John P. Irish
John Powell Irish (1843–1923) was a leader of the Democratic Party in Iowa, a landowner in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta region of California, a fiery and influential public speaker, and an opponent of prejudice against Japanese, the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, women's suffrage and labor unions. He was, according to U.S. Interior Secretary Franklin K. Lane, "a fiery orator of the denunciatory type." He was reckoned as "a leader among editorial writers" of his generation.
Irish was born to Frederick Macy Irish and Elizabeth Ann Robinson on January 1, 1843, in Iowa City, Iowa, where he received a "common school" education. He was married to Anna (McClellan) Fletcher in 1875, and in 1880 they moved to California. One headline writer noted in 1899 that Irish at that time was "averse to wearing a necktie."
Irish was mentioned in three poems in Ambrose Bierce's book of poetry, Black Beetles in Amber (1892). In one poem, the narrator dies and goes to Hell, only to be surprised that the landscape is pleasant and attractive.
"Ah, no, this is not Hell," I cried;
"The preachers ne'er so greatly lied.
"This is Earth's spirit glorified!
"Good souls do not in Hades dwell,
"And, look, there's John P. Irish!" "Well,
The Voice said, "that's what makes it Hell."
Irish died at the age of eighty on October 6, 1923, from a fall while attempting to board a moving streetcar in Oakland, California. Honorary pallbearers at his funeral on October 9 in the Unitarian church in that city included former California governor George C. Pardee, George Shima (known as the Japanese "potato king") and Ng Poon Chew, Chinese editor. The officiating minister was Charles William Wendte.
Irish's first job as a seventeen-year-old was that of teacher. At age twenty-one he became editor of the Iowa City Press, where he remained for twenty years. He "developed such ability both as a writer and public speaker that he was soon recognized as one of the leaders of the Democratic party of the state." He was elected three times to represent Johnson County, Iowa, in the state's General Assembly, from 1869 to 1872.
He had, as a teacher, seen the harm of electing members of school boards on a partisan ticket, and was the author of the law changing the time of electing school officers from the general to a special election, thus taking their election our of partisan politics.
He was an elected regent of the State University of Iowa, and in 1871 was instrumental in securing the return of the corpse of a woman whose body had been stolen from a town cemetery and which resulting "resurrection affair" had been trumpeted by newspapers that attacked the "medical hyenas attending the University." But before the affair died down, two medical students, a janitor and Irish himself were arrested. A grand jury "declined to find any of them at fault."
In 1868, he was the unsuccessful Democratic candidate for Congress in the Fourth District. In 1877 he was the losing Democratic candidate for governor against Governor John H. Gear. He was also a trustee of the Iowa Soldiers' Orphans' Home.
As a newspaper publisher, fine public speaker, politician and leading citizen of unblemished name, he won attention and respect. With high qualifications for a brilliant political career, he never seemed to "hit things right." There was always something the matter. For various reasons, he "pulled up" and went to California. There he . . . had everything he wanted but political success. That always evaded him."
After 1888, Irish was a contributor to "the most comprehensive visual coverage of the Far West" then available — a printed work called Picturesque California and the Region West of the Rocky Mountains from Alaska to Mexico. In the chapter about the Sacramento Valley, for which he was responsible, "John P. Irish implicitly chides those who might denigrate the West by pointing out a wheat field in the irrigated Sacramento Valley nearly twice the size of Rhode Island and worth more than sixteen million dollars, the same amount the federal government paid Mexico in 1848 for California, Nevada, Utah, Arizona, and parts of Colorado and New Mexico."
He was the Democratic candidate for Congress in the 3rd Congressional District in 1890, losing to Joseph McKenna.
In 1893 Irish was a featured speaker at a Los Angeles meeting of the influential National Irrigation Congress, where he warned the delegates that "we should not look to a paternal government to irrigate our lands for us, but should encourage individual effort."
Irish, in Omaha, Nebraska, to speak at a meeting of the Jackson Club in January 1894, told a reporter that he and the "California people" were opposed to annexing the Kingdom of Hawaii because "We know the revolution there was simply a job, largely by those who robbed themselves rich in this country [the United States], and are trying to do the same thing" in Hawaii.
