List of 2018 FIFA World Cup controversies

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

As with the 2014 Winter Olympics, the choice of Russia as host of the 2018 FIFA World Cup had been challenged. Controversial issues have included the level of racism in Russian football and the discrimination against LGBT people in wider Russian society. Russia's involvement in the ongoing conflict in Ukraine has also caused calls for the tournament to be moved, particularly following the annexation of Crimea and support of separatists in war in Donbass. The then FIFA President Sepp Blatter declined requests for the tournament to be moved.

The 2015 allegations and criminal investigations of corruption, including a Swiss inquiry into the bidding process for the 2018 World Cup, intensified the public discussion of the appropriateness of Russia as the World Cup venue. In late May 2015, Russia's president Vladimir Putin said that he viewed the corruption investigations as an attempt by the U.S. to oust Sepp Blatter from his post as punishment for his support of Russia as host for the 2018 World Cup.[1]

Allegations of corruption[edit]

In 2014, England's Football Association chairman David Bernstein called for all UEFA nations to boycott the 2018 and 2022 World Cups due to allegations of corruption in the bidding processes

The English FA, which competed against Russia to host the tournament, was not satisfied by the 42 page summary released by FIFA, in November 2014, of the 350 page Garcia Report, which cleared both Russia and Qatar of corruption in the bidding processes for the 2018 and 2022 World Cups. FA Chairman Greg Dyke called for a re-investigation of the claims,[2] while his predecessor David Bernstein called on all UEFA nations to boycott the two tournaments.[3]

Reinhard Rauball, President of the Deutsche Fußball Liga (DFL),[4] called on UEFA to secede from FIFA unless the corruption investigation was released in full.[5]

Anatoly Vorobyov said "We have enough disciplinary measures which are laid out in our regulations. On the other hand, perhaps they need to be used more strictly".[6]

In an interview published on 7 June 2015, Domenico Scala, the head of FIFA's Audit And Compliance Committee, stated that "should there be evidence that the awards to Qatar and Russia came only because of bought votes, then the awards could be cancelled".[7][8]

Military conflict in Ukraine[edit]

Crimea[edit]

U.S. Senator Dan Coats wrote to Sepp Blatter requesting that Russia be barred from the 2018 World Cup due to its annexation of Crimea

The annexation of Crimea by the Russian Federation in 2014 led to several British and American politicians calling on FIFA to overturn its decision of hosting the 2018 World Cup in Russia — British Shadow Secretary of State for Health Andy Burnham said that football's governing body should reconsider,[9] while two American Republican senators, Dan Coats and Mark Kirk, wrote a joint letter to FIFA president Sepp Blatter saying Russia should not only be prevented from hosting a World Cup but also be banned from participating in it, bringing up the precedent of Yugoslavia being banned from Euro '92 and the 1994 World Cup as course of action to be followed in this case and proclaiming equivalence between Russia hosting the Cup with the appeasement of the Nazis and Adolf Hitler in the 1930s before World War II.[10] In March 2014 Blatter declined their request and responded by saying: "The World Cup has been given and voted to Russia and we are going forward with our work".[11]

Deployment of troops in Eastern Ukraine[edit]

Following several reports of direct military involvement of Russian troops in Eastern Ukraine, European diplomats revealed on 29 August 2014 that British Prime Minister David Cameron was working for Russia to be stripped of its hosting of the World Cup, as part of an extended sanctions package.[12][13] Some days later it was revealed that this was on the list of proposals for extended EU sanctions against Russia. However, no immediate action was taken due to the fact that the proposal was made nearly four years before the tournament.[14]

Events after Russia winning to host the World Cup[edit]

Racism[edit]

Yaya Touré said in 2013 that black footballers could boycott the tournament if actions were not taken against racism in Russian football

After it was announced that Russia would host the 2018 World Cup, Dr Rafał Pankowski, a head of UEFA FARE Monitoring Centre, accused the Russian Football Union of downplaying racist chants in stadiums.[15] In October 2013, after allegedly being racially abused by fans of the Russian club CSKA Moscow, Ivorian footballer Yaya Touré stated that black players might boycott the 2018 World Cup unless Russia tackles racism in football.[16]

