List of Carnivàle episodes
Carnivàle is an American fantasy television series created by Daniel Knauf for HBO. The series premiered on September 14, 2003, on HBO and finished its two-season run of 24 episodes on March 27, 2005. Until late in the second season, each episode is split into two distinct but slowly converging storylines taking place in the United States Dustbowl of the mid-1930s. Nick Stahl starred as Ben Hawkins, a young Okie farmer with strange powers who joins a traveling carnival; Clancy Brown played his adversary Brother Justin Crowe, a California preacher who uses his similarly strange abilities to rise to power. Carnivàle was originally intended to run as a trilogy of paired seasons, with each pair being called a "book" and the series as a whole spanning the years from 1934 to 1945, but the series was canceled after two seasons due to low ratings. These two seasons complete the first book covering the years 1934 and 1935. The second book (seasons three and four) would have taken place around the years 1939 and 1940, and the third book (seasons five and six) would have played in 1944 and 1945, leading up to the end of World War II and the explosion at the Trinity test site.
The character of Samson, the diminutive co-manager of the carnival, sets up each season with a monologue, giving glimpses of the show's complex story and good-versus-evil mythology. By telling the story visually and deploying dialogue sparely, Carnivàle is a demanding show with a lot of subtext, and similar to reading chapters of a book, viewers need to watch episodes of Carnivàle in the right order or risk being spoiled with too little or too much story information. Many reviewers found the story too slow and confusing, but praised the show for its cinematography and realistic portrayal of the 1930s. Carnivàle received much award recognition in mostly technical categories, including fifteen Emmy nominations with five wins.
The stops of the carnival throughout the Southwestern United States play a significant part in the show, with many episodes bearing the name of the location of Ben and the carnival. Some stops like Alamogordo, New Mexico are of historical significance; others are fictional. The only episode titled after Brother Justin's location is Season 1's "The River". Both seasons of Carnivàle were filmed in Southern California, with the carnival set being moved to movie ranches and Lancaster. Brother Justin's story in the fictional Mintern, California was shot at Paramount Ranch in Malibu. The permanent filming location of the carnival in Season 2 was Big Sky Ranch, which was also used for Brother Justin's new home in fictional New Canaan. The show's interiors were filmed at Santa Clarita Studios.
|Season||Episodes||Originally aired||U.S. viewers
|First aired||Last aired|
|1||12||September 14, 2003||November 30, 2003||3.54|
|2||12||January 9, 2005||March 27, 2005||1.70|
Season 1 (2003) 
|“||Before the beginning, after the great war between heaven and hell, God created the Earth and gave dominion over it to the crafty ape he called man… and to each generation was born a Creature of Light and a Creature of Darkness… and great armies clashed by night in the ancient war between good and evil. There was magic then. Nobility. And unimaginable cruelty. And so it was until the day that a false sun exploded over Trinity, and man forever traded away wonder for reason.||”|
|Title||Directed by||Written by||Ben's location||Original air date||U.S. viewers
|1||1||"Milfay"||Rodrigo García||Daniel Knauf||Milfay, Oklahoma||September 14, 2003||5.33|
Milfay, Oklahoma Dustbowl, 1934. Ben Hawkins, a young farmer and chain gang fugitive, suffers strange dreams about a trench war and a tattooed man stalking in a cornfield. When Ben buries his mother who had just died from dust pneumonia, a traveling carnival arrives. Ben's house is about to be demolished, and the police are nearing, so the carnival picks him up and provides him shelter. Lodz, the carnival's mentalist, is suspicious of Ben's dreams. Before the carnival leaves to its next location, Ben puts his hands on a lame girl's legs and heals her, laying the surrounding field to waste. Samson, the carnival's co-manager, relays Management's comment about Ben being expected to Jonesy, the carnival's Ferris wheel operator who suffers from a crippling knee injury. Mintern, California.[a] The small town preacher Brother Justin Crowe makes an Okie church attendee spew coins. He also has the same dreams as Ben. In a particular dream, he sees a local Chinese establishment named Chin's where he later visits and has a vision of blood raining on himself and a cross manifesting on the neon signboard.
Awards: Emmy for "Outstanding Art Direction for a Single-Camera Series" and "Outstanding Costumes for a Series". VES Award for "Outstanding Special Effects in Service to Visual Effects in a Televised Program, Music Video or Commercial" and nomination for "Outstanding Visual Effects in a Television Series".
|2||2||"After the Ball Is Over"||Jeremy Podeswa||Daniel Knauf & Ronald D. Moore||N/A||September 21, 2003||3.49|
Ben is slowly setting in as a carnival roustabout. His co-workers make him clean up a mysterious baggage trailer where he finds a photograph of his mother with the inscription "H.S. and FLO". Ben shows it to snake charmer Ruthie, who identifies the woman on the photo as Henry Scudder's sweetheart Flora. Ruthie also hands Ben a photo of Scudder, a man who once worked in the carnival's geek show. Ben recognizes him as a soldier from his dreams. Brother Justin and Ben both have a cryptic dream about a diner with a soldier and Henry Scudder, where a waitress tells them that "every Prophet [is] in his House." Justin wants to turn Chin's into a church for the migrants and appeals to Carol Templeton, the establishment's owner. Templeton does not give in until Justin shows him the true nature of his sins.
