|The Rising, The Regime, The Rapture, Left Behind, Tribulation Force, Nicolae, Soul Harvest, Apollyon, Assassins, The Indwelling, The Mark, Desecration, The Remnant, Armageddon, Glorious Appearing, Kingdom Come
Jerry B. Jenkins
|Published||1995 – 2007|
|Media type||Print (Hardback & Paperback)|
Left Behind is a series of 16 best-selling religious novels by Tim LaHaye and Jerry B. Jenkins, dealing with Christian dispensationalist End Times: the pretribulation, premillennial, Christian eschatological interpretation of the Biblical apocalypse. The primary conflict of the series is the members of the Tribulation Force, an underground network of converts, against an NWO-esque organization, Global Community, and its leader Nicolae Carpathia—the Antichrist. Left Behind is also the title of the first book in the series. The series was first published between 1995–2007 by Tyndale House, a firm with a history of interest in dispensationalism.
The series has been adapted into four films to date. The original series of three films are Left Behind: The Movie (2000), Left Behind II: Tribulation Force (2002), and Left Behind: World at War (2005). A reboot starring Nicolas Cage, entitled simply Left Behind, was released in 2014 through Cloud Ten Pictures. The series also inspired the PC game Left Behind: Eternal Forces (2006) and its several sequels.
- 1 Plot summary
- 2 Characters
- 3 Response
- 4 Influences on the authors
- 5 Reception
- 6 Books
- 7 Spin-offs
- 8 In other media
- 9 See also
- 10 References
- 11 Further reading
- 12 External links
Based on a dispensationalist interpretation of prophecies in the Biblical books of Revelation, Daniel, Isaiah and Ezekiel, Left Behind tells the story of the end times (set in the contemporary era), in which true believers in Christ have been "raptured" (taken instantly to heaven), leaving the world shattered and chaotic. As people scramble for answers, an obscure Romanian politician named Nicolae Jetty Carpathia rises to become secretary-general of the United Nations, promising to restore peace and stability to all nations. What most of the world does not realize is that Carpathia is actually the Antichrist foretold in the Bible. Coming to grips with the truth and becoming born-again Christians, airline pilot Rayford Steele, his daughter Chloe, their pastor Bruce Barnes, and young journalist Cameron "Buck" Williams begin their quest as the Tribulation Force to help save the lost and prepare for the coming Tribulation, in which God will rain down judgment on the world for seven years.
The Tribulation Force are a group of underground post-Rapture Christian converts. Throughout the series, they are in conflict with the Antichrist Nicolae Carpathia during the Tribulation, each in accordance with his or her own divinely-determined destiny.
The most well known of the Tribulation Force include Rayford Steele, Chloe Steele, Cameron "Buck" Williams, Tsion Ben-Judah, and Bruce Barnes (Deceased) 
Multiple books in the series have been on the New York Times best-seller list. Starting in 2000, Books 7 and 8 reached number one on the list followed by book 10, which debuted at number one. Total sales for the series have surpassed 80 million copies. Seven titles in the adult series have reached #1 on the bestseller lists for the New York Times, USA Today, and Publishers Weekly.
One reason often cited for the books' popularity is the quick pacing and action, and reflects the public's overall concern and fascination with the Apocalypse as portrayed in the Biblical Book of Revelation. Michelle Goldberg has written that, "On one level, the attraction of the Left Behind books isn't that much different from that of, say, Tom Clancy or Stephen King. The plotting is brisk and the characterizations Manichean. People disappear and things blow up." The New York Times also compared the series to Clancy's works. However, those views are not universally shared. Other reviewers have called the series "almost laughably tedious" and "fatuous and boring."
In 2007, the Evangelical Christian Publishers Association (ECPA) recognized the Left Behind series at its CBA & ECPA Awards Celebration in Atlanta, Georgia with the ECPA Pinnacle Award. ECPA President Mark Kuyper said, "In many ways this series established Christian fiction as a significant category in publishing in general." Jerry Falwell said about the first book in the series: "In terms of its impact on Christianity, it's probably greater than that of any other book in modern times, outside the Bible."
