Lego clone

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
For Lego Clone Wars-related subjects, see Lego Star Wars.
Mega Bloks building block (above) and Lego building brick (below)
Best-Lock and Lego-bricks compared. From left, Best-Lock followed by Lego repeated.

A Lego clone is a line or brand of children's construction blocks which is mechanically compatible with Lego brand blocks, but is produced by another manufacturer. The blocks were originally patented by The Lego Group in 1961 as "toy building bricks",[1] and the company has since remained dominant in this market. Some competitors have moved to take advantage of Lego brand recognition by advertising their own products as compatible with Lego, with statements such as "compatible with leading building bricks".[citation needed]

While the legal status of providing compatibility with Lego brand blocks is unclear, the underlying patents of invention are long expired, opening the field to rivals. Shortages of Lego's own branded product, such as after the release of 2014's The Lego Movie, have encouraged independent retailers to stock compatible rival products.[2]

Legal challenges[edit]

At least two of the largest clone manufacturers have been challenged in court by Lego. The lawsuits have been mostly unsuccessful, for courts have generally found the functional design of the basic brick to be a matter of patent rather than trademark law, and all relevant Lego patents have expired.

The Canadian company Mega Bloks was sued on the grounds that its use of the "studs and tubes" interlocking brick system was a violation of trademarks held by Lego. On November 17, 2005, the Supreme Court of Canada upheld Mega Bloks' right to continue selling the product in Canada.[3] A similar decision was reached by the European Union's Court of First Instance on November 12, 2008, upholding an EU regulatory agency's reversal of opinion following an objection by Mega Bloks against a trademark awarded to Lego in 1999.[4] On September 14, 2010, the European Court of Justice ruled that the 8-peg design of the original Lego brick "merely performs a technical function [and] cannot be registered as a trademark." [5]

The English company Best-Lock Construction Toys sued Lego in German courts in 2004 [6] and 2009.[7] The German Federal Court denied Lego trademark protection for the shape of its bricks in the latter case.[8]

The Lego Group did score a success in 2002, when its Swiss subsidiary Interlego AG sued the Tianjin CoCo Toy Co., Ltd. company for copyright infringement. A claims court found many CoCo bricks to be infringing; CoCo was ordered to cease manufacture of the infringing bricks, publish a formal apology in the Beijing Daily, and pay a small fee in damages to Interlego. On appeal, the Beijing High People's Court upheld the trial court's ruling.[9]

Major clone manufacturers[edit]

Brand Based in Lego compatible Misc.
Ausini China yes
BanBao China partial Recently won a lawsuit brought by the Lego Group, due to differentiation of its commercial offerings from the Lego Group's. Their blocks connect to Lego's, but they are not 100% compatible. Both their bricks and plates are thicker than their comparable Lego versions. BanBao's connecting studs are taller as well, thus causing gaps when you connect them to Lego pieces.
Best-Lock England yes
Brictek Quebec, Canada yes Founded 2012. Offers various sets, such as trains, at approximately 3/4 the cost of the name-brand product.[10]
Built to Rule ? yes From Hasbro, based upon existing toys and characters from the Hasbro brand, such as G.I. Joe and Transformers.
Cobi Poland ? Continues to be marketed independently since merging with Best-Lock in 2006.
Character Options UK yes They produce products in several ranges including Doctor Who, HM Armed Forces, Deadly 60, Ben 10, and others.
CoCo China ? Produced by Tianjin COKO Toy Co., Ltd. until 2002.
Cogo China yes Produced by Shantou Little White Dragon Toy Industry Co., Ltd./Loongon Toy Industry Co., Ltd. Appear similar to Lego bricks and Lego sets.[11]
Enlighten Brick China yes Produced by Concord Toys International Ltd.
K'nex US partial Large engineering-themed toy producer, mainly non compatible girder-based elements, but some sets feature Lego-compatible studs. K'nex bricks have holes in them.
Kre-O ? yes Produced by Hasbro, and released six years after the end of the "Built to Rule" line. Sets come with Minifigure-like characters called Kreons.
Laser Pegs US ? They are "The Original Lighted Construction Set" with the main distinguishing factor being that it lights up.
Lite Brix US ? They are in patent a dispute with Laser Pegs over similar technology.
Mega Bloks Canada yes The Lego Group's closest competitor, with a large product line, a leading presence in preschool construction toys, major third-party licenses such as World of Warcraft, Need for Speed, Halo, Call of Duty, Smurfs, Skylanders, Barbie and Hello Kitty, and a presence in mainstream toy outlets.[12]
Nintendo Japan yes Manufactured Nintendo Block (later rebranded N&B Block) starting in 1968, notable for featuring curved blocks before Lego offered them in Japan. N&B ceased production in the early 1970s.
Oxford South Korea ? Distributed in the West by Hasbro under the Kre-O brand.
Rokenbok US ?
Sluban China ? Their sets are largely clones of Oxford sets.
Star Diamond China ? Their sets are clones of Lego sets.
Tyco Super Blocks US partial Tyco Super Blocks was a short-lived building system by Tyco Toys (now a division of Mattel) that was released in 1985. Magazine advertisements which ran at the time stated: 'Tyco Super Blocks look and feel like Lego blocks. And they work together, too. Tyco just costs much less. So, if you can't tell the difference, why pay the difference?' Here is the difference: Tyco Super Blocks standard bricks are identical in size to Lego bricks. However, Tyco Super Blocks use a 2:1 size ratio between their plates and bricks (2 plates stacked together = 1 brick) as opposed to Lego's 3:1 ratio (3 plates stacked = 1 brick). In addition to the thickness difference between their comparable plates, Tyco also opted to make their slope pieces taller than Lego standard. Hence, in the battle of cost vs. compatibility, it would seem Tyco's compatibility came up short because they were too tall.
Super Blox US ? A brand of the CRA-Z-ART company.

References[edit]

  1. ^ US patent 3005282, Christiansen, Godtfred Kirk, "Toy Building Brick", issued 1961-10-24, assigned to Interlego A.G. 
  2. ^ "Lego shortage leaves independent stores with empty shelves". CBC News. 15 December 2014. 
  3. ^ "2005 SCC 65". CanLII. Retrieved 2015-03-09. 
  4. ^ "Lego loses trademark ruling in EU". Nytimes.com. October 12, 2008 
  5. ^ [1][dead link]
  6. ^ [2][dead link]
  7. ^ von RA Dennis Breuer (2012-04-19). "Pressemitteilung des BGH Nr. 158/2009: Legostein als Marke gelöscht | markenmagazin:recht". Markenmagazin.de. Retrieved 2012-10-09. 
  8. ^ "Pressemitteilung Nr. 147/04 vom 3.12.2004". Juris.bundesgerichtshof.de. Retrieved 2015-03-09. 
  9. ^ "News". Ccpit-patent.com.cn. Retrieved 2012-10-09. 
  10. ^ "Canadian company Brictek thrives amid Lego shortage". Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. 16 December 2014. 
  11. ^ "广东小白龙玩具实业有限公司". Cogoblocks.com. Retrieved 2015-03-09. 
  12. ^ "Home". Mega Bloks. Retrieved 2015-03-09.