On 13 July 2014, when the World Cup was handed over from Brazil to Russia[clarification needed], Russian President Vladimir Putin said: "President Blatter puts a lot of personal effort into addressing social issues, and we hope that the preparations for the World Cup in Russia will also contribute to tasks, such as fighting drugs, racism and other challenges we face today".[17]

In March 2015, Anatoly Vorobyov, the general secretary of the Russian Football Union, said that "not everything is going smoothly" in the campaign to eliminate the "virus" of racism from Russian football before the tournament.[6] Later that month, Vyacheslav Koloskov, a member of the Russian bid team and former Vice President of FIFA, said that too much is made of racism in Russia, and that monkey chanting is not racist.[18]

LGBT activism[edit]

In response to perceived discrimination against LGBT people in the country, a number of petitions have been circulated calling for FIFA to strip Russia of hosting rights. Thousands have signed these petitions, including United States senators Mark Kirk and Dan Coats and gay rights activists Greg Louganis, Stephen Fry and George Takei.[19][20]

Ban on negative news reporting[edit]

Russia's interior ministry ordered police not to provide negative news to the media during the World Cup and instead report only of solved crime cases to project a more positive image of the country. Russian police was instructed not to publish information about conducted raids or results of investigations into the crimes such as robberies and murders.[21][22]

UK response, reception and the British media[edit]

UK news media had repeatedly warned English football fans travelling to Russia of potential hooligan violence, anti-British hostility and racist intimidation.[23][24][25] English fans who have travelled have said they have received a warm welcome after arriving in Russia.[26][27][28] The Independent reported that "Most of the English fans blamed the low attendance for a 2-1 win on what they described as alarmist press stories."[29] Also Polish media reported on the friendly reception of Polish fans in Moscow and fears of repeated violence between Polish and Russian fans in Warsaw 2012 have not been met.[30]

England's failed attempt to stage the 2018 World Cup[edit]

The Daily Telegraph reported in June 2017 that the former British Prime Minister David Cameron and Prince William, Duke of Cambridge "were at a meeting during which a vote-swapping deal between England and South Korea was discussed, according to an official report ... At one point officials discussed the possibility of arranging a meeting with the Queen for one FIFA representative whose vote could have helped England."[31][32]

Skripal poisoning and aftermath[edit]

British Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson

On 14 March 2018, following the apparent poisoning of former spy Sergei Skripal and his daughter in Salisbury in the United Kingdom, the British government announced that all official visits to the World Cup were suspended.[33] No ministers or members of the Royal Family will attend matches or other ceremonies. The participation of the England team would not be affected.[34] On 21 March, British Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson accused the Russian government of planning to use its hosting of the World Cup for propaganda, comparing it to Nazi Germany's use of the 1936 Olympics in Berlin for such purposes. Contrarily, however, he added that it would be unfair to ban the British football teams from competing. Russia denied the accusations and denounced Johnson's statements as "unacceptable and totally irresponsible" and "poisoned with venom of hate, unprofessionalism and boorishness".[35][36]

United States sanctions against Iran[edit]

American company Nike stopped supplying Iran's FIFA World Cup squad members with football boots just days before their opening match in the World Cup due to the new United States sanctions against Iran. Iran's football coach Carlos Queiroz said: "They should come out and apologise because this arrogant conduct against 23 boys is absolutely ridiculous and unnecessary."[37]

Use of Cossacks against protesters[edit]

"The new Cossacks are part of a broader movement of armed Russian nationalism," said Nikolay Mitrokhin, a senior research fellow at the University of Eastern Finland. "Most of them fought in the Donbass, and many of them took part in the occupation of Crimea. It would appear that the Kremlin is now thinking about using them in Moscow in the same way."

Don Cossacks, the volunteer paramilitary soldiers from Southern Russia who fought in Donbass, during the Ukrainian conflict were redeployed this time by the Kremlin to counter protesters and will be used to counter protesters of the World Cup.[38]

"The new Cossacks were figures of fun, with their strange paraphernalia and dubious claims of historical lineage. But in Vladimir Putin's third term, as the Kremlin looked to create a nationalist, conservative ideology, they became influential. They began to receive significant state funding and political support."[38]

During the World Cup[edit]

Mexican homophobic chanting[edit]

