] Furthermore, Spain's proximity to North Africa and its small land border with the Kingdom of Morocco (as well as Spanish colonial rule in North Africa which lasted from 1912 to 1975) made the Muslim presence in Spain possible. Moroccan Muslims played a significant role during Spain's Civil War (1936–1939), fighting on the Nationalist side, including a Lieutenant General named Mohamed Meziane, a close friend of General Francisco Franco, who later became Captain General of Ceuta, Galicia and governor of the Canary Islands during his post-war career.

Moroccans were not required to have a visa in order to enter Spain until 1985. This however changed with Spain's growing economic development and its entry into the European Union, after which stricter immigration controls were imposed. Immigration to Spain exploded in the 1990s, with Moroccans of both sexes arriving in large numbers and becoming Spain's first important economic immigrant community. In the 2000s, migrants started arriving in some numbers from other Muslim-majority countries (as well as from Latin America and Eastern Europe). Nowadays the Muslim population in Spain, which represents the 4.45% of the total Spanish population, is composed of 42% Spanish citizens (most of them with foreign family origins) and 38,8% Moroccans[4](see chapter 2).

History[edit]

The Great Mosque of Córdoba one of many former mosques turned church after the Reconquista.

Conquest[edit]

Hispania was the Latin name which was given to the whole Iberian Peninsula, and after the fall of the Western Roman Empire (476) the Teutonic tribe of Visigoths ended up ruling the whole peninsula until the Islamic conquest (during that time they pushed another Teutonic tribe out—the Vandals – and conquered another one—the Suevi). It is frequently stated in historical sources that Spain was one of the former Roman provinces where the Latin language and culture grew deep roots. After the fall of the Empire, the Visigoths continued the tradition by becoming what was probably the most Romanized Teutonic tribe. Under Visigothic rule Spain was filled with extreme instability due to lack of communication between the native Spaniards and the new rulers, who followed the Germanic notion of kingship. Visigothic kings were considered the first among equals (the nobility), and they could easily be overthrown if they did not keep the different factions happy.

News of the political unrest which existed from the late 6th century through the early 8th century was eventually received by the rulers of the growing Islamic empire which existed along the North African coast. Several historical sources state that the Islamic caliphate had not actually targeted the Visigothic Kingdom for conquest, but political divisions within it created an opportunity which was successfully exploited by an army which was led by the Muslim general Tariq ibn-Ziyad. The last Visigoth king, Roderick, was not considered a legitimate ruler by all of the inhabitants of the Spanish Kingdom, and some Visigothic nobles aided the Islamic conquest of Spain. One name frequently mentioned is Count Julian of Ceuta who invited Tariq ibn-Ziyad to invade southern Spain because his daughter had been raped by King Roderick.

On April 30, 711, Muslim General Tariq ibn-Ziyad landed at Gibraltar and by the end of the campaign most of the Iberian Peninsula (except for small areas in the north-west such as Asturias and the Basque territory) were brought under Islamic rule.[5] This campaign's turning point was the battle of Guadalete, where the last Visigothic king, Roderick, was defeated by general Tariq ibn-Ziyad. Roderick ceases the throne in the year 711, and is later executed by Tariq ibn-Ziyad. After the defeat of Roderick, the Visigoth dominion over the Iberian peninsula folded and fell apart from the Northern coast of the Iberian Peninsula, and the province of Septimania (an area of France going from the Pyrenees to Provence), all areas previously under the rule of the Visigoths were now under Islamic rule. Muslim forces attempted to move north-east across the Pyrenees Mountains toward France, but were defeated by the Frankish Christian Charles Martel at the Battle of Tours in 732.

Islamic rule of the Iberian peninsula lasted for varying periods of time which ranged from only 28 years in the extreme northwest (Galicia) to 781 years in the area which surrounded the city of Granada in the southeast. This Empire added contributions to society such as libraries, schools, public bathrooms, literature, poetry, and architecture. This work was mainly developed through the unification of people of all faiths.[6] While the three major monotheistic religious traditions certainly did borrow from one another in Al-Andalus, benefiting especially by the blooming of philosophy and the medieval sciences in the Muslim Middle East, recent scholarship has brought into question the notion that the peaceful coexistence of Muslims, Jews, and Christians — known as the convivencia — could be defined as "pluralistic."[7] People of other religions could contribute to society and the culture developed in this time. The Muslim Empire did not enslave any non-Muslim groups under its rule nor influence them to convert to Islam. One of the reasons for such great success under this empire was the legal terms which they offered to the public, which were very different from the conditions which were implemented by the Visigoth kingdom which preceded it[8]

Moreover, the appearance of Sufism on the Iberian peninsula is especially important because Sufism's "greatest shaykh," Ibn 'Arabi, was himself from Murcia.

The topic of Convivencia remains a very hotly debated topic among scholars, with some of them believing that Spain was pluralistic under Muslim rule while others believe it was a very difficult place for non Muslims to live in. Those who believe that Muslim ruled Spain was pluralistic point to the audio narration in the Museum of The Three Cultures In Cordoba, Spain, where the audio narration says that when the East was not separated from the West, Muslims were not separated from Jews or Christians”.[9] Another Scholar argues that “It became possible to be a pious Jew who could recite a pre-Islamic ode or a homoerotic poem or take the peripatetic tradition seriously, in great measure because pious Muslims did it”.[9] The Muslim ruler Abd-al-Rahman III “worked directly with the Mozarabs, a controversial term which is generally used to refer to Christians who lived under Muslim rule, and placed them in positions of power. Furthermore, the Jews and Christians could practice their religions without fear of harassment or persecution.”[10] The Muslim rulers of Spain "relied on the Jews for diplomacy and public administration who were inaugurated into posts of commerce and played important roles in cities such as Toledo and Cordoba”.[10]

On the other side of the debate, many scholars believe that Muslim rule of Spain was far from a utopian society where all religions treated each other with respect. In fact, “Uprisings in Cordoba in 805 and 818 were answered with mass executions and the destruction of one of the city’s suburbs”.[9] In addition, in regard to Jews and Christians in Andalusia, “one 11th-century legal text called them members of “the devil’s party” and they “were subject to special taxes and, often, dress codes”.[9] Many scholars believe that this more benign view of convivencia “masks the very presence of institutional fundamentalism in medieval Spain – both its Jewish and Muslim manifestations in the nature of forced conversions, exile, lower standards of citizenship, higher taxation and violence”.[10] It seems that class distinctions also played a role in convivencia. In fact, “many of the lower echelons of Jewish and Christian society remained segregated or in conflict with their Abrahamic counterparts”.[10] Other Scholars believe that Christians and Jews were treated as second class citizens where “Under Muslim rule, especially following the arrival of the Almoravids and the Almohades, both Christianity and Judaism were scarcely tolerated and regarded as decidedly “inferior” religions”.[11]

Rule[edit]

In time Islamic migrants from places as diverse as North Africa to Yemen and Syria and Iran invaded territories in the Iberian peninsula. The Islamic rulers called the Iberian peninsula "Al-Andalus".

