Early life and conversion
Born at Great Marlow, in the county of Buckinghamshire, and christened James Robert, Hope was the third son of General Sir Alexander Hope and a grandson of John Hope, 2nd Earl of Hopetoun. After a childhood spent at the Royal Military College, Sandhurst, of which his father was Governor, he was educated at Eton College and Christ Church, Oxford, where he was a contemporary and friend of William Ewart Gladstone and John Henry Newman. In 1838 Hope was called to the bar at Lincoln's Inn. Between 1840 and 1843 he helped to found Trinity College, Glenalmond. In 1840-1841 he spent some eight months in Italy, Rome included, in company with his close friend Edward Louth Badeley.
On his return he became, with Newman, one of the foremost promoters of the Tractarian movement at Oxford and was entirely in Newman's confidence. In 1841, he published an attack on the Anglican-German Bishopric in Jerusalem, and further defended the "value of the science of canon law, in a pamphlet. Edward Bouverie Pusey also valued Hope's advice and canvassed him in 1842 before publishing the Letter to the Archbishop of Canterbury on some Circumstances connected with the Present Crisis in the Church. Hope supported publication.
Along with other Anglo-Catholics, Hope was disturbed by the Gorham judgment, and on 12 March 1850 a meeting was held at his house in Curzon Street, London, which was attended by fourteen leading Tractarians, including Badeley, Henry Edward Manning, and Archdeacon Robert Isaac Wilberforce. They eventually published a series of resolutions which started the process of distancing Hope, Badeley, Manning and Wilberforce from the Anglican Church.
On 15 June 1841, Hope wrote to Gladstone:
My reason for staying in town is to read ecclesiastical law, and to prepare (if so be) for election committees. The former branch I reckon my flower-garden, the latter my cabbage-field.
Ormsby believed that Hope found some distraction from his frustration with the Anglican Church through his secular work.
By 1839, Hope was becoming involved in parliamentary work. He was retained as counsel for the British government on the Foreign Marriages Bill and in 1843, the report on the Consular Jurisdiction Bill. His brother's appointment as Under Secretary of State for the Colonies in Sir Robert Peel's administration may have opened some doors. In 1843-44 he was engaged again by the government in the matter of the aftermath of the Pastry War, whose settlement Britain had arbitrated, to prepare a report on some points in dispute between France and Mexico.
As an established ecclesiastical lawyer, he was much involved in the Ecclesiastical Courts Bill in 1843 and the same year he took the DCL degree at Oxford. In 1844 an English Criminal Code was under serious consideration and Bishop of London Charles James Blomfield recommended Hope to the Lord Chancellor John Copley, 1st Baron Lyndhurst as a commissioner to consider offences against religion and the Church. By the end of 1845 he stood at the head of the parliamentary bar but his objections to taking the Oath of Supremacy deterred him from accepting the professional honour of Queen's Counsel. In 1849, he therefore asked Lord Chancellor Charles Pepys, 1st Earl of Cottenham for, and was granted, a patent of precedence conferring equal status.
In 1852 he gave Newman the disastrously misleading legal advice that he was unlikely to be sued for libel by Giacinto Achilli, advice which ultimately led to Newman's criminal conviction for defamatory libel. Thereafter, Newman relied on Badeley for legal advice, though in 1855 Hope-Scott conducted the negotiations which ended in Newman's accepting the rectorship of the Catholic University of Ireland.
Personal and family life
In 1847 Hope married Charlotte Harriet Jane Lockhart, daughter of John Gibson Lockhart and granddaughter of Sir Walter Scott, and six years later, on her coming into possession of Scott's Abbotsford House estate, he assumed the surname of Hope-Scott. His wife died on 26 October 1858, and in 1861 he married as his second wife Lady Victoria Fitzalan-Howard, a daughter of the 14th Duke of Norfolk. Hope-Scott retired from the bar in 1870 and spent the rest of his life in charitable and literary work, in particular in making an abridgment of his father-in-law's seven-volume biography of Scott, with a preface dedicated to Gladstone. Hope-Scott maintained a lifelong correspondence with Badeley.
Both of his wives died in childbirth. He left an only daughter by his first marriage, Mary Monica (born 2 October 1852), later wife of Joseph Constable Maxwell, third son of William, Lord Herries. Two other children of this marriage died in infancy. By his second marriage he left a son, James Fitzalan Hope (1870–1949), who was created Baron Rankeillour, and three daughters. Two other children of the second marriage also died young.
- [Anon.] (1911) "James Hope-Scott", Encyclopædia Britannica
- Boothman (1913)
- Ornsby (1884) Ch.XVIII
- Hope (1842)
- Browne, E. G. K. (1861). Annals of the Tractarian Movement, from 1842 to 1860 (3rd ed.). London: privately published. p. 191.
- Ornsby (1884) Ch.XXI
- Ornsby (1884) Ch.XXII
- Courtney (2004)
- [Anon.] (1911) "John Gibson Lockhart", Encyclopædia Britannica
- Murphy (2006)
- Lockhart (1871)
- [Anon.] (1911) "James Robert Hope-Scott", Encyclopædia Britannica
- Herbermann, Charles, ed. (1913). "James Robert Hope-Scott". Catholic Encyclopedia. New York: Robert Appleton Company.
- Courtney, W. P., rev. G. Martin Murphy (2004) "Badeley, Edward Lowth (1803/4–1868)", Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, accessed 22 July 2007 (subscription or UK public library membership required)
- Hope, J. R. (1842). The Bishopric of the United Church of England and Ireland at Jerusalem, Considered in a Letter to a Friend (2nd ed. revised ed.). London: C. J. Stewart.
- Lockhart, J. G.; ed. J. R. Hope-Scott (1871). The Life of Sir Walter Scott, Bart. Edinburgh: Adam & Charles Black.
- Murphy, G. M. (2006) "Scott, James Robert Hope- (1812–1873)", Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, online edn, accessed 23 July 2007 ((ODNBsub))
- Ormsby, R. (ed.) (1884). Memoirs of James Robert Hope-Scott, with Selections from His Correspondence (2 vols. ed.). London: John Murray.