Juanita Broaddrick

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Juanita Broaddrick
Born (1942-12-13) December 13, 1942 (age 73)
United States
Residence Van Buren, Arkansas
Nationality American
Occupation Nursing home administrator
Spouse(s) Gary Hickey (divorced 1979)
David Broaddrick (married 1981 - divorced 2004)
Children Kevin Hickey (born, 1969 lawyer), grandson, two granddaughters

Juanita Broaddrick (born December 13, 1942)[citation needed] is an American former nursing home administrator. She alleged in 1999 that United States President Bill Clinton raped her in April 1978 when she was 35 years old and he was Arkansas Attorney General. President Clinton's attorney, David Kendall, denied the allegations on his client's behalf. Clinton declined to comment further on the issue.

Rumors circulated about Broaddrick's allegations for many years, but she refused to speak to the media. In a sworn statement in 1997 with the placeholder name "Jane Doe #5,"[1] Broaddrick filed an affidavit with Paula Jones' lawyers stating there were unfounded rumors and stories circulating "that Mr. Clinton had made unwelcome sexual advances toward me in the late seventies... These allegations are untrue".[2]

Nevertheless, speculation that Broaddrick had more to say on the matter persisted. Finally, in an interview with Dateline NBC that aired on February 24, 1999, Broaddrick told her story in public in full for the first time, this time stating that she had indeed been raped by Clinton.[3] It is the most serious of the allegations among the Bill Clinton sexual misconduct allegations that emerged during the 1990s.

Background[edit]

Broaddrick is from Van Buren, Arkansas, a town in the northwest part of the state.[1] She attended a nursing school[which?] and graduated from it.[when?][4] She then worked as a registered nurse at several nursing homes.[4][5] Around 1973 she decided she wanted to run a nursing home herself and so she bought one in Van Buren.[4][5]

Juanita Broaddrick was first married to Gary Hickey. They had a son who was born around 1969. At the time of the alleged 1978 rape, she was having an affair with David Broaddrick, who also was married to another person.[6]

Allegations against Bill Clinton[edit]

Her account[edit]

Broaddrick, who was known as Juanita Hickey at the time, first met Clinton when he made a visit to her nursing home during his 1978 gubernatorial campaign. Clinton was Arkansas Attorney General at the time. Broaddrick wanted to volunteer for the campaign, and says Clinton invited her to stop by the campaign office in Little Rock.[7] She contacted the office a few weeks later while in the area for a nursing home conference. Clinton said he would not be in the campaign office that day and suggested they meet at her hotel’s coffee shop instead. Upon his arrival, however, he allegedly requested that they instead have coffee in her room to avoid a crowd of reporters in the lobby. Broaddrick agreed.[3]

Broaddrick says the two spoke briefly in her room, with Clinton describing plans to renovate a prison visible from her window if he became governor. Then, according to Broaddrick, Clinton suddenly kissed her.[3] Broaddrick says she pushed Clinton away and told him she was married and not interested, but he persisted. As recounted in the NBC interview:[3]

Then he tries to kiss me again. And the second time he tries to kiss me he starts biting my lip … He starts to, um, bite on my top lip and I tried to pull away from him. And then he forces me down on the bed. And I just was very frightened, and I tried to get away from him and I told him ‘No,’ that I didn’t want this to happen but he wouldn’t listen to me. … It was a real panicky, panicky situation. I was even to the point where I was getting very noisy, you know, yelling to ‘Please stop.’ And that’s when he pressed down on my right shoulder and he would bite my lip. … When everything was over with, he got up and straightened himself, and I was crying at the moment and he walks to the door, and calmly puts on his sunglasses. And before he goes out the door he says ‘You better get some ice on that.’ And he turned and went out the door.”

