Kenneth J. Zucker
|Born||1950 (age 69–70)|
|Alma mater||University of Toronto, Roosevelt University, & Southern Illinois University|
|Institutions||University of Toronto & Private Practice|
Kenneth J. Zucker (/ /; born 1950) is an American-Canadian psychologist and sexologist. He was named editor-in-chief of Archives of Sexual Behavior in 2001. He was psychologist-in-chief at Toronto's Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH) and head of its Gender Identity Service until its closure in December of 2015. Zucker is a professor in the departments of psychiatry and psychology at the University of Toronto.
Zucker collaborated with Susan Bradley, collecting clinical and research data over a period of twenty years and became an international authority on gender dysphoria in children (GDC) and adolescents. In 2007, Zucker was chosen to be a member of the American Psychological Association Task Force on Gender Identity, Gender Variance, and Intersex Conditions, and in 2008 he was named chair of the American Psychiatric Association workgroup on "Sexual and Gender Identity Disorders" for the 2012 edition of the DSM-5. He previously served on workgroups for the DSM-IV and the DSM-IV-TR.
Zucker's views are controversial among some mental health professionals and many advocates. Citing a review by two adolescent psychiatrists stating that CAMH was out of step with current best practices for transgender youth, CAMH fired Zucker and closed the clinic. They later apologized to Zucker and paid him a financial settlement after one of the complaints in the review was found to be false. Zucker was featured in a BBC2 documentary in 2017.
Zucker was born in 1950 to Jewish parents and grew up in Skokie, Illinois. Zucker received his B.A. from Southern Illinois University, his M.A. from Roosevelt University, and his Ph.D. from University of Toronto in 1982. He holds a certification from College of Psychologists of Ontario.
Zucker became interested in gender identity after reading Richard Green's 1974 book Sexual Identity Conflict in Children and Adults. Zucker's graduate work in developmental psychology resulted in his master's thesis on normative gender identity development in children. While in graduate school, Zucker met his future collaborator, Susan Bradley, a child psychiatrist on staff at the Child and Adolescent Service of the Clarke Institute of Psychiatry (now the Child and Family Studies Centre of the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health), a public mental health centre and teaching hospital of the University of Toronto Faculty of Medicine.
Zucker was impressed with the Clarke Institute and met with then chief of psychology, Kingsley Ferguson, who told Zucker of Bradley's new working group assessing children and adolescents with gender identity problems. He joined Bradley's group.
Therapeutic intervention for gender variance
Since the mid-1970s, Zucker has treated about 500 preadolescent gender-variant children to have them accept the gender identity they were assigned at birth until they are at an age he believes they may determine their own gender identity. Considerable disagreement exists between academic sex researchers, who say the sciences supports Zucker's approach, and activists who compare it to conversion therapy attempting to change gay men and lesbians into heterosexual men and women.
Zucker says he tries to encourage children to accept their birth sex and supports them in transitioning should they still experience gender dysphoria into adolescence.
For children assigned as male at birth, Zucker reportedly asked parents to take away toys associated with girls and to instruct their child not to play alongside or draw pictures of girls, although the parent that originally made this claim has more recently expressed that there was a miscommunication in the original interview and that such directives were to treat the social isolation that stemmed from her son's obsession with dolls. Psychologist Darryl Hill wrote that Zucker and Bradley believed that reparative treatments can reduce rejection by enabling gender non-conforming children to mix with children of the same sex, reducing the possibility of adult gender dysphoria.
Among Zucker's publications is the case history of two patients who were male by birth but underwent a penectomy and were shortly thereafter reassigned as female. At age 26 both denied ever feeling the desire to be male. Both patients reported more masculine behavior and bisexuality, about which Zucker suspects that gender role and sexual orientation develop mostly before birth while gender identity development begins shortly after birth. There is some support for the position that "prenatal sex differentiation can at least sometimes trump social influences."
Zucker says parents set the goals at his clinic. "We recommend that one goal be to help the child feel more secure about his or her actual gender, another to deal with the child's emotional difficulties, and a third to help with problems in the family. It's helpful to have parents set limits on things like cross-dressing, which many parents have not done before coming to us." Zucker's follow-up of 50 treated children found that "about 10 percent are still very unhappy about their gender, still cross-dressing, and thinking about having sex reassignment surgery" as young adults. Zucker has stated that "the therapist must rely on the 'clinical wisdom' that has accumulated and to utilize largely untested case formulation conceptual models to inform treatment approaches and decisions."