Irish helped found the State Home for the Adult Blind, where he was president of the governing board and for twenty-five years was a director. In 1912 the institution was investigated upon a charge that Irish had used one of the residents as a "sort of servant at the Irish home," but the claimant apologized to investigators appointed by Governor Hiram Johnson and shook hands with Irish. "Mr. Irish said the home stood as a model for such institutions, not only in the United States, but in European countries" the Associated Press reported.
Irish was one of the Democratic leaders who broke away from William Jennings Bryan over the latter's stand on a monetary system based on silver, and instead lobbied for a gold standard for U.S. currency. He was a member of the executive committee of the Monetary Congress organized in 1897 in Indianapolis, Indiana, to promote the gold standard. He opened a similar meeting in the same city in 1900.
In September and October 1895 Irish and Thomas V. Cator, who argued in favor of free silver, toured California with a series of debates on the question. The next year Irish attended the Democratic National Convention in Chicago but repudiated the national ticket headed by Bryan, whom he called a "raw man, who has achieved nothing in public or private life to fit him for the Presidency — a man who has won his reputation delivering orations at county fairs and Populist picnics." He called the Democratic platform "a league with larceny and a covenant with murder."
Opposed to unions
In October 1882, Irish, by then the "principal owner" of the Oakland Times, was attacked by a union printer who attempted to stab him while he was addressing a meeting. The man's anger was said to "have been caused by Mr. Irish employing in his newspaper office 'rats' and non-union printers."
In a 1906 address to the Starr King Fraternity of the First Unitarian Church of Oakland, Irish assailed "arrogant labor unions" for a rise in juvenile crime because they were "opposed to the apprenticeship of the American boy." "I now take the opportunity to say publicly that I never employ any one but a "scab," he added, "and in that way enter my protest against a system that is driving our young men into lives of idleness."
Organized labor has come to be a synonym for organized crime. Its principles are at war with American institutions and its practices are at war with the rights of man. You have suffered, and your men have fallen, as much in the cause of liberty as if you had been leading them on the battlefield. All honor to your high courage and to their memory.
Against votes for women
Irish gave many speeches in the early 'teens opposed to allowing women to vote. Typical was this 1911 speech reported in the San Francisco Chronicle:
The burden of the argument of Irish was that there could not be power without responsibility. Man was the voter because law primarily rested on the power to enforce the law. Woman could not serve on a posse comitatus or in the army. He did not think any one would want women to be locked up as jurors. There could not be power without responsibility. . . . Irish took the four suffrage states of Colorado, Wyoming, Utah and Idaho as horrible examples of what suffrage could bring about. Colorado had more juvenile delinquents in proportion to population than any other state because the women neglected their home duties to do politics, he said.
During the 1916 campaign for women's suffrage in Iowa, Irish came to Iowa from California to speak against a referendum that would adopt it, but suffragists uncovered favorable comments he had written about votes for women in his early years and circulated them widely. They also "reprinted his editorials written during the Civil War, in which his disloyalty to Lincoln and to the Union was shown. He was much disturbed by this publicity and soon left the State."
Favored Japanese and Chinese immigration
As an editor and agriculturalist, "Irish became concerned with the treatment of people of Japanese descent living in the United States and he wrote, spoke and acted on the behalf of these people for many years. He founded and organized the American Committee on Justice to further this cause."
Irish had no regard for Congressman Thomas J. Geary of San Francisco, who wrote the Geary Act of 1892, which extended the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 and added onerous new requirements for Chinese residents in the United States. In December 1907, Irish opened a campaign for repeal of the Exclusion Act with a speech at a gathering of California fruit growers in Marysville. He attacked "San Francisco and unionism" for the "vast injury of fruit interests and other industries in the interior."
In 1919 Irish published a pamphlet, Japanese Farmers in California, in which he repeated the remarks he had made to the 52nd convention of the California Fruit Growers and Farmers that year, saying that
When we treated our treaty with China as a scrap of paper and by the Geary Act excluded thirty thousand Chinese who were legally domiciled here, and by murdering and destroying the property of other Chinese, drove them out, there was created a shortage in farm labor, and this economic vacuum drew in the Japanese, who came protected by a solemn treaty between their government and ours. . . . Against this minute element many of our people are being lashed into a fury of apprehension, hatred and rage.