For a time, Al-Andalus was one of the great Muslim civilizations, reaching its summit with the Umayyad Caliphate in the 10th century. Al-Andalus[5] had the following chronological phases:

(Note: the dates when the different taifa kingdoms were annexed by Almoravids and Almohads vary)

The Madrasah of Granada was founded by the Nasrid dynasty monarch Yusuf I, Sultan of Granada in 1349 and housed many of the most greatest prominent scholars of the period.[12]

Reconquista[edit]

Moorish and Christian Reconquista battle, taken from The Cantigas de Santa María

After the disintegration of the Caliphate, Islamic control was gradually eroded by the Christian Reconquista. The Reconquista (Reconquest) was the process by which the Catholic Kingdoms of northern Spain eventually managed to succeed in defeating and conquering the Muslim states of the Iberian Peninsula. The first major city to fall to Catholic powers was Toledo in 1085,[13] which prompted the intervention of Almoravids. After the battle of Las Navas de Tolosa in 1212, most of Al-Andalus fell under control of the Catholic kingdoms, the only exception being the Nasrid dynasty Emirate of Granada. The Granada War (Guerra de Granada) of the Reconquista began in 1482 against the Emirate of Granada. It was not until 1492 that the Emirate of Granada with city of Granada and the Alhambra and Generalife Palaces, the last remaining Muslim territory in al-Andalus, fell in the Battle of Granada to forces of the Catholic Monarchs (los Reyes Catolicos), Queen Isabella I of Castile and her husband King Ferdinand II of Aragon.

After the Reconquista[edit]

The conquest was accompanied by the Treaty of Granada signed by Emir Muhammad XII of Granada, allowing the Spanish crown's new Muslim subjects a large measure of religious toleration. They were also allowed the continuing use of their own language, schools, laws and customs.[citation needed] But the interpretation of the royal edict was largely left to the local Catholic authorities. Hernando de Talavera, the first Archbishop of Granada after its Catholic conquest, took a fairly tolerant view.[citation needed]

However 1492 started the monarchy's reversal of freedoms beginning with the Alhambra Decree. This continued when Archbishop Talavera was replaced by the intolerant Cardinal Cisneros, who immediately organised a drive for mass forced conversions and burned publicly thousands of Arabic books (manuscripts).[14] Outraged by this breach of faith, in 1499 the Mudéjars rose in the First Rebellion of the Alpujarras, which was unsuccessful and only had the effect of giving Ferdinand and Isabella a pretext to revoke the promise of toleration. That same year, the Muslim leaders of Granada were ordered to hand over almost all of the remaining books in Arabic, most of which were burned. (Only medical manuscripts were spared; those manuscripts are in the Escorial library.) Beginning in Valencia in 1502, Muslims were offered the choice of baptism or exile. The option of exile was often not feasible in practice because of the difficulty in uprooting one's family and making the journey to Muslim lands in North Africa, the inability to pay the fee required by the authorities for safe passage, and the general tendency by the authorities to discourage and hinder such exodus.[15]

The Moors request permission from James I of Aragon

The majority therefore are forced to accept conversion, becoming known as "New Christians". Many of the New Christians (also called "Moriscos"), though outwardly Catholic, continued to adhere to their old beliefs in private as crypto-Muslims.[16] Responding to a plea from his co-religionists in Spain, in 1504 Ahmad ibn Abi Jum'ah, an Islamic scholar in North Africa, issued a fatwa, commonly named the "Oran fatwa", saying that Muslims may outwardly practice Christianity, as well as drink wine, eat pork and other forbidden things, if they were under compulsion to conform or persecution.[17] There were good reasons for this, for abstinence from wine or pork could, and did, cause people to be denounced to the Spanish Inquisition.

Coat of arms of Vélez-Málaga, Andalusia

The clandestine practice of Islam continued well into the 16th century. In 1567, King Philip II finally made the use of the Arabic language illegal, and forbade the Islamic religion, dress, and customs, a step which led to the Second Rebellion of Alpujarras, involving acts of brutality. In one incident, troops commanded by Don John of Austria destroyed the town of Galera east of Granada, after slaughtering the entire population. The Moriscos of Granada were rounded up and dispersed across Spain. 'Edicts of Expulsion' for the expulsion of the Moriscos were finally issued by Philip III in 1609 against the remaining Muslims in Spain. The expulsion was particularly efficient in the eastern region of Valencia where they made up 33% of the population and ethnic tensions between Muslim and non-Muslim populations were high. The corresponding expulsion of Muslims from the Kingdom of Castille and Andalusia was officially completed in 1614 although its success has been questioned by modern scholars. Unlike the Kingdom of Aragon and Valencia, Moriscos were highly integrated in the rest of Spain significant number of them avoided expulsion or returned en masse, with the protection of non-morisco neighbours and local authorities.

The decline in revenue, and loss of technical skills, from the expulsion of Muslims from Aragon precipitated the downfall of Aragon, and the prominence of Castille. Further, the loss of revenue and skills from Valencia led to a shift of Catalan power from Valencia to regions around Barcelona which had far fewer Muslims and were thus less-affected.

The last mass prosecution against Moriscos for crypto-Islamic practices occurred in Granada in 1727, with most of those convicted receiving relatively light sentences. By this stage, the indigenous Islam is considered to have been effectively extinguished in Spain.[3]

Nevertheless, communities of Morish freed slaves known as "moros cortados" continued to be present throughout various parts of Spain, many of which had been freed as a result of a reciprocal deal with Morocco in 1767. Such former slaves, although baptised continued to discreetly practice their religion. As a result of a second Treaty with Morocco in 1799, the King of Spain formally guaranteed the right of Moroccans in Spain to practice their religion in exchange for Spanish Catholics being granted the same rights in Morocco.[18]

Demography and ethnic background[edit]

The Spanish Constitution of 1978 declares in Art. 16 that “No one may be compelled to make statements regarding his religion, beliefs or ideologies[19] which means that all the data on religious beliefs is approximated. The evolution of the Muslim population has been linked to the increase of immigration in the last two decades, which began with the entry of Spain in the European Economic Community (1986), following the economic growth and the closure of European borders to third countries.[20] While in 2003 there were 1.23% of Muslims (both nationals and foreigners) compared to the total population, in 2019 the percentage has raised to 4.45%.[21][22] The Autonomous Communities with the highest Muslim population, in absolute terms, are Catalonia, Andalusia, the Community of Madrid, and the Region of Murcia. However, in relation to the overall population within the Autonomous Communities, the cities of Ceuta and Melilla stand out with the highest percentages of Muslims, following the Region of Murcia, Catalonia, and La Rioja. Moreover, it is worth mentioning that the Muslim population in the cities of Ceuta and Melilla, mostly from Morocco, has been active in the creation of associations and pioneer in the implementation of Islam related measures in different political fields.[23] Sources for the subsequent tables and graphics:[24][25]

