Cover art by John Foxx
|Studio album by Porcupine Tree|
|Released||22 May 2000|
|Recorded||Foel Studio/No Man's Land
Nov. 1999 – January 2000
|Genre||Progressive rock, alternative rock|
|Porcupine Tree chronology|
|Singles from Lightbulb Sun|
This album, along with their prior album Stupid Dream, are considered to have a more commercial, poppier sound, opposed to the abstract instrumental sound of their prior albums, or the heavier metal sound in their subsequent albums of the 2000s. The album is divided into two parts between "Rest Will Flow" and "Hatesong". The first part concentrates more on melodic, pop elements of Porcupine Tree's style, while the second has a more experimental character.
Writing and recording
Frontman Steven Wilson remarked that album was "The quickest album we ever made (in 3 months flat)" and yet still "our best work to date", and was released a mere 14 months after their previous album, Stupid Dream. Lyrically, Wilson had tired of writing about abstract concepts like war or religion, and felt he had the confidence to write more personal and emotional lyrics, leading to some especially negative lyrics being displayed in tracks such as "Hatesong" and "Feel So Low".
Musically, Wilson stated he wanted to bring back some of the experimental aspects they had moved away from on Stupid Dream, stating "Richard [Barbieri] and I worked on creating some unique keyboard sounds for the album – e.g. the 'fairground' on 'How is Your Life Today?' and the 'insects' at the end of 'Russia On Ice'". He also spoke of the influence of metal music on the album, stating, "... part of the beauty of the guitar solo on 'Where We Would Be' comes from the fact that it was played relatively straight but then fed through so many distortion and lo-fi processes that it began to fizz and disintegrate. The riffing guitars on 'Russia On Ice' are pure metal and one of the solos of 'Hatesong' I call my 'Korn solo' on account of the fact that the bottom strings on the guitar are tuned down so low that the notes can be bent several tones". Conversely, the band added more unconventional instruments to the compositions as well, such as the banjo, hammered dulcimers, and more string sections. String sections in Lightbulb Sun were arranged and produced by Dave Gregory from alternative rock band XTC at Christchurch Studios, Clifton, Bristol in January 2000, recorded by John Waterhouse.
Wilson describes the album as more organic sounding than his previous albums, stating that, "In a song like 'Winding Shot' [the name for the first half of the track 'Last Chance to Evacuate Planet Earth ...'] there are shades of Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young and Nick Drake, although the end result is hopefully pure Porcupine Tree. This effect is accentuated by the fact that many of the instruments and vocals on the album are much more up front and given less of a sheen than on Stupid Dream ... Organic is the word I like to use."
Richard Barbieri described his approach to his keyboard playing, saying that "... Much of my keyboard experimenting took place on tracks like 'Russia On Ice', 'Last Chance to Evacuate Planet Earth ...', 'Feel So Low' and '4 Chords That Made a Million', while other tracks didn't seem to need a great deal of keyboards. I'm not one for playing all over a track if I can't see a genuine need for it."
Many songs from Lightbulb Sun and Stupid Dream recording sessions, that were left off their respective albums, were later released on the B-side compilations album Recordings in 2001.
Wilson states that, while there is no unifying theme or concept behind the album,
"There are at least four or five songs on that record which I call the divorce songs, the relationship songs, which are all about various stages of the splitting up a relationship, of dissolving a relationship. Russia On Ice, How Is Your Life Today, Shesmovedon, Feel So Low, I mean, the last track of the album. The period in a relationship, where the relationship is kind of... still exists, but it's in that period where, really, there is nothing left but hatred and despise - Hatesong is the other one. But then on the other hand, there are groups of songs on the album which are all about various childhood... nostalgic childhood reminisces, Lightbulb Sun and the first part of Last Chance To Evacuate Planet Earth, Where We Would Be. So there are kind of groups of songs. And then there's a couple of songs that don't have any relation to anything else. Four Chords That Made A Million doesn't have any relation to anything else on the album, or anything else I've ever written. It's just that."
The tracks "Four Chords That Made a Million", "Where We Would Be" and "Russia on Ice" were premiered during the Stupid Dream tour in 1999, several months before Lightbulb Sun's release.
The track "Last Chance to Evacuate Planet Earth Before It Is Recycled" features a speech by the leader of the Heaven's Gate religious cult. This U.S. cult believed that they were from another planet and only visiting earth. In order to return to their own "dimension" before the earth was "recycled", such extraterrestrial entities must find each other and commit mass suicide. The words are taken from the video they made before killing themselves to explain to the rest of the world why they had done it.
