John Crichton-Stuart, 3rd Marquess of Bute
John, 3rd Marquess of Bute
|Born||12 September 1847|
Mount Stuart, Scotland, United Kingdom
|Died||9 October 1900(aged 53)|
|Buried||Isle of Bute; Mount of Olives, Jerusalem|
|Residence||Mount Stuart House|
|Parents||John, 2nd Marquess|
Lady Sophia Rawdon-Hastings
Succeeding to the marquisate at the age of only six months, his vast inheritance reportedly made him the richest man in the world. His conversion to Catholicism from the Church of Scotland at the age of 21 scandalised Victorian society and led Prime Minister Benjamin Disraeli to use the Marquess as the basis for the eponymous hero of his novel Lothair, published in 1870. Marrying into one of Britain's most illustrious Catholic families, Bute became one of the leaders of the British Catholic community. His enormous expenditure on building and restoration made him the foremost architectural patron of the 19th century.
Lord Bute died in 1900, at the age of only 53; his heart was buried on the Mount of Olives in Jerusalem. He was a Knight Grand Cross of the Holy Sepulchre, Knight of the Order of St. Gregory the Great and Hereditary Keeper of Rothesay Castle.
The future Marquess was born at the family seat of Mount Stuart, on the Isle of Bute in Scotland, to John, 2nd Marquess of Bute, and Lady Sophia Rawdon-Hastings (daughter of The 1st Marquess of Hastings, an Anglo-Irish peer from Ulster). For the first nearly six months of his life, he was known as the Earl of Dumfries. The Crichton-Stuarts were illegitimate offspring of the Scottish royal House of Stuart, ennobled in the 17th century. The foundations of the family's fortunes were laid by John, 3rd Earl of Bute, Prime Minister to King George III, who married an heiress, Mary Wortley-Montagu, and attained great political prominence, although this was not accompanied by great political success. His son, John, 1st Marquess of Bute, out-stripped his father by marrying two heiresses, Charlotte Hickman, daughter of The 2nd Viscount Windsor, and Frances Coutts, of the Coutts banking dynasty. By his first marriage, the Marquess fathered John Stuart who in turn fathered John, 2nd Marquess of Bute, the founder of modern Cardiff and father of the 3rd Marquess. The 2nd Marquess was a far-sighted early industrialist and began, at great financial risk, the development of Cardiff as a port to export the mineral wealth of the South Wales Valleys. Accumulating great debts and mortgages on his admittedly vast estates, the Marquess rightly foresaw the potential of Cardiff, telling his concerned solicitor in 1844, "I am willing to think well of my income in the distance." The following fifty years saw his faith triumphantly vindicated, but the ensuing riches were to be enjoyed, and spent, by his son, "the richest man in the world", rather than himself.
The 2nd Marquess died in 1848 and his son succeeded to the Marquessate when less than six months old. He was educated at Harrow School and Christ Church, Oxford. His mother died when he was twelve. Bute had been attracted to the Roman Catholic Church since childhood, and the efforts of his guardians to weaken this attraction only added to it. He was never a member of the Church of England, despite efforts by Henry Parry Liddon to attract him to it. Bute's letters to one of his very few intimate friends during his Oxford career show with what conscientious care he worked out the religious question for himself. On 8 December 1868, he was received into the Church by Monsignor Capel at a convent in Southwark, and a little later was confirmed by Pius IX in Rome, resulting in a public scandal. His conversion was the inspiration for Benjamin Disraeli's novel, Lothair.
Lord Bute's eclectic early education gave him a lifelong interest in architecture, and his father's accumulated wealth was to give him the means to indulge this interest on a stupendous scale. He came to love scholarly research, and wrote on the Celtic and mediaeval periods. But it would be entirely wrong to view the 3rd Marquess as a dilettante; his interests were serious, scholarly and profound.
The Marquess's vast range of interests, which included religion, medievalism, the occult, architecture, travelling, linguistics, and philanthropy, filled his relatively short life. A prolific writer, bibliophile and traveller, as well as, somewhat reluctantly, a businessman, his energies were on a monumentally Victorian scale. "A liturgist and ecclesiologist of real distinction", he published on a wide range of topics. But at a distance, just over one hundred years from his death, it is his architectural patronage as "the greatest builder of country houses in nineteenth-century Britain" that creates his lasting memorial.
In 1865, the Marquess met William Burges and the two embarked on an architectural partnership, the results of which long outlasted Burges' own death in 1881. Bute's desires and money allied with Burges' fantastical imagination and skill led to the creation of two of the finest examples of the late Victorian era Gothic Revival, Cardiff Castle and Castell Coch. The two buildings represent both the potential of colossal industrial wealth and the desire to escape the scene of that wealth's creation. The theme recurs again and again in the huge outpouring of Bute's patronage, in chapels, castle, abbeys, universities and palaces. Bute's later buildings are hardly less remarkable than his collaborations with Burges. Robert Rowand Anderson rebuilt the Georgian Mount Stuart House for him, and Bute worked in collaboration with many of Burges's colleagues, including William Frame and Horatio Walter Lonsdale, on the interiors. John Kinross was Bute's architect for the sympathetic and creative reworking of the partially ruined Falkland Palace. Kinross also restored Greyfriars in Elgin for Bute.