Muslim Population
YearPop.±%
2003 525,000—    
2004 801,284+52.6%
2005 1,064,904+32.9%
2006 1,080,478+1.5%
2007 1,145,424+6.0%
2008 1,310,148+14.4%
2009 1,446,939+10.4%
2010 1,498,707+3.6%
2011 1,595,221+6.4%
2012 1,671,629+4.8%
2013 1,732,191+3.6%
2014 1,858,409+7.3%
2015 1,887,906+1.6%
2016 1,919,141+1.7%
2017 1,946,300+1.4%
2018 1,993,675+2.4%
2019 2,091,656+4.9%
Source: [26]
Evolution of the total and Muslim population from 2003 to 2019. Note that the X-axis starts at 39 million, so it only shows around 1/6th of the population but it includes all the Muslims.
Autonomous
Communities
Muslim
population 2019
Percentage
 Melilla 44,958 51.98
 Ceuta 36,822 43.43
 Region of Murcia 112,527 7.53
 Catalonia 564,055 7.35
 La Rioja (Spain) 19,462 6.14
 Balearic Islands 59,418 5.17
 Aragon 59,821 4.53
 Navarre 29,563 4.52
 Community of Madrid 299,311 4.49
 Valencian Community 221,355 4.42
 Andalusia 341,069 4.05
 Canary Islands 75,662 3.51
 Castile-La Mancha 69,914 3.44
 Basque Country 62,466 2.83
 Extremadura 19,858 1.86
 Castile and León 41,275 1.72
 Cantabria 5,526 0.95
 Asturias 8,623 0.84
 Galicia 19,971 0.74
Spain 2,091,656 4.45

The ethnic background of Muslim population has two main nationalities: Spanish and Moroccan, it follows the Pakistani and the Senegalese nationality. Within the foreign Muslim population, three geographic zones can be highlighted: the Arab Maghreb, West Africa, the Indian Subcontinent and the Middle East.

Map showing the countries of origin of the Muslim population living in Spain in 2019
Country of origin Population
 Spain 879,808
 Morocco 812,412
 Pakistan 88,783
 Senegal 70,879
Others 63,286
 Algeria 63,051
 Nigeria 39,241
 Mali 24,965
 Gambia 20,354
 Bangladesh 18,093
 Guinea 10,784
Total population 2,091,656

In “Others” we can find the following countries: Mauritania (8,165), Syria (7,321), Cameroon (6,232), Iran (5,913), Turkey (5,000), Guinea-Bissau (4,413), Ivory Coast (4,249), Egypt (4,020), Albania (3,004), Kazakhstan (2,438), Tunisia (2,287), Lebanon (2,116), Indonesia (1,764), Iraq (1,554), Jordan (1,315), Burkina Faso (1,276), Saudi Arabia (745), Sierra Leone (685), Togo (451), Benin (338).

Islamic Organisations[edit]

The creation of Islamic communities as legal entities has been an instrument for Muslims to organize themselves in order to communicate with public institutions and achieve the rights established in the legal arrangements. Since the signature of the Cooperation Agreement between the State and the Islamic Commission of Spain in 1992 and the increase of migratory flows, there has been a significant growth of organisations in form of religious communities, associations, and federations. The local communities and associations can incorporate themselves directly within the Islamic Commission or through an already integrated federation. In 2019, there were 49 Islamic federations, 1,704 communities, and 21 associations registered in the Religious Entities Office of the Ministry of Justice (RER). A total of 365 religious entities remained outside the Islamic Commission.

Map showing the distribution of Islamic religious entities per 10k Muslim inhab. among the Autonomous Communities of Spain in 2019
Autonomous
Communities
Islamic
entities (IE)
2019
IE rate
(per 10k
muslim inhab.)
 Ceuta 67 18.20
 Castile-La Mancha 116 16.59
 Navarre 46 15.56
 Extremadura 28 14.10
 Aragon 80 13.37
 La Rioja (Spain) 26 13.36
 Castile and Leon 53 12.84
 Asturias 11 12.76
 Galicia 25 12.52
 Basque Country 77 12.33
 Region of Murcia 128 11.38
 Valencian Community 235 10.62
 Balearic Islands 62 10.43
 Cantabria 5 9.05
 Andalusia 265 7.77
 Canary Islands 54 7.14
 Catalonia 340 6.03
 Community of Madrid 142 4.74
 Melilla 14 3.11
Total 1.774 8.48

Source:[27]

Relations between Islam and the State[edit]

In Spain, Islam is considered a minority though “deep-rooted” religion together with Judaism, the Evangelic Church, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, the Jehovah's Witnesses, Buddhism and the Orthodox Church.[28] In this sense, the Spanish state established a legal framework for the accommodation of those remarkable religions within the legal framework of cooperative church-state relations. Until now, just the Jewish, the Evangelic and the Muslim communities have signed a formal Agreement with the state.

Muslims and the state in the 20th century[edit]

The colonialist policy conducted by the Spanish state during the 19th and the 20th century mostly in North-Africa shaped also the politics toward the Islamic religion in the metropole. After the Spanish Civil War (1936-1939) the dictator Francisco Franco rewarded the engagement of Moroccan troops in his army with the construction of the first modern Mosque in the Iberian Peninsula since the Muslim presence in Al-Ándalus during the Middle Ages, namely the Al-Morabito Mosque in Córdoba.[29] Furthermore, at the beginning of the civil war, it was assigned a place within the San Fernando Cemetery in Sevilla (Cementerio de San Fernando) to bury Muslim soldiers, which was closed after the conflict.[30] However, the Spanish State during Franco’s dictatorship was defined as a Catholic confessional state and did not recognised any public expression of other religions until the Law of Religious Liberty in 1967[31], which means that from 1939 to 1967 Muslims could only exercise their religion in the private sphere. From then on, the Muslim community began to organise itself in associations. In 1971, Riay Tatary Bakr, the later president of the Islamic Commission of Spain (CIE), helped to create the Association of Muslims in Spain (AME) based in Madrid, which constructed the Madrid Central Mosque or Abu Bakr Mosque with private funds mostly from Saudi Arabia.[32]

The legal framework of religious diversity[edit]

In the Spanish case, the legal framework for the governance of religious diversity has its foundations in the historical church-state model. In political science, the theory explaining how historical patterns can influence new policy outcomes is called path dependency. Similarly, there have been many studies linking the governance of Islam in European countries to pre-existing church-state models.[33] During Franco’s dictatorship, the Spanish state signed the Concordat of 1953 with the Vatican, which granted the Catholic Church with some privileges such as state funding and the exemption from government taxation. In the Spanish transition to democracy, the government replicated the same model by signing new agreements in 1976[34] and 1979[35], which gave the concordat the status of an international treaty.