Awards: Emmy for "Outstanding Hairstyling for a Series".
|3||3||"Tipton"||Rodrigo García||Story by : Henry Bromell
Teleplay by : Henry Bromell & Daniel Knauf
|Tipton, Oklahoma||September 28, 2003||3.57|
|The sheriff of Tipton refuses to let the carnival set up in his town. But after inhabitants identify Ben as the healer of the little girl, Samson opens a revival with the aid of the local church, featuring Ben as the famous Reverend Benjamin St. John. In-between shows, Ben locates an old lady named Rebecca Donovan, the sheriff's mother, whose old trucks reminded him of the baggage trailer photo. Rebecca remarks upon Ben's uncanny resemblance to Henry Scudder and makes cryptic statements about supernatural powers. With her last breath, she tells Ben not to heal her, and reveals that Scudder went to Babylon. Samson lets Jonesy know that Management decided Babylon will be the carnival's next major stop. Brother Justin has turned Chin's into a ministry and orphanage, but Carol's nephew Val Templeton informs him that the building will be torn down soon.|
|4||4||"Black Blizzard"||Peter Medak||William Schmidt||N/A||October 5, 2003||2.88|
While several carnies disapprove of Babylon as the next carnival stop, Lodz takes Ben on a trip and tests the boy's powers. A dust storm approaches, but when Jonesy checks up on Management, he finds his trailer empty. Brother Justin learns from his mentor Norman that he must either comply with the church board's wishes and hand over Chin's to someone else, or face disciplinary actions. Justin expresses his exasperation to his sister Iris, but when Chin's burns down under mysterious circumstances, his worries change.
Awards: VES Award nomination for "Outstanding Special Effects in Service to Visual Effects in a Televised Program, Music Video or Commercial".
|5||5||"Babylon"||Tim Hunter||Dawn Prestwich & Nicole Yorkin||Babylon, Texas[b]||October 12, 2003||3.31|
The carnival sets up in Babylon, and Samson invites the carnies for a party in the ghost town. After drinking too much, Ben wakes up in an abandoned mineshaft and finds AVATAR written on the walls. Sofie, the carnival's Tarot reader, hears Scudder's name from her catatonic mother, and the carnival night ends with a tragic death. Brother Justin prays for the children who died in the ministry fire.
Awards: Emmy nomination for "Outstanding Makeup for a Series (Non-Prosthetic)".
|6||6||"Pick a Number"||Rodrigo García||Ronald D. Moore||Babylon, Texas[b]||October 19, 2003||3.41|
Still in the mineshaft, Ben experiences visions of Scudder, Lodz and a Russian soldier in the trench war. Lodz pressures Ben to tell him about his dreams. After last night's death, Jonesy accuses Samson of pretending Management's existence, and Ben participates in "carnival justice". After Samson has learned of Scudder's past in Babylon, the carnival resumes its journey South. Brother Justin entreats God for answers to the ministry fire and he receives signs to go into the wilderness. He tells campfire strangers that he has lost his God and unknowingly becomes acquainted with Los Angeles radio reporter Tommy Dolan.
Awards: Emmy for "Outstanding Cinematography for a Single-Camera Series".
|7||7||"The River"||Alison Maclean||Toni Graphia||Texas||October 26, 2003||3.91|
|Ben learns of Scudder's past with Ruthie and accidentally injures her son Gabriel in a fight. To correct his mistake, Ben heals Gabriel in a lake, killing all fish in the process. Cootch show talker Stumpy Dreifuss is inconsolable over the death of his daughter, while the friendship between his other daughter Libby and Tarot reader Sofie deepens. Following a suicide attempt at a bridge, Brother Justin gets to know two Russian immigrant children, Irina and Alexei. At the same time, Tommy Dolan visits Iris and offers to go public with the mysterious circumstances surrounding the ministry fire. After outwitting councilman Val Templeton in a live radio interview, Dolan learns about Iris's childhood – she and her brother emigrated from Russia and are the only survivors of a train accident.|
|8||8||"Lonnigan, Texas"||Scott Winant||Daniel Knauf||Lonnigan, Texas||November 2, 2003||2.97|
|Ben dreams of Justin and the gravely injured Russian soldier. The next morning, he has to run errands for Samson and meets freak-finder Boffo. When shaking hands, Ben comes in contact with Boffo's ring, which induces a powerful series of Knights Templar visions in him. Ben panics and drives off with the ring, but he has to return it to Boffo at the carnival. Samson possesses a medal with the same symbol as the ring; it bears the initials "H.S." on the back. When Samson turns to Management, he finds Lodz in the trailer talking about Scudder and is told to leave. As the relationship between Sofie and Jonesy seems to go nowhere, Jonesy is offered sexual relief with Stumpy's wife Rita Sue. Brother Justin is committed to an insane asylum, where he informs the doctors that he is "the left hand of God" and "His will made flesh". He practices his mind-bending powers on the people in the building.|
|9||9||"Insomnia"||Jack Bender||William Schmidt||N/A||November 9, 2003||3.42|
|To supplement the carnival's income, Samson arranges a "fireball show". Ben tries to drive off the torments of his dreams by staying awake. He remains defiant to Lodz's urges to listen to his dreams and learn from them. Samson hands Ben the medal, saying he is the rightful owner as Scudder's son. The medal's significance becomes clear when Lodz touches it and experiences the same strong visions as Ben had with Boffo's ring. When Sofie envisions her mother being raped by a tattooed man, she unburdens her heart to Jonesy and Samson. Iris, who is still in search of Justin, participates in Dolan's radio show but rejects his romantic advances. Brother Justin is released from the mental institution.|
