Very little is known of his early life, as Donatist writings were mostly destroyed in the following years. What we can garner of his life and beliefs is accessed through what his enemies said against him. He had been a reader or a lector in the church at Carthage, during the time that Caecilianus, had been an archdeacon at Carthage and Mesurius was Bishop of Carthage. He seems to have also had some domestic office in the household of a Roman noblewoman Lucilla. In 311 he was chosen as Bishop of Carthage, by a council of 70 bishops in Cirta led by Secundus of Tigisis. Secundus of Tigisis was the primate of Numidia and as such was meant to be consulted prior to the appointment of Caecilianus. This appointment was intended to depose the existing recently appointed bishop Caecilianus. Caecilianus had been the understudy of the recently deceased bishop Mensurius considered by many to be a traditor during the Diocletianic Persecution, though Mensurius denied the charges. Saying instead that he had hidden Christians and church property. The Council, however, held that Mensurius was traditor and that sacraments administered by Caecilianus were thus invalid. The situation was further complicated by the fact tha Caecilianus was consecrated by Felix of Aptunga, another traditor. However rather than depose Caecilianus, his appointment created a three-hundred-year-long schism in North African Christendom that would radically shape the intellectual life of Christianity.
Virtually everything we know of Majorinus comes from his enemies, many of whom did not hold back on their condemnation of him:
Optatus claims that a dispute broke out between Lucilla a woman of high rank and the deacon Caecilianus, who had reprimanded her for touching a relique of a saint. The offence, he claimed had festered and at the accession to the bishopric of Caecilianus, Lucilla joined with the Council of Bishops who Optatus called Antichrists and betrayers. he concluded ....the Schism was brought to birth by the anger of a disgraced woman, was fed by ambition, and received its strength from avarice He describes Majorinus:
"Majorinus, a member of the household of Lucilla----at her instigation, and through her bribes----was consecrated Bishop by Betrayers, who in the Numidian Council had (as we have already said) acknowledged their crimes and granted pardon to one another. It is, therefore, clear that both the Betrayers who consecrated, and Majorinus who was consecrated, went forth from the Church."
Augustine was scathing of Majorinus His elevation to bishop was a Wicked Crime of Frenzied Discord For Augustine the chief evil of Majorinus was his schism with the Roman Catholic Church. He wrote of the Donatists in an epistle:
"It is better indeed that men should be brought to serve God by instruction than by fear of punishment or by pain. But because the former means are better, the latter must not therefore be neglected.... Many must often be brought back to their Lord, like wicked servants, by the rod of temporal suffering before they attain the highest grade of religious development...."
Although he was the first leader of the Donatists church, itself a significant event in the Early African Church and resulting in the formation of doctrinal authodoxy for the Catholic portion of the church, Majorinus himself seems to have been little more than a puppet for the rigorists. He had been a fairly low ranking clergy thrust into the dispute that had been raging for some time. This, a lack of theological output, and the relivily short tenure of his leadership had reduced his actual impact on history.
- Robert McQueen Grant, Augustus to Constantine: The Rise and Triumph of Christianity in the Roman World (Westminster John Knox Press, 2004) p18.
- Munier, "Cirta" in The Encyclopedia of the Early Church (New York: Oxford University Press, 1992).
- Shand Mark, Augustine, the Donatists and the Catholic Church
- Emilien Lamirande, La correspondence entre Secundus et Mensurius, in: Œuvres de Saint Augustin 32 (Bibliothèque Augustinienne) 1965, p728.
- Timothy David Barnes, Constantine and Eusebius (Harvard University Press, 1981)p55.
- Munier, "Cirta" in The Encyclopedia of the Early Church (New York City: Oxford University Press, 1992).
- Katrin Kogman-Appel, Mati Meyer, Between Judaism and Christianity: Art Historical Essays in Honor of Elisheva (Elisabeth) Revel-Neher (BRILL, 2009)
- Allan Fitzgerald, John C. Cavadini Augustine Through the Ages: An Encyclopedia (Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing, 1999) p284.
- Optatus On The Origins Of Donatism XVI.
- Everett Ferguson, Encyclopedia of Early Christianity, Second Edition (Routledge, 8 Oct. 2013).
- Optatus On The Origins Of Donatism XV.
- Optatus On The Origins Of Donatism XIX.
- Optatus On The Origins Of Donatism XIX
- Saint Augustine (Bishop of Hippo.), Roland J. Teske, John E. Rotelle Letters 1-99, Part 2, Volume 1 (New City Press, 2001) p44.
- Saint Augustine (Bishop of Hippo.), Roland J. Teske, John E. Rotelle Letters 1-99, Part 2, Volume 1 (New City Press, 2001) p158.
- Augustine, Letter 185.
- Edward L. Smither, Rethinking Constantine: History, Theology and Legacy (James Clarke & Co, 25 Sep. 2014) p65.