The Constitution of 1978 stipulated in Article 16 that all beliefs within the Spanish society will be taken into account and the state will maintain cooperative relations with the Catholic Church as well as with other religious denominations.[36] Furthermore, The Organic Law of Religious Liberty (LOLR) of 1980 specified in Article 7 that the state should establish Cooperation Agreements with those “Churches, Confessions and Communities” that had achieved ‘deep-rootedness’ (Notorio arraigo) in Spanish society, due to their scope and the number of believers.[37]The criteria were the following ones:[38]

  • A sufficient number of members, referred to the federation or organism gathering the different churches or denominations of the requesting confession.
  • An appropriate and binding juridical organisation for all entities gathered within the organisation.
  • Historical roots in Spain, both legal and clandestinely, since a certain time that is deemed appropriate.
  • Importance of the social, care and cultural activities conducted by the requesting confession.
  • Confession’s scope assessed by his territorial extension, the number of local churches, worship places, etc.
  • Institutionalisation of the ministers of religion, i.e., proportionality in relation to the members of the confession, study certificate, stability…

This law allowed the state to sign Cooperation Agreements with the Jewish, the Evangelic and the Muslim communities, which were previously recognised as “deep-rooted” religions. The definition of the requirements and procedure for obtaining “deep-rootedness” was reformulated in the Royal Decree 593/2015.[39] In 1984, the Advisory Commission of Religious Liberty (CARL), an administrative organ within the Ministry of Justice, recognised both the Evangelic and the Jewish confessions, and in 1989 the Islamic religion achieved his recognition as well.[40]

Cooperation Agreement between the state and the Islamic Commission of Spain[edit]

Following the church-state model, the agreement would be signed by two parties: on the one side, the Ministry of Justice representing the Spanish State, and on the other side, one representative body for each religious denomination. This obligated the different religious communities to organise themselves in a centralised and hierarchal way within a short period of time. Moreover, this model did not take into account the heterogeneous nature of the communities, especially for the Islamic religion.[41] In 1989, after the recognition of the Islam as “deep-rooted” religion, the Spanish Federation of Islamic Religious Entities (FEERI) was created with 15 federated associations in order to serve as the single interlocutor with the state. However, in 1991 a group of communities left the Federation to form a new one under the name Union of Islamic Communities of Spain (UCIDE). So far, there were two competing Islamic federations, which wanted to monopolise the communication with the state. The request for a Cooperation Agreement should be carried out by the religious confession and then reviewed by the public administration. Both federations started to draft an agreement in parallel. Finally, the solution was found in the creation of the Islamic Commission of Spain (CIE), founded by the FEERI and the UCIDE and established on 18 February 1992.[42] Its raison d’être was the “negotiation, signature and follow- up on the Cooperation Agreement with the state” as it is written in the first article of his statutes.[43]

Logoweb of the CIE

1992 was chosen as the year for the signature of the Cooperation Agreements, due to the 500th anniversary regarding the conquest of the Nasrid Kingdom of Granada and the Expulsion of Jews from Spain. Because of that, many scholars have seen the Agreements as a symbolic act rather than as an instrument for the management of religious diversity.[44] Nevertheless, the agreements aimed to equate the one signed with the Catholic Church and so to accommodate the religions mentioned within public institutions and the school system, to guarantee the exemption from taxation and the involvement of the religious communities in the preservation of their related cultural heritage.[45] The Cooperation Agreement between the State and the CIE includes 14 articles and three additional provisions that can be summarised in 9 topics: legal affairs, worship places, imams, marriage and festivities, religious assistance, religious education, fiscal benefits, cultural heritage, and halal products. In the following sections, a summary with relevant facts is provided:[46]

  1. Legal affairs (arts. 1, 6): the CIE shall validate the incorporation of communities and federations within its body. The communities must be also registered in the Religious Entities Office of the Ministry of Justice (RER). The certification of religious purposes for the creation of religious entities can be issued by their belonging federation in accordance with the CIE or directly by the CIE.
  2. Worship places (art. 2): mosques or places of worship will be certified by the respective community in conformity with the CIE. Those worship places enjoy inviolability according to the terms established by law. Moreover, this topic comprises the right of those Islamic communities, which are integrated within the CIE, to the granting of plots in public cemeteries or the ownership of private ones.
  3. Imams (arts. 3, 4, 5): on the one side, the CIE is the organ that can certify imams and Islamic religious leaders. On the other side, the Ministry of Justice must first recognise those centres for religious instruction. Furthermore, those persons who meet the requirements will be covered by the General Social Security Plan.
  4. Marriage and festivities (arts. 6, 12): the marriage celebrated under Islamic Law will be effective if the applicants meet the criteria demanded by the Civil Code. Moreover, the members of the Islamic communities belonging to the CIE can apply for the interruption of their work every friday, the day of collective compulsory prayer, from 1:30 pm till 4 pm, and the cessation of the working day one hour before sunset during the month of Ramadan.
  5. Religious assistance (arts. 8, 9): the religious assistance is recognised as a right for Muslims within the Armed Forces and in public centres such as hospitals, penitentiary centres and Alien Interment Centres (CIES). Those public centres are responsible for covering the costs of religious assistance.
  6. Religious education (art. 10): the Spanish school system integrates already the possibility to course catholic religion as an optative subject. Article 10 opens thus the possibility for Muslims to request Islamic religious teaching in the levels of preschool, primary and secondary education. The communities belonging to the CIE will appoint the teachers in conformity with their own federation.
  7. Fiscal benefits (art. 11): the CIE as well as the communities, among other fiscal benefits, will be exempt from property taxes and other special contributions, from corporate income taxes and taxes on asset transfers and legal documents.
  8. Cultural heritage (art. 12): both the state and the CIE commit themselves to cooperate in order to conserve and promote the historical, cultural, artistic, Islamic heritage, which will continue to serve society for its contemplation and study.
  9. Halal products (art. 13): the CIE will elaborate a specific label for halal products in order to guarantee that those have been produced in accordance with Islamic Law. Nevertheless, the animal sacrifice should meet the health regulations in force. On the matter of food supplies in public centres and military units, it will be sought to adapt food and schedule to Islamic precepts.

