Labrador Retriever coat colour genetics
The genetic basis of coat colour in the Labrador Retriever (a highly popular breed of dog) has been studied in detail, and found to depend on several distinct genes. The interplay between these genes is broadly used as an example of epistasis.
Labrador Retrievers are a popular breed of dog in many countries. There are three recognised colours, black, chocolate, and yellow, that result from the interplay among genes that direct production and expression of two pigments, eumelanin and pheomelanin, in the fur and skin of the dog. The recognized colours are due to two genes, while a third gene affects the range of colouration observed within the yellow Labrador. These individual genes do not act independently of each other, and their interaction in affecting the trait of coat colour is used to demonstrate the genetic principle of epistasis, where multiple genes react synergistically to affect a single trait.
The genetics of mammalian colouration has been studied in detail, and similar mechanisms have been identified across many species. For this reason, much of the early work on the colouration of dogs in general and Labradors in particular have relied heavily on analogy to the traits characterized in mice and other mammals. Initial genetic studies of coat colour in dogs published in the 1950s concluded that there were two main genes involved, one distinguishing blacks from browns, and the other distinguishing blacks from reds and yellows. A 1977 study using crosses within a population of purebred Labradors showed the involvement of two specific genes in production of the three main coat colours of Labradors and described the underlying genetics of these colour varieties.
Eumelanin colour and distribution
The three recognised colours of Labrador Retrievers result from differences in two genetic loci that affect pigment expression. The first of these affects the colour of the dark pigment, eumelanin, and is referred to as the B (brown) locus. The variation displayed by this locus is observed in many mammals, reflecting a so-called 'dilution', a lightening, of black eumelanin to a brown colour. Initial genetic research excluded a role for the melanocortin 1 receptor and the Agouti locus as being the cause of the black dilution trait in dogs. Instead, TYRP1 (tyrosine related protein 1) was found to be responsible. This enzyme is localised to melanosomes, the cellular organelles that produce and store pigments, and serves to catalyze oxidation of eumelanin precursors. In dogs, three mutations in this gene have been identified, one resulting in a truncation of the protein, the other two leading to an amino acid deletion or a single amino acid substitution in the sequence of the protein. All of these mutations are found across the range of dogs, and hence are thought to have preceded the divergence of distinct breeds, and all three are found within Labrador Retrievers. Each of the mutations appears to eliminate or significantly reduce enzymatic activity, and the colouration phenotypes (the visible traits) produced by the three mutations are indistinguishable. These represent recessive mutations in the TYRP1 gene, and since mammals have two copies of each gene, one from each parent, an animal with at least one copy of the fully functioning TYRP1 protein (represented as 'B') will display the dominant trait, black pigmentation, while to display brown pigmentation, both copies of this gene must be mutant alleles (collectively represented as 'b'). Thus a dog with the genotypes BB or Bb will express black eumelanin, while brown eumelanin will be seen in dogs with the bb genotype.
A second gene affects whether these eumelanin pigments will be expressed in the fur or solely in the skin. Called the 'extension' (E) trait, this is directed by the melanocortin 1 receptor (MC1R). This receptor signals the pigment-producing cell in response to melanocortins and results in deposition of eumelanin into the hair. Mutations in this protein have been shown to be involved in pale or red colour phenotypes in a range of species, including humans, horses, pigs, cattle, mice, fur seals, mammoths and the Kermode bear, as well as colouration in whiptail lizards. In most dogs, activity of MC1R is modulated by two signaling molecules, a repressor that is a product of the Agouti gene (A locus), and an activator, β-Defensin 103 (CBD103), recently named the K locus. In Labradors a highly-active mutated version of the K gene, (KB) is invariant, producing uniform eumelanin distribution independent of the Agouti genotype and leaving differences in MC1R to mediate the sole variability of this signaling pathway. A recessive mutation in this E gene that truncates the protein, producing a non-functional receptor incapable of directing eumelanin deposition in the fur. Among dogs, this mutation is unique to yellow Labrador Retrievers and Golden Retrievers and is thought to have arisen in the retriever population before these individual breeds became distinct. The exact mutation has also been found to underlie the colouration of white coyotes found around Newfoundland, having apparently passed into that population through interbreeding with a Golden Retriever. As with the B locus, presence of a single copy of the functional receptor gene ('E') will result in the dominant phenotype: presence of eumelanin in the fur. If both copies of this gene are the recessive mutated variant ('e'), the dog will have no eumelanin in its fur. Such a dog will appear yellow, with eumelanin evident only in the skin of the nose, lips, eye rims and foot pads, of a colour determined by the B locus. A variant of the functional MC1R allele that produces a facial 'mask' in other breeds of dogs (Em) is also present in Labradors, but since the colour of the mask is determined by the B locus, in Labradors the mask this gene produces is indistinguishable from the overall coat colour.