When asked if there was any way Clinton could have thought it was consensual, Broaddrick said “No, not with what I told him and with how I tried to push him away. It was not consensual.”[3]

Broaddrick shared the hotel room with her friend and employee Norma Rogers. Rogers attended a conference seminar that morning, and says she returned to their room to find Broaddrick on the bed “in a state of shock,” her pantyhose torn in the crotch and her lip swollen as though she had been hit.[7] Rogers says Broaddrick told her Clinton had "forced himself on her."[7] Rogers helped Broaddrick ice her lip, and then the women left Little Rock. Rogers said that Broaddrick was very upset on the way home and blamed herself for letting Clinton in the room.[3] Broaddrick says she did not tell her husband, Gary Hickey, about the incident, and told him she accidentally injured her lip. He told NBC he did not remember the injury or her explanation.[3][8] David Broaddrick, however, has said he noticed her injured lip, and she told him that Clinton had raped her when he asked about it.[3] Three other friends confirmed that Broaddrick had told them about the incident at the time: Susan Lewis, Louis Ma, and Jean Darden, Norma Rogers’ sister.[3] Broaddrick did not recall the date of the alleged incident, but said it was spring of 1978 and that she had stayed in the Camelot Hotel. Records show Broaddrick attended a nursing home meeting at the Camelot Hotel in Little Rock on April 25, 1978.[3][8] The Clinton White House would not respond to requests for Clinton's official schedule for the date,[9] but news reports suggest that he was in Little Rock that day, with no official commitments in the morning.[3]

Three weeks after the alleged assault, Broaddrick participated in a small Clinton fundraiser at the home of a local dentist.[3] Broaddrick said she was “in denial” and felt guilty, thinking that she had given Clinton the wrong idea by letting him into her room.[3] When she arrived at the event, she says, her friend who had picked the Clintons up from the airport told her that Hillary Clinton had asked if she would be at the event.[10] Broaddrick says Bill Clinton did not speak to her at the event, but Hillary Clinton approached her, took her hand, and said "I just want you to know how much Bill and I appreciate what you do for him.”[10] When Broaddrick moved her hand away, she says, Hillary Clinton held on to her and said, "Do you understand? Everything that you do."[10] Broaddrick says she felt nauseated and left the gathering. Broaddrick says she interpreted the incident as Hillary Clinton thanking her for keeping quiet.[10]

She divorced Hickey in 1979 and married David Broaddrick in 1981. At some point[when?] she opened a second facility, to provide services for mentally disabled children in Fort Smith, Arkansas.[1][11]

In 1984, Broaddrick's nursing facility was adjudged the best in the state, which brought a congratulatory official letter from the governor. On the bottom was a handwritten note from Clinton, saying, "I admire you very much."[12]

Broaddrick said that in 1991, Clinton called her out of a state nursing standards meeting to try to apologize: "‘Juanita, I’m so sorry for what I did. I’m not the man that I used to be, can you ever forgive me? What can I do to make this up to you?’ And I’m standing there in absolute shock. And I told him to go to hell, and I walked off."[5][9] Darden also attended the meeting, and said she saw Broaddrick talking to Clinton in the hallway.[3] Clinton announced his 1992 presidential campaign soon after that alleged interaction.

Road to public disclosure[edit]

Though Broaddrick was resistant to talking to the media, rumors about her story began circulating no later than Clinton’s presidential bid in 1992.[7] Broaddrick had confided in Phillip Yoakum, whom she knew from business circles and at the time considered a friend. When Clinton won the Democratic nomination, Yoakum, widely considered to have a Republican agenda,[7] contacted Sheffield Nelson, Clinton’s opponent in the 1990 gubernatorial race. Yoakum arranged a meeting between Nelson and Broaddrick, who resisted Yoakum's and Nelson’s push that she go public.[1] Yoakum secretly taped the conversation and wrote a letter summarizing the allegations, which began to circulate within Republican circles. The story reached the New York Times and the Los Angeles Times in October 1992, but the papers dropped the story after Broaddrick refused to talk to reporters and Yoakum refused to release the recording.[7]

In the fall of 1997, Paula Jones’s private investigators tried to talk to Broaddrick at her home, also secretly taping the conversation.[13] Broaddrick refused to discuss the incident, saying “it was just a horrible horrible thing,” and that she “wouldn’t relive it for anything.”[14] The investigators told her she would likely be subpoenaed if she would not talk to them. Broaddrick said she would deny everything, saying “you can’t get to him, and I’m not going to ruin my good name to do it… there’s just absolutely no way anyone can get to him, he’s just too vicious.”[14] Broaddrick was subpoenaed in the Jones suit soon after and submitted an affidavit denying that Clinton had made “any sexual advances”.[1][2] The recording of Broaddrick’s conversation with the investigators was leaked to the press, but Broaddrick continued to refuse to speak to reporters.[13]