Laurie Goodstein, writing in 1998 for The New York Times, placed what she called the ""Left Behind" phenomenon" in the calendrical context of the approaching year 2000. Goodstein noted a 'proliferation' of similarly apocalyptic texts appearing at that time, by authors such as Jim Bakker and John Hagee. Goodstein cited the opinion of University of Wisconsin historian Paul Boyer who described such authors as "cashing in on the public preoccupation with the year 2000".
LaHaye and Jenkins cite the influence of Russell Doughten, an Iowa-based filmmaker who directed the Thief in the Night series, a series of four low-budget but popular feature-length films in the 1970s and 80s about the Rapture and Second Coming, starting with 1972's A Thief in the Night. Indeed, the title Left Behind echoes the refrain of Thief's early Christian rock theme song by Larry Norman, "I Wish We'd All Been Ready," in which he sings, "There's no time to change your mind, the son has come and you've been left behind."
While writing that the series fulfills the norms of mass-market fiction, as mentioned above, magazine writer Michelle Goldberg characterized the books as an attack on Judaism and liberal secularism, and suggested that the near-future "end times" in which the books are set seem to reflect the actual worldview of millions of Americans, including many prominent conservative leaders.
The books are written from a Protestant viewpoint. As a result, some believe the books are anti-Catholic, noting that many Catholics were not raptured concluding that no religion is free of false converts and that the new pope establishes a false religion. While the fictional Pope, John XXIV, was raptured, he is described as having embraced some of the views of the "Father of Protestantism" Martin Luther and it is implied that he was raptured for this reason. His successor, Pope Peter II, becomes Pontifex Maximus of Enigma Babylon One World Faith, an amalgam of all remaining world faiths and religions. Catholic Answers describes the series as anti-Catholic.
The co-author of the book, Jerry B. Jenkins, as well as LaHaye, stated that their books are not anti-Catholic and that they have many faithful Catholic readers and friends. According to LaHaye, "the books don’t suggest any particular theology, but try to introduce people to a more personal relationship with Jesus."
David Carlson, a Professor of Religious Studies and a member of the Greek Orthodox Church, wrote that the theology underpinning the Left Behind series promotes a "skewed view of the Christian faith that welcomes war and disaster, while dismissing peace efforts in the Middle East and elsewhere--all in the name of Christ".
This section is empty. You can help by adding to it. (March 2016)
Some premillennialists, while accepting many of the basic beliefs behind the series, describe problems with specific prophetical teachings in the Left Behind books. For instance, in The Mark, Chang Wong receives both the mark of the beast and the sealing of the Lord and he is later accepted into heaven, despite having the mark, because he was drugged and forced to have it against his own free will. This has led some readers to wonder how a Christian can have the mark of the beast and still be saved.
Along with some other rapture fiction novels, the Left Behind series demonstrates a specific understanding of the Gospel and the Christian life, one with which many have taken issue theologically. The books have not sold particularly well outside of the United States. Dispensationalism remains a minority view among theologians. For instance, amillennial and postmillennial Christians do not believe in the same timeline of the Second Coming as premillennialists, while preterist Christians do not interpret much of the Book of Revelation to predict future events at all. Brian McLaren of the Emergent Church compares the Left Behind series to The Da Vinci Code, and states, "What the Left Behind novels do, the way they twist scripture toward a certain theological and political end, I think [Dan] Brown is twisting scripture, just to other political ends." John Dart, writing in Christian Century, characterized the works as "beam me up theology."
Some practicing Christians, evangelical and otherwise, along with non-Christians have shown concern that the social perspectives promoted in the Left Behind series unduly sensationalize the death and destruction of masses of people. Harvey Cox, a professor of divinity at Harvard, says part of the appeal of the books lies in the "lip-licking anticipation of all the blood," and theologian Barbara Rossing, author of The Rapture Exposed: The Message of Hope in the Book of Revelation, said the books glorify violence. Time magazine said "the nuclear frights of, say, Tom Clancy's The Sum of All Fears wouldn't fill a chapter in the Left Behind series. (Large chunks of several U.S. cities have been bombed to smithereens by page 110 of Book 3.)"
Paul Nuechterlein accused the authors of re-sacralizing violence, adding that "we human beings are the ones who put our faith in superior firepower. But in the Left Behind novels the darkness of that human, satanic violence is once again attributed to God." In that same book ("Glorious Appearing") Jesus merely speaks and the bodies of his enemies are ripped open, forcing the Christians to drive carefully to avoid "hitting splayed and filleted bodies of men and women and horses."