|10||10||"Hot and Bothered"||Jeremy Podeswa||Dawn Prestwich & Nicole Yorkin||Loving, New Mexico[c]||November 16, 2003||3.20|
|Ben, whose lack of sleep results in more daydream visions of the Tattooed Man, joins Samson on a trip to Loving. They hope to find more clues at a local brotherhood organization, which bears the symbol of Scudder's trinket. But the manager of the Templar lodge is unwilling to help them, and Ben misses an important clue on a mural. Meanwhile, a Templar tells Sofie about "every Prophet [being] in her House." At night, Lodz taps into Ben's dream and informs Management that Scudder appeared to him in a cornfield. Brother Justin returns to Mintern and asks Iris about the missing pieces of his childhood. At the next church service, Tommy Dolan joins the Crowes and sees Justin unburdening his heart about his dark past in front of the audience. When seeing baptismal water on Justin's forehead transform into blood, Norman grows suspicious of his foster son.|
|11||11||"Day of the Dead"||John Patterson||Toni Graphia||Loving, New Mexico[c]||November 23, 2003||4.19|
|While Ben's dark visions about Justin and Scudder continue, Sofie learns of Jonesy's affair with Rita Sue. Lodz organizes Ruthie's death with Management's blessing, and Ben finds himself unable to revive her. As police reports appear about the ministry fire, Iris is forced to confess her guilt to Justin.|
|12||12||"The Day That Was the Day"||Rodrigo García||Ronald D. Moore||Loving, New Mexico[c]||November 30, 2003||3.53|
|Sofie schemes for revenge on Jonesy and Libby, and Lodz learns alarming news from Sofie's mother Apollonia. Ben approaches Lodz for help with Ruthie's resurrection and meets Management for the first time. After several hours, Ben still finds himself unable to act on Management's instructional advice and considers suicide, but a vision of Scudder insinuates his destiny as an Avatar. When Lodz's involvement in Ruthie's death becomes clear, Ben kills him, reviving Ruthie in the process. At the same time, Apollonia sets fire to her trailer and risks Sofie's, Jonesy's and her own life. Brother Justin sheds light into Norman's greatest evil but is deeply disturbed to learn that Norman's worst deed was to save him as a boy. A deal with Tommy Dolan allows Justin to hold his first radio speech.|
Season 2 (2005) 
|“||On the heels of the skirmish Man foolishly called the war to end all wars, the Dark One sought to elude his destiny… live as a mortal. So he fled across the ocean, to an empire called America… but by his mere presence, a cancer corrupted the spirit of the land. People were rendered mute by fools who spoke many words, but said nothing… for whom oppression and cowardice were virtues… and freedom, an obscenity. Into this dark heartland, the Prophet stalked his enemy… until, diminished by his wounds, he turned to the next in the ancient line of light. And so it was that the fate of all mankind came to rest on the trembling shoulders of the most reluctant of saviors.||”|
|Title||Directed by||Written by||Ben's location||Original air date||U.S. viewers
|13||1||"Los Moscos"[c]||Jeremy Podeswa||Daniel Knauf||Loving, New Mexico[c]||January 9, 2005||1.81|
|After showing Ben an explosion of massive destruction in a desert, Management reveals himself as Lucius Belyakov, the Russian soldier from Ben's dreams. He tells Ben to find Henry Scudder to learn the name of his enemy, the preacher from his dreams. Samson is to further act as their intermediary, and it is his first task to get rid of Lodz's body. Jonesy and Sofie are the only ones to survive the trailer fire; Samson presents Apollonia's burned body to the police, claiming that fugitive Ben was killed in the fire. Meanwhile, Scudder's trinket prompts Ben to revisit the Templar Lodge in Loving, where he learns that Scudder was once involved with chaplain Devin Kerrigan. After meeting in 1923, Kerrigan seemingly lost his mind and painted a tattooed man into a Templar mural; he is now institutionalized in Alamogordo. Brother Justin visits Norman, who after suffering a stroke is unable to speak. On his way home, Justin sees a decrepit tree that he already encountered in a vision about the Tattooed Man and the Usher. Following another vision at the foot of the tree, Justin declares, "this will be my New Canaan.[a] Here, I will build a temple." Wilfred Talbot Smith meets up with Brother Justin in Dolan's radio studio, predicting Justin will become the Prophet and the Usher as soon as he kills a man named Henry Scudder. He then hands Justin the Gospel of Matthias, a Templar book that once belonged to Scudder. Justin's "Church of the Air" radio speech reaches Varlyn Stroud in prison.|
|14||2||"Alamogordo, NM"||Jack Bender||William Schmidt||Alamogordo, New Mexico[d]||January 16, 2005||1.73|
Ben finds Kerrigan in his room covered with drawings of the Tattooed Man, repeating a mantra talking of a crone. On his way back to the carnival, Ben drives past the desert from an earlier vision. He also picks up an absent-minded Sofie, accompanied by visions of the Tattooed Man. Sofie finds a new home in Lodz's trailer, but Lodz's former lover, Lila, grows suspicious of his unexplained disappearance. After receiving Kerrigan's poem and one of his drawings, Management informs Ben of the relevance of the Tattooed Man as the Usher, and that they need to find an old lady in Ingram, Texas. Varlyn Stroud, Brother Justin's "archangel made flesh", escapes from prison and sets out to find Henry Scudder. He first visits the Hawkins Farm and then proceeds to Tipton. After killing the sheriff, he finds a 1921 letter to Rebecca Donovan from Scudder in Babylon. While Brother Justin breaks ground for his Temple of Jericho near the decrepit tree, Dolan collects information about Iris and the ministry fire. Justin gets his chest and back tattooed with a tree.
