Page extended-protected

Khojaly massacre

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from Khojaly Massacre)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Khojaly massacre
Part of the First Nagorno-Karabakh War
Khojaly Genocide memorial 3.JPG
Khojaly massacre memorial in The Hague, Netherlands
LocationKhojaly, Nagorno-Karabakh
TargetAzerbaijani civilians mixed with military
Weaponssmall arms and light weapons
Deaths200+ (per Human Rights Watch)[1][2]
485 (per Azerbaijani parliament)[3]
613 (per Azerbaijani government)[4]
PerpetratorsIrregular Armenian forces
366th CIS regiment[5]

The Khojaly massacre was the mass killing of Azerbaijanis — mostly civilians, but also armed troops — by local[6] irregular Armenian forces and the 366th Commonwealth of Independent States Guards Motor Rifle Regiment in the town of Khojaly on 26 February 1992.[3][7][8][5][9] It was one of the four events that defined the war in 1992, along with the Karabakh Armenian seizure of Shusha, the Karabakh Armenian capture of Lachin and Lachin corridor between Nagorno Karabakh and Armenia and the June 1992 Azerbaijani offensive against Mardakert province in Nagorno Karabakh.[10]

Khojaly is a formerly Azerbaijani-populated town of some 6,300 people within the Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast, it had the region's only airport in 1992.[11] The town was subject to the mutual shelling and blockade by Armenian and Azerbaijani forces during the First Nagorno-Karabakh War. Without supply of electricity, gas, or water, it was defended by the local forces consisted of about 160 lightly armed men. The local Armenian and CIS forces launched an offensive in early 1992, forcing almost the entire Azerbaijani population of the enclave to flee, and committing what was reported as "unconscionable acts of violence against civilians" as they were fleeing.[1]

On the night of 26 February 1992, the Armenian forces seized the town, taking prisoner or killing the civilians remaining in it. At the same time, a large number of Azerbaijani civilians were trying to escape the town and moving towards the Azerbaijani-controlled territories. However, local Armenian forces fired upon the fleeing Azerbaijani refugees, resulting in hundreds of deaths.[11][2]

The massacre was one of the turning points in the First Nagorno-Karabakh War. The death toll claimed by the Azerbaijani authorities is 613 civilians, including 106 women and 63 children.[4] According to Human Rights Watch, it resulted in death of at least 200 Azerbaijanis, though it is possible that as many as 500–1,000 may have died.[2][6][12]

Name

Most governments and media use the term "massacre" to refer to the incident.[13] Azerbaijani sources, especially those with governmental relationships, oftentimes refer to the massacre as a "tragedy" (Azerbaijani: Xocalı faciəsi) or even a "genocide" (Xocalı soyqırımı).[14][15][16]

Background

In the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, both Armenians and Azerbaijanis became victims of pogroms and ethnic cleansing, which resulted in numerous casualties and displacement of large groups of people.[3] By 1992, the conflict had escalated into a full-scale war. In February 1992 the capital of Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast, Stepanakert, was under a blockade by Azerbaijani forces.[17]

In 1988 the town had 2,135 inhabitants. Due to the First Nagorno-Karabakh War, population exchanges occurred between Armenia and Azerbaijan, and Meskhetian Turk refugees leaving Central Asia subsequently settled in Khojaly.[18][19] According to Thomas de Waal, Khojaly had been the focus of a large resettlement program by the Azerbaijan government in the late 1980s and early 1990s. This coincided with the First Nagorno-Karabakh War and increased the population to 6200 by 1991.[20]

Khojaly was on the road from Shusha and Stepanakert to Agdam and had the region's only airport. The airport was of vital importance for the survival of the population in Karabakh, which had no land connection with Armenia and was under a total blockade by Azerbaijan. According to reports from Human Rights Watch, Khojaly was used Azerbaijani forces as a base for shelling Stepanakert. The indiscriminate shelling and sniping killed or maimed hundreds of civilians, destroyed homes, hospitals and other objects that are not legitimate military targets, and generally terrorized the civilian population.[1][21][22]

In October 1991, the Nagorno Karabakh forces cut the road connecting Khojaly and Aghdam, so that the only way to reach the town was by helicopter. According to the Russian Memorial civil rights society, from autumn 1991 Khojaly was practically blockaded by Armenian armed forces, and after the withdrawal of the Soviet Internal Troops from Karabakh the blockade became total. Some inhabitants left the blockaded town, but the civilian population was not fully evacuated, despite insistent demands of the head of executive power of Khojaly, Elman Mammadov.[23] Khojaly was defended by local OMON forces under the command of Alif Hajiyev, which numbered about 160 or so lightly armed men.[3] Khojaly was shelled by Armenian forces almost daily in the winter of 1991–1992, and people grew accustomed to spending nights in basements,[24] surviving the totally blockade, and the lack of electricity, gas and water.[25][26]

Warnings, ultimatum and provision of a humanitarian corridor

The report of Memorial stated that the Armenian side claimed that a free corridor was provided for fleeing civilians. The Memorial report says:

According to the officials of the NKR and those taking part in the assault, the Khojaly population was informed about the existence of this 'corridor' through loudspeakers mounted on armoured personnel carriers. NKR officials also noted that, several days prior to the assault, leaflets had been dropped on Khojaly from helicopters, urging the Khojaly population to use the 'free corridor'. However, not a single copy of such a leaflet has been provided to Memorial's observers in support of this assertion. Likewise, no traces of such leaflets have been found by Memorial's observers in Khojaly. When interviewed, Khojaly refugees said that they had not heard about such leaflets. Several days prior to the assault, the representatives of the Armenian side had, on repeated occasions, informed the Khojaly authorities by radio about the upcoming assault and urged them to immediately evacuate the population from the town. The fact that this information had been received by the Azerbaijani side and transferred to Baku is confirmed by Baku newspapers (Bakinskiy Rabochiy)[27]

