Linothorax

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Achilles heals Patroclus, since he learned the arts of medicine from his tutor, Chiron. Both men are believed to be wearing linothoraxes.[citation needed] attic red-figure kylix, signed by Sosias, c. 500 BC, Antikensammlung Berlin (F 2278)

The linothorax (pronounced /ˈlnθɔːræks/; from Ancient Greek: λινοθώραξ Ancient Greek[linotʰɔ̌ːraːks]) is a type of upper body armor used throughout the ancient Mediterranean world. The term linothorax is a modern term based on the Greek λινοθώραξ, which means "wearing a breastplate of linen";[1] A number of ancient Greek and Latin texts from the 6th century BCE to the third century CE mention θώρακες λίνεοι thorakes lineoi (Greek) or loricae linteae (Latin) which means 'linen body armour.' These are usually equated with some of the armours showed in sculptures and paintings from Italy and Greece from 575 BCE onwards. Very little is known about how ancient linen armour was made. Linen armour in other cultures was usually quilted and stuffed with loose fibre or stitched together many layers thick, but it could also have been made with a special weave called twining which creates a thick, tough fabric.[2] The theory that it was made of layers of linen glued together comes from a mistranslation of a summary of a description of medieval armour in 1869.[3]

By the late 6th century BCE, many paintings and sculptures show hoplites and other warriors in the Aegean wearing the linothorax instead of a bronze cuirass. This could have been due to the lower price, lesser weight, or cooler material. Artists continue to show it in the Hellenistic period after the death of Alexander the Great. The Roman emperor Caracalla equipped a 'Macedonian phalanx' with linen armour around 200 CE (Cassius Dio 78.7).

History[edit]

Some scholars believe that Homer refers to a linothorax when he describes Ajax the Lesser as 'linen-breasted' (Iliad 2.529 and 2.830). Other scholars believe that this refers to a linen tunic or smooth glossy skin.

The first clear reference to linen armour in any ancient language is a line by the poet Alcaeus who lived around 650-550 BCE.[4] From the fifth century BCE to the first century CE, Greek and Roman writers mention soldiers from many nations wearing linen armour, but they rarely describe it in detail. These writers include Herodotus (2.182, 3.47, 7.63), Livy (4.19.2–20.7), Strabo (Geography, 3.3.6, 13.1.10), Suetonius (Galba 19.1), and Pausanias. The philosopher Plutarch says that Alexander the Great wore a "double linen breastplate" at the battle of Gaugamela (Plutarch, Life of Alexander 32.8-12). References to linen armour become much rarer in the Roman imperial period. It seems likely that as the Roman army developed cheap forms of iron armour such as the lorica segmentata, there was less demand for linen armour.

The Alexander Mosaic of Pompeii, depicting Alexander the Great, king of Macedon, wearing the linothorax[5]

Beginning around 575 BCE, artists in the Aegean often show a distinctive style of armour with a smooth piece wrapped around the chest, two flaps over the shoulders, and a skirt of flaps covering the hips and belly.[6] By the 4th century BCE armour with a similar shape appears in wall paintings in Italy, sealstones in Persia, gold combs in Crimea, and stone carvings in Gaul. Because only a few armours shaped like this survive, researchers such as Peter Connolly identify the lost armours with the linen armour in texts. Linen would decay and so leave little archaeological evidence. On the Alexander Sarcophagus and Alexander Mosaic, Alexander the Great and his soldiers wear this type of armour. Artists of the Roman imperial period rarely show this type of armour. The extant armours with this shape are made of iron plate, iron scales, or iron mail, so the armours which decayed were probably made of more than one material too.

Researchers at the University of Wisconsin-Green Bay built and tested some glued linen armour. Their replica was resistant to broad-head arrows and slashing damage of weapons with sharp edges. The bend of the fabric would allow the energy of the arrows to dissipate through the material and protect the user from lacerations, and arrows that struck at an angle would often deflect to penetrate a space between different layers of linen, rather than penetrating the linen itself. Blunt force trauma would still transfer through the armor, however, and possibly damage the internal organs of the soldier.

Depictions[edit]

Painted depiction of a soldier wearing the linothorax, from the Tomb of Judgement in Mieza in Imathia, Greece, 4th/3rd century BC

Since this armour is only known through texts, paintings, and sculptures, rather than archaeological finds, modern scholars can only guess at its makeup and design. Artistic depictions show armor that has a top piece which covers the shoulders and is tied down on the chest, a main body piece wrapping around the wearer and covering the chest from the waist up, and a row of pteruges or flaps around the bottom which cover the belly and hips. Vase paintings from Athens often show scales covering part of the armour. A team of researchers at the University of Wisconsin–Green Bay lead by Professor Emeritus Gregory S. Aldrete have catalogued art from Italy and the Aegean which shows this armour.[7] Five armours shaped like the armour in Athenian vase paintings survive from sites in south-eastern Europe from the 4th century BCE to the 1st century CE.[8] Two are of iron plate, one is of iron scales on a leather foundation, and two are of mail interwoven with scales. Some of the linen armour in ancient texts was probably shaped the same way, but how this ancient linen armour was made is unknown.