Despite Broaddrick’s denial in her affidavit, Jones’ lawyers included Yoakum’s letter and Broaddrick's name in a 1998 filing.[13] The letter suggested that the Clintons had bought Broaddrick’s silence, describing a phone call where Broaddrick’s husband asked Yoakum to say the incident never happened and said that he intended to ask Clinton “for a couple of big favors.”[15] This, along with the discrepancy between the letter and Broaddrick’s affidavit, attracted the attention of independent counsel Kenneth Starr, who was investigating Clinton for obstruction of justice. After being approached by the FBI, Broaddrick consulted her son, a lawyer, who told her she could not lie to federal investigators.[7] After Starr granted her immunity,[16] thus assuring that she would not be prosecuted for perjury regarding her affidavit in the Jones case, Broaddrick recanted the affidavit. However, she insisted that Clinton had not pressured or bribed her in any way, and so Starr concluded that the story was not relevant to his investigation and his report only mentioned the recanting in a footnote.[1]

Rumors continued to circulate in tabloids and on talk radio, now with Broaddrick's name attached.[13] Broaddrick was upset by a tabloid report that she had been paid to keep quiet, and decided to agree to an interview with NBC's Lisa Myers. Myers interviewed her on January 20, 1999, the day after Clinton was impeached. The interview only aired on February 24, 1999, 35 days later and after Clinton had been acquitted. NBC was accused of intentionally sitting on the story and invoking unusually demanding standards of corroboration until the impeachment process ended.[13] Broaddrick and another source said NBC gathered the key corroborating evidence within 10 days of the interview, NBC assistant producer Chris Giglio said it may have taken him 14 days—in either case, while the impeachment process was ongoing.[13] Though the story was unaired, at least one Republican senator reportedly invoked it to convince undecided Republicans to vote for impeachment.[7]

While NBC waited to air the interview, Broaddrick was approached by Dorothy Rabinowitz, who wrote for the Wall Street Journal editorial page. Upset with NBC's delay, Broaddrick agreed to speak with Rabinowitz, and the story debuted on the Wall Street Journal's editorial page on February 19.[17] NBC aired Myers' interview soon after.

Clinton response to allegations[edit]

On Friday night, February 19, 1999, Clinton's attorney, David Kendall, denied the allegations on Clinton's behalf.[18] Kendall stated: "Any allegation that the president assaulted Mrs. Broaddrick more than 20 years ago is absolutely false. Beyond that, we're not going to comment."[18]

President Clinton himself did not say anything on the matter.[13] When asked about Broaddrick's claims at a news conference on February 24, 1999, Clinton said: "Well, my counsel has made a statement about the ... issue, and I have nothing to add to it."[9]

Clinton has never been charged with anything in connection with Broaddrick's allegations.[11]

Public and press reactions[edit]

Because of the time elapsed since the alleged incident and the nature of acquaintance rape cases, there was limited corroborating evidence and so the allegations rested on Broaddrick's testimony. Because she had filed and then recanted an affidavit saying there was no assault, some thought she was not credible.[8] According to the New York Times in 1999, the problems with Broaddrick's accusations were that "There is no physical evidence to verify it. No one else was present during the alleged encounter in a Little Rock hotel room nearly 21 years ago. The hotel has since closed. And Mrs. Broaddrick denied the encounter in an affidavit in January 1998 in the Paula Jones case, in which she was known only as ''Jane Doe No. 5.'' Through all those years, she refused to come forward. When pressed by the Jones lawyers, she denied the allegation. And now, she has recanted that denial."[7]

In March 1999 Slate magazine ran an much-cited analysis piece, called "Is Juanita Broaddrick Telling the Truth?", that gave possible grounds upon which Broaddrick should be believed, or should not be believed, regarding each of a number of key points.[8] On the disbelief side, it was suggested the five people that said Broaddrick had confided in them soon after the incident could be lying.[8] Rogers and Darden had an independent reason to dislike Clinton: as they notified NBC, Clinton had commuted the life sentence of the man who killed their father.[3] The disbelief argument proposes that they may have a grudge against Clinton. Even if the confidants were telling the truth, skeptics noted that Broaddrick could have been lying when she originally confided in them.[8]