Awards: Emmy nomination for "Outstanding Makeup for a Series (Non-Prosthetic)".
|15||3||"Ingram, TX"||John Patterson||John J. McLaughlin||Ingram, Texas||January 23, 2005||N/A|
|Sofie abandons her job as a fortuneteller and finds comfort in manual labor. Money problems force the Dreifuss family to work harder. Lodz repeatedly appears to Ruthie. Ben learns the route to the Crone from a tramp, but he loses the way in a forest and is met by locals who torture him; only Scudder's trinket saves him from death. Stroud arrives in Babylon and learns that Scudder was the only man to survive the 1921 mine cave-in. While more and more people arrive at the Temple of Jericho, Justin sexually abuses his new maid in the presence of Norman, who has been transferred to the Crowes' new home.|
|16||4||"Old Cherry Blossom Road"||Steve Shill||Dawn Prestwich & Nicole Yorkin||Ingram, Texas||January 30, 2005||N/A|
The locals bring Ben to Emma "The Crone" Krohn, the mother of Henry Scudder, and their and Ben's grandmother. Ben not only learns much about the fate of his relatives, but also finds his father's death mask. Before Ben leaves again, Emma gives him a trench knife, explaining that he will need it where he is going, a place "where the dog and the wolf howl at the moon." Meanwhile, Jonesy sympathizes with Sofie as the only female among the roustabouts, but cannot prevent Rita Sue from noticing his growing affection for Libby. Ruthie repeatedly sees Apollonia in burned clothes. After visiting the Templar Lodge in Loving, Stroud learns that a boy and a midget asked about Scudder. Dolan confronts Justin with evidence of Iris's guilt, but Justin remains unconvinced. The Crowes get a new maid.
Awards: Emmy co-nomination for "Outstanding Art Direction for a Single-Camera Series".
|17||5||"Creed, OK"||Jeremy Podeswa||Tracy Tormé||Creed, Oklahoma||February 6, 2005||1.10|
|The maker's address on Scudder's death mask leads Ben to Evander Geddes in Creed, Oklahoma. After an unsettling experience in Geddes' workshop, Ben leaves with the knowledge that Scudder is still alive. At the carnival, Ruthie approaches Sofie about her experiences with dead people, and Sofie starts seeing her mother as well. Stroud meets up with the carnival and irritates Jonesy about the safety of Ferris wheels, while Samson tries to put him off the scent by forwarding him to another carnival, The Daily Brothers Show. Late at night, Sofie gives Ben a card reading, inducing visions of Scudder in a tuxedo, a man scarred beyond recognition, and a location where a dog and a wolf howl at the moon. After looking through Samson's photo album, Ben recognizes the location as Damascus, Nebraska. Dolan has final evidence that Iris has something to hide. After a talk with her brother, Iris lets Dolan take her confession. Justin receives a mask of Ben by mail.|
|18||6||"The Road to Damascus"||Tucker Gates||Dawn Prestwich & Nicole Yorkin||N/A||February 13, 2005||1.50|
On the road to Damascus, the carnival meets members of the burned-down Daily Brothers Show. They suspect the former owners to have laid the fire, not knowing that Stroud had his hands in the matter. Felix admits his continued money problems to Rita Sue and gets into a fight with Jonesy over Libby. Lila has a strange encounter with Ruthie reminding her of Lodz. Ben and Sofie, who spent all day with each other, get intimate. Right after Ben leaves the carnival to close on Stroud, the carnival heads for its next location, leaving Sofie behind. Stroud exploits the idea that "the best way to follow someone is to get ahead of them." Preparations for Iris's public confession are underway, but in a mysterious twist, the police arrest Dolan as the culprit.