Armenian fighters claimed to HRW investigators that they sent ultimata to the Azerbaijani forces in Khojaly warning that unless missile attacks from that town on Stepanakert ceased, Armenian forces would attack. The report quotes the testimony of an Azerbaijani woman: "According to A.H., an Azerbaijani woman interviewed by Helsinki Watch in Baky, "After Armenians seized Malybeyli, they made an ultimatum to Khojaly... and that Khojaly people had better leave with a white flag. Alif Gajiev [the head of the militia in Khojaly] told us this on 15 February, but this didn't frighten me or other people. We never believed they could occupy Khojaly" [28]

Salman Abasov, one of the survivors of Khojaly tragedy, stated:

Several days before the tragedy the Armenians told us several times over the radio that they would capture the town and demanded that we leave it. For a longtime helicopters flew into Khojali and it wasn't clear if anyone thought about our fate, took an interest in us. We received practically no help. Moreover, when it was possible to take our women, children out of the town, we were persuaded not to do so.[29]

Azerbaijani filmmaker Ramiz Fataliev testified in his interview that the Azerbaijani authorities did not evacuate the civilians from Khojaly because they thought that by doing so they would invite the Armenians to occupy Khojaly:

On the 22nd of February, in the president's, prime-minister's, KGB minister's and others' presence, the meeting of the National Security Council was held… At the meeting, a resolution was made not to evacuate the people from Khojaly. It was considered that if we evacuated the population, we would invite Armenians to occupy the settlement. That is, we would ourselves incite Armenians to attack. Even the members of the Security Council didn't believe that Armenians could commit this sort of actions that resulted in genocide. They thought that if the population left the settlement we ourselves would give Khojaly up.[30]

Elmar Mammadov, the Mayor of Khojaly testified that the Azerbaijani authorities knew about the attack but they took no measure to evacuate the civilians:

On 25 February 1992 at 8:30 pm we were told that the tanks of the enemy have been placed around the city in a fighting position. We informed everybody about this over the radio. Furthermore, on 24 February I called Aghdam and told them, that a captured Armenian fighter has informed us on the impending attack... There was no response. I have also asked to send a helicopter for the transportation of the elderly, women and children. But no help came.[31]

None of the witnesses interviewed by Helsinki Watch on the Azerbaijani side said that they knew beforehand of such a corridor.[32]

The assault

Ambulance cars in Baku carrying bodies of Azerbaijanis killed in Khojaly

On 25-26 February 1992, Armenian forces went on the offensive, forcing almost the entire Azerbaijani population of the enclave to flee, and committing what HRW describes as "unconscionable acts of violence against civilians" as they fled.[1] According to HRW, the tragedy struck when "a large column of residents, accompanied by a few dozen retreating fighters, fled the city as it fell to Armenian forces. It is reported that as they approached the border with Azerbaijan, they came across an Armenian military post and were cruelly fired upon".[1][33][34]

According to Memorial society, part of the population started leaving Khojaly soon after the assault began, trying to flee towards Agdam, and armed people from the town's garrison were among some of the fleeing groups. People left in two directions: 1) from the east side of the town northeastwards along the river, passing Askeran to their left (this route, according to Armenian officials, was provided as a "free corridor"); and 2) from the north side of the town northeastwards, passing Askeran to their right (it appears that fewer refugees fled using this route). Thus, the majority of civilians left Khojaly, while around 200–300 people stayed in the town, hiding in their houses and basements. As a result of the shelling of the town, an unascertained number of civilians were killed in Khojaly during the assault. The Armenian side practically refused to tell Memorial observers how many people perished. The refugees in both groups were fired upon, resulting in death of many of them. Those who remained alive dispersed. Running refugees came across Armenian military posts and were fired upon. Some refugees managed to escape to Agdam, while some, mainly women and children (the exact number is impossible to determine), froze to death while wandering around in mountains, some were captured near the villages of Nakhichevanik and Pirjamal.[23]

Helsinki Watch reported that "the militia, still in uniform, and some still carrying their guns, were interspersed with the masses of civilians" and according to eyewitness accounts, there was a shooting between Armenian forces and the Azerbaijani forces who were mixed with the civilians.[35] At the same time, Human Rights Watch and Memorial stated that the killing of civilians could not be justified under any circumstances. Human Rights Watch noted that

"The attacking party is still obliged to take precautionary measures to avoid or minimize civilian casualties. In particular, the party must suspend an attack if it becomes apparent that the attack may be expected to cause civilian casualties that are excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated. The circumstances surrounding the attack at Nakhichevanik on those fleeing from Khojaly indicate that Armenian forces and the troops of the 366th CIS regiment (who were not apparently acting on orders from their commanders) deliberately disregarded this customary law restraint on attacks".[36][32]

However, the obligation to protect the civilians was likewise breached by the Azerbaijani side. As stated by HRW report:

The parties may not use civilians to shield military targets from attack or to shield military operations including retreats. Thus a party that intersperses combatants with fleeing civilians puts those civilians at risk and violates its obligation to protect its own civilians.[37]

The Armenian side officially asserts that the killings occurred as a result of wartime military operations, and were caused by the prevention of the town inhabitants' evacuation by Azerbaijani forces, who shot those attempting to flee.[38] This explanation, however, is widely disputed. Among others, the executive director of Human Rights Watch has stated that: "we place direct responsibility for the civilian deaths with Karabakh Armenian forces. Indeed, neither our report nor that of Memorial includes any evidence to support the argument that Azerbaijani forces obstructed the flight of, or fired on Azeri civilians".[36] British journalist Thomas de Waal noted that "the overwhelming evidence of what happened has not stopped some Armenians, in distasteful fashion, trying to muddy the waters".[39] However, De Waal has also stated that the tragedy in Khojaly was a result of a chaotic situation, and not a "deliberately planned" action by the Armenians.[40][41]