Mexico's fans at 2018 FIFA World Cup in Russia

During the Germany versus Mexico group stage match, Mexican fans chanted "puto" at German goalkeeper Manuel Neuer; "puto" is a homophobic slang for a male sex worker that Mexicans and other South Americans have frequently used to taunt opposing teams. The origins of the insults against Neuer have been attributed to an incorrect Spanish translation of his statement "it would be good if a professional football player came out because it would help others to do the same", a South American publication concluded that he was gay, which was taken up by many other media and is since widely believed in the Spanish speaking world.[39][40][41]

The FIFA disciplinary committee fined the Mexican Football Federation 10,000 Swiss francs ($10,400) for the homophobic chants. The Mexican Football Federation was earlier sanctioned 12 times including 10 fines for anti-gay slurs during its World Cup qualifying campaign. Mexico's striker Javier Hernandez posted on Instagram. "To all Mexican fans in the stadiums, don't shout 'pu--'. Let's not risk another sanction."[42]

Swiss celebrations against Serbia[edit]

In Switzerland's 2–1 win over Serbia, Swiss goalscorers Xherdan Shaqiri and Granit Xhaka both celebrated their goals with the double-headed eagle gesture with their hands. The gesture can be interpreted as a symbol of Albanian nationalism, and both Shaqiri and Xhaka are of Kosovar Albanian heritage. Kosovo, the former Serbian province that unilaterally declared independence in 2008, is a partially recognized country claimed by Serbia. Both Kosovar President Hashim Thaçi and Albanian Prime Minister Edi Rama shared their support for the celebration on social media, while it was called "a disgrace" by several Serbian newspapers. FIFA subsequently opened an investigation into the incident on 23 June. While some Serbian supporters booed the players, their general anger after the match was more directed at some debatable referee decisions rather than the goal celebrations.[43][44][45]

During the match some Serbian fans wore shirts with pictures of war criminal Ratko Mladić, while some fans reportedly chanted anti-Albanian slogans.[46]

On 26 June 2018 Shaqiri and Xhaka were each fined 10,000 Swiss francs by FIFA for the celebrations, although a crowd funding start-up in Albania had already raised enough money to cover the fines. Reactions to the fines imposed were mixed, some Albanian and Kosovar fans said the fine would discourage players celebrating their identity, while some Serbian fans thought that the players in question should have been banned from playing.[47]

Croatian celebrations against Russia[edit]

Dejan Lovren (right) and his teammates line-up for Croatia before the game with Russia, 7 July 2018

Croatian goalscorer Domagoj Vida and Croatian team's coaching staff assistant Ognjen Vukojevic celebrated Croatia's World Cup victory over Russia by shouting "Glory to Ukraine!",[48] a slogan adopted by Ukrainian nationalists.[49] FIFA's disciplinary code prohibits political, nationalist and racist slogans in any form.[48] Vida, celebrating the victory with former Croatian international and current assistant coach, Ivica Olić, was also recorded saying "Belgrade, is burning!" in Croatian.[50] However, Serbian media reported "Belgrade" refers to the name of a pub in Kiev that Vida had frequented, not the capital of Serbia, and that the phrase was used to encourage the pub to have a party.[51] Aleksandar Holiga, editor of Croatian website Telesport, has largely downplayed the incident saying "I don't think Vida understood the full meaning and context of what he was saying. Both of them were just doing it because they are close to Dynamo Kiev. It's something that fans would chant" and that "politically, Croatia doesn't have a perfect relationship with Russia, but then who does in the rest of Europe?"[52] BBC reported that "Ukrainians accused Fifa of siding with Russia and flooded the football body's Facebook page with declarations of "Glory to Ukraine"."[50] After victory over England on July 11 in an interview to Russia 24 Vida said, speaking Russian, that "he was mistaken" and "apologized to Russian people".[53] Domagoj Vida received an official warning by FIFA and Ognjen Vukojević has been fined 15,000 Swiss francs and expelled from Croatian team's coaching staff by the Croatian Football Federation.[54]

Group H fair play controversy[edit]

Japan and Senegal finished Group H with the same number of points, the same goal difference, the same number of goals scored and a 2–2 draw as their head-to-head record.[55] Japan beat Senegal into second place based on their fair play record, as they had fewer yellow cards (four against six).[55]