Implementation of the Cooperation Agreement[edit]

The implementation of the Cooperation Agreement has been a long process that has not been yet completed. When the Agreement was signed in 1992, no other regulations regarding the concrete implementation nor financial means were determined directly afterward. Moreover, since Spain is a semi-federal state, the competencies over the agreed measures correspond to different administrative levels: the Spanish government, the autonomous government, and the municipal council.

Worship places[edit]

The Cooperation Agreement identifies as Islamic worship places the mosques and cemeteries. In Spain, there are 13 big mosques in the cities of Madrid (2), Valencia (1), Córdoba (2), Granada (1), Ceuta (2), Melilla (2), Fuengirola (1), Marbella (1) and Málaga (1). [See: List of Mosques in Spain]. However, in practice, most common places of worship are small oratories established in commercial premises, garages, and private apartments. The religious communities are mostly renting these establishments, just a minority are private property. A study from 2009 about the religious situation in Castile-La Mancha identified 46 religious communities of which only 4 had a private property. At the autonomic level, the Community of Madrid signed an agreement with the UCIDE in 1998[47], which referred in the third clause to the promotion of transfer of land to construct mosques and worship places in Madrid. In Catalonia, on the other side, a law was adopted in 2009 to deal with the granting of licenses by municipal councils.[48] Especially in Catalonia, there have been many cases of social opposition to mosques. In a study conducted by Avi Stor 41 cases were reported in Catalonia between 1990 and 2013, the total cases in Spain was 74 from 1985 to 2013.[49]

Social Opposition to Mosques in Spain 1985- 2013
Autonomous
Communities
Worship
places in 2019
Cemeteries
in 2019
 Catalonia 324 5
 Andalusia 271 11
 Valencian Community 227 4
 Community of Madrid 131 1
 Region of Murcia 121 1
 Castile-La Mancha 109 0
 Basque Country 78 1
 Aragon 75 1
 Ceuta 63 1
 Balearic Islands 57 1
 Canary Islands 53 3
 Castile and León 51 3
 Navarre 45 1
 Extremadura 28 0
 La Rioja (Spain) 25 1
 Galicia 23 0
 Melilla 14 1
 Asturias 10 1
 Cantabria 5 0
Spain 1710 36

[50]

Religious assistance[edit]

The competence over religious assistance varies across the institutions involved. For instance, the central government is responsible for the religious assistance in penitentiary centres except in Catalonia. For the religious assistance in Alien Internment Centres (CIES) has also the Spanish government, under the Directorate-General of the Police (DGP), the jurisdiction. On the other side, the Autonomous Communities have the competencies in the area of healthcare, thus they have to manage the religious assistance in hospitals and other healthcare centres. In 2006, a decree was adopted to regulate the religious assistance in penitentiary centres, and in 2007 an economic agreement was signed for its financing.[51] Furthermore, the Generalitat de Catalunya signed in 2008 a collaboration agreement with the Islamic and Cultural Council of Catalonia (Consell Islàmic i Cultural de Catalunya) to guarantee the religious assistance in Catalan penitentiary centres through the Directorate General of Religious Affairs (DGAR).[52] This collaboration agreement was updated in 2015 and in 2019, this time with the involvement of the Federation Islamic Council of Catalonia.[53] Until 2019, there were 20 imams for the religious assistance in penitentiary centres in Spain, 8 of them engaged in Catalan prisons. Regarding the religious assistance in CIES, 7 imams were reported in 2019.[54] Moreover, there is no available data for the employment of imams in health care centres. Finally, the religious assistance in the Armed forces, under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Defence, has not been implemented yet.

Religious education[edit]

Education is a complex matter since there is no exact distribution of competencies between the state and the Autonomous Communities. The state establishes some basic rules for applying Article 27 of the Constitution[55], while the communities have to develop the legislative framework and execute the educational programmes. While the education competencies have been transferred to most of the Autonomous Communities, the Education Ministry remains responsible for the competencies in Andalusia, Aragon, the Canary Islands, Cantabria, Ceuta, and Melilla.

Regarding the regulatory framework, the Spanish government signed an agreement about the designation and economic regime of the Islamic religion teachers that went into effect for the 1996-1997 school year.[56] This agreement referred just to public schools in primary and secondary education, although the Cooperation Agreement explicitly mentioned the semi-private schools, which are co-funded by the Public Administration. In 2000, 20 teachers were designated for the cities of Ceuta and Melilla and in 2005 another 20 teachers would cover the Islamic religious teaching in the communities whose competencies remained by the Spanish State.[57] Since then, the Islamic Commission of Spain has signed different agreements with the remaining Autonomous Communities for the implementation of Islamic religious teaching. However, there was not always the need for an agreement at the autonomic level, since some communities introduced Islamic religious teaching in their school systems on the basis of the Cooperation Agreement of 1992. In 2019, a total of 80 Islamic religious teachers were reported.[58] On the following table, the Autonomous Communities are listed with the respective year of implementation of the Islamic religion subject and the total number of teachers for each one in 2019. While Navarre, Galicia, and Asturias opened the opportunity to take the subject if the requirements are fulfilled, the Region of Murcia and Catalonia have not yet answered the petitions of the CIE.[59]

Autonomous
Communities
Year of
implementation
Islamic religious
teachers in 2019[60]
 Ceuta 2000[61] 14
 Melilla 2000[62] 10
 Andalusia 2005[63] 23
 Basque Country 2005[64] 5
 Aragon 2005[65] 5
 Canary Islands 2005[66] 1
 Cantabria 2005[67] 0
 Castile and León 2016[68] 6
 Community of Madrid 2016[69] 3
 La Rioja (Spain) 2018[70] 5
 Valencian Community 2018[71] 3
 Extremadura 2018[72] 3
 Castile-La Mancha 2018[73] 2
 Balearic Islands 2020[74] 0
 Navarre opened[75] 0
 Galicia opened[76] 0
 Asturias opened[77] 0
 Catalonia denial 0
 Region of Murcia denial 0
Spain 80

Economic Cooperation[edit]

The Cooperation Agreement established fiscal benefits and tax exemptions for the Islamic religious communities but did not stipulate a financial mechanism similar to the one for the Catholic Church. However, in the aftermath of the Madrid bombings of 2004, the Spanish government saw the need for integrating Muslims in Spanish society besides of formulating policies to ensure national security.[78] In December of 2004, the Foundation for Pluralism and Coexistence (FPC) was created to support programmes related to cultural, educative, and social integration for those religions with “deep-rootedness”, i.e. the Evangelic Church, Judaism, and Islam.[79] Catalonia’s regional government had already in 2000 created the Directorate General of Religious Affairs (DGAR) and in 2004, this public agency launched a programme to provide access to public funding for activities regarding the integration of minority religions, which was developed before the creation of the FPC at the national level.[80]

Halal Products[edit]

