Italian conquest of British Somaliland
|Italian conquest of British Somaliland|
|Part of the East African Campaign of World War II|
The Italian invasion of British Somaliland in August 1940
|Commanders and leaders|
| Reade Godwin-Austen
| Guglielmo Nasi
Carlo De Simone
|5,000 regular troops[nb 1]||24,000 colonial troops|
|Casualties and losses|
120 missing[nb 2]
7 aircraft destroyed
10 aircraft damaged
1 tug lost
2 vessels slightly damaged
4 aircraft destroyed
|Up to 2,000 Somalis killed or wounded fighting in the Bande irregolari against British rule.[nb 3]
Around 1,000 Somali clansmen killed or wounded fighting in irregular bands against the Italian invasion.[nb 4]
The Italian conquest of British Somaliland was a military campaign in the Horn of Africa, which took place in August 1940 between forces of Italy and those of several British Commonwealth countries. The expedition formed part of the East African Campaign.
When Italy declared war on 10 June 1940, the Italian troops were not prepared for a prolonged war in North Africa or East Africa. As a consequence, Italian dictator Benito Mussolini ordered only some limited aggressive actions to capture territory along the borders of Egypt, Kenya, and Sudan.
Later in June, Amedeo, Duke of Aosta, the Governor-General and Viceroy of Italian East Africa, convinced the Italian Supreme Command (Comando Supremo) to plan a campaign to conquer British Somaliland. The King of Italy, Victor Emmanuel III, and Mussolini agreed with the Duke of Aosta and by the beginning of August the campaign was ready to commence.
Order of battle
The Italian force attacking British Somaliland in August 1940 was commanded by Lieutenant General Guglielmo Nasi, General Officer Commanding Eastern Sector. The force included twenty-three colonial battalions of regular native troops in five brigades, three Blackshirt battalions, and three bands (bande) of dubats and other locally recruited irregulars. The Italians also had armoured vehicles (a small number of both light and medium tanks), artillery, and, most importantly, superior air support. The Italian troops numbered about 24,000.
On Italy's declaration of war in June 1940, the British forces in British Somaliland were placed under the command of Lieutenant-Colonel Arthur Reginald Chater, the commander of the Somaliland Camel Corps. At the start of August, the newly promoted Brigadier Chater commanded a contingent of about 4,000 soldiers comprising the lightly armed Somaliland Camel Corps, the 2nd (Nyasaland) Battalion King's African Rifles (KAR), the 1st Battalion Northern Rhodesian Regiment (KAR), the 3/15th Punjab Regiment, and 1st East African Light Battery (four 3.7 in (94 mm) howitzers). They were joined from Aden on 7 August by the 1/2nd Punjab Regiment and 8 August by 2nd Battalion Black Watch. Chater's force was not only critically short of artillery, it had neither tanks nor armoured cars nor any anti-tank weapons to oppose the Italian medium and light tanks.
In the early hours of the 3 August 1940, the Italian Army crossed the border between Italian East Africa (called by the Italians Africa Orientale Italiana, AOI) and British Somaliland.
Because of the rugged hills (rising to over 4,500 ft (1,400 m)) which run parallel to the coast some 50 mi (80 km) inland there were three approaches to Berbera, the capital of British Somaliland and the only port of consequence, which would support the passage of wheeled and tracked vehicles. The most direct route with the widest pass was via Hargeisa.
As a consequence, the Italians advanced with three columns along these three routes. The western column advanced toward the small port of Zeila near the border with French Somaliland, the centre column toward Hargeisa and Adadlek and the eastern column toward Odweina and Burao.
The Italian plan was for the western column to seal off French Somaliland[nb 5] and then send light forces eastwards. The central column would establish a base at Hargeisa and then carry the main weight of the attack through the Mirgo Pass towards Berbera. The eastern column would move to Odweina to cover the central column's flank and be prepared to link up with it if necessary.
On 5 August, the port of Zeila was occupied by the Italian western column commanded by Lieutenant-General Bertoldi. Any possibility of help from French Somaliland for the British was eliminated. As planned small forces then proceeded southeast along the coast and occupied the village of Bulhar.
The Italian central column, commanded by Lt-Gen Carlo De Simone, faced more difficulties because of the mountainous terrain through which it advanced. The column was held up at Hargeisa by the Camel Corps assisted by a company of the Northern Rhodesia Regiment, but De Simone brought up some light tanks, and by 5 August the opposing troops had fallen back. De Simone took two days to reorganise his supply position at Hargeisa and then resumed his advance through the Karrim Pass toward the Tug[nb 6] Argan, a dry sandy river bed, in the Assa Hills.
The eastern column, under Brigadier General Bertello and comprising mainly irregular troops, reached Odweina on 6 August and then headed north west toward Adadle a village on the Tug Argan.