The interplay between these two genes determines the colour of a Labrador Retriever. If a dog possesses the dominant phenotype for the extension allele (genotype EE or Ee), then it will display the fur colouration determined by its brown locus genotype, while a dog with the recessive extension trait (ee) will have a yellow coat with either black (BB, Bb) or brown (bb) exposed skin. This results in the three coat colours seen:
- Black Labradors can have any genotype with at least one dominant allele at both the B and E loci: BBEE, BBEe, BbEE, or BbEe.
- Chocolate Labradors will have a genotype with at least one dominant E allele, but must have only recessive b alleles: bbEE and bbEe.
- Yellow Labradors with black skin pigment will have a dominant B allele but must have recessive e alleles: BBee or Bbee.
- Yellow Labradors with pale or chocolate pigment, or an absence of skin pigment, can have only recessive alleles at both loci: bbee. These dogs are often referred to as Dudleys, and are disqualified in the showring, although are eligible for registration under current standards. Aging-related declines in eumelanin production can cause the exposed skin in a Labrador with black skin pigmentation begin to appear lighter, but Dudley dogs have this colouration throughout their lives.
These genes assort independently, so a single genetic cross involving two black Labradors each with a recessive allele at both the B and the E locus (BbEe) has the potential of producing all of the possible colour combinations, while crosses involving chocolate dogs can never produce black (there being no dominant B allele in either parent) but can give rise to yellow, while yellow Labradors will breed true with regard to fur colour but those with black skin can potentially produce a Dudley. Dudleys breed true for both fur and skin. The ability of the E locus to override the coat colour directed by the B locus is a classical example of epistasis, where multiple genetic loci affect the same observed trait.
Pheomelanin in yellow Labradors
The E locus also determines whether the phenotype due to the third genetic locus affecting coat colour will be evident. This locus is recognised as affecting coat colour through the expression of pheomelanin, the pigment responsible for red and yellow pigmentation. The effects on pheomelanin pigmentation are only seen if there is no eumelanin expressed in the fur, else the dark eumelanin will mask any pheomelanin present, and thus these differences are visible only in yellow Labradors. The result is dogs of colours ranging from a red to a light cream. It had long been thought that the genetic locus for this trait was the same seen regulating pheomelanin in other mammals, subsequently identified as tyrosinase. This enzyme makes both eumelanin and pheomelanin, and when subject to a knockout mutation results in albinism. A less extreme mutation of the same tyrosinase gene, the so-called Chinchilla trait, produces a dilution that selectively affects pheomelanin alone, similar to the phenotype observed in yellow Labradors. Thus, as with Chinchilla-related pheomelanin dilution in other species, this trait in Labradors has been represented by the letter C. However, genetic analysis of the inheritance of coat colour in yellow Labradors has shown that the locus responsible is entirely distinct from the Chinchilla trait of the tyrosinase gene, and likewise is distinct from SLC45A2, the so-called cream gene responsible for the dilution of pheomelanin in buckskin, palomino and cremello horses and also for the absence of pheomelanin in the white tiger, while a mutation in SLC7A11 found to cause pheomelanin dilution in mice was not found in a survey of cream-coloured dogs. The gene responsible for colour variation within the yellow Labrador remains unidentified, but the variation it causes is formally recognised as part of the normal pigmentation spectrum seen within Labradors. A pattern of incomplete dominance is observed: individuals with two copies of the more active allele (CC) would be the darkest, those with one copy of each (Cc) would be intermediate, and those having two copies of the lower-expressing version (cc) would be the lightest.
