James Maxton

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

James Maxton
MP
James Maxton.jpg
Member of Parliament
for Glasgow Bridgeton
In office
15 November 1922 – 23 July 1946
Preceded by Alexander MacCallum Scott
Succeeded by James Carmichael
Personal details
Born (1885-06-22)22 June 1885
Pollokshaws, Glasgow, Scotland
Died 23 July 1946(1946-07-23) (aged 61)
Nationality Scottish
Political party Labour (until 1932)
ILP (1932–1946)

James Maxton (22 June 1885 – 23 July 1946) was a Scottish left-wing politician, and leader of the far-left faction of the Independent Labour Party.[1] He was a pacifist who opposed both world wars. A prominent proponent of Home Rule for Scotland,[2][3] he is remembered as one of the leading figures of the Red Clydeside era. He broke with Ramsay MacDonald and the second minority Labour government, and became one of its most bitter critics. As the leader of the Independent Labour Party (ILP), he disaffiliated the ILP from the mainstream party in 1932. After that he was a marginal independent figure on the far left-wing.

Biography[edit]

Early years[edit]

Born in the then burgh of Pollokshaws (now Pollok, Glasgow) in 1885, James Maxton was the son of two schoolteachers. He would himself later enter that profession after his education at Hutchesons' Grammar School and the University of Glasgow.

Maxton had whilst studying at the University of Glasgow described his political loyalties as lying with the Conservatives. He soon came to socialism, however, and in 1904 he joined the Barrhead branch of the Independent Labour Party (ILP). Maxton's move to socialism was heavily influenced by John Maclean, a fellow student at Glasgow University. In addition to Maclean's influence, Maxton was moved towards socialism by a meeting which he attended in Paisley which was addressed by party leader Philip Snowden. He was also influenced by the written word, including books by Robert Blatchford and Peter Kropotkin.[4]

Later in life Maxton claimed that the biggest influence in his decision to become a socialist was the grinding poverty experienced by many of the children he taught. He subsequently convinced all his siblings to join the ILP, with his sister Annie becoming a prominent figure in the organisation.

From 1906 to 1910 Maxton was active in the Schoolmasters' Union, where he refined his talents as a propagandist and orator."[5]

Political career[edit]

Campaign leaflet from Maxton's first unsuccessful bid for parliament, 1918.

Maxton was known as an effective public speaker. Historian Robert Keith Middlemas offers this vivid description:

He was well-known as a platform orator with a thin hatchet face and mane of long black hair which fell across his face giving it a saturnine and piratical appearance, but although he was an established speaker and propagandist for the ILP, his considerable intellect had been somewhat masked by the showman's facility. The genuine hero-worship which grew around him was restricted to his native Barrhead where the ILP branch was his private preserve.[6]

Maxton was a vociferous opponent of World War I. He was a conscientious objector, refusing conscription into the military, and instead being given work on barges. During this time he was involved in organizing strikes in the shipyards as part of the Clyde Workers' Committee. Maxton was arrested in 1916, charged with sedition. He was subsequently found guilty and imprisoned for a year.[7]

In 1918 Maxton was elected to the National Council of the Labour Party.[8] He and Ramsay MacDonald were responsible for moving the motion at the Labour Party's National Executive Committee which dictated that Labour members of the wartime coalition government resign from it in preparation for the 1918 general election. He was also a keen supporter of Scottish Home Rule and was for a while the President of The Scottish Home Rule Association when Ramsay MacDonald was the Secretary of the London Branch.

Maxton stood for parliament in the 1918 general election as a Labour Party candidate but was defeated in this first effort.

In his next electoral attempt Maxton was successful, winning a seat as Member of Parliament (MP) for Glasgow Bridgeton in the 1922 general election. Once in parliament, however, Maxton's forthright views often caused controversy. In 1923 his parliamentary privileges were withdrawn temporarily when he called the Conservative MP Sir Frederick Banbury a "murderer", following the government's decision to withdraw school milk. When Ramsay MacDonald, with whom Maxton had long since quarrelled, gave his last meandering, incoherent speech to Parliament, it was interrupted by Maxton calling out: "Sit down, man, you're a bloody tragedy."