The Agreement stipulated that the CIE would be the one responsible for obtaining the Halal guarantee mark from the Industrial Property Registry. In practice, it was the Islamic Committee of Spain (Junta Islámica de España), which is one of the communities integrated within the FEERI, the one that created a Halal Institute in 2003 to regulate and certify food and products in line with the requirements of Islamic rituals under the trademark “Halal Guarantee Distinction of the Islamic Committee” (Marca de Garantía Halal de Junta Islámica).[81] Their claim to be the only official Institution in Spain that guarantees the halal production has not been in fact accomplished since we can find so far 45 national trademarks in the Spanish Patent and Trademark Office website[82] which refer to the same product categories (Nice Classification: 1, 5, 29-33, 39, 43), without counting the European and international products commercialised in Spain. Furthermore, one of these trademarks was registered by the CIE in 2018, claiming their official mandate established in the Cooperation Agreement.[83]

Radicalization[edit]

Jihadists were present in Spain from 1994, when an al-Qaeda cell was established.[84] In 1996, the Armed Islamic Group of Algeria, an organisation affiliated with al-Qaeda, founded a cell in the province of Valencia. In 2004, Madrid commuters suffered the 2004 Madrid train bombings, which were perpetrated by remnants of the first al-Qaeda cell, members of the Moroccan Islamic Combatant Group plus a gang of criminals turned into jihadists.[84] In the 1995-2003 period, slightly over 100 people were arrested for offences related to militant salafism.[84]

See also[edit]

Further reading[edit]

  • Harvey, L. P. (16 May 2005). Muslims in Spain, 1500 to 1614. University of Chicago Press. ISBN 978-0-226-31963-6.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
  • W. Montgomery Watt and Pierre Cachia, A History of Islamic Spain. Piscataway, NJ: Transaction Publishers, 2007.
  • Brian A. Catlos, Kingdoms of Faith: A New History of Islamic Spain Hurst/Basic Books, 2018. Review: Nicola Clarke: "Abraham's Descendants in Love, Life and War". History Today Vol. 68/10, October 2018, pp. 98–99.
  • López García, Bernabé and Planet Contreras, Ana I.: Islam in Spain Hunter, Shireen T. (ed.), Islam, Europe’s Second Religion. The new social, cultural and political landscape. Connecticut London: Praeger, 2002.

References[edit]