At the same time, some Armenian sources admitted the responsibility of the Armenian side. According to Markar Melkonian, the brother of the Armenian military leader Monte Melkonian, "Khojaly had been a strategic goal, but it had also been an act of revenge." The date of the massacre in Khojaly had a special significance: it was the run-up to the fourth anniversary of the anti-Armenian pogrom in the city of Sumgait where the civilian Armenian population was brutally murdered solely because of their ethnic origin.[3] Melkonian particularly mentions the role of the fighters of two Armenian military detachments called the Arabo and Aramo, who stabbed to death many Azeri civilians, despite strict orders given by Monte Melkonian, that no captives were to be harmed.[42]

According to Serzh Sargsyan, long-time Defense Minister and Chairman of Security Council of Armenia who was also the president of Armenia, "A lot was exaggerated" in the casualties, and the fleeing Azerbaijanis had put up armed resistance. At the same time, he stated:

Before Khojali, the Azerbaijanis thought that they were joking with us, they thought that the Armenians were people who could not raise their hand against the civilian population. We were able to break that [stereotype]. And that's what happened. And we should also take into account that amongst those boys were people who had fled from Baku and Sumgait. Although I think that is still very much exaggerated, very much. Azerbaijanis needed an excuse to equate a place to Sumgait, but they can not be compared. Yes, in fact, was in Khojaly civilians, but along with the civilians were soldiers. [W]hen a shell is flying through the air, it doesn't distinguish between a civilian resident and a soldier; it doesn't have eyes. If the civilian population stays there, even though there was a perfect opportunity to leave, that means that they also are taking part in military operations . . .[3][43][44]

According to Memorial society,

Official representatives of the NKR and members of the Armenian armed forces explained the death of civilians in the zone of the 'free corridor' by the fact that there were armed people fleeing together with the refugees, who were firing at Armenian outposts, thus drawing return fire, as well as by an attempted breakthrough by the main Azerbaijani forces. According to members of the Armenian armed forces, the Azerbaijani forces attempted to battle through Agdam in the direction of the 'free corridor'. At the moment when the Armenian outposts were fighting off this attack, the first groups of Khojaly refugees approached them from the rear. The armed people who were among the refugees began firing at the Armenian outposts. During the battle, one outpost was destroyed, but the fighters from another outpost, of whose existence the Azerbaijanis were unaware, opened fire from a close distance at the people coming from Khojaly. According to testimonies of Khojaly refugees (including those published in the press), the armed people inside the refugee column did exchange gunfire with Armenian outposts, but on each occasion, the fire was opened first from the Armenian side.[23]

Victims

Human Rights Watch described the Khojaly massacre in their 1994 report as "the largest massacre to date" in Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict. Mentioning that "there are no exact figures for the number of Azeri civilians killed because Karabakh Armenian forces gained control of the area after the massacre", HRW estimated the number of Azerbaijani civilian deaths at least 161[1] in 1993 and then to at least 200 in 1994,[2] mentioning the possibility that as many as 500-1,000 may have died".[2] The death toll given by Azerbaijani authorities was 613 civilians, including 106 women and 63 children.[4][2] By 28 March 1992, over 700 civilians from Khojaly, mostly women and children detained both in the city and on their way to Aghdam, were delivered to the Azerbaijani side, according to Moscow-based Memorial society.[12] Memorial described the actions of Armenian militants as in gross violation of a number of basic international human rights conventions.[12]

Reports and analyses

Anatol Lieven wrote in The Times after visiting the site of the massacre: "Scattered amid the withered grass and bushes along a small valley and across the hillside beyond are the bodies of last Wednesday’s massacre by Armenian forces of Azerbaijani refugees. ... Of the 31 we saw, only one policeman and two apparent national volunteers were wearing an uniform. All the rest were civilians, including eight women and three small children. Two groups, apparently families, had fallen together, the children cradled in the women’s arms. Several of them, including one small girl, had terrible head injuries: only her face was left. Survivors have told how they saw Armenians shooting them point blank as they lay on the ground."[45]

Helen Womack reported in The Independent: "The exact number of victims is still unclear, but there can be little doubt that Azeri civilians were massacred by Armenian fighters in the snowy mountains of Nagorny Karabakh last week. Refugees from the enclave town of Khojaly, sheltering in the Azeri border town of Agdam, give largely consistent accounts of how their enemies attacked their homes on the night of 25 February, chased those who fled and shot them in the surrounding forests. Yesterday I saw 75 freshly dug graves in one cemetery in addition to four mutilated corpses we were shown in the mosque when we arrived in Agdam late on Tuesday. I also saw women and children with bullet wounds, in a makeshift hospital in a string of railway carriages at the station",[46] "I have little doubt that on this occasion, two weeks ago, the Azeris were the victims of Armenian brutality. In the past, it has been the other way round"[47]

Russian journalist Victoria Ivleva entered Khojaly after it fell to Armenian armed forces. She took photos of the town streets strewn with dead bodies of its inhabitants, including women and children.[48] She described how she saw a large crowd of Meskhetian Turks from Khojaly who were led to captivity by the Armenian militants and she was hit by an Armenian soldier who took her for one of the captives, when she was helping a woman falling behind the crowd with four children, one of which wounded, and the other one newly born. The captives were later exchanged or released, and in 2011 Ivleva found that woman in Azerbaijan. Her little child grew up, but did not speak, this was attributed to the shock she suffered in childhood.[49]

After the seizure of Khojaly, Armenians allowed Azerbaijanis to claim their dead, based on which the Azerbaijanis later grounded their accusations of the massacre.[50][51] As argued by Walker, the group committing a massacre would have hardly taken up any of these measures.[50]

Video footage and photographs

Azerbaijanis who managed to escape the massacre taking refuge in the Agdam Mosque