Maxton was chairman of the ILP from 1926 to 1931, and from 1934 to 1939; he was generally seen as the symbol of the ILP after its break from Labour in 1932. A militant socialist, he was horrified by the perceived class collaborationism of the Trades Union Congress after the defeat of the 1926 General Strike, and was co-author with the left-wing Miners leader, Arthur Cook, of the "Cook-Maxton Manifesto" of 1928 calling for class warfare in the overthrow of capitalism.

In 1932, Maxton published a popular biography of Bolshevik leader V. I. Lenin. Maxton wrote of him: "We are still too near to [Lenin] in time, too close to the happenings incidental to his work, too much under the influence of partisan antipathies or sympathies to venture final assessments. It is not yet possible to say that Russia has in practice realised the Utopian state of plenty, of liberty and of happiness, nor is it possible to say that other countries may not reach a better state in speedier and less harsh ways. It is possible to say that this man, quiet, unassuming, unimposing, set himself a task of immense size when still a boy, and stuck to it tenaciously to the end of his life."[9]

In 1936, following the abdication of Edward VIII, Maxton proposed a "republican amendment" to the Abdication Bill, which would have turned the UK from a monarchy into a republic. Maxton argued that while the Monarchy had benefited Britain in the past, it had now "outlived its usefulness." The amendment was defeated by 403 votes to five.[10]

In his diary for 3 September 1939 Sir Ralph Glyn reports that "James Maxton, the pacifist, rose, gaunt, a Horseman from the Apocalypse, doom written across his face," and declared, "Don't let's talk of national honour: what do such phrases mean? The plain fact is that war means the slaughter of millions. If the Prime Minister can still maintain the peace, he will have saved those lives, he mustn't be rushed."[11]

During the Second World War Maxton visited Brixton Prison to talk with Oswald Mosley, the leader of the British Union of Fascists, who was then being detained under the Defence Regulations.

Death and legacy[edit]

Maxton died in 1946, still sitting as MP for Bridgeton. After his death the ILP stagnated until it ceased to be a viable independent political party.

Maxton was considered one of the greatest orators of the time, both within and outside the House of Commons. Churchill, whilst holding political opinions wholly inconsistent with those of Maxton, described him as "the greatest parliamentarian of his day". His biographer Graham Walker concludes:

Maxton was one of the most charismatic figures in twentieth-century British public life. He was essentially a Scottish radical whose propagandist skills for the wider British labour movement have earned him folk hero status in socialist circles.[12]

Maxton heavily influenced his family's political opinions, and his mother and all his siblings also joined the ILP. His brother John was also a conscientious objector in the First World War. His son James and his nephew John Maxton were conscientious objectors to National Service after the Second World War. John went on to become Labour MP for the Cathcart division of Glasgow from 1979 to 2001 and was made a life peer in 2004.

Gordon Brown, former British Prime Minister, has published a biography, Maxton, based on his PhD thesis at the University of Edinburgh.

Footnotes[edit]