  1. ^ Apperception, Knowledge, and Experience. University of Ottawa Press. 1994. ISBN 9780776603971.
  2. ^ Dadson, Trevor J. (15 October 2018). "Tolerance and Coexistence in Early Modern Spain: Old Christians and Moriscos in the Campo de Calatrava". Boydell & Brewer Ltd – via Google Books.
  3. ^ a b Soria Mesa, Enrique (1 January 2012). "Los moriscos que se quedaron. La permanencia de la población de origen islámico en la España Moderna: Reino de Granada, siglos XVII-XVIII" [The Moriscos who remained. The permanence of Islamic origin population in Early Modern Spain: Kingdom of Granada, XVII-XVIII centuries]. Vínculos de Historia (in Spanish) (1): 205–230. ISSN 2254-6901. Archived from the original on 15 July 2017. Retrieved 18 May 2019 – via Dialnet.
  4. ^ Observatorio Andalusí (2020). "Estudio demográfico de la población musulmana Explotación estadística del censo de ciudadanos musulmanes en España referido a fecha 31/12/2019" (PDF). Unión de Comunidades Islámicas de España (UCIDE).
  5. ^ a b Bouchard, Constance Brittain, Chief Consultant. (Distinguished Professor of Medieval History, University of Akron) "Knights in History and Legend" Firefly Books Ltd.. 2009. ISBN 978-1-55407-480-8 . Page 202
  6. ^ "BBC - Religions - Islam: Muslim Spain (711-1492)". www.bbc.co.uk. Archived from the original on 2017-02-27. Retrieved 2018-12-31.
  7. ^ O'Shea, Stephen (2006). Sea of Faith: Islam and Christianity in the Medieval Mediterranean World. New York: Walker & Company.
  8. ^ "BBC - Religions - Islam: Muslim Spain (711-1492)". www.bbc.co.uk. Archived from the original on 2017-02-27. Retrieved 2018-12-31.
  9. ^ a b c d Rothstein, Edward (2003-09-27). "Was the Islam Of Old Spain Truly Tolerant?". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Archived from the original on 2019-11-03. Retrieved 2019-11-03.
  10. ^ a b c d Thomas, Sarah-Mae. "The Convivencia in Islamic Spain". fountainmagazine.com. Archived from the original on 2019-11-03. Retrieved 2019-11-03.
  11. ^ "The Myth of the Golden Age of Tolerance in Medieval Muslim Spain". www.newenglishreview.org. Retrieved 2019-11-03.
  12. ^ Robinson, Cynthia; Pinet, Simone (10 December 2008). Courting the Alhambra: Cross-Disciplinary Approaches to the Hall of Justice Ceilings. BRILL. p. 52. ISBN 978-90-474-2688-2. Archived from the original on 15 February 2017. Retrieved 24 January 2017.
  13. ^ "Muslim Spain (711-1492): Decline and fall". BBC. 4 September 2009. Archived from the original on 22 February 2009. Retrieved 13 August 2008.
  14. ^ Eisenberg, Daniel (1992). "Cisneros y la quema de los manuscritos granadinos". Journal of Hispanic Philology (16): 107–124. Archived from the original on 15 October 2014. Retrieved 7 August 2014.
  15. ^ Harvey 2005, p. 48.
  16. ^ Harvey 2005, p. 270.
  17. ^ Harvey 2005, p. 60.
  18. ^ Martínez Almira, Magdalena (2013). Masferrer, Aniceto; Obarrio Moreno, Juan A.; Ramos Vázquez, Isabel; Franco Chasán, José; Aitslin, Anna; Cañizares, Juan B.; Mirow, Matthew; Simpson, Andrew (eds.). "El intercambio de moros cortados entre España y Marruecos tras la firma del Tratado de 1767. La Comunidad de Musulmanes de Cartagena" [The Rescue of Moors (Moros Cortados) Between Spain and Marocco after the 1767 Treaty. The Case of Moorish Community Cartagena] (PDF). Glossae. European Journal of Legal History (in Spanish). Institute for Social, Political and Legal Studies (10): 226–252. Archived (PDF) from the original on 23 September 2016. Retrieved 18 May 2019.
  19. ^ Boletín Oficial del Estado, BOE. "The Spanish Constitution" (PDF). Retrieved 18 April 2020.
  20. ^ Planet Contreras, Ana I. (2013). La organización del Islam en España (PDF). Orozco de la Torre, Olivia and Alonso García, Gabriel (eds.), El Islam y los musulmanes hoy. Dimensión internacional y relaciones con España. Cuadernos de la Escuela Diplomática, No. 48. pp. 265-280 (p.266).
  21. ^ Observatorio Andalusí (2020). "Estudio demográfico de la población musulmana Explotación estadística del censo de ciudadanos musulmanes en España referido a fecha 31/12/2019" (PDF). Unión de Comunidades Islámicas de España (UCIDE).
  22. ^ Instituto Nacional de Estadística, INE. "Demografía y población". Retrieved 18 April 2020.
  23. ^ Planet Contreras, Ana I. (2013). La organización del Islam en España (PDF). Orozco de la Torre, Olivia and Alonso García, Gabriel (eds.), El Islam y los musulmanes hoy. Dimensión internacional y relaciones con España. Cuadernos de la Escuela Diplomática, No. 48. pp. 265-280 (p.267).
  24. ^ Observatorio Andalusí (2020). "Estudio demográfico de la población musulmana Explotación estadística del censo de ciudadanos musulmanes en España referido a fecha 31/12/2019" (PDF). Unión de Comunidades Islámicas de España (UCIDE).
  25. ^ Instituto Nacional de Estadística, INE. "Demografía y población". Retrieved 18 April 2020.
  26. ^ Observatorio Andalusí. "Informes Anuales". Retrieved 29 April 2020.
  27. ^ Observatorio Andalusí (2020). "Estudio demográfico de la población musulmana Explotación estadística del censo de ciudadanos musulmanes en España referido a fecha 31/12/2019" (PDF). Unión de Comunidades Islámicas de España (UCIDE).
  28. ^ Observatorio del Pluralismo Religioso. "Notorio Arraigo". Retrieved 29 April 2020.
  29. ^ Moreras, Jordi (1999). Musulmanes en Barcelona. Espacios y dinámicas comunitarias. Barcelona: CIDOB editions. p. 86.
  30. ^ Valencia, Rafael (1995). "El cementerio musulmán de Sevilla" (PDF). ILU, Revista de ciencias de las religiones: 263–270.
  31. ^ BOE, Boletín Oficial del Estado. "Ley 22/1967, de 28 de junio, regulando el ejercicio del derecho civil a la libertad en materia religiosa". Retrieved 14 April 2020.
  32. ^ Moreras, Jordi (1999). Musulmanes en Barcelona. Espacios y dinámicas comunitarias. Barcelona: CIDOB editions. pp. 87–88.
  33. ^ Fuess, Albrecht (2016). Islam in Europa und Amerika. Brunner, Rainer (ed.), Islam: Einheit und Vielfalt einer Weltreligion. pp. 550–573.
  34. ^ Boletín Oficial del Estado, BOE. "Instrumento de Ratificación de España al Acuerdo entre la Santa Sede y el Estado Español, hecho en la Ciudad del Vaticano el 28 de julio de 1976" (PDF). Retrieved 19 April 2020.
  35. ^ Boletín Oficial del Estado, BOE. "Instrumento de Ratificación del Acuerdo entre el Estado español y la Santa Sede sobre asuntos económicos, firmado en Ciudad del Vaticano el 3 de enero de 1979" (PDF). Retrieved 19 April 2020.
  36. ^ Boletín oficial del Estado, BOE. "The Spanish Constitution" (PDF).
  37. ^ Boletín Oficial del Estado, BOE. "Ley Orgánica 7/1980, de 5 de julio, de Libertad Religiosa" (PDF). Retrieved 19 April 2020.
  38. ^ Jiménez-Aybar, Iván (2004). El Islam en España: aspectos institucionales de su estatuto jurídico. Navarra Gráfica Ediciones.
  39. ^ Observatorio del Pluralismo Religioso en España. "Notorio Arraigo [deep-rootedness]". Retrieved 20 April 2020.
  40. ^ Boletín Oficial del Estado, BOE. "Real Decreto 593/2015, de 3 de julio, por el que se regula la declaración de notorio arraigo de las confesiones religiosas en España". Retrieved 20 April 2020.
  41. ^ Astor, Avi; Griera, Mar (2016). "La gestion de la diversidad religiosa. The management of religious diversity". Anuario CIDOB de la Inmigración 2015-2016: 248-270 (p.254). doi:10.24241/AnuarioCIDOBInmi.2016.248.
  42. ^ Jiménez Estévez, Jennifer (2016). "La problemática de la Comisión islámica de España. The difficulties from the Islamic Commission of Spain" (PDF). Trabajos Académicos. Universidad de Cantabria, Facultad de Derecho. p.21.
  43. ^ Comisión Islámica de España, CIE. "Estatutos de la CIE 2015" (PDF). Retrieved 20 April 2020.
  44. ^ Astor, Avi; Griera, Mar (2016). "La gestion de la diversidad religiosa. The management of religious diversity". Anuario CIDOB de la Inmigración 2015-2016: 248-270 (p.253). doi:10.24241/AnuarioCIDOBInmi.2016.248.
