Death of Joy Gardner
|Date||1 August 1993|
|Location||Crouch End, north London|
|Cause||Cerebral hypoxia, cardiac arrest|
|Burial||Lavender Hill Cemetery, Enfield, north London.|
|Verdict||DC Burrell cleared on the orders of the judge.
DS Evans and DC Whitby found not guilty.
Joy Angelia Gardner (née Burke, 29 May 1953 – 1 August 1993) was a 40-year-old Jamaican mature student living as an undocumented migrant in London, England. She died following an attempt by police officers to detain her for deportation.
During a police raid on her home in Crouch End, London, she was restrained with handcuffs and leather straps and gagged with a 13-foot length of adhesive "Elastoplast" tape wrapped around her head. Unable to breathe, she collapsed and suffered brain damage due to asphyxia. She was placed on life support but died following a cardiac arrest four days later. In 1995, three of the police officers involved stood trial for Gardner's manslaughter, but were acquitted.
The case became a cause célèbre for civil rights and justice campaigners, and for the first time brought wide public attention to what the Modern Law Review called "the inhumanity of the methods used routinely in the execution of deportation orders". Despite continuing pressure by campaigners, no coroner's inquest or public inquiry into the circumstances of Gardner's death has been held.
Joy Gardner was born in Long Bay Beach, Jamaica, in May 1953. Her mother, Myrna Simpson, emigrated from Jamaica – then still a British colony – in 1961, with the intention of sending for her child once she had achieved some financial stability, a common and accepted practice at the time. Simpson subsequently became a British citizen. Prior to 1981, Gardner would have had the right to British citizenship through her mother, but changes to immigration legislation in the British Nationality Act 1981 meant this was no longer possible. As well as her mother, Gardner's half-brother, three uncles and two aunts were also living in England at the time.
Gardner first travelled to England in 1987, leaving an adult daughter behind in Jamaica. She entered the country legally using a six-month visitor's visa, but overstayed when the visa elapsed. She was pregnant at the time of her arrival, and subsequently gave birth to a son. In September 1990 she married Briton John Gardner, who applied to the Home Office for his new wife to be granted permanent residence. Five weeks later they separated and he withdrew the request.
In October 1990, Gardner was advised by the Home Office that she should leave the country voluntarily or risk deportation. In December 1990 she applied for a judicial review of her case which was turned down in April 1991. A notice of intention to deport was served on her in October 1991, which she subsequently appealed. During the appeal process a restriction order was applied requiring her to report regularly to local police. The Immigration Appeals Tribunal denied the appeal and a deportation order was issued in April 1992. Gardner was interviewed by immigration officials again in early June 1992, and reported to Stoke Newington police station later that month. A flight to Jamaica was arranged for Gardner in the summer of 1992, but she failed to attend at the airport, stating later that she had not received notification to do so, and her solicitor Djemal Dervish lodged a further appeal, citing "compelling compassionate circumstances."
While living in the UK Gardner moved home several times, but remained in contact with the police, her mother's local MP Bernie Grant and immigration services. By the summer of 1993 she was studying Media Studies at London Metropolitan University and living in a housing association home in Topsfield Close, Crouch End. On 28 July 1993 — the day the police raided Gardner's home — Dervish received 2 letters from the Home Office, dated 26 and 27 July. The first letter informed him that arrangements to deport his client would be made "shortly". The second stated that arrangements would be made "now". Charles Wardle, the immigration minister, later admitted that the letters were held back and timed to arrive after the raid to prevent any further judicial appeals being made and to avoid giving Gardner any notice of her deportation, which was to take place at 3.00pm the same day from Heathrow Airport.
Aliens Deportation Group
The Metropolitan Police Service's (MPS) Aliens Deportation Group (ADG) was a specialist squad of uniformed police officers belonging to Scotland Yard's Specialist Operations branch. The squad was composed of a Detective Inspector, a Detective Sergeant, and seven Detective Constables. They were tasked with accompanying immigration officers - who had no power of arrest - who were serving deportation orders where violent resistance by the deportee was considered probable. The squad operated in groups of three, with two officers then accompanying the deportee on their flights out of the country.