Awards: Emmy nominations for "Outstanding Cinematography for a Single-Camera Series" and "Outstanding Costumes for a Series".
|19||7||"Damascus, NE"||Alan Taylor||Story by : William Schmidt
Teleplay by : John J. McLaughlin
|Damascus, Nebraska||February 20, 2005||N/A|
While Sofie's absence seems to be a hot topic at the carnival, Jonesy sleeps with Libby. In the meantime, Ben has located Scudder's old hotel room in Damascus, where he has further visions of a man acid-burning his face. Ben finds this man near the reception and heals him, revealing Scudder. They escape Stroud and head to the carnival, where Scudder informs Management that Alexei Belyakov, Management's son, is Ben's enemy. When Management attacks Scudder in rage, Ben comes to his father's aid and stabs Management countless times with his grandmother's blade. While Brother Justin suffers visions of his approaching death in correlation with a Ferris wheel, the ambulance picks up another of the Crowes' maids in "a case of bad nerves." At a public radio sermon, Brother Justin turns against the pre-approval plans of his supervisory.
Awards: Emmy nomination for "Outstanding Prosthetic Makeup for a Series, Miniseries, Movie or a Special". Emmy co-nomination for "Outstanding Art Direction for a Single-Camera Series".
|20||8||"Outskirts, Damascus, NE"||Tim Hunter||Daniel Knauf||Damascus, Nebraska||February 27, 2005||N/A|
|As Management draws his last breath, he teaches Ben the right way for the blade to enter the tree. Ben informs Samson about the events leading to Management's death, that he is now in possession of Management's full knowledge and that he knows about Stroud's intentions and his link to the Usher. Samson only starts to believe him when Ruthie unburdens her heart over seeing Scudder and a bald-headed man as yet two other dead people last night. Meanwhile, Ruthie rejects Lila's approaches about her supposed sleepwalking. The Dreifuss family faces new troubles with Libby's marriage to Jonesy, and when they attempt to sort out their problems with a family dinner, a fatal Ferris wheel accident occurs. When Samson sees Ben transfer a mother's life to her child, Ben gains Samson's trust and designates the carnival's route westwards. Parallel to Management's death, Justin has a fit, which Wilfred Talbot Smith explains as Justin's enemy receiving his boon. Justin approaches councilman Templeton to participate in his Sermon on the Mount for a New America, and the Crowes get a new maid – Sofie.|
|21||9||"Lincoln Highway"[e]||Rodrigo García||William Schmidt||Lincoln Highway, Wyoming[e]||March 6, 2005||1.96|
Although the carnival has safely crossed the border to Wyoming, Jonesy and Libby are kidnapped by a man revenging the Ferris wheel death of his wife. The next morning, Ben has located Stroud and Scudder using astral projection and heads to Cheyenne when he encounters Libby on the road waving for help. To save the life of tarred and feathered Jonesy, Ben needs to use his healing powers and unintentionally also mends Jonesy's bad knee. Meanwhile, Ruthie's irritations grow after waking up and finding the words "Sofie is the Omega -L" on her mirror. Lila keeps close watch on her. Iris overhears Justin talking to stroke-afflicted Norman about his childhood nightmares: A carnival is approaching, hiding his enemy. The same day, Iris disposes another potential enemy and arrives late for Templeton's declaration of Congress candidacy. As Norman's gunshot misses his foster son, Justin shocks the crowd with forgiveness, but Iris finds a new ally in her plot against Justin.
Awards: Emmy nominations for "Outstanding Music Composition for a Series (Dramatic Underscore)" and "Outstanding Cinematography for a Single-Camera Series".
|22||10||"Cheyenne, WY"||Todd Field||Tracy Tormé||Cheyenne, Wyoming||March 13, 2005||2.50|
|Jonesy and Ben leave Libby with the carnival and drive to the motel of Ben's vision. Stroud and Scudder have already left, but Ben recognizes the preacher of his dreams in a newspaper article about a near-fatal shooting in California. After bribing the motel's clerk into delivering the newspaper to Samson, Ben and Jonesy leave for New Canaan. Meanwhile, Ruthie/Lodz pays Lila another midnight visit and informs her of the circumstances surrounding his death. Libby inadvertently amuses her mother with the story of Jonesy's healing, and Samson tells the carnies to pack up. Stroud delivers Scudder to Justin, but Wilfred Talbot Smith prevents Scudder's early death and a near disaster for Justin. Stroud increases security with his Knights of Jericho, Iris recognizes her niece in Sofie, and Justin vitiates Iris's plans by handing Norman into Sofie's care. At night, Scudder massacres Smith and escapes in Stroud's car, but is decapitated by Justin already waiting for him.|
|23||11||"Outside New Canaan"||Dan Lerner||Story by : John J. McLaughlin
Teleplay by : Dawn Prestwich & Nicole Yorkin
|New Canaan, California[a]||March 20, 2005||N/A|
As Ben does not want to miss a chance to kill his enemy, only Jonesy returns to the carnival for assistance. He finds Lila instigating a mutiny over Samson and a seemingly nonexistent Management, but when Jonesy shows his healed knee, he gains the carnies' support for Ben's mission, and the carnival leaves for an arranged setup in New Canaan. Meanwhile, Iris meets Ben armed with an axe in Justin's room and forwards him to a baptism taking place at the lake. Ben runs across Sofie and tells her of Justin's background as an evil man, but she refuses to believe him. When she however overhears the Crowes conversing in Russian and finds Ben's mask in a drawer, she turns away from Justin's advances.