The site of the Khojaly mass killing was filmed on videotape by Azerbaijani journalist Chingiz Mustafayev, who we was accompanied by the Russian journalist Yuri Romanov in the first helicopter flight to the scene of the tragedy. Romanov described in his memoir how he looked out of the window of the helicopter and jumped back from an incredibly horrible view. The whole area up to the horizon was covered with dead bodies of women, elderly people and boys and girls of all ages, from newly born to teenagers. Amid the mass of bodies two caught his sight. An old woman with uncovered grey head was lying face down next to a little girl in a blue jacket. Their legs were tied with barbed wire, and the old woman's hands were tied as well. Both were shot in their heads, and the little girl in her last move was stretching out her hands to her dead grandmother. Shocked, Romanov initially forgot about his camera, but started filming after recovering from the shock. However, the helicopter came under the fire, and they had to leave.[52] Czech journalist Dana Mazalova said that in Baku she had seen Chingiz Mustafayev's unedited footage of the dead bodies without the signs of mutilation that were shown in later footage.[39][53][54]

Eynulla Fatullayev and "Karabakh Diary"

Azerbaijani journalist Eynulla Fatullayev traveled in 2005 to Armenia and Nagorno-Karabakh and wrote an article called "Karabakh Diary". He claimed that he met some refugees from Khojaly, temporarily settled in Naftalan, who said that the Armenians had indeed left a free corridor and the Armenian soldiers positioned behind the corridor had not opened fire on them. Some soldiers from the battalions of the National Front of Azerbaijan instead, for some reason, had led part of the refugees in the direction of the village of Nakhichevanik, which during that period had been under the control of the Armenians' Askeran battalion. The other group of refugees were hit by artillery volleys while they were reaching the Agdam Region.[55][56]

However, in his statement to the European Court of Human Rights Fatullayev noted that in the article "The Karabakh Diary", he had merely conveyed the statements of a local Armenian, who had told Fatullayev his version of the events during the interview. Fatullayev claimed that his article did not directly accuse any Azerbaijani national of committing any crime and that in his article, there was no statement asserting that any of the Khojaly victims had been killed or mutilated by Azerbaijani fighters.[55]

Eynulla Fatullayev was sued for defamation and convicted in an Azerbaijani court to eight and a half years in prison and a penalty fee of $230,000. "Reporters without Borders" strongly condemned this decision, stating that the judgment was based on no evidence but is purely political.[57] [58]The European Court of Human Rights ruled that Fatullayev must be released, because in their opinion "although “The Karabakh Diary” might have contained certain exaggerated or provocative assertions, the author did not cross the limits of journalistic freedom". The Court also noted that "The Karabakh Diary" did not constitute a piece of investigative journalism focusing specifically on the Khojaly events and considered that Fatullayev's statements about these events were made rather in passing, parallel to the main theme of the article.[55] Fatullayev was subsequently pardoned by the Azerbaijani president and released from jail.

However, after being released from prison in May 2011, Eynulla Fatullayev defended his 2005 comments which held Azerbaijani fighters and not Armenians responsible for the 1992 killings in Khojaly and added that the Azerbaijani government has long sought to use the Khojaly events to persecute its opponents, like the first president of Azerbaijan, Ayaz Mutalibov, who at the time was still under criminal investigation for complicity in the Khojaly events. He also mentions Fahmin Hajiyev, the head of Azerbaijan's interior troops of the country who spent 11 years in prison because of the Khojaly events.[59] Hajiyev was sentenced on charges of criminal negligence for surrendering the city of Khojaly to Armenian troops.[60]

Yet in February 2014 in a televised interview to ANS TV Fatullayev said that the Armenians perpetrated a genocide in Khojaly, and that he never questioned that, even in his "Karabakh Diary". He also mentioned that he personally joined a "Justice for Khojaly" rally in Strasbourg.[61] In subsequent article in Azeri Daily Fatullayev blamed both Armenians and the Popular Front of Azerbaijan (PFA) in the tragedy, writing that:

They (i.e. Azerbaijanis in Khojaly) were killed by the Armenians only because they were Azerbaijanis. And along with the Armenian expeditionary corps, they were also killed by 'ours.' By their indifference, betrayal, attempt to transfer the war from Karabakh to Baku. The Armenian military units and these 'ours' opened the way to the Khojaly massacre!

— [62]

Fatullayev defended Mutalibov, writing that "Mutalibov officially denied the thought attributed to him that the mass extermination of Azerbaijanis in Khojaly was the work of the rebellious Azerbaijani opposition. Yes, Mutallibov in this interview condemned the opposition exchanging the country's national interests for narrow political interests, turning Karabakh into a kind of a bargaining chip. But the Czech journalist changed the meaning of the words of the ex-president". Fatullayev also accused Nikol Pashinyan of "justifying the crimes of his predecessors and the main political enemies in Khojaly".[63] In another article, Fatullayev wrote that "the Armenian expeditionary corps massacred the Azerbaijani population in Khojaly".[64]

The 366th CIS regiment's role

According to international observers, soldiers and officers of the 366th Guards Motor Rifle Regiment of United Armed Forces of the Commonwealth of Independent States. took part in the attack on Khojaly.[65] Memorial called for an investigation of the facts of participation of CIS soldiers in the military operations in the region and transfer of military equipment to the sides of the conflict. Soon after the massacre, in early March 1992, the regiment was withdrawn from Nagorno-Karabakh. Paratroopers evacuated the personnel of the regiment by helicopter, but over 100 soldiers and officers remained in Stepanakert and joined the Armenian forces, including the commander of the 2nd battalion major Seyran Ohanyan,[3] who later served as a Minister of Defense of Armenia. The Krasnaya Zvezda newspaper reported:

Despite categorical orders of the command of the military district, some military personnel of the 366th regiment took part in military operations near Khojaly on Karabakhi side on the 20s of February. At least two such instances were recorded. And during evacuation of the military personnel of the regiment paratroopers selectively searched several servicemen and found large amounts of money on them, including foreign currency.[66]

Legacy

Memorials

Memorials have been erected in Azerbaijan and abroad to commemorate Khojaly massacre.