  45. ^ Mantecón, Joaquín (2016). "España: Los acuerdos del estado con la Santa Sede y las Confesiones Minoritarias". Revista Latinoamericana de derecho y Religión. 2 (2): 1-32 (p.7). doi:10.7764/RLDR.3.28.
  46. ^ Boletín Oficial del Estado, BOE. "Ley 26/1992, de 10 de noviembre, por la que se aprueba el Acuerdo de Cooperación del Estado con la Comisión Islámica de España". Retrieved 23 April 2020.
  47. ^ Boletín Oficial del Estado, BOE, 1998. "Convenio de Colaboración entre la Comunidad de Madrid y la Unión de comunidades Islámicas de España". Anuario de Derecho Eclesiástico del Estado. Retrieved 4 May 2020.
  48. ^ Diari Oficial de la Generalitat de Catalunya, DOGC. "LLEI 16/2009, del 22 de juliol, dels centres de culte". Retrieved 4 May 2020.
  49. ^ Astor, Avi (2016). "Social Position and Place-Protective Action in a New Immigration Context: Understanding Anti-Mosque Campaigns in Catalonia". International Migration Review. 50 (1): 95-132 (p.131-132). doi:10.1111/imre.12115.
  50. ^ Observatorio del Pluralismo Religioso en España, 2019. "Directorio de lugares de culto". Retrieved 4 May 2020.CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  51. ^ Observatorio Andalusí (2019). "Informe especial 2018. Institución para la observación y seguimiento de la situación del ciudadano musulmán y la islamofóbia en España" (PDF). Union de Comunidades Islámicas de España (UCIDE).
  52. ^ "Conveni de Col·laboració entre l'Administració de la Generalitat de Catalunya, mitjançant el Departament de Justícia i el Departament de la Vicepresidència, i el Consell Islàmic Cultural de Catalunya, per tal de garantir el dret de l'assistència religiosa dels interns als centres penitenciaris de Catalunya" (PDF). 2008. Retrieved 5 May 2020.
  53. ^ "Conveni de col·laboració entre el Departament de Justícia i la Federación Consell Islàmic de Catalunya per garantir el dret al desenvolupament espiritual i l'assistència religiosa dels interns als centres penitenciaris de Catalunya en el marc de la seva rehabilitació" (PDF). 2019. Retrieved 5 May 2020.
  54. ^ Observatorio Andalusí (2020). "Estudio demográfico de la población musulmana Explotación estadística del censo de ciudadanos musulmanes en España referido a fecha 31/12/2019" (PDF). Unión de Comunidades Islámicas de España (UCIDE). Retrieved 18 April 2020.
  55. ^ Boletín Oficial del Estado, BOE. "The Spanish Constitution" (PDF). Retrieved 18 April 2020.
  56. ^ Boletín Oficial del Estado, BOE. "Resolución de 23 de abril de 1996, de la Subsecretaría, por la que se dispone la publicación del Acuerdo del Consejo de Ministros, de 1 de marzo de 1996, y el Convenio sobre designación y régimen económico de las personas encargadas de la enseñanza religiosa islámica, en los centros docentes públicos de Educación Primaria y Secundaria" (PDF). Retrieved 5 May 2020.
  57. ^ Mantecón, Jaoquín (2006). "El status legal del Islam en España". Derecho y Religión (1): 165-208 (p.189).
  58. ^ Observatorio Andalusí (2020). "Estudio demográfico de la población musulmana Explotación estadística del censo de ciudadanos musulmanes en España referido a fecha 31/12/2019" (PDF). Unión de Comunidades Islámicas de España (UCIDE). Retrieved 18 April 2020.
  59. ^ La Opinión de Murcia, 2019. "En la Región de Murcia no se imparte religión islámica pese a su reconocimiento legal". Retrieved 5 May 2020.CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  60. ^ Observatorio Andalusí (2020). "Estudio demográfico de la población musulmana Explotación estadística del censo de ciudadanos musulmanes en España referido a fecha 31/12/2019" (PDF). Unión de Comunidades Islámicas de España (UCIDE). Retrieved 18 April 2020.
  61. ^ Jiménez Gámez, Rafael (2006). "La enseñanza del Islam en los centros educativos de Ceuta" (PDF). Universidad de Cádiz: 52.
  62. ^ Jiménez Gámez, Rafael (2006). "La enseñanza del Islam en los centros educativos de Ceuta" (PDF). Universidad de Cádiz: 52.
  63. ^ Jiménez Aybar, Iván (2006). "Diagnóstico sobre la integración jurídica social del Islam en España bajo la sombra del 11-M". Hesperia Culturas del Mediterráneo. 1 (5): 235-256 (p.251).
  64. ^ Jiménez Aybar, Iván (2006). "Diagnóstico sobre la integración jurídica social del Islam en España bajo la sombra del 11-M". Hesperia Culturas del Mediterráneo. 1 (5): 235-256 (p.251).
  65. ^ Jiménez Aybar, Iván (2006). "Diagnóstico sobre la integración jurídica social del Islam en España bajo la sombra del 11-M". Hesperia Culturas del Mediterráneo. 1 (5): 235-256 (p.251).
  66. ^ Ministerio de Justicia, 2015. "Informe anual sobre la situación de la libertad religiosa en España 2014". Retrieved 5 May 2020.CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  67. ^ Jiménez Aybar, Iván (2006). "Diagnóstico sobre la integración jurídica social del Islam en España bajo la sombra del 11-M". Hesperia Culturas del Mediterráneo. 1 (5): 235-256 (p.251).
  68. ^ Heraldo, 2016. "Soria será pionera en impartir religión islámica en CyL el próximo curso". Retrieved 5 May 2020.CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  69. ^ Radioya, 2017. "El Gobierno del PP acuerda la enseñanza del Islam en las escuelas". Retrieved 5 May 2020.CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  70. ^ Comisión Islámica de España, CIE, 2018. "Firmado el Convenio de la Enseñanza Religiosa Islámica en La Rioja". Retrieved 5 May 2020.
  71. ^ Comisión Islámica de España, CIE, 2017. "Enseñanza islámica en colegios valencianos a partir del próximo curso". Retrieved 5 May 2020.
  72. ^ Comisión Islámica de España, CIE, 2018. "Firmado el Convenio de la enseñanza islámica con la Consejería de Educación de la Junta de Extremadura". Retrieved 5 May 2020.
  73. ^ Islam España, 2018. "Reunión entre la Consejería de Educación, Cultura y Deportes, de la Comunidad Autónoma de Castilla La Mancha y la Comisión Islámica de España". Retrieved 5 May 2020.CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  74. ^ Ferragut, Mar, 2019. "La comunidad islámica prevé una respuesta masiva a la oferta de Islam en los colegios de Baleares". Retrieved 5 May 2020.
  75. ^ Comisión Islámica de España, CIE, 2018. "Boletín Informativo, Abril 2018" (PDF). Retrieved 5 May 2020.
  76. ^ Ministerio de Justicia, 2018. "Informe anual sobre la situación de la libertad religiosa en España 2017". Retrieved 5 May 2020.CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  77. ^ Ministerio de Justicia, 2018. "Informe anual sobre la situación de la libertad religiosa en España 2017". Retrieved 5 May 2020.CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  78. ^ Astor, Avi (2014). "Religious Governance and the Accommodation of Islam in Contemporary Spain". Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies. 40 (11): 1716–1735 (p.1725). doi:10.1080/1369183X.2013.871493.
  79. ^ Mantecón, Jaoquín (2006). "El status legal del Islam en España". Derecho y Religión (1): 165-208 (p.191).
  80. ^ García-Romeral, Gloria; Griera, Maria del Mar (2011). "La Construcción de l'Islam Com a Objecte de Polítiques Públiques a Catalunya [The Construction of Islam as an Object of Public Policies in Catalonia]". Societat Catalana 2011: 231–253 (p.248).
  81. ^ Mantecón, Jaoquín (2006). "El status legal del Islam en España". Derecho y Religión (1): 165-208 (p.194).
  82. ^ Oficina Española de Patentes y Marcas, OEPM. "Marcas y Nombres Comerciales". Retrieved 5 May 2020.
  83. ^ EUROPA PRESS, 2018. "La Comisión Islámica registra la Marca Halal España y trabaja con Gobierno y CCAA para que llegue a los colegios". Retrieved 5 May 2020.CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  84. ^ a b c Vidino; et al. (2018). De-Radicalization in the Mediterranean - Comparing Challenges and Approaches (PDF). Milano: ISPI. pp. 24, 35–36. ISBN 9788867058198. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2018-08-24. Retrieved 2018-09-08.