Brig. Chater used his Camel Corps supplemented by small patrols of the Illalos (a small force of tribal levies normally employed on police duties) to skirmish with and screen against the advancing Italians as the other British and Commonwealth forces pulled back towards Tug Argan.
Battle of Tug Argan
By 10 August, De Simone had closed up on the British positions behind the Tug Argan and made his preparations to attack.
On 7–8 August, the British and Commonwealth forces in British Somaliland had received reinforcements with the arrival of the 1/2nd Punjab Regiment and the 2nd battalion Black Watch. General Archibald Wavell, Commander-in-Chief Middle East Command in Cairo, had also ordered a further battalion of infantry and more artillery to Berbera but these reinforcements did not arrive in time. He also considered it appropriate to appoint a major-general to command this expanding force and on 11 August, a new commander, Major-General Reade Godwin-Austen, reached Berbera.
The defensive positions of the British army were centered around six hills overlooking the only road toward Berbera. On 11 August, one of De Simone's brigades attacked the hill defended by a company of the 3rd Battalion 15th Punjab Regiment and captured it, taking heavy casualties. The British launched two unsuccessful counterattacks but fought off Italian attacks on two other hills. The next day, all the British positions were attacked. By evening, Mill Hill had been taken from the Northern Rhodesian Regiment after severe fighting. More critically, two of the scarce East African Light Battery howitzers were lost and Italian forces had established themselves in the Assa Hills, dominating the southern side of the gap through which the road to Berbera ran.
On 13–14 August, no further positions were taken despite heavy fighting but the Italians continued to improve their position through infiltration. By 14 August, the defenders' situation started to look critical: the Italians were almost in a position to cut the road and thus the defenders' only line of supply and retreat. On 14 August, Godwin-Austen informed Middle East Command of the situation concluding that further resistance at Tug Argan would be futile and likely to result in the loss of the whole force. He believed that a withdrawal would result in 70% of the force being saved. On 15 August, he received orders to withdraw his forces from British Somaliland.
Late on 15 August, the Italians took Observation Hill and after dark the defenders of Tug Argan commenced their withdrawal. The Black Watch together with two companies of the 2nd KAR and elements of 1/2nd Punjab Regiment formed a rearguard position at Barkasan on the Berbera road some 10 mi (16 km) behind the Tug Argan position.
British evacuation from Berbera
While the British made their retreat to Berbera, the Royal Navy had constructed an all-tide jetty and had commenced evacuating civilian and administrative officials. On 16 August, the British started to embark troops onto the waiting ships. Repeated Italian aerial assaults were made on British vessels in the Gulf of Aden and Berbera, beginning on 8 August to little effect. HMAS Hobart was slightly damaged in two of these attacks, and the auxiliary vessel Chakdina was hit by splinters in one.
On 17 August, an Italian column was reported at Bulhar, some 40 mi (64 km) west of Berbera. The light cruiser HMS Ceres—patrolling off the coast—engaged the column and halted it. De Simone's forces advancing from Tug Argan were very cautious and did not attack the Barkasan rearguard until late morning on 17 August when they were held by determined resistance including a fierce bayonet charge by the Black Watch. After dark, the rearguard was withdrawn to Berbera. The entire British Commonwealth contingent withdrew to Berbera with minimal losses and loading of the ships was completed in the early hours of 18 August, although HMAS Hobart—with the force headquarters aboard—remained at Berbera to collect stragglers and continue the destruction of vehicles, fuel and stores until the morning of 19 August before sailing for Aden. Three Australians from HMAS Hobart missing feared dead were to become the first Australian WW2 POWs. In total, 7,000 people, including civilians, were evacuated. The local Somalis of the Somaliland Camel Corps had been given the choice of evacuation or disbandment and the large majority chose to remain and were allowed to retain their arms. Among the losses in the embarkation was the tug Queen, the only British ship lost in the operation.
The British defenders had little interference in this operation. It is possible that this was because on 15 August, the Duke of Aosta had ordered Gen. Nasi to allow the British to evacuate without too much fighting. He did this in the hope of a possible future peace agreement, that was being promoted through the Vatican mediation, between Italy and Great Britain.
On 19 August, the Italians took control of Berbera and then moved down the coast to complete their conquest of British Somaliland. The British colony was annexed by Mussolini to the "Italian Empire" as a part of Italian East Africa.
According to the Italian official history published in 1952, during the campaign to conquer British Somaliland the casualties were 250 for the British army and 205 for the Italian. British air crew losses were twelve killed and three wounded. However, according to the British official History of the Second World War published in 1954 total British casualties were 260 and Italian losses were estimated at 2,052. A more recent Italian assessment by Andrea Molinari published in 2007 gave total Italian casualties as 1995. The brunt of the Italian losses were suffered by their ascari colonial troops; only 161 of the casualties were Italians.