In popular culture

Footage

The footage of Chingiz Mustafayev increased the awareness of the campaign.[67] In 2010, it was broadcast by American television channel CNN.[68]

In sport

On 11 May 2014, Arda Turan of Atlético Madrid, sponsored by Azerbaijan,[69] commemorated the Khojaly massacre.[70][71][72] The footballer explained by wanting to raise awareness about this issue and promoting world peace.[73][74] The sponsorship by Azerbaijan has been condemned by Reporters Without Borders.[75] Atlético Madrid admitted its sponsorship deal with Azerbaijan has a political dimension, saying the intention is to "promote the image of Azerbaijan".[69]

Denial

Denial of the Khojaly massacre, by either claiming that the massacre was committed by Azerbaijanis themselves or that no civilian was killed is common among the Armenian public, officials and organisations.[76][10][77][78] According to Rachel Avraham, senior media research analyst at the Israeli Center for Near East Policy Research, Armenia's non-recognition of the Khojaly massacre was an "impediment for peace" in the region, and that the "same state that perpetrated that crime against humanity" is continuing to not take responsibility for their actions.[79] To date, noone has been prosecuted for the massacre in Khojaly.[11]

In November 2019, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan called the massacre "a blatant lie," claiming that it was "carried out by Azerbaijanis themselves", despite the findings by Human Rights Watch which placed direct responsibility for the civilian deaths with Karabakh Armenian forces.[10][6]

Pashinyan referred to Ayaz Mutalibov's interview to claim that the massacre had been committed not by Armenian soldiers but by Popular Front of Azerbaijan militants who allegedly shot their own civilians escaping through the corridor. Nevertheless, attempting to minimize his own role did not help him.[80] In one of his interviews Mutalibov stated that the event was "organized" by his political opponents to force his resignation.[81][82] The interview was much cited in Armenia.[80]

As the survivors of Khojaly say, all this was organized to create a cause for my resignation. A certain power was working for discrediting the President. I don't think the Armenians, who are very accurate and who know very well how to behave in such situations, would have allowed the Azerbaijanis to obtain evidence from Khojaly, which would expose them in committing fascist acts… I assume that someone had a vested interest in showing these photos in the session of the Supreme Council and placing all the blame on me… However, the general background of arguments is, that a corridor by which the people could leave, was, nevertheless, left by Armenians. Why then would they begin to shoot?"[83][84]

In later interviews, however, Mutalibov would condemn the Armenians, claiming that they blatantly misinterpreted his words.[85] He also denied ever accusing the Popular Front of Azerbaijan of having anything to do with these events, saying that he only meant that the PFA took advantage of the situation to focus the popular resentment on him. Mutalibov stated that after the massacre he called the speaker of the Supreme Soviet of NKAO Artur Mkrtchyan, and the latter assured him that the people of Khojaly were given a corridor to escape, and he only referred to Mkrtchyan's words, without making any assertions as to whether the corridor actually existed.[86][87]

Armenian organisations such as Armenian National Committee of America, Political Science Association of Armenia and Armenian National Committee of Australia have embraced the denialism of the massacre by calling it "propaganda" and "fabricated".[88][89][90][91]

Politicization

Commemorations of the Khojaly massacre in Turkey and Azerbaijan are used to counter the narrative of the Armenian genocide. Speeches during the commemoration ceremonies in Turkey have an intense anti-Armenian coloring. Their messages boil down to claiming that since Armenians committed the massacre, it is them who are "perpetrators", Turks are "victims", and the Armenian Genocide is a lie.

In the opinion of journalist Aykan Sever, the instrumentalization of the Khojaly massacre for creating a victim image for Turks intensified following the assassination of ethnic Armenian journalist Hrant Dink in January 2007 in Istanbul.

British journalist Thomas de Waal thinks that the massacre's commemoration as a purported "genocide" not only depicts Azerbaijan as a “victim of aggression”, but also has become the countering and "competing" idea against the extermination of Armenians.[92]

Historian and genocide scholar Yair Auron calls the use of the term "genocide" for the events in Khojaly a "cynical Azeri fabrication" fostered by Azerbaijan. According to Auron, the use of the term "genocide" for the Khojaly massacre desecrates the memory of the Holocaust. Auron also criticized Israel for "supporting this Azerbaijani claim directly and indirectly". He further stated that "there are several versions regarding what happened in the Armenian enclave, including a disputed numbers of victims. There are some who claim there was not even a massacre, but one thing is clear: No genocide took place there. I say this as a genocide researcher and as a person who believes that the murder of even one person because of his affiliation is an intolerable crime."[93]