In 1920 he took on Senator James D. Phelan, who had been prominent in fostering anti-Japanese feeling in California. In a column in the Los Angeles Times, Irish wrote that
the present anti-Japanese agitation, like the anti-Chinese movement of years ago, has the same psychology as the Russian anti-Jewish pogrom, which always starts with the lie that Jews have murdered Christian children to use their blood in the rites of the synagogue. . . . Senator Phelan . . . has made no record of any benefit to the State in the Senate; so he must divert attention from his uselessness as a Senator by attacking the Japanese and trying to stampede the State by lying about them.
- Florin, California, for a statement by Irish about Japanese farmers
- Anne Wintermute Lane and Louise Herrick Wall, editors, The Letters of Franklin K. Lane, page 9
- "Joseph Eugene Baker," Past and Present of Alameda County, California, volume 2
- "John P. Irish," Keb/Irish Gazette, volume 2, issue 2, April 1, 1999
- Benjamin F. Gue, History of Iowa From the Earliest Times to the Beginning of the Twentieth Century
- John Powell Irish Papers, Biography, Stanford University
- The Keb/Irish Gazette, a genealogy site, says of Irish: "On November 8, 1875 he married Anna McClellan and had two sons, Frances on November 11, 1876 and John Peck on October 28, 1881." The site also says, "John later resumed the study and took up the practice of International Law. He was distinguished in appearance and of pleasing address, with a well-rounded figure of more than medium height, light hair, blue eyes and fair complexion." "John P. Irish," Keb/Irish Gazette, volume 2, issue 2, April 1, 1999 Another genealogy site gives similar information and adds that Irish "was Ambassador to Port of San Salvador." Linc & Teri Haymaker
- "Idaho's Governor Is Coming to This City," San Francisco Chronicle, August 19, 1899, page 14 Access to this link may be restricted.
- Misnamed as "Charles C. Pardee" in the source.
- "Funeral for Col. J.P. Irish Takes Place," Los Angeles Times, October 10, 1923, page 11 Access to this link requires the use of a library card.
- "Grave Robbers" at the University of Iowa Medical Museum site
- H.C. Parkhurst, "Western Newspaper Men," Nebraska History, pages 91 and 92
- "Col. Irish Talks," Los Angeles Times, October 13, 1893, page 2Access to this link requires the use of a library card.
- "A Journalist Assaulted," Los Angeles Times, November 1, 1882, page 1 Access to this link requires the use of a library card.
- Sue Rainey, "Picturesque California," Common-Place.org, volume 7, number 3, April 2007
- "Irrigation," Los Angeles Times, October 11, 1893, page 7 Access to this link requires the use of a library card.
- "John P. Irish," Los Angeles Times, January 8, 1894, page 3 Access to this link requires the use of a library card.
- Minutes, June 16, 1894
- Or the California Blind Directory Home, as one source named it. John Powell Irish Papers, Biography, Stanford University
- "Blind Asylum a Model," Los Angeles Times, December 19, 1912 page II-5 Access to this link requires the use of a library card.
- "The Monetary Convention, New York Times, January 12, 1897 Access to this link may require a subscription to the newspaper or its website.
- "Gold Democrats in Indiana," New York Times, September 28, 1900 Access to this link may require a subscription to the newspaper or its website.
- "Joint Debate on Money," San Francisco Call, September 25, 1895, page 7
- "John P. Irish Not a Dynamiter," New York Times, July 16, 1896 Access to this link may require a subscription to the newspaper or its website.
- "The Door of Opportunity," Los Angeles Times, February 4, 1906, page VII-4 Access to this link requires the use of a library card.
- "Cannot Doubt the Agency," Los Angeles Times, October 5, 1910, page 13 Access to this link requires the use of a library card.
- "Scores Union Exemption Law," Los Angeles Times, July 14, 914, page 13 Access to this link requires the use of a library card.
- "Suffragists Hiss John P. Irish," San Francisco Chronicle, August 30, 1911, page 2 Access to this link may be restricted.
- Ida Husted Harper, editor, The History of Woman Suffrage, volume 6
- "Fruit Growers Score Unions," Los Angeles Times, December 5, 1907, page 13 Access to this site requires the use of a library card.
- Text of the pamphlet from USArchive.org
- "Col Irish on the Japs," Los Angeles Times, August 30, 1920, page 15. Access to this site requires the use of a library card.