Awards: Emmy nomination for "Outstanding Hairstyling for a Series". Emmy co-nomination for "Outstanding Art Direction for a Single-Camera Series".
|24||12||"New Canaan, CA"||Scott Winant||Story by : Tracy Tormé
Teleplay by : Daniel Knauf
|New Canaan, California[a]||March 27, 2005||2.40|
After hearing how Ben's powers work, Samson devises a grand plan. Libby and Jonesy have an open talk about his feelings for Sofie, and Iris confesses her sins to Norman. Meanwhile, Stroud locks Sofie in an abandoned barn after she saw Justin's tattooed chest and insulted him. Sofie experiences a series of visions of her carny past, of Justin, the Tattooed Man, Lodz's words to her mother, and finally of herself with Justin's black eyes saying, "this is your House." Jonesy, Ben and Samson hope to abduct Sofie from Justin's property, but when Samson and his carnies arrive to receive Iris's honorarium, they encounter Justin and Stroud. As Samson denies knowing a "Sofie", Stroud informs Justin of the obvious setup.Supported by many carnies, Ben's and Brother Justin's first and the series' final battle takes place on and near the carnival grounds. As Justin and Iris mount the Ferris wheel for a long ride, Ben begins to perform a mass-healing act as Benjamin St. John. After crumbling in pain and ripping his shirt open for everyone to see, Justin stops the Ferris wheel and enters Ben's tent. He pulls out the sickle that already killed Scudder, lacerates several devotees and Norman standing in his way, and pursues Ben into a cornfield. Justin cuts Ben on the arm and abdomen, and Ben's blade breaks apart. With Justin towering over him ready to carry out his last task, Ben remembers Management's words, grabs his broken blade and plunges it deep into Justin's tattooed chest where the branches meet. Meanwhile, Jonesy has tracked Stroud to Sofie's place, overpowers him and releases her, but Sofie shoots Jonesy down. The next morning, the carnies find Brother Justin with Emma's blade in his chest and bring Ben, still breathing, back to their camp. Stumpy and Rita Sue, whose outstanding debts are now covered by Iris's honorarium, reassure Libby that Jonesy will soon return. In the meantime, Sofie approaches Justin and places her hands on his chest. As Iris sees the corn die around them, the carnival leaves New Canaan with Ben's unconscious body bouncing in Management's bed... (see also Characters of Carnivàle: Season 2 finale and character fates).
a. ^ a b c d Mintern is a fictional town in the San Joaquin Valley in San Benito County, California, near Salinas. When Brother Justin loses his faith in God in the middle of Season 1, he leaves his Mintern home and heads for the San Joaquin Valley wilderness near Kingsburg. After visiting Norman in the hospital early in Season 2, Brother Justin and Iris head home and pass a tree; Justin names this location "New Canaan", the future site of his temple. New Canaan is also located in San Benito County, California, south of Salinas. The last Season 2 episode is named "New Canaan, CA" on DVDs.
b. ^ a b Babylon is a fictional town in Texas. It became a ghost town after a cave-in in 1921 killed all miners but Scudder. There is a historical reference to a real Babylon, Texas located in Navarro County.
c. ^ a b c d e Los Moscos is a real area in Chihuahua, Mexico, near the southwest U.S. New Mexico border, but its significance as the name of the first season 2 episode is never clarified. It is however established that Ben and the carnival spend most of their time in Loving, New Mexico during this and the previous episodes. Carnivàle suggests that Loving does not refer to Loving, New Mexico in the southeast of the state, near Texas, since the (fictional) town is said to be less than a mile from the Mexican border in the Western part of New Mexico, thematically and geographically likely close to Los Moscos.
d. ^ Alamogordo, New Mexico was the headquarters of the Trinity site, where humankind's first nuclear test took place in 1945. Ben's vision of the atomic bomb takes place in a desert nearby, ten years before the nuclear explosion would actually occur.
e. ^ a b Lincoln Highway is the first road across America, conceived in 1912. During the episode, the carnival rests in Wyoming close to the Nebraska border, but the episode is misleadingly called "Lincoln Highway, UT" on DVDs.
- "Interview de Daniel Knauf" (in French). Jimmy.fr. April 2005. Archived from the original on October 10, 2007. Retrieved September 17, 2007.
- Daniel Knauf at Carny Con 2006. Available on a Convention DVD Archived 2012-07-01 at WebCite via Carnycon.com. Event summarized at Yahoo Carnivale HBO ,  (registration required) (April 25, 2006). Retrieved August 5, 2007.