References

Footnotes

  1. ^ a b c d e f "Human Rights Watch World Report 1993 – The Former Soviet Union". Hrw.org. Archived from the original on 18 February 2015. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  2. ^ a b c d e f Human Rights Watch/Helsinki (1994). Azerbaijan: Seven Years of Conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh. New York [u.a.]: Human Rights Watch. p. 5. ISBN 1-56432-142-8. Retrieved 12 March 2014.
  3. ^ a b c d e f g de Waal, Thomas (2004). Black garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan through peace and war. ABC-CLIO. pp. 172–173. ISBN 0-8147-1945-7. Archived from the original on 3 June 2016.
  4. ^ a b c "Letter dated 26 February 2015 from the Permanent Representative of the Republic of Azerbaijan to the United Nations Office at Geneva addressed to the President of the Human Rights Council". Archived from the original on 11 January 2016.
  5. ^ a b Bloodshed in the Caucasus: escalation of the armed conflict in Nagorno Karabakh, vol. 1245 of Human rights documents, Human Rights Watch, 1992, p. 24
  6. ^ a b c "Response to Armenian Government Letter on the town of Khojaly, Nagorno-Karabakh". hrw.org. Human Rights Watch. 23 March 1997. Retrieved 25 February 2021. Yet we place direct responsibility for the civilian deaths with Karabakh Armenian forces.
  7. ^ "New York Times – massacre by Armenians Being Reported". Commonwealth of Independent States; Azerbaijan; Khojaly (Armenia); Armenia: Select.nytimes.com. 3 March 1992. Archived from the original on 11 March 2007. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  8. ^ Smolowe, Jill (16 March 1992). "TIME Magazine – Tragedy Massacre in Khojaly". Time.com. Archived from the original on 28 February 2005. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  9. ^ Small Nations and Great Powers: A Study of Ethnopolitical Conflict in the Caucasus By Svante E. Cornell
  10. ^ a b c "Armenian and Azerbaijani leaders embrace denialism". eurasianet.org. Eurasianet. 22 November 2019. Retrieved 25 February 2021.
  11. ^ a b c "ДОКЛАД ПРАВОЗАЩИТНОГО ЦЕНТРА «МЕМОРИАЛ» О МАССОВЫХ НАРУШЕНИЯХ ПРАВ ЧЕЛОВЕКА, СВЯЗАННЫХ С ЗАНЯТИЕМ НАСЕЛЕННОГО ПУНКТА ХОДЖАЛЫ В НОЧЬ С 25 НА 26 ФЕВРАЛЯ 1992 г. ВООРУЖЕННЫМИ ФОРМИРОВАНИЯМИ" (PDF). memohrc.org. Memorial. Retrieved 26 February 2021.
  12. ^ a b c "Report of Memorial Human rights center (In Russian)". Memo.ru. Archived from the original on 22 June 2014. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  13. ^ "Armenians Gain in New Battle With Azerbaijanis". New York Times. 27 February 1992. Archived from the original on 30 March 2014. Retrieved 14 December 2014.
  14. ^ "TÜRKSAM- Türkiye Uluslararası İlişkiler ve Stratejik Analizler Merkezi, Türkiye'nin en köklü düşünce kuruluşlarından biridir". TÜRKSAM. Archived from the original on 3 March 2011.
  15. ^ "Welcome". Hocalisoykirimi.com. Archived from the original on 23 July 2013. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  16. ^ "State Commission on prisoners of war, hostages and missing persons – Khojaly genocide". Human.gov.az. Archived from the original on 1 November 2012. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  17. ^ Human Rights Watch/Helsinki. Bloodshed in the Caucasus: Escalation of the Armed Conflict in Nagorno Karabakh. New York: Human Rights Watch, 1992. pp. 12–13.

    By the winter of 1991–92, as a result of Azerbaijan’s three-year economic and transport blockade, Nagorno Karabakh was without fuel (though it did have natural gas), electricity, running water, functioning sanitation facilities, communications facilities, and most consumer goods... Life in Stepanakert during the Helsinki Watch visit in April 1992 was at a standstill...


    <...>

    In January 1992, Azerbaijani forces began attacking Stepanakert with Grad missiles, which are jet-propelled rockets intended as anti-personnel weapons.