The track "The Rest Will Flow" is slower on the remaster, due to having been sped up from its originally recorded speed in the original master in order to make it more "radio-friendly". It originally was in danger of being left off the album altogether, as some band members questioned if it fit in with the rest of the album, but Wilson ultimately kept it on, arguing that it had "single potential". The song was in fact intended to be the album's third single, scheduled for October 2000 release, but it was cancelled for undisclosed reasons.
The song "Feel So Low" was re-recorded in 2004 by Blackfield, which is a project that consists of Porcupine Tree's Steven Wilson and Israeli singer/songwriter Aviv Geffen. The first verse of that version was sung in Hebrew by Geffen. This version only made it to the vinyl edition of the first Blackfield album. Later live renditions of this track by Blackfield were sung entirely in English but differed significantly from the Porcupine Tree original, as they added a long, heavy instrumental section at the end.
Wilson believes that the track "Buying New Soul", which was later only released on the b-side compilation Recordings and the 2008 reissue of the album, probably would have been included on the original release of the album had it been written and completed a few months earlier.
|2.||"How Is Your Life Today?"||2:48|
|3.||"Four Chords That Made a Million"||3:38|
|5.||"Last Chance to Evacuate Planet Earth Before It Is Recycled"||4:50|
|6.||"The Rest Will Flow"||3:36|
|8.||"Where We Would Be"||4:14|
|9.||"Russia on Ice"||13:05|
|10.||"Feel So Low"||5:16|
|German tour edition bonus disc|
|1.||"Buying New Soul (Edit)"||Barbieri, Edwin, Maitland, Wilson||6:09|
|2.||"Pure Narcotic" (Same version as one on Stupid Dream)||5:20|
|3.||"Tinto Brass" (Live)" (Live recording of the Stupid Dream track)||Barbieri, Edwin, Maitland, Wilson||6:48|
|4.||"The Rest Will Flow (string section)" (hidden track)||Barbieri, Edwin, Maitland, Wilson|
A reissue of Lightbulb Sun was released on 21 April 2008 through Kscope as 2 disc set; or a 3 disc set for the first 5,000 pre-ordered copies. Disc one is a CD containing a remastered version of the original album, while disc two is a DVD-A containing the album remixed into 5.1 surround sound. Disc 2 also contains three bonus tracks at the end: "Disappear", "Buying New Soul", and "Cure for Optimism", which were recorded during the same sessions. A limited edition third disc contains two instrumental tracks: "Novak", the b-side to the original 7" "Shesmovedon" single; and "Buying New Soul (Instrumental Backing Track)", the original version of "Buying New Soul", with 4 minutes more music that were cut at the same time as the vocals were overdubbed.
A double vinyl edition of the remaster was released through Tonefloat on 8 July 2008, in memory of Michael Piper, a member of the Porcupine Tree crew, founder of the Gates Of Dawn record label, who died in April 2008. It was available in a limited run of 1,000 numbered copies on 180 grams coloured vinyl in gatefold picture sleeve and a regular edition on 180 grams black vinyl in gatefold picture sleeve.
|2.||"How Is Your Life Today?"||2:46|
|3.||"Four Chords That Made A Million"||3:36|
|5.||"Last Chance To Evacuate Planet Earth Before It Is Recycled"||4:49|
|1.||"The Rest Will Flow"||3:18|
|3.||"Where We Would Be"||4:13|
|1.||"Russia On Ice"||13:05|
|2.||"Feel So Low"||5:22|
|2.||"Buying New Soul"||10:26|
|3.||"Cure For Optimism"||6:36|
|Drowned In Sound||(8/10) |
Reception for the album has been largely positive. Classic Rock magazine described the album as "an album of stunning songs and startling musicianship… breathtaking."  Allmusic praised the album's quality and its more commercial direction, and called the tracks "Feel So Low" and "The Rest Will Flow" "flat out two of Wilson's best tunes anywhere." ArtistDirect warned that while it is different than later Porcupine Tree releases such as Fear of a Blank Planet, and conventional progressive rock in general, "Porcupine Tree achieves something altogether more enjoyable here. And, while audiophiles may find the dense harmonies and musical arrangements intriguing in surround sound, the strength of Lightbulb Sun is in melancholic melodies that would sound every bit as good in mono." The Real Musician music website echoed similar sentiments, and considered it to be "the last 'old' Porcupine Tree cd" (prior to their move into a more metal direction with 2002's In Absentia), and continued "Out of that old band, Lightbulb Sun is the very best album they created".