The last two matches were played simultaneously. When Colombia scored against Senegal to go 1–0 ahead in the 74th minute, Japan went into second ahead of Senegal on the fair play rule. During their last game against Poland, the Japanese team were made aware of their advantageous position with ten minutes left and decided to play a very conservative game. They passed to one another and kept the ball in their own box, seeking to avoid any bookings.[55] They did not attempt to score, despite being one goal behind.[55] Poland, for their part were happy to let them do this as they were already winning but had no chance of advancing into the next round.[55] Some fans at the match booed the players.[56]

After the match the Japanese manager, Akira Nishino, said in an interview "I am not too happy about this, but I forced my players to do what I said. It's the World Cup, and sometimes these things can't be avoided."[56]

However, there was widespread criticism from football figures throughout the world. Comparisons were made to the 1982 'Disgrace of Gijón'.[57] Japanese social media users also criticised their own team.[57] However, others defended the Japanese team and FIFA said it had no plans to drop the fair play rule, despite calls for it to do so.[58][59]

Russian pension reform[edit]

On the opening day of the World Cup (14 June) the authorities of Russia announced the extremely unpopular pension reform presuming a substantial increase of the retirement age. Ordinary Russian citizens accused their government and president of trying to hide such information amid the euphoria of the tournament, i.e. to use the event as a cover.[60][61] Alexei Navalny interpreted this reform as a “robbery of tens of millions of people”.[60]

Sexism[edit]

Late in the tournament FIFA requested that television and photographic coverage of fans at matches should give less emphasis to attractive young women.[62] One Russian fan shown several times in the telecast of the opening match turned out to be a glamour model.[62][63] Getty Images apologised for publishing a gallery of "the hottest fans at the World Cup".[64] There were reports of Russian women and female media personnel being harassed by male fans.[62][64] A Brazilian reporter was commended for upbraiding a man who attempted to kiss her during a live broadcast.[64] Patrice Evra was accused of patronising fellow player-turned-pundit Eni Aluko after applauding a point made by her during ITV's coverage.[65]

Burger King social media campaign[edit]

Burger King issued an apology for an insensitive advertisement that was launched on the Russian social media outlet VK, promising a payment of $47,000 plus a lifetime supply of Whoppers, for any Russian woman if they were to become pregnant with a child fathered by a World Cup player.[66] The ad claimed the women should get "the best football genes" and "ensure the success of the Russian team for generations to come", following the trend of playing on sexist stereotypes that are seen often in Russian ads.[67]

Riots in France[edit]