  18. ^ Доклад общества «Мемориал» Archived 22 June 2014 at the Wayback Machine (Memorial). Независимая газета, 18 June 1992
  19. ^ "Карабахские депутаты: Ходжалу стал жертвой политических интриг и борьбы за власть в Азербайджане. ИА REGNUM, 25 February 2008". Regnum.ru. Archived from the original on 3 December 2013. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  20. ^ The Black Garden, Thomas de Waal, ISBN 0-8147-1944-9, Page 170
  21. ^ Kaufman, Stuart (2001). Modern Hatreds: The Symbolic Politics of Ethnic War. New York: Cornell Studies in Security Affairs. pp. 49–66. ISBN 0-8014-8736-6.
  22. ^ The Armenian account states that in the situation of complete blockade and continuous shelling of Stepanakert the Karabakh Armenians had no choice but to seize Khojaly to stop the bombardment. Torosyan Tigran. Conflict Resolution in the Framework of International Law: Case of Nagorno Karabakh. 2010.
  23. ^ a b c ДОКЛАД ПРАВОЗАЩИТНОГО ЦЕНТРА "МЕМОРИАЛ" (in Russian). Memorial. Archived from the original on 31 July 2010. Retrieved 23 February 2012.
  24. ^ Human Rights Watch. Bloodshed in the Caucasus: Escalation of the Armed Conflict in Nagorno Karabakh. ISBN 1-56432-081-2
  25. ^ Hugh Pope, "Sons of the conquerors: the rise of the Turkic world", New York: The Overlook Press, 2006, p. 59, ISBN 1-58567-804-X
  26. ^ Denber Rachel. Bloodshed in the Caucasus: Escalation of the Armed Conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh. New York: Helsinki Watch, September 1992, pp. 19–21. ISBN 1-56432-081-2.
  27. ^ European Court of Human Rights. "The European Court of Human Rights. Case of Fatullayev v. Azerbaijan" (PDF). p. 3. Archived (PDF) from the original on 17 March 2011.
  28. ^ "Bloodshed in the Caucasus: escalation of the armed conflict in Nagorno Karabakh. Human Rights Watch, 1992. ISBN 1-56432-081-2, ISBN 978-1-56432-081-0, p. 20" (PDF). Archived (PDF) from the original on 21 September 2013. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  29. ^ de Waal, Thomas (2004). Black garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan through peace and war. ABC-CLIO. p. 172. ISBN 0-8147-1945-7. Archived from the original on 3 June 2016.
  30. ^ İlqar Rəsul (13 September 2009). "Ramiz Fataliev's interview to radio "Azadlig" (Liberty) in Azerbaijani". Azadliq.org. Archived from the original on 29 April 2014. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  31. ^ Эльмира Ахундова (1993). Ходжалы. Хроника геноцида (PDF) (in Russian). Азернешр. p. 15. ISBN 5-552-01317-4. Archived from the original on 9 December 2012.CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
  32. ^ a b Human Rights Watch/Helsinki. Bloodshed in the Caucasus: Escalation of the Armed Conflict in Nagorno Karabakh. New York: Human Rights Watch, 1992. pp. 24.
  33. ^ Kristen Eichensehr, William Michael Reisman. Stopping wars and making peace: studies in international intervention, 2009, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers p. 63,
  34. ^ Annika Rabo, Bo Utas. "The role of the state in West Asia", Istanbul 2005, p. 175,
  35. ^ Helsinki Watch. "Bloodshed in the Caucasus: Escalation of the Armed Conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh" New York, September 1992 p. 21
  36. ^ a b "Letter to the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Armenia from the Executive Director of Human Rights Watch dated March 24, 1997". Hrw.org. 24 March 1997. Archived from the original on 6 September 2008. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  37. ^ "Bloodshed in the Caucasus: escalation of the armed conflict in Nagorno Karabakh. Human Rights Watch, 1992. ISBN 1-56432-081-2, ISBN 978-1-56432-081-0, pp. 23–24" (PDF). Archived (PDF) from the original on 21 September 2013. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  38. ^ "Letter to the UN from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Armenia". Un.org. Archived from the original on 23 June 2014. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  39. ^ a b Thomas De Waal. "More War in the Caucasus". Archived from the original on 29 April 2014. Retrieved 25 February 2012.
  40. ^ "Том де Ваал: Трагедия в Ходжалы – результат хаоса, "спонтанная", а не "преднамеренная" акция". Regnum.ru. Archived from the original on 14 March 2014. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  41. ^ "Interview with De Waal". Youtube.com. 10 November 2010. Archived from the original on 10 July 2014. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  42. ^ Markar Melkonian. My Brother's Road: An American's Fateful Journey to Armenia. New York: I.B. Tauris, 2005 ISBN 1-85043-635-5, p.p. 213-214
  43. ^ " + hours + ':' + min + " " + time + ". "A President, an Interview, and a Tragic Anniversary". Carnegieendowment.org. Archived from the original on 29 April 2014. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  44. ^ Томас де Ваал (19 March 2012). "Serzh Sargsyan on Khojaly". Radioazadlyg.org. Archived from the original on 29 April 2014. Retrieved 28 April 2014.
  45. ^ The Times, 3 March 1992. Anatol Lieven, "Bodies Mark Site of Karabakh Massacre".
  46. ^ The Independent, 5 March 1992. Helen Womack. Azeris hunted down and shot in the forest; Refugees and fresh graves confirm massacre by Armenians.
  47. ^ The Independent, 8 March 1992. Helen Womack. Karabakh falls prey to revenge; Helen Womack confronts the evidence of a massacre on her arrival in Agdam.
  48. ^ Victoria Ivleva. The corpses of people killed during the Armenian attack in the streets of the settlement of Khojaly, Nagorno-Karabakh, February 1992. Photograph 1 Archived 24 March 2012 at the Wayback Machine, Photograph 2 Archived 24 March 2012 at the Wayback Machine
  49. ^ "Новая газета - Novayagazeta.ru". Новая газета - Novayagazeta.ru. Archived from the original on 9 February 2013.
  50. ^ a b Walker J. Christopher (1996) The Armenian presence in mountainous Karabakh. In Wright F. R. John, Goldenberg Suzanne and Schofield Richard (eds.) Transcaucasian boundaries. London: UCL Press, pp. 89–111
  51. ^ Cox, Caroline and John Eibner (1993). Ethnic Cleansing in Progress: War in Nagorno Karabakh. Zürich; Washington: Institute for Religious Minorities in the Islamic World.
  52. ^ "Романов Юрий. "Я снимаю войну". Школа выживания". Scribd. Archived from the original on 12 May 2016.
  53. ^ Dana Mazalova. "Press conference: Justice for Khojaly" (in Russian). Novosti. Archived from the original on 10 August 2011. Retrieved 25 February 2012.
  54. ^ ДАНА МАЗАЛОВА: "ТО, ЧТО ОНИ ПОКАЗЫВАЮТ, – НЕ ХОДЖАЛУ" (in Russian). 13 March 2010. Archived from the original on 30 December 2012. Retrieved 25 February 2012.