At 7.40 am on 28 July 1993, three officers from the ADG, accompanied by two officers from Hornsey police station and an official from the UK Immigration Service, raided Gardner's home with orders to "detain and remove" her and her 5-year old son for immediate deportation to Jamaica. The officers had with them a 4-inch wide restraint belt with attached handcuffs, and leather straps and rolls of adhesive tape to restrain her thighs and ankles. When Gardner resisted the officers' attempts to place her in the restraint belt, she was overpowered, shackled, gagged, and adhesive tape was also wrapped around her head and face. She suffered respiratory failure almost immediately and was taken to the Whittington Hospital, North London. She died on 1 August 1993 due to cerebral hypoxia and cardiac arrest, without regaining consciousness.
Cause of death
Gardner was examined by four forensic pathologists who concluded that the cause of death was cerebral hypoxia. As she had suffered a minor head injury during the struggle samples of brain tissue were subsequently examined by an independent neuropathologist to establish whether brain injury may have caused the hypoxia rather than asphyxiation as a direct result of the gag and tape. Two further tests were then conducted by independent neuropathologists who both dismissed the head injury as a factor.
On 15 May 1995, three police officers from the ADG stood trial accused of Gardner's manslaughter. A key part of the defence case was that Gardner's death was caused by head trauma sustained as she violently resisted the officers and not as a direct result of the tape used to gag her. Paula Lannas, a forensic pathologist, testified: "There were bruises on the scalp that indicates the head had struck a hard surface. The lack of oxygen was secondary to the head injury. The brain was injured. That led to deprivation of oxygen and death. Such a swelling would lead to cardiac arrest and the deprivation of oxygen." Experts for the prosecution and other pathologists disputed Lannas' findings.
On 2 June 1995, Detective Constable John Burrell was acquitted on the directions of the judge, Mr Justice Mantell. Detective Sergeant Linda Evans and Detective Constable Colin Whitby were found not guilty by the jury on 14 June 1995. Following the trial, the Police Complaints Authority announced that there would be no internal disciplinary inquiry. The PCA said that "a disciplinary charge of authority would in substance be the same as the criminal charge of which the officers have been acquitted" and "an officer cannot be tried on both criminal and discipline charges for the same offence".
In 1996, questions were raised about the work of Paula Lannas, the defence pathologist. During a trial at the Old Bailey in June 1998 she testified that bruising on the neck of a 16-month-old child "resulted from strangulation by the mother's boyfriend." The defendant was acquitted when forensic pathologist Iain West testified that the post mortem examination had been so "cack-handed" that the bruising may have been inflicted by Lannas, and the prosecution informed the jury that her conclusions were "suspect" and could not be relied on as evidence. In May 2000, two men had their convictions for manslaughter quashed when it was disclosed that Lannas had testified at their trial that the victim had been killed by a stab wound and had no other injuries. Subsequent examination found a potentially fatal skull fracture. A 2001 disciplinary tribunal alleged that Lannas's pathology work "consistently fell substantially short" of expected standards and there were "substantive deficiencies" in "her technical approach and medical knowledge."
In popular culture
The incident has been the subject of a number of poems including:
- Mills, Heather (7 March 1999). "A life without Joy". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 22 July 2015.
- Bowling & Phillips 2001, p. 131.
- Scraton & McCulloch 2006, p. 7.
- Chigwada-Bailey 2008, p. 126.
- "Death in Police Custody of Joy Gardner" (PDF). Amnesty International. 1 August 1995. EUR/45/05/95. Retrieved 22 December 2015.
- Young 1996, p. 70.
- Evans 2011, p. 107.
- Mansfield, Michael (Summer 2000). "Straw in the wind". Socialist Lawyer (32): 16–21.
- Harlow 1994, p. 624.
- "Unlawful Killing verdicts and prosecutions: 1995". Inquest. 8 July 2015. Retrieved 24 July 2015.
- Young 1996, p. 67.
- Young 1996, p. 68.
- Malik 1996, p. 38.
- "Joy Gardner: Case History". The Times (64713) (London). 3 August 1993. p. 3.
- Torode, John (3 August 1993). "When deportation means death: Joy Gardner died after police raided her home". The Independent (London). Retrieved 22 July 2013.
- Ford, Richard (15 June 1995). "Long search for a better life that ended in death". The Times (65294) (London). p. 3.
- Victor, Peter (20 March 1994). "Labour puts on the pressure for inquiry into death of Joy Gardner: Investigation of deportee case stalled by disputes". The Independent (London). Retrieved 22 December 2015.
- Cohen, Nick (8 August 1993). "Why did Joy Gardner die?". The Independent (London). Retrieved 22 July 2015.
- Young 1996, p. 69.