Many reviewers felt the album sounded similar to the work of Pink Floyd. The album has also been praised for being more accessible than most progressive rock, with Bill Kopp of Musoscribe stating "Lightbulb Sun is, like all (Porcupine Tree), really, very accessible stuff. In many ways, Porcupine Tree can serve as a listener's entree into a heretofore unexplored genre: if you're a rock fan but not so into prog, (it) can ease you in gently. If...you're no metal fan, the band ... can show you the benefits of that genre without going all Metallica on you."
- Steven Wilson – vocals, guitars, piano, mellotron, hammered dulcimer, samples, banjo, harp, production
- Richard Barbieri – synthesizers, hammond organ, fender rhodes, clavinet, mellotron
- Colin Edwin – bass, drum machine, guimbri
- Chris Maitland – drums, backing vocals
- Additional musicians
- The Minerva String Quartet
- Katy Latham – violin
- Lisa Betteridge – violin
- Sarah Heines – viola
- Emmeline Brewer – cello
- Other personnel
- Chris Blair – mastering
- John Foxx – cover photograph, additional photography
- Luigi Colasanti Antonelli – group portraits, other photography
- "Kscope - Blog Archive - Classic Porcupine Tree on Kscope". 2008-04-04.
- "Specials - Steve Wilson Interview". Dprp.net. Retrieved 2014-07-03.
- Ned Raggett (2000-07-11). "Lightbulb Sun - Porcupine Tree | Songs, Reviews, Credits, Awards". AllMusic. Retrieved 2014-07-03.
- "Lightbulb Sun Review | Porcupine Tree | Compact Discs | Reviews @". Ultimate-guitar.com. Retrieved 2014-07-03.
- "Porcupine Tree - The Official Site". Web.archive.org. 2000-09-15. Archived from the original on 15 September 2000. Retrieved 2014-07-03.
- "Porcupine Tree - Background". porcupinetree.com. Retrieved 2008-04-12.
- "Steven Wilson - The Complete Discography (7th Edition), p. 49" (PDF). Retrieved 2008-04-13.
- "Official Website". Porcupine Tree. Retrieved 2014-07-03.
- "Specials - Steven Wilson Interview". The Dutch Progressive Rock Page. Retrieved 2008-04-07.
- "PORCUPINE TREE". Retrieved 2008-04-13.
- "Interviews: Porcupine Tree - Sea of Tranquility - The Web Destination for Progressive Music!". Sea of Tranquility. 2001-11-08. Retrieved 2014-07-03.
- "tonefloat". Retrieved 2008-06-22.
- Raggett, Ned (2011). "Lightbulb Sun - Porcupine Tree | AllMusic". allmusic.com. Retrieved 6 July 2011.
- Magnuson, Mike (2011). "@ ARTISTdirect.com - Shop, Listen, Download". artistdirect.com. Retrieved 6 July 2011.
- Nettleton, Chris (2011). "Porcupine Tree - Lightbulb Sun / Releases / Releases // Drowned In Sound". drownedinsound.com. Retrieved 6 July 2011.
- Griffith, Craig (2011). "Porcupine Tree: Lightbulb Sun: Pitchfork Record Review". web.archive.org. Archived from the original on 2008-06-22. Retrieved 6 July 2011.
- Richardson, Ken (2011). "Porcupine Tree: Lightbulb Sun | Sound and Vision Magazine". soundandvisionmag.com. Retrieved 6 July 2011.
- "@ARTISTdirect". Artistdirect.com. Retrieved 2014-07-03.
- "Porcupine Tree Lightbulb Sun Review". Therealmusician.com. Retrieved 2014-07-03.
- Nettleton, Chris (2000-11-07). "Album Review: Porcupine Tree - Lightbulb Sun / Releases / Releases // Drowned In Sound". Drownedinsound.com. Retrieved 2014-07-03.
- "Porcupine Tree - Lightbulb Sun (album review 5)". Sputnikmusic. 2009-08-14. Retrieved 2014-07-03.
- "Porcupine Tree – Lightbulb Sun – Review". Archived from the original on 2012-05-06.
- "Porcupine Tree - Lightbulb Sun". Musoscribe.com. Retrieved 2014-07-03.