The Marquess's patronage was extensive, with a particular enthusiasm for buildings of religion and academia. Whilst Rector of the University of St Andrews, he provided the University with a new home for its Medical School and endowed the Bute Chair of Medicine. A supporter of education for women, he also paid for St Andrews University's first female lecturer, who taught anatomy to women medical students when Professor James Bell Pettigrew refused to do so. At the University of Glasgow, he gifted the funds required to complete the University's huge central hall, named the Bute Hall in his honour, and he is commemorated both at the University's Commemoration Day and on its Memorial Gates. He was made the Honorary President (Scottish Gaelic: Ceannard Urramach a' Chomainn) of the Highland Society of the University of Edinburgh.
In 1866 he donated a site in Cardiff Docks for the Hamadryad Hospital Ship for sick seafarers and, on his death in 1900, bequeathed £20,000 towards the cost of a new bricks-and-mortar hospital, which became the Royal Hamadryad.
The Marquess of Bute's Case
The Marquess was involved in a notable company law case, known as "the Marquess of Bute's Case", reported on appeal in 1892, called Re Cardiff Savings Bank  2 Ch 100. The Marquess had been appointed to the board of directors of the Cardiff Savings Bank as "President", at the age of six months, in effect inheriting the office from his father. He only attended one board meeting in the next 38 years. When the bank became insolvent following a fellow director's fraudulent dealing, Stirling J held that the Marquess was not liable as he knew nothing of what was going on. It was not suggested that he ought to have known what was going on, or that he had a duty of care to inform himself as to the affairs of the bank. The case set a famous legal precedent, now superseded, for the minimal view of the duties of company directors. It was naturally a considerable embarrassment for the Marquess, although he escaped legal blame.
- Lady Margaret Crichton-Stuart (24 December 1875 – 6 June 1954)
- John, 4th Marquess of Bute (20 June 1881 – 16 May 1947)
- Lord Ninian Edward Crichton-Stuart (15 May 1883 – 2 October 1915)
- Lord Colum Edmund Crichton-Stuart (3 April 1886 – 18 August 1957)
- John, Marquess of Bute (1911). Brendan's Fabulous Voyage. via Project Gutenberg
- The Roman Catholic Church; John, Marquess of Bute (transl) (1908) [1st pub in 1879]. The Roman breviary(1908) (New Rev ed.). Edinburgh and London: William Blackwood and Sons.CS1 maint: uses authors parameter (link) via The Internet Archive
Lord Bute died on 9 October 1900 after a protracted illness (Bright's disease), his first stroke having occurred in 1896, and was buried in a small chapel on the Isle of Bute, his ancestral home. His heart was buried on the Mount of Olives in Jerusalem.
In his will he left £100,000 to each of his children, with the exception of his eldest son, who inherited the Bute estates including Cardiff Castle and the family seat, Mount Stuart House on the Isle of Bute, and Dumfries House in Ayrshire.
- Converts to Rome by Gordon Gorman 1885
- Hannah 2012, p. 3.
- Crook 2013, p. 231.
- Hannah 2012, p. ?.
- Davies 1981, p. 26.
- Cannadine 1992, p. 489.
- Hall 2009, p. 91.
- Girouard 1979, pp. 273-290.
- Girouard 1979, pp. 336-345.
- ""Lord" Mayor Of Cardiff". The Cardiff Times. 25 October 1890. p. 6 – via Welsh Newspapers Online.
- Lynn F. Pearson, Mausoleums, Shire Publications Ltd. (2002), page 39. ISBN 0 7478 0518 0
- "Lord Bute's Will - Bequest To The Seaman's Hospital - Explanation Of The Conditions". Western Mail. 19 October 1900. p. 5. Retrieved 10 December 2015 – via British Newspaper Archive.
- Llewelyn Davies, Sir William (1959). "Bute, marquesses of Bute, Cardiff Castle, etc". Dictionary of Welsh Biography. National Library of Wales. Retrieved 16 October 2020.
- Cannadine, David (1992). The Decline & Fall of the British Aristocracy. London, UK: Pan. ISBN 0-330-32188-9.CS1 maint: ref duplicates default (link)
- Crook, J. Mordaunt (2013). William Burges and the High Victorian Dream. London, UK: Francis Lincoln. ISBN 9780711233492.
- Davies, John (1981). Cardiff and the Marquesses of Bute. Cardiff, UK: University of Wales Press. ISBN 9780708324639.
- Girouard, Mark (1979). The Victorian Country House. New Haven, US: Yale University Press. ISBN 9780300023909.
The Victorian Country House.
- Hall, Michael (2009). The Victorian Country House: From The Archives of Country Life. London: Aurum Press Ltd. ISBN 978-1-84513-457-0.
- Hannah, Rosemary (2012). The Grand Designer: Third Marquess of Bute. Edinburgh, UK: Birlinn. ISBN 9781780270272.
- Hansard 1803–2005: contributions in Parliament by the Marquess of Bute
- Catholic Encyclopedia article
- Works by John Crichton-Stuart, 3rd Marquess of Bute at Project Gutenberg
- Works by or about John Crichton-Stuart, 3rd Marquess of Bute at Internet Archive
- K. D. Reynolds. "Stuart, John Patrick Crichton-, third marquess of Bute (1847–1900)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/26722. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
The Marquess of Dufferin and Ava
| Rector of the University of St Andrews
| Lord Lieutenant of Buteshire
|Peerage of Great Britain|
| Marquess of Bute