Note: The books are listed initially in story-line (chronological) order but then numbered in order of publication.
|Chron Seq.||Pub Seq.||Title (with subtitle)||Pub Date|
|1||13||The Rising: Antichrist is Born: Before They Were Left Behind||2005|
|2||14||The Regime: Evil Advances: Before They Were Left Behind #2||2005|
|3||15||The Rapture: In the Twinkling of an Eye: Countdown to Earth's Last Days #3||2006|
|4||1||Left Behind: A Novel of the Earth's Last Days||1995|
|5||2||Tribulation Force: The Continuing Drama of Those Left Behind||1996|
|6||3||Nicolae: The Rise of Antichrist||1997|
|7||4||Soul Harvest: The World Takes Sides||1999|
|8||5||Apollyon: The Destroyer Is Unleashed||1999|
|9||6||Assassins: Assignment: Jerusalem, Target: Antichrist||1999|
|10||7||The Indwelling: The Beast Takes Possession||2000|
|11||8||The Mark: The Beast Rules the World||2000|
|12||9||Desecration: Antichrist Takes the Throne||2001|
|13||10||The Remnant: On the Brink of Armageddon||2002|
|14||11||Armageddon: The Cosmic Battle of the Ages||2003|
|15||12||Glorious Appearing: The End of Days||2004|
|16||16||Kingdom Come: The Final Victory||2007|
There are also graphic novels, CDs, a Left Behind series for teens, and movies. Audio dramatizations based on the first twelve titles have also been produced for broadcast on Christian radio. The series written for teens, called Left Behind: The Kids, has the same plot as the adult series, but the main protagonists are teenagers. Several of the main books have also been turned into movies by the Canadian motion picture studio Cloud Ten Pictures; the film titles include: Left Behind: The Movie (2000), Left Behind II: Tribulation Force (2002), and Left Behind: World at War (2005).
- Apocalypse Dawn
- Apocalypse Crucible
- Apocalypse Burning
- Apocalypse Unleashed
Left Behind: The Kids by Jerry B. Jenkins & Tim LaHaye with Chris Fabry
- 1 The Vanishings
- 2 Second Chance
- 3 Through The Flames
- 4 Facing The Future
- 5 Nicolae High
- 6 The Underground
- 7 Busted!
- 8 Death Strike
- 9 The Search
- 10 On The Run
- 11 Into The Storm
- 12 Earthquake!
- 13 The Showdown
- 14 Judgment Day
- 15 Battling The Commander
- 16 Fire From Heaven
- 17 Terror In The Stadium
- 18 Darkening Skies
- 19 Attack Of Apollyon
- 20 A Dangerous Plan
- 21 Secrets Of New Babylon
- 22 Escape From New Babylon
- 23 Horsemen Of Terror
- 24 Uplink From The Underground
- 25 Death At The Gala
- 26 The Beast Arises
- 27 Wildfire!
- 28 The Mark Of The Beast
- 29 Breakout!
- 30 Murder In The Holy Place
- 31 Escape To Masada
- 32 War Of The Dragon
- 33 Attack On Petra
- 34 Bounty Hunters
- 35 The Rise Of False Messiahs
- 36 Ominous Choices
- 37 Heat Wave
- 38 The Perils Of Love
- 39 The Road To War
- 40 Triumphant Return
- End of State
- Impeachable Offense
- Necessary Evils
In other media
The success of the Left Behind books has led to the release of four motion pictures based on the series so far. All four have been produced by brothers Paul & Peter LaLonde, and have been released through Cloud Ten Pictures, an independent Canadian-based Christian movie studio.
The first, Left Behind: The Movie, was based on the first book of the series and was released in 2000. In a very unusual marketing scheme, the studio released the movie on home video, and then released it to the theaters. The movie fared poorly in theaters. The movie starred former Growing Pains star Kirk Cameron as Buck Williams. Cameron, who praised the book series as "inspiring", is a practicing evangelist (and co-host with Ray Comfort on the TV show The Way of the Master).
The sequel, Left Behind II: Tribulation Force, based on the second book, Tribulation Force, was released in 2002. The film debuted at #2 on Nielson's video scan reports, behind Spider-Man (2002), and was #1 in terms of overall sales for two days on Amazon.com.