For adolescent clients expressing gender identity disorder, Zucker's treatment protocol resembles that for adult GID, consisting of hormone replacement therapy to aid the adolescent in a social transition. Zucker's clinic does not provide recommendations for sex reassignment surgery – instead, clients are encouraged to pursue reassignment through the adult Gender Identity Clinic at CAMH, which controls funding for the procedure in Ontario.
Activists have compared Zucker's approaches with reparative therapy. The Gay and Lesbian Medical Association believes "'reparative' therapy that seeks to reverse sexual orientation or gender identification" is an "extreme example" of bias that "may lead to increased self hatred and mental health problems." Psychiatrist Simon Pickstone-Taylor has cited similarities between Zucker's therapeutic intervention and reparative therapy for homosexuals. Zucker responded that prevention of homosexuality was never a goal in their treatments and cites a lack of empirical evidence for the most effective approach. Journalist Marc Lostracco described Zucker's therapy as "well-meaning" but "problematic and harsh." Others, like author Phyllis Burke, object to any diagnosis of GID in children, considering it to be "child abuse." Zucker dismisses Burke's book as "simplistic" and "not particularly illuminating;" journalist Stephanie Wilkinson said Zucker characterized Burke's book as "the work of a journalist whose views shouldn't be put into the same camp as those of scientists like Richard Green or himself."
Closure of the CAMH Gender Identity Clinic for Children
In 2015, the Ontario provincial parliament introduced legislation banning conversion therapy. Members of Rainbow Health Ontario, a provincial health promotion and navigation organization, approached CAMH expressing their concerns regarding Zucker's clinic. They alleged that cases of suicide of transgender youth results from methods used by Zucker and that the ban on conversion therapy made those methods illegal. CAMH stopped the clinic from accepting new patients and initiated an external review of the clinic's practices.
The reviewers were child and adolescent psychiatrists Suzanne Zinck of Halifax, and Antonio Pignatiello of Toronto. They invited stakeholders to comment on their experiences in the clinic. A former client, now an adult, claimed Zucker "asked him to remove his shirt in front of other clinicians present, laughed when he complied, and then referred to him as a 'hairy little vermin'." The review noted numerous strengths of the clinic, but also described it as an insular entity with an approach dissimilar from other clinics and described it as being out of step with current best practices, including WPATH SOC version 7. They also raised concerns about clinicians asking age inappropriate questions.
After the review, CAMH shut down the clinic and fired Zucker. Kwame McKenzie, medical director of CAMH's child, youth, and family services, said "We want to apologize for the fact that not all of the practices in our childhood gender identity clinic are in step with the latest thinking" and that Zucker is "no longer at CAMH." CAMH announced a process of consultation with community leaders to examine how best to offer care.
CAMH director Kwame McKenzie said that Zucker's treatments were against the centre's guidelines. Prior to the review, he stated that there exists two groups of thinking on such therapy for children under 11 among professionals.
CAMH removed the report from its website and apologized, and replaced it with a summary of the report which has not survived a move to its new website.
Zucker subsequently sued McKenzie and CAMH.
When the settlement was announced, CAMH stated that it "stands by its decision to close the child and youth gender identity clinic following an external review which concluded the clinic was not meeting the needs of gender expansive and trans children and their families" "We believe our modernized approach to delivering services to youth better supports diverse patients through best practice and timely care."
Archives of Sexual Behavior
As editor of Archives of Sexual Behavior, Zucker published a controversial study on reparative therapy by Robert Spitzer. According to The New York Times, after his presentation of the study caused controversy, Spitzer asked Zucker to publish it. "I knew Bob and the quality of his work, and I agreed to publish it," Zucker said in an interview. "But I told him I would do it only if I also published commentaries". Spitzer later recanted the study's conclusions.
Several LGBT activists spoke out against Zucker's 2008 appointment to the DSM-5 working group. The National Gay and Lesbian Task Force issued a statement questioning the APA's decision to appoint Zucker and a second member of the work panel. According to a response released by American Psychiatric Association, Zucker does not advocate reparative therapy for transgender adults or for trans youth in all cases, and he opposes change therapy for gay people under all circumstances.