The dilute gene in the Labrador Retriever
The American Kennel Club (AKC) and other kennel clubs around the world recognize three coat colours in the Labrador: black, yellow and chocolate. In recent years, other colours have become more prominent in the breed. Breeders refer to these colours as 'silver', 'charcoal' and 'champagne'. These dogs typically have a metallic-looking sheen to the hair. These are conformation disqualifications within the breed. The gene affecting this colour variation in all dog breeds is the recessive 'dilution' (D) locus. It is possible for each of the standard Labrador colour genotypes to be diluted if the dog carries two copies of the recessive dilute allele, dd. Dogs that carry at least one D will not have a diluted coat. If two dogs carrying the Dd genotype are bred, diluted offspring could be produced. Studies have linked the diluted trait to a mutation in the melanophilin (MLPH) gene.
The dilution factor was not originally a visible part of the genetics of Labrador Retrievers, and therefore, controversy surrounds the topic. Information known about the dilution factor's absence from the Labrador suggests that it was introduced into the breed in the United States at some point, probably in the late 1940s or early 1950s, apparently through crossbreeding with a dilute breed such as Weimaraners. Geneticists have maintained that recessive traits can remain hidden for many generations. There is speculation that the dilution gene could have remained hidden in the breed, then began rapidly appearing with the popularity of the chocolate Labrador retrievers in the 1970s and 1980s, due to heavy line breeding intended to produce the chocolate colour. There are many breeders in the United States who specialize in breeding diluted "Labradors". The standard for Labrador Retriever does not include dilution colours, although the American Kennel Club will register purebred Labs that are dilute in colour under their base coat colour of black, yellow or chocolate. The Labrador Retriever Club, Inc. states that there is no silver gene in pure-bred Labrador Retrievers. However, the American Kennel Club has maintained that their registry is based on parentage, not colour. It is widely accepted that breeding for colour alone increases the risk of health issues in the resulting progeny, and thus is considered inappropriate. The Labrador Retriever Club Inc of USA states on its website that it "does not recognize, accept or condone the sale or advertising of any Labrador as a 'silver' Labrador".
Mosaics and other "mis-marks"
At least one example of a Labrador Retriever mosaic for pigmentation has been described. This male dog exhibited random but distinct black and yellow patches throughout his coat. He was the result of a black female heterozygous for yellow (B_Ee) bred to a yellow male (B_ee), and was mated with Labradors of each of the recognised colours. The resulting puppies were all consistent with the inheritance pattern of a yellow Labrador with black pigment. The most probable cause was either a somatic mutation early in development or a fusion between two zygotes that left some cells with genetics capable of producing dark fur, and others including the reproductive cells incapable of doing so.
Other “mis-marks” such as brindling, tan points, white spots, and rings around the tails are not uncommon in Labradors. Each of these conditions have various underlying genetic as well as environmental causes.
- Carol Coode, Labrador Retrievers Today, Howell Book House: New York, 1993.
- Jane B. Reese et al., Campbell Biology, 9th Ed., Benjamin Cummings, Boston, 2011, p. 273.
- Christopher B. Kaelin and Gregory S. Barsh, "Genetics and Pigmentation in Dogs and Cats", Annual Review of Animal Bioscience, 1: 125-156 (2013)
- O. Winge, Inheritance in Dogs with Special Reference to the Hunting Breeds, (Ithaca, NY: Comstock Publishing, 1950)
- C. C. Little, Inheritance of Coat Color in Dogs, (Ithica, NY: Comstock Publishing, 1957)
- Sheila M. Schmuts, Tom G. Berryere and Angela D. Goldfinch, "TYRP1 and MC1R genotypes and their effects on coat color in dogs", Mammalian Genome, 13: 380-387 (2002)
- Templeton, J.; Stewart, A.; Fletcher, W. (1977). "Coat Colour Genetics in the Labrador Retriever". The Journal of Heredity. 68: 134–136.
- J.A. Kerns, M. Oliver, G. Lust and G. S. Barsh, "Exclusion of Melanocortin-1 Receptor (Mc1r) and Agouti as Candidates for Dominant Black in Dogs", Journal of Heredity, 94: 75-79 (2003)
- Lucy Peters; Emily Humble; Nicole Kröcker; Birgit Fuchs; Jaume Forcada; Joseph I. Hoffman (August 2016). "Born blonde: a recessive loss-of-function mutation in the melanocortin 1 receptor is associated with cream coat coloration in Antarctic fur seals". Ecology and Evolution. 6: 5705–5717. doi:10.1002/ece3.2290. PMC 4983585. PMID 27547348.