The second sequel, Left Behind: World at War, was released first to churches on October 21, 2005 for church theatrical viewings and was released to DVD and video on October 25, 2005. Much of the main cast from the previous two films, excluding Clarence Gilyard, reprised their respective roles for Left Behind: World At War. Gilyard, who played Bruce Barnes, was unable to return for the third movie due to a scheduling conflict with a play in New York. The movie is based very loosely on the final 50 pages of Tribulation Force and features Louis Gossett Jr. as the President of the United States, Gerald Fitzhugh. The third movie was the least identifiable with events in any of the books. Recognizable events were the marriages of Buck with Chloe Steele, and of Rayford Steele with Amanda White; the death of Bruce Barnes; and President Fitzhugh's heading an attack, resulting in World War III, with Great Britain and Egypt fighting against the Global Community. Major parts of the movie, however, were taken from subsequent books in the series. These events include the poisoning of Barnes by GC forces, instead of Nicolae Carpathia himself, and an attempt by Fitzhugh to assassinate Nicolae Carpathia. Buck's meeting with the President in the books makes it into the movie, but in a totally different form.
The movies have been criticized for, among other things, low production values. A Slate reviewer[who?] commented that in 2004, Cloud Ten Pictures made a deal with Sony Entertainment to release all of its pictures under the Sony banner and has been doing so ever since.
In 2010, Cloud Ten Pictures announced that a remake of the Left Behind series was in development, with production set to begin in late 2012 for an October 2014 release date. The movie, starring Nicolas Cage as Steele and Chad Michael Murray as Buck Williams, was released to theaters October 3, 2014. It earned overwhelmingly negative reviews and flopped at the box office.
The video game Left Behind: Eternal Forces (2006) and its three sequels, Left Behind: Tribulation Forces, Left Behind 3: Rise of the Antichrist, and Left Behind 4: World at War, were developed by a publicly traded company, Left Behind Games. The games are real-time strategy games wherein the player controls a "Tribulation Forces" team and allows the player to "use the power of prayer to strengthen your troops in combat and wield modern military weaponry throughout the game world." The original game was released in the United States on November 14, 2006, and received mixed reviews. Distribution was initially planned to work through churches and megachurches.
Although the original game was accused of encouraging religious violence, not all reviewers of the game or critics of the Left Behind series shared that view. Representatives of the company have responded that the game's message is pacifist, because shooting nonbelievers instead of converting them costs the player "spirit points", which can be recovered by pausing to pray. The company also responded to these criticisms in an online newsletter, stating, "There is no violence, only conflict," and, "The most successful way to fight, is through the means of spiritual warfare; PRAYER and WORSHIP. Soldiers and military weaponry are available, but once anyone plays the game, they’ll see how difficult it is to succeed by using these less effective means of warfare."
|People Get Ready|
|Soundtrack album by Various artists|
|Released||November 17, 1998|
People Get Ready: A Musical Collection Inspired by The Left Behind Series (1998) is "a musical collection inspired by the Left Behind series".
- "People Get Ready" Crystal Lewis 4:24
- "UFO" Geoff Moore & The Distance 3:08
- "Come Quickly Lord" Rebecca Saint James 4:29
- "I Wish We'd All Been Ready" dc Talk 3:44
- "Horses" Margaret Becker 4:05
- "Eve of Destruction" Barry McGuire 3:34
- "People Get Ready" Impressions 2:38
- "Thief in the Night" Big Tent Revival 3:38
- "Elijah" Rich Mullins 5:14
- "New Body" Audio Adrenaline 4:00
- "I'll Lead You Home" Michael W. Smith 5:22
- "Jesus Is Waiting" Al Green 8:08
Williams professor Glenn Shuck has written the book Marks of the Beast: The Left Behind Novels and the Struggle for Evangelical Identity, published by NYU Press in 2005. He followed this with a collection of original essays co-edited with Jeffrey J. Kripal of Rice University on the Esalen Institute in California, published by Indiana University Press in 2005.
Robert M. Price has written the book The Paperback Apocalypse published by Prometheus Books in 2007 which reviewed the whole genre of apocalypse fiction.