According to the Web of Science, Zucker has published almost 100 articles in peer-reviewed journals. These articles have been cited over 2000 times, with an h-index of 20. He has published several books, including:
- Gender Identity Disorder and Psychosexual Problems in Children and Adolescents (1995)
- Attachment and Psychopathology (1997)
- Ex-Gay Research: Analyzing the Spitzer Study And Its Relation to Science, Religion, Politics, and Culture (2006)
- "Dr. Kenneth Zucker". Centre for Addiction and Mental Health. Archived from the original on April 17, 2015. Retrieved 22 October 2017.
- "CAMH to 'wind down' controversial gender identity clinic services". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved 15 December 2015.
- Awad G.A. (1999). "Gender Identity Disorder and the Psychosexual Problems in Children and Adolescents (review)". American Journal of Psychotherapy. 53 (2): 265–267. doi:10.1176/appi.psychotherapy.1918.104.22.1685.
- Bradley S.J., Blanchard R, Coates SW, Green R, Levine SB, Meyer-Bahlburg HFL, Pauly IB, Zucker KJ (1991). "Interim report of the DSM-IV Subcommittee on Gender Identity Disorders". Archives of Sexual Behavior. 20 (4): 333–343. doi:10.1007/bf01542614. PMID 1953325.CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
- Morton, Gillian (January 11, 2001). "Drop the doll!". Xtra. Retrieved 23 March 2015.
- Winters, Kelley; Temple Newhook, Julia; Pyne, Jake; Feder, Stephen; Jamieson, Ally; Holmes, Cindy; Lynne Sinnott, Mari; Pickett, Sarah; Tosh, Jemma (18 June 2018). "Learning to Listen to Trans and Gender Diverse Children: A Response to Zucker (2018) and Steensma and Cohen-Kettenis (2018)". International Journal of Transgenderism. 19 (2): 246–250. doi:10.1080/15532739.2018.1471767.
- Cross, Jessica Smith (March 18, 2015). "Outcry prompts CAMH to review its controversial treatment of trans youth". Metro. Metro International. Archived from the original on 2015-03-20. Retrieved March 20, 2015. Cite has empty unknown parameter:
- Rizza, Alanna (7 October 2018). "CAMH reaches settlement with former head of gender-identity clinic". Toronto Star.
- Transgender Kids, Who Knows Best?
- Schwartzapfel, Beth (March 14, 2013). "Born This Way?". The American Prospect. Retrieved March 23, 2015.
- Zucker, Kenneth J.; Bradley, Susan J. (1995). Gender Identity Disorder and Psychosexual Problems in Children and Adolescents. Guilford Press. p. v. ISBN 978-0-89862-266-9.
- Brown, Patricia Leigh (December 2, 2006). "Supporting Boys or Girls When the Line Isn't Clear". The New York Times.
- Rizza, Alanna (9 October 2018). "Former CAMH psychologist defends his work at youth gender identity clinic". CityNews.
- "Diagnostic Criteria of Gender Identity Disorder". TVOntario.
- Spiegel, Alix (May 7, 2008). "Two families grapple with sons' gender preferences". All Things Considered. National Public Radio.
- Singal, Jesse (7 February 2016). "How the Fight Over Transgender Kids Got a Leading Sex Researcher Fired". New York Magazine.
- Hill D.B., Rozanski C., Carfagnini J., Willoughby B. (2006). "Gender Identity Disorders in Childhood and Adolescence: A Critical Inquiry". In Karasic D, Drescher J (eds.). Sexual and Gender Diagnoses of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM): A Reevaluation. Haworth Press. pp. 7–34. ISBN 978-0-7890-3214-0.
- SJ, Bradley; Oliver GD; Chernick AB; Zucker KJ (1998). "Experiment of Nurture: Ablatio Penis at 2 Months, Sex Reassignment at 7 Months, and a Psychosexual Follow-up in Young Adulthood". Pediatrics. 102 (1): e9. doi:10.1542/peds.102.1.e9. PMID 9651461.
- Dingfelder, Sadie F. (2004). "Gender bender". Monitor on Psychology. 35 (4): 48. Retrieved June 17, 2008.
- Goleman, Daniel (March 22, 1994). "The 'Wrong' Sex: A New Definition Of Childhood Pain". The New York Times.