Unofficially, De Simone estimated that nearly one thousand irregular Somalis fighting against the Italian invasion were casualties during the campaign. These armed men operated as local "Bande", with only minimal control from British officers (like Brigadier Chater). Lieutenant-General Luigi Frusci, commander of the Italian East Africa Northern Sector, also referred to these thousand casualties in his writings, and believed that the Somalis fighting as "armed Bands" on the Italian side suffered two thousand casualties (the most popular local tribal chief, Afchar, greeted the Italians after the conquest of Zeila and offered his men against the British).[nb 7]
According to De Simone, the Italian troops captured a considerable amount of British military equipment. He reported the capture of five artillery pieces, five mortars, more than one hundred trucks, three armoured carriers, thirty anti-tank guns, seventy-one machine guns, and a large number of small arms and ammunition.
The British Prime Minister (Winston Churchill) criticised Gen. Wavell concerning the loss of British Somaliland. It was Wavell's Middle East Command which was responsible for the loss of the colony. Because of the low casualty rate, Churchill fretted that the colony had been abandoned without enough of a fight and proposed a court of enquiry. In response to this criticism, Wavell claimed that Somaliland was a textbook withdrawal in the face of superior numbers. He pointed out to Churchill that "A bloody butcher’s bill is not the sign of a good tactician." According to Churchill's staff, Wavell's retort moved Churchill to greater fury than they had ever seen before and probably marked the start of the decline of Wavell's position with Churchill that led to his dismissal.
British Somaliland remained part of Italian East Africa for a matter of months. On 16 March 1941, the British executed Operation Appearance which was staged from Aden; two battalions from the Indian Army and one Somali commando detachment were landed on both sides of Berbera. The two Sikh battalions (which had been part of the defending force evacuated in August 1940), made the first successful Allied landing on an enemy-held beach during World War II. Shortly afterwards the British and Indians re-captured the whole of British Somaliland from its Italian occupiers.
The campaign in Somaliland was like most of the others of the Axis: it initially started with a victory, then after a period of time (like the campaigns in the Balkans, in the Philippines or in Russia), finished with a complete defeat. But in the specific case of the Italian conquest of British Somaliland, the defeat (that happened in spring 1941) was followed by nearly two years of Italian guerrilla warfare.
Other observations are:
- The invasion of British Somaliland showed that Italian forces could co-ordinate columns separated by many miles of desert.
- British forces showed good discipline in the retreat and were able to salvage most of their forces.
- The invasion of British Somaliland was the first campaign the Italians won in World War II.
- British Somaliland was the first British colony to fall to enemy forces in World War II.
- After the first months of the war were over, Mussolini boasted that Italy had conquered a territory (made of British Somaliland, the Sudan area around the border outposts of Karora, Gallabat, Kurmak and Kassala, and the area in Kenya around Moyale and Buna) the size of England in the Horn of Africa.
- The campaign of British Somaliland in August 1940 was the only one in which the British army could not get strong support from the Royal Air Force, showing the importance of the air forces in the Allies' victories.
- East African Campaign (World War II)
- Eric Charles Twelves Wilson, awarded the Victoria Cross for actions at Observation Hill
- Hugh Sweeny, captured at Tug Argan and one of the first Australian prisoners of World War II
- Italian Empire
- According to Wavell the total casualties of the British forces (including Indian and African troops) of 258 amounted to "...little more than five per cent of the force." This implies a total force of about 5,000. Molinari's book estimates the British forces at 11,000 but it can normally be assumed that Italian sources are more accurate for Italian forces and British sources for British forces.
- According to Wavell almost half the casualties were from the Northern Rhodesia Regiment and he believed that the great majority of the missing had been killed. It subsequently transpired that most of the missing had been taken prisoner.
- Lieutenant-General Luigi Frusci, commander of the Italian East Africa Northern Sector, wrote in his memoirs that the Somalis fighting as "armed Bands" on the Italian side suffered two thousand casualties. He stated that the most popular local tribal chief of British Somaliland greeted the Italians after the conquest of Zeila and offered him his men against the British.
- Unofficially, De Simone estimated that nearly one thousand irregular Somalis fighting against the Italian invasion were casualties during the campaign. These armed men operated as local "Bande", with only minimal control from British officers (like Brigadier Chater).
- Despite the terms of the armistice between France, Germany and Italy, the Viceroy remained suspicious of the intentions of the French in French Somaliland because of the activities of the Gaullist Major-General Paul Legentilhomme there.
- A "tug" is the local name for a dry sandy river bed.
- The photo of this tribal chief can be seen by following this link. His picture is in the third row from the bottom next to the photo of General Frusci.
- Wavell, p. 2725.