- Julie A. Kerns; Edward J. Cargill; Leigh Anne Clark; Sophie I. Candille; Tom G. Berryere; Michael Olivier; George Lust; Rory J. Todhunter; Sheila M. Schmutz; Keith E. Murphy; Gregory S. Barsh (July 2007). "Linkage and Segregation Analysis of Black and Brindle Coat Color in Domestic Dogs". Genetics. 176: 1679–1689. doi:10.1534/genetics.107.074237. PMC 1931550. PMID 17483404.
- Sophie I. Candille; Christopher B. Kaelin; Bruce M. Cattanach; Bin Yu; Darren A. Thompson; Matthew A. Nix; Julie A. Kerns; Sheila M. Schmutz; Glenn L. Millhauser; Gregory S. Barsh (November 2007). "A β-Defensin Mutation Causes Black Coat Colour in Domestic Dogs". Science. 318 (5855): 1418–1423. doi:10.1126/science.1147880. PMC 2906624. PMID 17947548.
- Ruvinsky, A., Sampson, J. The Genetics of the Dog, 2001, Wallingford, Oxfordshire, UK, ebook.
- Everts, R.; Rothuizen, J.; van Oost, B (2000). "Identification of a premature stop codon in the melanocyte-stimulating hormone receptor gene (MC1R) in Labrador and Golden retrievers with yellow coat colour". Animal Genetics. 31: 194–199. doi:10.1046/j.1365-2052.2000.00639.x.
- Brockerville, Ryan M.; et al. (2013). ", (2013) "Sequence analysis of three pigmentation genes in the Newfoundland population of Canis latrans links the Golden Retriever Mc1r variant to white coat color in coyotes". Mammalian Genome. 24: 134–141. doi:10.1007/s00335-012-9443-x.CS1 maint: Explicit use of et al. (link)
- E. K. Conant, R. Juras, and E. G. Cothran, (2011) "Incidence of the mask phenotype M264V mutation in Labrador Retrievers", Research in Veterinary Science 91: e98-e99
- Sheila M. Schmutz and Tom G. Berryere, The Genetics of Cream Coat Color in Dogs, Journal of Heredity, 98: 544-548 (2007)
- Xiao Xu, et al., The Genetic Basis of White Tigers, Current Biology, 23: 1031-1035 (2013)
- S. M. Schmutz and T. G. Berryere, Genes affecting coat colour and pattern in domestic dogs: a review, Animal Genetics, 38: 539-549 (2007)
- Coode, C. 1993. Colour Inheritance. Labrador Retrievers Today. Howell Book House, New York. 28-32.
- Philipp, U.; Hamann, H.; Mecklenburg, L.; Nishino, S.; Mignot, E.; Günzel- Apel, A.R.; et al. (2005). "Polymorphisms within the canine MLPH gene are associated with dilute coat color in dogs". BMC Genetics. 6: 34. doi:10.1186/1471-2156-6-34. PMC 1183202. PMID 15960853.CS1 maint: Explicit use of et al. (link)
- Drögemüller, C.; Philipp, U.; Haase, B.; Günzel-Apel, A.R.; Leeb, T. (2007). "A noncoding melanophilin gene (MLPH) SNP at the splice donor of exon 1 represents a candidate causal mutation for coat color dilution in dogs". Journal of Heredity. 98 (5): 468–473. doi:10.1093/jhered/esm021. PMID 17519392.
- Schmutz, S.M.; Berryere, T.G. (2007). "Genes affecting coat colour and pattern in domestic dogs: a review". Animal Genetics. 38: 539–549. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2052.2007.01664.x. PMID 18052939.
- Philipp, U.; Quignon, P.; Scott, A.; André, C.; Breen, M.; Leeb, T. (2005). "Chromosomal assignment of the canine melanophilin gene (MLPH): a candidate gene for coat color dilution in Pinschers". Journal of Heredity. 96 (7): 774–776. doi:10.1093/jhered/esi079.
- Kurtz, K. 2013. Genetic aspects and controversies of coat color inheritance in the Labrador retriever. Animal Science 314, Michigan State University.
- Vanderwyk, Jack 2012. Analysis of the ‘silver’ Labrador population. http://labradornet.com/silverlabsanalysis.html
- "Silver Labradors - The Labrador Retriever Club, Inc". thelabradorclub.com.
- "Silver Labs – More Info - The Labrador Club". labradorclub.org.nz.
- Sponenberg, D. P.; Bigelow, B.J. (1986). "An Extension Locus Mosaic Labrador Retriever Dog". Journal of Heredity. 78: 406.