In 2002 a series of graphic novels published by Tyndale House was launched that comprised the first two books in the series, Left Behind and Tribulation Force. The original idea was to release sets of 3 to 5 novels (each about 45–50 pages) for each book in the original series. However, after the 5th and final novel for Tribulation Force was released, the graphic novel series was apparently discontinued, and the novels that were released are now (as of December 2006) out of print. A compilation of the graphic novels for the first book was later released as one novel.
- "Watch Nicolas Cage in the Left Behind Trailer". Vulture. 30 May 2014. Retrieved 4 October 2014.
- "Left Behind official website". Retrieved 14 May 2014.
- "Official Website of the Left Behind Series". Leftbehind.com. Retrieved September 8, 2007.
- "New York Times Bestsellers". New York Times. June 11, 2000.
- Left Behind http://leftbehind.com/05_news/tim-lahaye-passes-at-90.asp. Retrieved May 11, 2018. Missing or empty
- Goldberg, Michelle (July 29, 2002). "Fundamentally unsound". Salon. Archived from the original on December 14, 2007.
- LaHaye, Tim; Jenkins, Jerry B.; Swanson, Sandi (2005). The Authorized Left Behind Handbook. Tyndale House Publishers. p. 336.
- Dreyfuss, Robert Dreyfuss (January 28, 2004). "Reverend Doomsday: According to Tim LaHaye, the Apocalypse is now". Rolling Stone. Archived from the original on 2007-08-06.
- Haber, Gordon Haber (August 23, 2004). "The Ministry of Fear". New York Sun.
- "Tim and Beverly LaHaye". TIME. Archived from the original on 2005-02-03. Retrieved September 8, 2007.
- Goodstein, Laurie (October 4, 1998). "Fast-Selling Thrillers Depict Prophetic View of Final Days". The New York Times.
- Dean A. Anderson, The original "Left Behind", Christianity Today, Published 7 March 2012, Retrieved 13 March 2012.
- "Salon.com: Fundamentally unsound". Retrieved 4 October 2014.
- Catholic.com – No Rapture for Rome Archived July 6, 2007, at the Wayback Machine.
- 'Left Behind' authors begin tour of the South, The Associated Press via USA Today, 2004-03-31.
- Writing the Rapture: Prophecy Fiction in Evangelical America, Crawford Gribben, Oxford University Press, 2009.
- Akin, Jimmy (2008). "Catholic Answers Special Report: False Profit: Money, Prejudice, and Bad Theology in Tim LaHaye's Left Behind Series". Archived from the original on 2008-07-11.
- "Tim LaHaye: The Left Behind Series". Catholic League. Archived from the original on June 29, 2007. Retrieved 2007-12-31.
When a reader complained online that Tribulation Force was anti-Catholic, Left Behind co-author Jerry B. Jenkins vehemently insisted that the books are “not anti-Catholic” and that “almost every person in the book who was left behind was Protestant. Astute readers will understand where we’re coming from. True believers in Christ, regardless of their church ‘brand’ will be raptured” (Amazon.com, August 26, 1999). LaHaye responded by insisting that “our books are not anti-Catholic. In fact, we have many faithful Catholic readers and friends” (Religion News Service, June 26, 2003). The books don’t suggest any particular theology, he said, but try to introduce people to a more personal relationship with Jesus.”
- "Left Behind" and the Corruption of Biblical Interpretation".
- "Tim & Beverly LaHaye: General Teachings/Activities". Retrieved 4 October 2014.
- "LeftBehind.com – General FAQs". Retrieved 4 October 2014.
- Boston, Rob (February 2002). "If Best-Selling End-Times Author Tim LaHaye Has His Way, Church-State Separation Will Be... Left Behind". Americans United for Separation of Church and State. Archived from the original on 2011-11-18. Retrieved 1 April 2015.
- Dart, John (September 25, 2002). "'Beam me up' theology—The Debate Over 'Left Behind'". Christian Century Foundation. Archived from the original on 2013-10-09.
- McLaren, Brian. "Brian McLaren on the Da Vinci Code". Grace Fellowship. Sojourners Magazine.
- Barbara R. Rossing (1 March 2007). The Rapture Exposed. Basic Books. ISBN 978-0-465-00496-6.
- John Cloud and Rancho Mirage. "Meet the Prophet". Time. June 23, 2002.
- John W. Whitehead. "God So Loved the World that He Gave Us World War III". OldSpeak. July 1, 2004.
- "Re-Sacralizing Violence in the Left Behind Books". May 18, 2004.