Some details in Broaddrick's account corresponded with other women's allegations. In an interview that emerged after Broaddrick's allegations, Elizabeth Ward Gracen said that Clinton bit her lip during a consensual encounter that became rough.[19]

Broaddrick said that after the assault, Clinton told her not to worry about pregnancy because childhood mumps had rendered him sterile.[17] When contacted about the issue, Gennifer Flowers, who Clinton later admitted to a sexual relationship with, agreed that Clinton had thought he couldn't have children.[20]

In March 1999, shortly after the allegations publicly aired, 56% of Americans believed the allegations were false, while a third believed that Broaddrick's allegation of rape was at least possibly true. Similarly, 29% of the public felt the press should continue to cover the story, while 66% felt that the media should stop pursuing the story.[21]

The public and media had "scandal fatigue" from the repeated sexual misconduct allegations against Clinton and, after his impeachment and acquittal, many felt the charges had nowhere to go.[22] Many reporters had encountered the story while it was being disseminated by Republican activists and felt they had already looked into it.[23] Jack Nelson, Washington bureau chief of the Los Angeles Times, said "This is a story that's been knocked down and discredited so many times ... [E]veryone's taken a slice of it, and after looking at it, everyone's knocked it down. The woman has changed her story about whether it happened. It just wasn't credible."[23] Julia Malone, a Cox Communications reporter, became frustrated by what she perceived as media neglect of the story and held a National Press Club panel on the issue entitled “Too Hot for a ‘Scandal-Weary’ New Media to Handle?"[13] Sam Donaldson of ABC News said he was frustrated over his fellow reporters' unwillingness to press Clinton to respond to the allegations: Clinton refused to comment when Donaldson asked about the allegations, and no one else would press the issue.[13]

Judgement on the Broaddrick matter has varied among book-length treatments of the Bill Clinton years. Joe Conason and Gene Lyons' book The Hunting of the President argued that Broaddrick's claim is not credible, noting that the FBI had found evidence for the allegations "inconclusive".[24] Michael Isikoff's book, Uncovering Clinton, stated that Clinton's lawyers figured that he might well have had consensual, extramarital sex with Broaddrick, but they did not believe he would have forced himself on her.[24] Christopher Hitchens' book, No One Left to Lie To, argued that Broaddrick's claim is credible and shows similarities to Paula Jones' later allegation of sexual harassment.[25]

Aftermath[edit]

Broaddrick filed a lawsuit against Clinton in December 1999 to obtain documents that the White House may have gathered about her, claiming its refusal to accede to her demand for such documents violated the Privacy Act of 1974.[26] Her lawyer was conservative judicial activist Larry Klayman, head of Judicial Watch.[26] The suit was dismissed by U.S. District Court Judge Henry H. Kennedy, Jr. in March 2001.[27] The judge ruled that the Privacy Act did not apply in this case and that Broaddrick had failed to show evidence that the U.S. Department of Justice had improperly released documents about her.[27] The lawsuit did not ask for money, and indeed unlike many of the women involved in Bill Clinton instances, Broaddrick did not seek out financial settlements, publishing deals, or a role as a celebrity.[11]

During that time, Broaddrick's business was audited by the IRS which she charged was retaliation: "I do not believe this was coincidence," Broaddrick declared, "I do not think our number just came up."[28]

The Broaddricks divorced in 2004. David Broaddrick had opposed her going public with her rape story in 1999. Juanita Broaddrick felt, according to a 2005 book, that the publicity around the Dateline interview contributed significantly to the end of her second marriage.[6] She says she also developed a fear of enclosed spaces as a result of what happened.[11]

In 2008 Broaddrick sold her nursing home business and retired,[29] having done well as a businesswoman.[11] She continues to live in Van Buren, on a 23-acre farm.[11]

2016 renewed attention[edit]