- Molinari (2007), p. 115
- Stone, Bill (1998). "The Invasion of British Somaliland. The Aftermath". Stone & Stone Second World War Books. Retrieved 2008-06-08.
- Collins, D. J. E. "The Royal Indian Navy, 1939–1945". ibiblio. HyperWar Foundation. Retrieved 7 July 2014.
- Molinari (2007), p. 117
- Maravigna (1949), p. 453.
- Rovighi (1952), p. 188
- Playfair (1954), p. 174
- Mackenzie (1951), p. 23
- Playfair (1954), p. 172
- Playfair (1954), p. 173
- Mockler (1984), pp. 243–45.
- Mackenzie (1951), p. 22
- Original Video of the Italian conquest of British Somaliland (in Italian)
- Del Boca (1986), p. 74
- Playfair (1954), pp. 167–168
- Playfair (1954), p. 175
- Playfair (1954), p. 176
- Playfair (1954), p. 177
- The Abyssinian Campaigns, p. 19.
- Collins, 39–40
- Wavell, p. 2724
- Playfair (1954), p. 178
- Collins, 40
- Rovighi (1952), p. 138
- Mockler (1984), pp. 245–49.
- Rovighi (1952), p. 49
- Playfair (1954), pp. 178–179
- Mockler (1984), p. 251.
- Jackson, Ashley (2006). The British Empire and the Second World War. London: Hambledon Continuum. p. 211. ISBN 978-1-85285-517-8.
- Rohwer & Hümmelchen (1992), p. 54
- Little Dunkirk
- Antonicelli (1961),[page needed]
- Abdisalam, Mohamed Issa-Salwe (1996). The Collapse of the Somali State: The Impact of the Colonial Legacy. London: Haan Associates. ISBN 9781874209911.
- Antonicelli, Franco (1961). Trent'anni di storia italiana 1915 – 1945 (in Italian). Torino: Mondadori ed.
- Del Boca, Angelo (1986). Italiani in Africa Orientale: La caduta dell'Impero (in Italian). Roma-Bari: Laterza. ISBN 88-420-2810-X
- Ferrara, Orazio. La battaglia di Tug Argan Pass (La conquista del Somaliland britannico). in Eserciti nella Storia, Anno VI, n° 32, 2005.
- Mackenzie, Compton (1951). Eastern Epic. London: Chatto & Windus.
- Maravigna, General Pietro (1949). Come abbiamo perduto la guerra in Africa. Le nostre prime colonie in Africa. Il conflitto mondiale e le operazioni in Africa Orientale e in Libia. Testimonianze e ricordi (in Italian). Roma: Tipografia L’Airone.
- Mockler, Anthony (1984). Haile Selassie's War: The Italian-Ethiopian Campaign, 1935–1941. New York: Random House. ISBN 0-394-54222-3
- Molinari, Andrea (2007). La conquista dell'Impero. 1935–1941 La guerra in Africa Orientale. Collana Saggi storici (Historical Essays series) (in Italian). Milan: Hobby & Work. ISBN 9788878515147.
- Playfair, Major-General I.S.O.; with Stitt R.N., Commander G.M.S.; Molony, Brigadier C.J.C. & Toomer, Air Vice-Marshal S.E. (2004) [1st. pub. HMSO 1954]. Butler, J.R.M, ed. The Mediterranean and Middle East, Volume I The Early Successes Against Italy (to May 1941). History of the Second World War, United Kingdom Military Series. Naval & Military Press. ISBN 1-84574-065-3.
- Rohwer, Jürgen; Hümmelchen, Gerhard (1992) . Chronology of the war at sea, 1939–1945: the naval history of World War Two (in German) (2nd, rev. exp. ed.). Annapolis, MD: Naval Institute Press. ISBN 1-55750-105-X.
- Rovighi, Alberto (1952). Le Operazioni in Africa Orientale (in Italian). Roma: Stato Maggiore Esercito,Ufficio storico.
- UK Ministry of Information (1942). Tha Abyssinian campaigns; the official story of the conquest of Italian East Africa. London: HMSO. OCLC 184818818.
- Wavell, Archibald, Operations in the Somaliland Protectorate, 1939–1940 (Appendix A – G. M. R. Reid and A.R. Godwin-Austen) published in The London Gazette: . 4 June 1946. Retrieved 2009-12-05.
- "Archibald Wavell's Despatch on Operations in the Somaliland Protectorate, 1939–1940 (Appendix A – G. M. R. Reid and A.R. Godwin-Austen)." (PDF). Supplement to the London Gazette, Number 37594. 4 June 1946. Retrieved 5 December 2009.
- Official Italian "Bulletins of War" on the conquest of British Somaliland (in Italian)
- Photos of the Italian conquest of Somaliland
- Maps and articles on the war in Italian East Africa (in Italian)
- WWII in the Italian colonies (in Italian)