Violence and riots erupted in Paris, Lyon, Marseille and across the country after the French World Cup victory.[68] Two French football supporters have died while celebrating.[69]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "Russia cries foul: Fifa arrests 'a conspiracy' says Moscow". BBC News. 28 May 2015. Retrieved 4 June 2015.
  2. ^ Roan, Dan (17 November 2014). "Greg Dyke: FA demands full report findings into World Cup corruption". BBC Sport. Retrieved 17 November 2014.
  3. ^ Ornstein, David (17 November 2014). "World Cup: Former FA chief David Bernstein calls for boycott". BBC Sport. Retrieved 17 November 2014.
  4. ^ "Dr. Reinhard Rauball". 8 January 2014.
  5. ^ "FIFA turbulence intensifies, Rauball moots UEFA split". Deutsche Welle. 16 November 2014. Retrieved 17 November 2014.
  6. ^ a b "Russian FA chief: Football must deal with 'virus' of racism". BBC Sport. 3 March 2015. Retrieved 7 March 2015.
  7. ^ "'Russia & Qatar may lose World Cups' - Fifa official". BBC News. 7 June 2015.
  8. ^ Owen Gibson (7 June 2015). "Russia and Qatar may lose World Cups if evidence of bribery is found". The Guardian.
  9. ^ "Fifa urged to rethink staging 2018 World Cup in Russia". Bbc.com, 2014-03-21. Retrieved 17 April 2014.
  10. ^ Winter, Stuart (2014-03-23): "US calls for Fifa to drop Russia from hosting World Cup in 2018". Express.co.uk. Retrieved 17 April 2014.
  11. ^ "Sepp Blatter: Russia will host 2018 World Cup despite Crimea". Bbc.com, 2014-03-21. Retrieved 17 April 2014.
  12. ^ Waterfield, Bruno (2014-08-29):"Ukraine crisis: Britain wants Russia stripped of right to host World Cup 2018". Telegraph.co.uk. Retrieved 1 September 2014.
  13. ^ Simon, Nik (2014-08-30): "David Cameron wants FIFA to strip Russia of 2018 World Cup in political sanction move". Dailymail.co.uk. Retrieved 1 September 2014.
  14. ^ "EU says boycott of Russia's 2018 World Cup 'possible'". DW.de, 2014-09-03. Retrieved 8 October 2014.
  15. ^ Syal, Rajeev (3 December 2010). "World Cup 2018 win raises Russian racism fears". The Guardian. Retrieved 20 August 2011.
  16. ^ "Yaya Toure: Black players may boycott 2018 Russia World Cup". BBC Sport. 25 October 2013.
  17. ^ Saakov, Rafael (22 July 2014). "Russia 2018: Major challenges for next World Cup hosts". BBC News. Retrieved 29 July 2014.
  18. ^ "'Too much made of racism in Russia', says former football head". BBC Sport. 19 March 2015. Retrieved 19 March 2015.
  19. ^ J.P. McCormick (25 March 2014). "Campaigns demand FIFA bans Russia from hosting 2018 World Cup due to anti-gay law". Pink News.
  20. ^ J. Lavin (28 February 2014). "Why FIFA Needs to Move the World Cup". advocate.com.
  21. ^ "Russian police told to keep lid on bad news during World Cup". Reuters. 14 June 2018. Retrieved 20 June 2018.
  22. ^ "Russian police was told 'not to provide the media with negative information' during World Cup". South China Morning Post. 15 June 2018. Retrieved 20 June 2018.
  23. ^ "What England fans travelling to Russia need to be concerned about". The Daily Telegraph. 1 June 2018.
  24. ^ "World Cup 2018: England football fans warned of potential 'anti-British harassment' when travelling to Russia". The Independent. 15 March 2018.
  25. ^ "World Cup 2018: New report highlights MPs' concern for England fans in Russia". BBC News. 8 June 2018.
  26. ^ "World Cup 2018: Russia's welcoming of England has been phenomenal". Sky News. 19 June 2018.
  27. ^ "England fan 'blown away' by warm welcome to Russia". The Belfast Telegraph. 18 June 2018.
  28. ^ "England fans welcomed with open arms in Volgograd ahead of opening 2018 World Cup match against Tunisia". The Daily Telegraph. 18 June 2018.
  29. ^ "World Cup 2018: England fans praise welcome by Russian hosts as they celebrate first win". The Independent. 19 June 2018.
  30. ^ "MŚ 2018. Polska - Senegal. Polscy kibice opanowali Moskwę. Cały świat śpiewa 'Polska biało-czerwoni'! MŚ 2018". Sport.pl (in Polish).
  31. ^ "Prince William and David Cameron caught up in Fifa corruption scandal". The Daily Telegraph. 27 June 2017.
  32. ^ "Video: David Cameron and Prince William implicated in FIFA corruption probe". Belfast Telegraph. 28 June 2017.
  33. ^ "World Cup 2018: Ministers & Royal Family will not go to Russia". BBC Sport. 2018-03-14. Retrieved 2018-06-03.
  34. ^ "How is the UK retaliating against Russia?". BBC News. 2018-03-14. Retrieved 2018-03-15.