  1. ^ Peter Ackers; Alastair J. Reid (2016). Alternatives to State-Socialism in Britain: Other Worlds of Labour in the Twentieth Century. Springer. p. 195. 
  2. ^ Knox, William (1987). James Maxton. Manchester University Press. p. 49. Retrieved 2009-10-10. 
  3. ^ "Letter from the Scottish Home Rule Association to James Maxton, 16 Nov 1922". Glasgow Digital Library. Centre for Digital Library Research, University of Strathclyde. Retrieved 2009-10-10. 
  4. ^ Robert Keith Middlemas, The Clydesiders: A Left Wing Struggle for Parliamentary Power. London: Hutchinson & Co., 1965. Page 48.
  5. ^ Middlemas, The Clydesiders, pg. 48.
  6. ^ Middlemas, The Clydesiders, pp. 47–48.
  7. ^ "James Maxton", Spartacus Educational, Retrieved 7 September 2009.
  8. ^ Middlemas, The Clydesiders, pg. 106.
  9. ^ Maxton, James (2018). Lenin: A Biography (PDF). Scottish Socialist Party. 
  10. ^ Denis Judd, George VI. London, IB Tauris, 2012. ISBN 9781780760711 (p.157).
  11. ^ The Mammoth Book of How It Happened, ed. Jon E. Lewis, London: Robinson, 2000, p. 399
  12. ^ Walker (2011)

Publications by James Maxton[edit]

  • A Living Wage for All: Dr. Salter's Speech in the House of Commons on Wednesday, March 7, 1923. London: Bermondsey Independent Labour Party, 1923.
  • The Left Wing: Its Programme and Activities. London: National Left Wing Provisional Committee, n.d. [c. 1926].
  • Twenty Points for Socialism. London: ILP Publication Department, n.d. [c. 1927].
  • Our Case for a Socialist Revival. With A.J. Cook. London : Workers' Publications, n.d. [c. 1928].
  • The Roads to Socialism: Chairman's Address at the ILP Conference. London: ILP Publication Department, 1929.
  • The Case of Benn v. Maxton: Being a Correspondence on Capitalism and Socialism, to which is Appended the Report of a Broadcast Debate. With Ernest John Pickstone Benn. London: E. Benn, 1929.
  • Speech on the Government's Unemployment Proposals in the House of Commons 4 November 1929. London: ILP Publication Department, n.d. [1929].
  • Where the ILP Stands: Presidential Address of J. Maxton to the ILP Conference, together with the Declaration on the Relation of the ILP to the Labour Party. London: ILP Publication Department, 1930.
  • Lenin. New York: D. Appleton & Co., 1932.
  • Widespread Poverty: "The Existing Social Order Must Go." London: Independent Labour Party, 1933.
  • A Clear Lead. With Fenner Brockway. London: Independent Labour Party, 1933.
  • Keir Hardie: Prophet and Pioneer. London: F. Johnson, n.d. [c. 1933].
  • Dictators and Dictatorship. London: Independent Labour Party, n.d. [c. 1934].
  • If I Were Dictator. London: Methuen, 1935.
  • The Unity Campaign. With Stafford Cripps and Harry Pollitt. London : National Unity Campaign Committee, 1937.
  • Maxton's Great Anti-War Speech. Glasgow : Civic Press, n.d. [1939].
  • Why We Oppose Conscription. London: Independent Labour Party, n.d. [1939].
  • Break Truce with Tories and Build Labour Unity! A Statement for Consideration by Men and Women of the Labour Movement. With Fenner Brockway. n.c. [London]: Independent Labour Party, n.d. [1943].

Further reading[edit]

  • Gordon Brown: Maxton: A Biography. n.c.: Mainstream Publishing Co., 1986.
  • Robert E. Dowse: Left in the Centre: The Independent Labour Party 1893–1940. London: Longman's, 1966.
  • Robert Keith Middlemas, The Clydesiders: A Left Wing Struggle for Parliamentary Power. London: Hutchinson & Co., 1965.
  • Graham Walker, "Maxton, James (1885–1946)", Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, 2004; online edn, Jan 2011 accessed 2 Aug 2016

External links[edit]

Parliament of the United Kingdom
Preceded by
Alexander MacCallum Scott
Member of Parliament for Glasgow Bridgeton
19221946
Succeeded by
James Carmichael
Political offices
Preceded by
Clifford Allen
Chairman of the Independent Labour Party
1926–1931
Succeeded by
Fenner Brockway
Preceded by
Fenner Brockway
Chairman of the Independent Labour Party
1934–1939
Succeeded by
C. A. Smith