The Broaddrick case received renewed attention during the United States presidential election, 2016, as Hillary Clinton was the Democratic nominee for president.[29]

In this context, the Broaddrick case has often brought about unease on the part of people who are generally supportive of the Clintons. In an October 2016 recap of the case, Dylan Matthews of Vox said: "The basic answer is that some of the claims [against Bill Clinton] appear more credible than others. There are three main accusers [the others being Jones and Willey], of whom it seems by far the most credible — based on the publicly available evidence — is Broaddrick."[24] Matthews continues: "Given the prevailing view among many progressives — including Hillary Clinton — that one should default to believing rape accusers, the Broaddrick allegation thus poses a problem."[24] Michelle Goldberg of Slate wrote in a late 2015 essay, "our rules for talking about sexual assault have changed since the 1990s, when these women were last in the news. Today, feminists have repeatedly and convincingly made the case that when women say they’ve been sexually assaulted, we should assume they’re telling the truth. Particularly when it comes to Broaddrick, it’s not easy to square the arguments against believing her with the dominant progressive consensus on trusting victims. This is a tension that people on the right are eager to exploit."[30]

Conversely, many conservative commentators who in the normal course were typically quite skeptical of sexual assault claims without firm evidence, found Broaddrick's allegations quite believable.[11] As Katie J. M. Baker of BuzzFeed lamented, "In theory, partisan politics shouldn’t play a role in determining whether an alleged rape victim deserves to be heard."[11] Similar observations have been made by Robby Soave of Reason magazine.[31]

The now-retired NBC reporter who broadcast her story, Lisa Myers, has said: "“No one can objectively look at Juanita's story and not be troubled. One of the things that makes her so credible is who she is — open, straightforward, seemingly guileless.”[11]

When in late 2015, during a town hall that was an event during the Hillary Clinton presidential campaign, 2016, Hillary Clinton was asked about this question in terms of these women's charges, she responded: "Well, I would say that everyone should be believed at first until they are disbelieved based on evidence."[32]

In January 2016, Broaddrick shared on the social networking site Twitter, “I was 35 years old when Bill Clinton, Ark. Attorney General raped me and Hillary tried to silence me. I am now 73….it never goes away.”[29] Broaddrick said she was neither a Democrat nor a Republican, but she supported Donald Trump's presidential campaign: "He says the things I like to hear."[29] In the United States presidential election, 2008 she voted for Barack Obama and gave more than $1,000 to his campaign because he was running against Hillary Clinton.[11] She agreed with Trump's injection of Bill Clinton's acknowledged and alleged sexual misdeeds into the campaign.[29] And as the campaign went on, she more and more aligned herself with conservative actions and outlook.[11]