- Callaghan, Dylan (2005). "In the Ring with Good and Evil". Writers Guild of America. Archived from the original on February 25, 2013. Retrieved September 17, 2007.
- "Carnivale: "Los Moscos"". IGN. January 7, 2005. Retrieved September 11, 2007.
- Kasch, Andrew (September 8, 2006). "Carnivàle: The Complete Second Season (DVD)". Dread Central. Retrieved July 31, 2007.
- Gallo, Phil (September 11, 2003). "Recently Reviewed – Carnivàle". Variety. Retrieved July 31, 2007.
- Chocano, Carina (September 12, 2003). "TV Review – Carnivale (2003)". Entertainment Weekly. Retrieved September 8, 2007.
- Lowry, Brian (January 6, 2005). "Recently Reviewed – Carnivàle". Variety. Retrieved July 31, 2007.
- "Carnivale". Emmys.com. Retrieved April 22, 2012.
- Daniel Knauf (2006). Carnivàle: Complete Season 2 – "The Road to Damascus" audio commentary (DVD). HBO Home Video.
For a show that is really about people that are on the road all the time, this is really the only episode where we had them on the road.
- "Credits". Santa Clarita Stuidos. Archived from the original on April 27, 2012. Retrieved April 22, 2012.
- U.S. cable ratings for episodes 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.10 1.11 1.12 (German). Quotenmeter.de. Retrieved October 5, 2007
- "Development Update: March 31". The Futon Critic. March 31, 2005. Retrieved August 5, 2007.
- "Carnivàle: Complete First Season". DVD Talk. December 1, 2004. Retrieved July 29, 2007.
- Rodrigo García (2003-09-14). "Milfay". Carnivàle. Season 1. Episode 1. HBO.
- "2nd Annual VES Awards". Visual Effects Society. Archived from the original on July 17, 2011. Retrieved April 22, 2012.
- Fitzgerald, Toni (September 24, 2003). "Alas, Emmys just aren't Fox's thing". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on October 25, 2006. Retrieved April 8, 2015.
- Jeremy Podeswa (2003-09-21). "After the Ball is Over". Carnivàle. Season 1. Episode 2. HBO.
- Fitzgerald, Toni (October 1, 2003). "Can ABC keep up the momentum?". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on October 25, 2006. Retrieved March 6, 2016.
- Rodrigo García (2003-09-28). "Tipton". Carnivàle. Season 1. Episode 3. HBO.
- Fitzgerald, Toni (October 8, 2003). "NBC's quicky Friday night rescue". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on November 4, 2005. Retrieved March 6, 2016.
- Peter Medak (2003-10-05). "Black Blizzard". Carnivàle. Season 1. Episode 4. HBO.
- Fitzgerald, Toni (October 15, 2003). "The six new shows facing the axe". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on October 31, 2005. Retrieved April 8, 2015.
- Tim Hunter (2003-10-12). "Babylon". Carnivàle. Season 1. Episode 5. HBO.
- Fitzgerald, Toni (October 22, 2003). "Fox baseball's double-whammy". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on April 5, 2008. Retrieved March 6, 2016.
- Rodrigo García (2003-10-19). "Pick a Number". Carnivàle. Season 1. Episode 6. HBO.
- Fitzgerald, Toni (October 29, 2003). "CBS bites deep into NBC's Thursday". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on February 13, 2012. Retrieved April 8, 2015.
- Alison Maclean (2003-10-26). "The River". Carnivàle. Season 1. Episode 7. HBO.
- Fitzgerald, Toni (November 5, 2003). "What Fox must do to fix Mondays". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on February 13, 2012. Retrieved April 8, 2015.
- Scott Winant (2003-11-02). "Lonnigan, Texas". Carnivàle. Season 1. Episode 8. HBO.
- Fitzgerald, Toni (November 12, 2003). "A wilting 'Friends' in its final season". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on January 4, 2006. Retrieved April 8, 2015.
- Jack Bender (2003-11-09). "Insomnia". Carnivàle. Season 1. Episode 9. HBO.
- Livsey, A.J. (November 19, 2003). "In a barren season, 'Tree' sprouts for WB". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on October 25, 2006. Retrieved April 8, 2015.
- Jeremy Podeswa (2003-11-16). "Hot and Bothered". Carnivàle. Season 1. Episode 10. HBO.
- Livsey, A.J. (November 26, 2003). "What's got NBC itchy on Wednesday". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on October 25, 2006. Retrieved April 8, 2015.
- John Patterson (2003-11-23). "Day of the Dead". Carnivàle. Season 1. Episode 11. HBO.
- Livsey, A.J. (December 3, 2003). "ABC's winning play with '8 Simple Rules'". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on October 25, 2006. Retrieved April 8, 2015.
- Rodrigo García (2003-11-30). "The Day that was the Day". Carnivàle. Season 1. Episode 12. HBO.
- Livsey, A.J. (December 10, 2003). "Fox: Don't blow it with 'Simple Life'". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on October 25, 2006. Retrieved April 8, 2015.
- "Carnivale – The Complete Second Season". DVD Talk. July 18, 2006. Retrieved September 8, 2007.
