Lie with Me
|Lie with Me|
|Directed by||Clément Virgo|
|Produced by||Damon D'Oliveira
|Written by||Tamara Faith Berger (novel and screenplay)
Clément Virgo (screenplay)
|Starring||Lauren Lee Smith
|Music by||Byron Wong|
|Edited by||Susan Maggi|
|September 10, 2005|
|Budget||CAD 2,200,000 (estimated)|
Lie with Me is a Canadian drama film with graphic sexual content that played at the 2005 Toronto International Film Festival. It is based on the novel of the same name by Tamara Berger. The film features Lauren Lee Smith and Eric Balfour. An outgoing, sexually aggressive young woman meets and begins a torrid affair with an equally aggressive young man in which their affair begins to bring a strain on their personal lives. The backdrop of a very hot summer in the city adds to the steamy nature of the relationship.
Included in the soundtrack is music by Broken Social Scene.
The camera slowly zooms out on a young woman masturbating to a porn tape. She gets up abruptly and goes out to a party, looking for sex. Leila has learned she has some power over men with sex but feels a part of her is still untouched, holding back, despite her assertiveness. Before she can choose a partner for the night she is corraled by David, into a bathroom, while his girlfriend calls through the door. She leaves, but keeps her eye on David as she picks up a shy guy, with whom she has sex against a fence outside as David watches from his car while his girlfriend fellates him. Leila is in complete control of her encounter while David remains completely passive.
He next sees her walking down the street, and follows her. She smiles but does not speak to him and breaks into a run, leading him to a playground. They crouch inside a small tunnel and watch each other as she begins to touch herself. But this time he leaves.
Leila visits her parents and learns that her mother is leaving her father and selling her childhood home. Her father is devastated, staying stoned on pot and refusing to do anything while her mother clears out the house. Leila's best friend, Victoria, is getting ready to be married, but confesses that she's had sex with an old boyfriend recently, despite her insistence that she loves her fiance and is ready to settle down. Leila is sceptical but supportive, and Victoria laughs when she turns on the VCR and discovers the porn tape Leila was watching; Leila tells her nothing about David.
When Leila sees David again they finally speak to each other, and he takes her home, where they have sex. He asks Leila if she will go out with him on a real date, giving her his number when she leaves.
They finally do go out, and begin a real romance. She meets his father, who is physically fragile but very funny, teasing her about having sex and making noise in their apartment. David cares very tenderly for the old man, who is charmingly brusque. Leila is still skittish, although she is not intimidated when David's old girlfriend confronts her at her job, warning her that David has intimacy issues. When they go back to the club again, Leila dances suggestively with a couple of men while watching David's reaction, and he is hurt and angry when they return to his place. She brushes off his fears when he confesses that he thinks of nothing but her, that he needs her, but she acts like it's all a game. He begs to her to promise that she won't leave him, and she does, but doesn't believe it herself.
When David finds his father dead he turns to her for consolation but she doesn't know how to comfort him. This leads to conflict and ends with him telling her to leave and going back to his ex-girlfriend. But he soon tells her to leave, knowing she isn't really who he wants. However, he is unable to find Leila again as he knows nothing about her except for her first name. Leila finds her sexual world more and more unsatisfying and becomes increasingly frustrated. She picks up the shy guy again, but strikes at him in anger when he is unable to follow her peremptory commands, and she throws him out of her apartment in disgust.
Leila spends time with her parents as they go their separate ways, and gets ready for the wedding while the summer is coming to an end. As she rides her bicycle to the ceremony David sees her and follows in his truck. He waits outside the synagogue and approaches her as everyone floods out onto the sidewalk following the wedding, and then Victoria grabs Leila's hand and she calls out to David, to ask if he's coming. At the reception David watches Leila dance with an old man, but she runs away again when he approaches her. This time he follows her all the way home, and all the way inside, telling her he won't leave her again.
- Lauren Lee Smith as Leila
- Eric Balfour as David
- Polly Shannon as Victoria
- Mayko Nguyen as Kika
- Michael Facciolo as Shy Guy
- Kate Lynch as Marla
- Ron White as Ben
- Kristin Lehman as Rachel
- Don Francks as Joshua
- Richard Chevolleau as Vigorous
- Frank Chiesurin as Joel
- Nicola Lipman as Rabbi
- Theresa Tova as Russian Wedding Singer
- John Paul Buccat as the Hooker
Lie with Me has 5.5 stars out of 10 on IMDb's website, but only a 38% "Rotten" rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Writing for Variety, Leslie Felperin says that "Barry Stone's lensing, favoring a soft, Northern-climes afternoon light for the sex scenes in particular, looks dreamy throughout", but that "with its drawn-out last act and sentimental ending, [this] pic is a long way from being the Gen-Y "Last Tango in Paris" it would like to think it is." Ron Mashate, writing for the now-defunct Stylus, concurred in part: "Similar to Virgo’s well-received Rude (1995), Lie with Me is about capturing a distinctive mood. In a 2005 interview with NOW Magazine, Virgo explains his intentions with respect to the later film:
- 'When I read the book, it wasn't about the story, it was about this feeling that the book conjured up in me, this kind of visceral, raw energy, that was like what I felt when I first fell in love, that sexual aspect of falling in love. That was the challenge of it for me, to take a plot-driven narrative and capture an emotion.'
It’s certainly the case that Virgo skimped on the narrative in favor of the mood. At times, the film comes off inert and aimless, absent of an apparent conflict. The Bee Hives version of Lover’s Spit asserts itself, representing Virgo’s telos: sinuousness, elegiac, inaccessible. And if Woody Allen writes love letters to New York, Virgo is attempting the epistletory equivalent with Toronto."
- Felperin, Leslie (October 12, 2005). "Lie With Me". Variety. Los Angeles, CA: RBI. p. 1. Retrieved 30 July 2012.
- Mashate, Rob (May 8, 2006). "Lie With Me". Stylus. USA: stylusmagazine.com. p. 1. Retrieved 30 July 2012.