On October 8, 2016, in the wake of the Donald Trump Access Hollywood controversy, Trump retweeted Broaddrick's tweets about in which she calls Bill Clinton a "rapist" and calls Hillary Clinton's actions "horrific".[33][34] On October 9 Broaddrick appeared in a panel appearance with Trump and Paula Jones and Kathleen Willey (a fourth woman at the panel, Kathy Shelton, had an unrelated grievance against Hillary Clinton) an hour before the second debate between Trump and Clinton in the general election portion of the United States presidential election debates, 2016.[35] Broaddrick and the others were also in the audience during the debate, as was Bill Clinton, although debate organizers kept them in separate areas.[36] The Trump campaign said it had paid for Broaddrick's travel to the debate.[37]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b c d e f Romano, Lois; Baker, Peter (February 20, 1999). "Another Clinton Accuser Goes Public". Washington Post. 
  2. ^ a b Broaddrick, Juanita (January 2, 1998). "Affidavit From Jane Doe #5" – via Washington Post. 
  3. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o Dateline NBC: February 24, 1999. The Washington Post published a story about the interview on February 25, 1999.
  4. ^ a b c Dorothy Rabinowitz, "Juanita Broaddrick Meets the Press", The Wall Street Journal, February 19, 1999
  5. ^ a b c Full Transcript of NBC Dateline report on Juanita Broaddrick
  6. ^ a b "The Rape of Juanita Broaddrick", wnd.com, May 26, 2005. With excerpt about Broaddrick from Candice Jackson’s book, Their Lives: The Women Targeted by the Clinton Machine.
  7. ^ a b c d e f g h i New York Times: On Tortuous Route, Sexual Assault Accusation Against Clinton Resurfaces. February 24, 1999.
  8. ^ a b c d e f "Is Juanita Broaddrick Telling the Truth?". Slate. March 3, 1999.
  9. ^ a b c Kurtz, Howard (February 25, 1999). "Clinton Accuser's Story Aired". Washington Post. p. A15.
  10. ^ a b c d FOX News: Interview with Sean Hannity. June 10, 2003. Excerpt available via YouTube.
  11. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k "Juanita Broaddrick wants to be believed", BuzzFeed, August 14, 2016
  12. ^ Wall Street Journal: Juanita Broaddrick Meets the Press. February 19, 1999.
  13. ^ a b c d e f g h i Weiss, Philip. (April 19, 1999). "NBC’s Vetting of Juanita Broaddrick: Clinton’s Accuser Discusses Agonizing Weeks as NBC Dragged It Out". New York Observer.
  14. ^ a b transcript of conversation recorded by Rick Lambert
  15. ^ Yoakum's letter regarding "Jane Doe #5" was posted by the Washington Post on December 23, 1998.
  16. ^ http://www.mediaite.com/online/hacked-clinton-email-reveals-strategy-to-refute-juanita-broaddricks-rape-claims/
  17. ^ a b Editorial Commentary, Dorothy Rabinowitz; February 19, 1999; Page A18.
  18. ^ a b http://www.cnn.com/ALLPOLITICS/stories/1999/02/20/assault.allegation/
  19. ^ Isikoff, Michael (May 30, 2000). Uncovering Clinton. Three Rivers Press. p. 256
  20. ^ The Weekly Standard. (February 20, 1999). "A Case of the Mumps?".
  21. ^ Holland, Keating (March 1, 1999). "Poll: Most believe media should lay off Broaddrick allegation". CNN.
  22. ^ Kurtz, Howard (March 1, 1999). "No Rest for the Scandal-Weary". Washington Post.
  23. ^ a b Walsh, Joan (February 20, 1999). "The Ugliest Story Yet". Salon.
  24. ^ a b c d Matthews, Dylan (2016-10-09). "The rape allegation against Bill Clinton, explained". Vox. Retrieved 2016-10-09. 
  25. ^ http://www.salon.com/1999/06/07/hitchens/
  26. ^ a b http://www.cnn.com/1999/ALLPOLITICS/stories/12/20/broaddrick.suit/index.html?_s=PM:ALLPOLITICS
  27. ^ a b Josh Gerstein, "White House Wag: Courts Back Clinton", April 2, 2001.
  28. ^ Their Lives: The Women Targeted by the Clinton Machine. World Ahead Publishing, 2005. ISBN 9780974670133 p. 241.
  29. ^ a b c d e "Bill Clinton rape accuser: Hillary 'tried to silence' me", The Hill, January 6, 2016.
  30. ^ "Why Bill's past could still hurt Hillary", Michelle Goldberg, Slate, December 30, 2015
  31. ^ http://reason.com/blog/2016/08/17/on-rape-liberals-dont-believe-the-victim
  32. ^ http://www.cnn.com/2015/12/03/politics/hillary-clinton-paula-jones-question/index.html
  33. ^ Nelson, Louis (October 8, 2016). "Trump puts Clinton on watch by retweeting Juanita Broaddrick". POLITICO. Retrieved October 9, 2016. 
  34. ^ Blake, Aaron (October 8, 2016). "Donald Trump just retweeted Juanita Broaddrick calling Bill Clinton a rapist. All bets are now off.". Washington Post. Retrieved October 9, 2016. 
  35. ^ http://www.politico.com/story/2016/10/donald-trump-bill-clinton-accusers-229441?lo=ap_a2
  36. ^ http://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/2016-presidential-debates/trump-planned-debate-stunt-invited-bill-clinton-accusers-rattle-hillary-n663481
  37. ^ http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/trump-ally-paid-sexual-assault-victim-critical-of-clinton/ar-BBxdln6?li=BBnbfcL&ocid=TSHDHP