- Jeremy Podeswa (2005-01-09). "Los Moscos". Carnivàle. Season 2. Episode 1. HBO.
- "Development Update: January 12". The Futon Critic. January 12, 2005. Retrieved October 5, 2007.
- Jack Bender (2005-01-16). "Alamogordo, NM". Carnivàle. Season 2. Episode 2. HBO.
- Vasquez, Diego (January 20, 2005). "'Idol's gains are NBC's newest pains". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on September 19, 2011. Retrieved April 8, 2015.
- John Patterson (2005-01-23). "Ingram, TX". Carnivàle. Season 2. Episode 3. HBO.
- Steve Shill (2005-01-30). "Old Cherry Blossom Road". Carnivàle. Season 2. Episode 4. HBO.
- Jeremy Podeswa (2005-02-06). "Creed, OK". Carnivàle. Season 2. Episode 5. HBO.
- Vasquez, Diego (February 9, 2005). "Friday setback for CBS's 'Numb3rs'". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on September 30, 2007. Retrieved April 8, 2015.
- Tucker Gates (2005-02-13). "The Road to Damascus". Carnivàle. Season 2. Episode 6. HBO.
- "Development Update: February 16". The Futon Critic. February 16, 2005. Retrieved October 5, 2007.
- Alan Taylor (2005-02-20). "Damascus, NE". Carnivàle. Season 2. Episode 7. HBO.
- Tim Hunter (2005-02-27). "Outskirts, Damascus, NE". Carnivàle. Season 2. Episode 8. HBO.
- Rodrigo García (2005-03-06). "Lincoln Highway". Carnivàle. Season 2. Episode 9. HBO.
- "Development Update: March 9". The Futon Critic. March 9, 2005. Retrieved October 5, 2007.
- Todd Field (2005-03-13). "Cheyenne, WY". Carnivàle. Season 2. Episode 10. HBO.
- Fitzgerald, Toni (March 16, 2005). "New worry for 'Arrested Development'". Media Life Magazine. Archived from the original on September 30, 2007. Retrieved April 8, 2015.
- Dan Lerner (2005-03-20). "Outside New Canaan". Carnivàle. Season 2. Episode 11. HBO.
- Daniel Knauf (2006). Carnivàle: Complete Second Season – "Magic & Myth" (DVD). HBO Home Video.
At the end of season 2, our main characters have come together and have had what amounts to their first battle.
- Scott Winant (2005-03-27). "New Canaan". Carnivàle. Season 2. Episode 12. HBO.
- Norman: "The Buick Phaeton. Silver and black. Runs like a greyhound. Salinas to Mintern in just over an hour." ("After the Ball is Over").
- Tommy Dolan: "Val [Templeton] is an important man here in Mintern. Indeed, he is fast becoming one of the most important men in the entire San Joaquin Valley." ("The River").
- Tommy Dolan: "Your car was seen leaving the area ten minutes before the fire." / Brother Justin: "A Model A was seen." / Dolan: "A black Model A Sedan was seen." / Justin: "There must be thousands." / Dolan: "Right, but only 29 registered in San Benito County and four in Mintern property." ("Los Moscos").
- Tommy Dolan: "Tonight, I'd like to tell you another story I found on the road in the Great San Joaquin Valley. […] It's the story of a man named Brother Justin and a town called Mintern." ("Pick a Number").
- Tommy Dolan: "We [Justin and I] were passing a bottle around a campfire just outside Kingsburg." ("The River").
- Ned Munson: "Without them Okies, Devine has a fix on the whole district." / Brother Justin: "Once the voters of San Benito County understand the choice presented to them, there will be no question for whom they will cast their ballot." ("Outside New Canaan").
- Samson: "We're going to New Canaan. […] Big Christian camp in California. Couple hours from here. […] South of Salinas." ("Outside New Canaan").
- Postmark on Scudder's letter to Rebecca Donovan: "BABYLON – JUL 24, 1921 P.M. – TEX" ("Alamogordo, NM").
- "BABYLON, TX". Texas State Historical Association. Retrieved April 22, 2012.
- "Los Moscos". Google Maps. Retrieved October 9, 2007.
- Streetsign: "Welcome to Loving, N.M. Pop. 2,315" ("Hot and Bothered").
- Streetsign near the carnival's location: "Wonderful Wyoming – Entering Wyoming – Drive carefully – Enjoy your trip vacation." ("Lincoln Highway").
- Samson: "But we're over state line now. So the Nebrasky cops can't get to us. Or whoever else has a mind to." ("Lincoln Highway").
- Samson: "There. Cheyenne." / Ben: "That's right down the highway." / Samson: "If you skin for it, I'll wager you'd make it in two, three hours, tops." ("Lincoln Highway").
- Streetsign on Ben's route to Cheyenne: "Lincoln Highway – Cheyenne 53 mi. Laramie 91 mi. Rock Springs 250 mi." ("Lincoln Highway").
- Streetsign where Ben heals Jonesy: "Cheyenne – Clean & Friendly Motor Court – 17 miles" ("Lincoln Highway").