  55. ^ a b c "CASE OF FATULLAYEV v. AZERBAIJAN. STRASBOURG. 22 April 2010" (PDF).
  56. ^ European Stability Initiative. "Generation Facebook on trial" (PDF).
  57. ^ https://www.reporter-ohne-grenzen.de/pressemitteilungen/meldung/achteinhalb-jahre-haft-und-hohe-geldstrafe-fuer-eynulla-fatullaiev (in German)
  58. ^ ""Aserbaidschan" Menschenrechte | Aktuelle Entwicklungen & Aktionen". www.amnesty.de. Retrieved 27 November 2021.
  59. ^ "Fatullayev: 'I'm Still Here -- Alive, Working, and Telling the Truth'". RadioFreeEurope/RadioLiberty. Retrieved 27 November 2021.
  60. ^ Messrs Stefan Trechsel, Evert Alkema and Alexander Arabadjiev (16 July 2001). "Council of Europe, Secrétaire Général. Cases of alleged political prisoners in Armenia and Azerbaijan - Addendum to the Report of the Independent Experts,".
  61. ^ Mir Şahin və Eynulla Fətullayev "Hesabat"da. 23.02.2014 Archived 24 February 2018 at the Wayback Machine
  62. ^ Fatullayev, Eynulla. "Let's not forget another culprit of Khojaly: Popular Front of Azerbaijan! (Our memory)". Azeri Daily. Retrieved 28 November 2021.
  63. ^ Fatullayev, Eynulla. "Pashinyan with Ilham Aliyev about 'last day of Pompeii'". Azeri Daily. Retrieved 28 November 2021.
  64. ^ Фатуллаев, Эйнулла (14 July 2020). "Газиев вернулся, чтобы свергнуть власть - портрет на фоне поражения" (in Russian). haqqin.az. Retrieved 28 November 2021.
  65. ^ Bloodshed in the Caucasus: escalation of the armed conflict in Nagorno Karabakh. Human Rights Watch, 1992. ISBN 1-56432-081-2, ISBN 978-1-56432-081-0, p. 21
  66. ^ Красная звезда, 11.03.92. Карабах: война до победного конца? несмотря на категорические приказы командования округа, некоторые военнослужащие 366-го мсп всё же принимали участие на стороне карабахцев в боевых действиях под Ходжалы в двадцатых числах февраля. По крайней мере зафиксировано два таких случая. А при эвакуации личного состава полка десантники на выбор проверили несколько военнослужащих и обнаружили у них большие суммы денег, в том числе и в иностранной валюте
  67. ^ Goldberg, Carey (5 March 1992). "Enclave Horror Echoed in a Cameraman's Sobs : Karabakh: Film is shown in Moscow as Azerbaijanis and Armenians again trade charges over Khojaly attack". Los Angeles Times. Archived from the original on 6 November 2013. Retrieved 5 November 2013.
  68. ^ Ahmadova, Sevinj. "CNN состоялся показ видеосюжета Чингиза Мустафаева о Ходжалинской трагедии". bakililar.az (in Russian). Archived from the original on 5 November 2013. Retrieved 5 November 2013.
  69. ^ a b Atletico Madrid: Azerbaijan logo edited out of Iran paper Archived 9 May 2016 at the Wayback Machine. BBC. 9 May 2014. Retrieved 27 February 2016
  70. ^ "Arda Turan 'Hocalı' mesajı yayınladı". www.zaman.com.tr (in Turkish). Archived from the original on 12 May 2014. Retrieved 11 May 2014.
  71. ^ "Meaningful Message from Arda Turan". van.habermonitor.com. Archived from the original on 12 May 2014. Retrieved 11 May 2014.
  72. ^ АРДА Туран: В финале Лиги чемпионов не мог найти себе места, вот и поменял костюм на "спортивку". www.azerisport.com (in Russian). Archived from the original on 29 May 2014. Retrieved 29 May 2014.
  73. ^ "Atletico Madrid FC to commemorate Khojaly victims". www.azertag.gov.a. Archived from the original on 11 May 2014. Retrieved 11 May 2014.
  74. ^ "Arda Hocalı kurbanlarını unutmadı". www.aljazeera.com.tr. Al Jazeera. Archived from the original on 12 May 2014. Retrieved 11 May 2014.
  75. ^ DO YOU KNOW WHO ATLÉTICO MADRID’S REAL SPONSOR IS? Archived 4 March 2016 at the Wayback Machine. Reporters Without Borders. 22 May 2014. Retrieved 27 February 2016
  76. ^ Thomas De Waal (24 February 2012). "A President, an Interview, and a Tragic Anniversary". carnegieeurope.eu. Carnegie Europe. Retrieved 26 February 2021. But, keen to minimize their own acts of aggression, many Armenians have sought to deny that their soldiers killed civilians that day.
  77. ^ "Azerbaijan: Baku Presses Genocide Recognition Campaign for Khojaly". eurasianet.org. Eurasianet. 28 February 2012. Retrieved 25 February 2021.
  78. ^ "Genocide Emergency Alert on the War in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh)". genocidewatch.com. 6 November 2020. Because of Armenia’s denial of war crimes such as the Khojaly massacre and other crimes against Azerbaijanis, and the current shelling of Azerbaijani civilians by Armenian artillery, Genocide Watch considers Armenia to be at Stage 8: Persecution and Stage 10: Denial
  79. ^ Rachel Avraham (23 February 2021). "Why Israel Should Build a Khojaly Memorial". Retrieved 25 February 2021.
  80. ^ a b de Waal, Thomas (2004). Black garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan through peace and war. ABC-CLIO. p. 171. ISBN 0-8147-1945-7. Archived (PDF) from the original on 26 February 2019.
  81. ^ Novoye Vremya, 6 March 2001
  82. ^ Cox, Caroline. "Ethnic Cleansing in Progress: War in Nagorno Karabakh" (PDF).
  83. ^ Nezavisimaya Gazetta, 2 April 1992
  84. ^ Zvyagin Sergei (2010) Ходжалу: правда и вымыслы. (Khojaly: the truth and the fabrications) Nezavisimaya Gazeta, 05 March 2010. Archived 25 May 2014 at the Wayback Machine
  85. ^ Interview of Ayaz Mutalibov Archived 30 September 2007 at the Wayback Machine, Regnum News Agency
  86. ^ ""Антиазербайджанская революция прошла под красным знаменем": интервью экс-президента Азербайджана Аяза Муталибова ИА REGNUM". ИА REGNUM. Archived from the original on 5 December 2012.
  87. ^ Я никогда не говорил, что в Ходжалинском геноциде виноваты азербайджанцы (in Russian). Vesti.az. Archived from the original on 13 February 2016. Retrieved 30 June 2013.
  88. ^ "Khojaly denialism continues, despite hard proof and survivor testimony". republic-underground.com. 24 February 2021. Retrieved 25 February 2021.
  89. ^ "Armenian Legislative Caucus Urges Colleagues to Reject Azeri Propaganda". asbarez.com. Armenian National Committee of America. 19 February 2021. Retrieved 25 February 2021.
  90. ^ "The Khojaly Genocide Fabrication". anc.org.au. Armenian National Committee of Australia. Retrieved 25 February 2021.
  91. ^ "Khojaly a Symbol of Azeri Propaganda, Researchers Say". horizonweekly.ca. 25 February 2014. Retrieved 25 February 2021.
  92. ^ What and How Do We Remember? The Politics of Official Commemoration in Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Turkey. The Caucasus Edition. Retrieved 20 March 2021
  93. ^ Israel Must Stop Saying the Azeris Were Victims of Genocide. Haaretz. 10 April 2018. Retrieved 24 September 2021

External links

Non-partisan

From Azerbaijani perspective

From Armenian perspective

Coordinates: 39°54′40″N 46°47′21″E / 39.91111°N 46.78917°E / 39.91111; 46.78917