- Ford, Richard (3 August 1993). "Focus turns on aliens squad". The Times (64713) (London). p. 3.
- Duce, Richard (16 May 1995). "Police used 13ft of sticky tape to gag woman, court told". The Times (65268) (London). p. 3.
- Frost, Bill; Ford, Richard (4 August 1993). "Police suspended after deportation death". The Times (64714) (London). p. 1.
- Alibhai-Brown, Yasmin (9 January 2012). "We will repeat the past if we don't remember it". The Independent (London). Retrieved 23 July 2015.
- Ford, Richard (11 August 1993). "Joy Gardner died 'after form of suffocation'". The Times (64720) (London). p. 5.
- Johnstone, Helen (5 August 1993). "Mother claims police taped deportee's mouth". The Times (64715) (London). p. 3.
- "Jamaican dies after deportation collapse". The Times (64712) (London). 2 August 1993. p. 2.
- Kirby, Terry (12 December 1993). "Doubts delay inquiry into Joy Gardner's death". The Independent (London). Retrieved 23 December 2015.
- Wilson, Jamie (15 February 1999). "Joy Gardner's son issues writ over immigration case death". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 22 December 2015.
- "Joy Gardner 'was not killed by gag'". The Times (65274) (London). 23 May 1995. p. 8.
- Duce, Richard (3 June 1995). "Policeman cleared of suffocating Gardner". The Times (65284) (London). p. 3.
- Duce, Richard; Tendler, Stewart (15 June 1995). "Joy Gardner case police cleared of manslaughter". The Times (65294) (London). p. 1.
- "Gardner police in clear". The Times (65318) (London). 13 July 1995. p. 2.
- Haacke 1997, p. 37.
- Tendler, Stewart (13 January 1994). "Gardner death ends gagging of deportees". The Times (64851) (London). p. 5.
- Verkaik, Robert (31 January 2003). "Second pathologist under scrutiny after Clark case". The Independent (London). Retrieved 22 December 2015.
- Summers, Chris (25 January 2003). "Hopes grow for 'Rettendon Two'". BBC News. Retrieved 22 December 2015.
- Morris, Steven (25 April 2001). "Pathologist disciplinary case collapses". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 22 December 2015.
- "Pathologist's integrity dealt fatal blow". Inside Time (39). 2000. Retrieved 22 December 2015 – via Miscarriages of Justice UK.
- Morris, Steven (20 March 2001). "Expert witness's work 'deficient'". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 22 December 2015.
- "Joy Gardner's family sues police". BBC News. 15 February 1999. Retrieved 22 December 2015.
- Persoon, James; Watson, Robert R. (2013). Encyclopedia of British Poetry. New York: Facts on File. ISBN 978-1-438-14074-2.
- Lindsay, Maurice; Duncan, Lesley, eds. (2005). The Edinburgh Book of Twentieth-century Scottish Poetry. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. ISBN 978-0-748-62015-9.
- Bowling, Ben; Phillips, Coretta (2001). Race, Crime and Criminal Justice. Harlow: Pearson Education. ISBN 978-0-582-29966-5.
- Chigwada-Bailey, Ruth (2008). "Black women and the criminal justice system". In Evans, Karen; Jamieson, Janet. Gender and Crime: A Reader. Maidenhead: Open University Press. p. 126. ISBN 978-0-335-22523-1.
- Evans, Karen (2011). Crime Prevention: A Critical Introduction. London: Sage Publications. ISBN 978-1-847-87067-4.
- Haacke, Carl (1997). Cartner, Holly; PoKempner, Dinah; Laber, Jeri, eds. Racist Violence in the United Kingdom. New York City: Human Rights Watch. ISBN 978-1-564-32202-9.
- Harlow, Carol (1994). "Accidental Loss of an Asylum Seeker". Modern Law Review 57 (4): 620–626. doi:10.1111/j.1468-2230.1994.tb01963.x.
- Malik, Kenan (1996). The Meaning of Race: Race, History and Culture in Western Society. New York City: New York University Press. ISBN 978-0-814-75552-5.
- Scraton, Phil; McCulloch, Jude (2006). "Deaths in Custody and Detention". Social Justice 33 (4): 1–14.
- Young, Alison (1996). Imagining Crime. London: Sage Publications. ISBN 978-0-803-98623-7.
- "Justice Denied". Migrant Media. 1995. (50 minutes) Documentary about the case. Directed by Ken Fero. Retrieved 23 July 2015 – via Vimeo.