  35. ^ "Boris Johnson compares Russian World Cup to Hitler's 1936 Olympics". The Guardian. 2018-03-21. Retrieved 2018-03-23.
  36. ^ "Boris Johnson's Hitler remarks unacceptable, says Russian envoy". The Guardian. 2018-03-22. Retrieved 2018-03-23.
  37. ^ "Iran coach Carlos Queiroz slams Nike over World Cup boots snub". Euronews. 13 June 2018.
  38. ^ a b "Kremlin deploys Cossacks to Moscow for first time in a century to suppress protests". Independent. 2018-05-12. Retrieved 2018-05-12.
  39. ^ Christenson, Marcus (3 May 2011). "Love of Jens Lehmann has Manuel Neuer ready to rock Manchester United". The Guardian. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
  40. ^ "Manuel Neuer se declara homosexual". planoinformativo.com (in Spanish). 2 September 2013. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
  41. ^ Balta, Victor (18 June 2018). "'Homophobic and not very clever': why puto chants haunt Mexican football". The Guardian. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
  42. ^ "World Cup: Mexico Fined for Fans Using Homophobic Chants". The Hollywood Reporter. 20 June 2018.
  43. ^ "FIFA opens disciplinary case over Xherdan Shaqiri, Granit Xhaka celebrations". ESPN FC. 23 June 2018. Retrieved 23 June 2018.
  44. ^ "'Double eagle' celebration provokes Serbs". BBC Sport. 23 June 2018. Retrieved 23 June 2018.
  45. ^ McCauley, Kim (23 June 2018). "Switzerland stars Xherdan Shaqiri, Granit Xhaka under FIFA investigation for 'Albanian Eagle' goal celebration". SB Nation. Retrieved 23 June 2018.
  46. ^ Rumsby, Ben (24 June 2018). "Stephan Lichtsteiner joins Switzerland team-mates Xherdan Shaqiri and Granit Xhaka in dock as diplomatic row erupts over 'eagle' salute" – via www.telegraph.co.uk.
  47. ^ Ames, Nick (27 June 2018). "Goal celebration or political statement? For Xhaka and Shaqiri, the eagle symbol was both". ESPN FC. Retrieved 27 June 2018.
  48. ^ a b "World Cup 2018: Croatia defender likely to face Fifa punishment over post-match celebrations after Russia win". The Independent. 8 July 2018.
  49. ^ "Croatia's Domagoj Vida investigated over 'Glory to Ukraine' chant". The Sunday Telegraph. 8 July 2018.
  50. ^ a b "Domagoj Vida: Fifa 'looking into' new video of Croatia defender". BBC News. 11 July 2018.
  51. ^ https://www.rt.com/sport/432489-croatia-vida-video-fifa-ukraine-belgrade/
  52. ^ Fitzpatrick, Richard (10 July 2018). "Domagoj Vida: The Controversial Joker Beloved by His Croatian Teammates". Bleacher Report. Retrieved 22 July 2018.
  53. ^ https://www.vesti.ru/fifaworldcup/news/883423
  54. ^ "The Latest: Official fined, banned; player only gets warning". Washington Post.
  55. ^ a b c d e Japan go through but final group game ends in 'mind-boggling farce'
  56. ^ a b "news.com.au" - 'Japan lost more than just its match against Poland'
  57. ^ a b "[[South China Morning Post]]" - Fifa World Cup fair play farce embarrasses Japan fans as social media users slam 'anti-football' tactics.]
  58. ^ No plans to change fair play rule: FIFA - Channel NewsAsia
  59. ^ Senegal complain to Fifa over fair play rule · The42
  60. ^ a b S. Walker (2018-07-01). "Russians protest over pension age rise announced during World Cup". The Guardian. Retrieved 2018-07-31.
  61. ^ A. Biryukov, A. Andrianovа (2018-06-14). "World Cup gives Russia cover for unpopular pension-age increase". Bloomberg. Retrieved 2018-06-17.
  62. ^ a b c Press Association (11 July 2018). "FIFA warns TV to cut out cutaways of 'hot' female fans in anti-sexism drive". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 16 July 2018.
  63. ^ Mehta, Ankita (23 June 2018). "Porn star and Russia's hottest World Cup fan Natalya Nemchinova bares it all for Maxim magazine". International Business Times, India Edition. Retrieved 16 July 2018.
  64. ^ a b c Rannard, Georgina (26 June 2018). "Is this World Cup still sexist?". BBC News. Retrieved 16 July 2018.
  65. ^ "Patrice Evra criticised for 'patronising' applause of Eni Aluko – video". The Guardian. 17 June 2018. Retrieved 16 July 2018.
  66. ^ "Burger King apologizes for offensive Russian World Cup pregnancy ad". USA TODAY. Retrieved 2018-06-21.
  67. ^ "Burger King Apologizes for Russian World Cup Pregnancy Ad". Time. Retrieved 2018-06-21.
  68. ^ "Looters, violence and road accidents tarnish French World Cup party". The Local. 15 July 2018.
  69. ^ "World Cup 2018: Two France fans die while celebrating as violence erupts after Les Bleus' final victory". The Independent. 16 July 2018.