- Zucker K.J. (2008). "Children with gender identity disorder: Is there a best practice?". Neuropsychiatrie de l'Enfance et de l'Adolescence. 56 (6): 358–364. doi:10.1016/j.neurenf.2008.06.003.
- Bailey J.M.; Zucker K.J. (1995). "Childhood Sex-Typed Behavior and Sexual Orientation: A Conceptual Analysis and Quantitative Review". Developmental Psychology. 31 (1): 43–55. doi:10.1037/0012-1622.214.171.124.
- Dean, Laura; et al. (2000). "Lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender health: Findings and concerns". Journal of the Gay and Lesbian Medical Association. 4 (3): 102–151. doi:10.1023/A:1009573800168.
- Ryan, C.; Bradford, J.; Honnold, J. (1999). "Social workers' and counselors' knowledge and understanding of lesbians". Journal of Lesbian and Gay Social Services. 9 (4): 1–26. doi:10.1300/j041v09n04_01.
- Pickstone-Taylor, Simon D. (2003). "Children with gender nonconformity". Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. 42 (3): 266. doi:10.1097/00004583-200303000-00005. PMID 12595778.
- Bradley, Susan J.; Zucker, Kenneth J. (2003). "Children With Gender Nonconformity: Drs. Bradley and Zucker reply". Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 42 (3): 266–268. doi:10.1097/00004583-200303000-00004.
- Lostracco, Marc (May 9, 2008). "But for today I am a boy". Torontoist.
- Burke, Phyllis (1996). Gender Shock. Anchor. ISBN 978-0-385-47718-5.
- Wilkinson, Stephanie (2001). "Drop the Barbie!". Brain, Child. Archived from the original on July 8, 2011.
- Mann, Arshy (2015-12-15). "Toronto centre shutters youth gender clinic". The Daily Xtra. Retrieved 2019-09-12.
- "External review of the Gender Identity Clinic of the child, youth and family services in the underserved populations program at the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health" (PDF). CAMH. 2015-11-26. Retrieved 2019-09-12.
- Ubelacker, Sheryl (December 15, 2015). "CAMH to 'wind down' controversial gender identity clinic services". The Globe and Mail. Canadian Press. Retrieved 15 December 2015.
- "CAMH to 'wind down' gender identity clinic after review of services". CBC News. Canadian Press. December 15, 2015. Retrieved December 15, 2015.
- Paterson, Tara (21 February 2015). "As trans issues become mainstream, question of how to address variant gender expression comes to forefront". National Post.
- "Gender Identity Service Review Announced". CAMH.ca. Retrieved 27 July 2015.
- Singal, Jesse (27 January 2016). "A False Accusation Helped Bring Down Kenneth Zucker, a Controversial Sex Researcher". NYMag.
- Roberts, Jennifer (29 January 2016). "Alleged exchange with gender identity doctor didn't happen, CAMH says". The Globe and Mail.
- "CAMH Apology". CAMH. 2018. Archived from the original on 2018-10-06. Retrieved 2019-09-12.
- Rizza, Alanna (7 October 2018). "CAMH to pay more than half a million settlement to head of gender identity clinic after releasing fallacious report". National Post.
- "CAMH reaches settlement with former head of gender identity clinic". The Canadian Press. 2018-10-07. Retrieved 2019-09-12.
- Carey, Benedict (18 May 2012). "Psychiatry Giant Sorry for Backing Gay 'Cure'". The New York Times. Retrieved 12 August 2012.
- Chibarro, Lou Jr. (May 30, 2008). "Activists alarmed over APA: Head of psychiatry panel favors 'change' therapy for some trans teens". Washington Blade. Archived from the original on June 2, 2008.
- Rau, Krishna (July 7, 2008). "Trans activists infuriated by doctors in charge of gender identity definitions". Xtra.
- National Gay and Lesbian Task Force. "Task Force questions critical appointments to APA's Committee on Sexual and Gender Identity Disorders". Archived from the original on July 25, 2012. Retrieved August 13, 2012.
- "Statement on Dr. Kenneth Zucker and Gender Identity Disorder". May 23, 2008. Archived from the original on October 15, 2011. Retrieved August 13, 2012.
- "Web of Science". 2008. Retrieved July 1, 2008.