- Nicholas D. Kristof. "Jesus and Jihad". New York Times. July 17, 2004.
- "(All Libraries)". Retrieved 4 October 2014.
- "(All Libraries)". Retrieved 4 October 2014.
- "Audio". LeftBehind.com. p. Products.
- "Left Behind: Military Series". Retrieved 4 October 2014.
- "Left Behind: Political Series". Retrieved 4 October 2014.
- "Imdb.com: Left Behind (2000) – Box-office/Business". IMDb. Retrieved 4 October 2014.
- clarionledger.com: Audition for TV role or be 'Left Behind' Archived 2001-07-01 at Archive.is
- "End-Times Thriller Left Behind II: Tribulation Force Ousts Spider-Man Over the Weekend to Become the #1 Selling Video Overall on Amazon.com". Manta. Retrieved 4 October 2014.
- "Cloud Ten Plans Big Budget Left Behind Remake" (PDF). October 13, 2010. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2011-10-27. Retrieved 18 January 2015.
- "Left Behind". Retrieved 4 October 2014.
- "Critics blast 'Left Behind'". USA Today. December 14, 2006. Retrieved May 7, 2010.
- "Left Behind: Eternal Forces – The Video Game". Adl.org. Archived from the original on 2012-03-07.
- "Left Behind: Eternal Forces Review". IGN.
- "Reviews: Games: Left Behind: Eternal Forces". Artstechnica. p. 1.
- "Left Behind: Eternal Forces Review". GameSpy.
- Lelchuk, Ilene (January 9, 2011). "'Convert or die' game divides Christians / Some ask Wal-Mart to drop Left Behind". The San Francisco Chronicle.
- "LB Games – Newsletter".
- People Get Ready (November 17, 1998). People Get Ready: A Musical Collection Inspired by The Left Behind Series (Enhanced Audio CD ed.). Forefront. ASIN B00000DMGR.
- DeMar, Gary, Left Behind: Separating Fact from Fiction. Powder Springs, Georgia, 2009. ISBN 0-915815-38-9
- Eford, James M. Left Behind? What the Bible Really Says about the End Times. Macon, Georgia, Smyth & Helys, 2006. ISBN 1-57312-461-3
- Forbes, Bruce David and Jeanne Halgren Kilde (eds.), Rapture, Revelation, and the End Times: Exploring the Left Behind Series. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2004. ISBN 1-4039-6525-0
- Frykholm, Amy Johnson. Rapture Culture: Left Behind in Evangelical America. Oxford University Press, 2004. ISBN 0-19-515983-7
- Monahan, Torin. (2008). "Marketing the Beast: Left Behind and the Apocalypse Industry" (pdf). Media, Culture, & Society. 30 (6): 813–830. doi:10.1177/0163443708096095.
- Olson, Carl E. Will Catholics be Left Behind? San Francisco, Ignatius Press, 2003. ISBN 0-898709-50-4
- Standaert, Michael, 2006 Skipping Towards Armageddon: The Politics and Propaganda of the Left Behind Novels and the LaHaye Empire (Soft Skull Press)
- Reed, David A., LEFT BEHIND Answered Verse by Verse. Morrisville, NC: Lulu.com, 2008. ISBN 1-4357-0873-3
- Rossing, Barbara R., The Rapture Exposed: The Message of Hope in the Book of Revelation, New York: Basic Books, 2004. ISBN 0-8133-4314-3
- Shuck, Glenn W.. Marks Of The Beast: The Left Behind Novels And The Struggle For Evangelical Identity. New York University Press, 2004. ISBN 0-8147-4005-7
- Gribben, Crawford, Rapture Fiction and the Evangelical Crisis. Evangelical Press, 2006. ISBN 0-85234-610-7.
- Snow Flesher, LeAnn,Left Behind? The Facts Behind the Fiction. Valley Forge, Judson Press, 2006. ISBN 0-8170-1490-X
- Tuley, Glenn, Not Left Behind: A Tribulation Survival Manual. Bedford, TX, Burkhart Books, 2015. ISBN 978-1-940359-25-0
- Official website
- Archive of Left Behind radio shows in RealAudio
- WELS Topical Q&A: Left Behind Series (a Confessional Lutheran perspective)
- Slacktivist blog analysis and critique of Left Behind