Research[edit]

Modern researchers have had difficulty studying ancient linen armor because linen is biodegradable and leaves few remains for archeologists to discover. In recent times, many cultures from India to Scotland to South America made linen armour by quilting many layers of fabric together or stuffing them with loose fibres such as cotton.[9] The type stuffed with loose fibres often looks bumpy and unlike the ancient art, but the type of many layers of cloth can be smooth. Textile archaeologist Hero Granger-Taylor proposes that ancient linen armour was woven using a special technique called twining.[10] Twined textiles were used in military contexts in Bronze Age Egypt, Roman Syria, and Maori New Zealand, so it is plausible that they were also used in Classical Greece and Italy before the Roman conquest.

In the 1970s, Peter Connolly built a linothorax by gluing layers of linen cloth together and cutting them to shape.[11] His reconstruction inspired many other reconstructions[12] including one by Professor Emeritus Gregory S. Aldrete and his student Scott Bartell. This project was present at the joint American Philological Association/Archaeological Institute of America Convention held in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania in January 2009, and published in a book from Johns Hopkins University Press in 2013.[13] The project received considerable media attention after Aldrete tested his construction by shooting an arrow at Bartell with cameras rolling.[14][15] But Peter Connolly's reconstruction was based on a mis-remembered, twice-translated summary of a Byzantine chronicle which did not mention glue, not on an ancient text, artefact, or depiction.[16] No culture before the 20th century is known to have made linen armour in this way.

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ λινοθώραξ. Liddell, Henry George; Scott, Robert; A Greek–English Lexicon at the Perseus Project.
  2. ^ H. Granger-Taylor, “Fragments of Linen from Masada, Israel—the Remains of Pteryges?—and Related Finds in Weft-and Warp-Twining Including Several Slings,” in Marie-Louise Nosch (ed.), Wearing the Cloak: Dressing the Soldier in Roman Times. Ancient Textiles Series, Vol. 10. Oxford: Oxbow Books, 2012. pp. 56–84
  3. ^ S. Manning, “The History of the Idea of Glued Linen Armour,” Mouseion 17.3 (2020) pp. 492-514 https://doi.org/10.3138/mous.17.3.003
  4. ^ Aldrete, Bartell, and Aldrete 2013: 11-20, Manning 2020 p. 492 note 5
  5. ^ "Laminated Linen Protected Alexander the Great : Discovery News". 2010-01-11. Archived from the original on 2010-01-29. Retrieved 2019-11-04.
  6. ^ Aldrete, Bartell, and Aldrete 2013: 22-28, Manning 2020 p. 492 note 5
  7. ^ Aldrete, Bartell, and Aldrete 2013
  8. ^ Manning 2020: 508
  9. ^ Manning 2020: 508-510
  10. ^ Granger-Taylor, Hero. 2012. “Fragments of Linen from Masada, Israel—the Remains of Pteryges?—and Related Finds in Weft-and Warp-Twining Including Several Slings,” in Marie-Louise Nosch (ed.), Wearing the Cloak: Dressing the Soldier in Roman Times. Ancient Textiles Series, Vol. 10. Oxford: Oxbow Books. pp. 56–84.
  11. ^ Connolly, Peter (1977) The Greek Armies. London: Macdonald Educational.
  12. ^ Matthew Amt, The Ancient Greek Hoplite - Armor 21 May 2017 https://web.archive.org/web/20171213072943/http://www.larp.com/hoplite/greekarmor.html
  13. ^ Gregory S. Aldrete; Scott Bartell; Alicia Aldrete (2013). Ancient linen body armor : unraveling the linothorax mystery. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. ISBN 9781421408194.
  14. ^ "Why did Greek warriors go to war wearing what today looks like a linen mini-dress?". Public Radio International. Retrieved 2019-11-03.
  15. ^ Scott Bartell, "Strange Love of Linen, or How I Learned to Stop an Arrow (and Enjoy the Process)", Johns Hopkins University Press Blog 18 August 2014 https://web.archive.org/web/20151127232840/http://jhupressblog.com/2014/08/18/strange-love-of-linen-or-how-i-learned-to-stop-an-arrow-and-enjoy-the-process/
  16. ^ Manning 2020

External links[edit]