Maximilian Bircher-Benner

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Maximilian Oskar Bircher-Benner
4bircher.JPG
Born(1867-08-22)August 22, 1867
DiedJanuary 24, 1939(1939-01-24) (aged 71)
OccupationPhysician, nutritionist
Known forCreated muesli
Works
Food Science for All

Maximilian Oskar Bircher-Benner, M.D. (August 22, 1867 – January 24, 1939) was a Swiss physician and a pioneer nutritionist credited for popularizing muesli and raw foodism.

Biography[edit]

Maximilian Oskar Bircher-Benner was born on August 22, 1867 in Aarau, Switzerland, to Heinrich Bircher and Berta Krüsi.[1] He attended the University of Zurich to study medicine, and later opened his own general clinic. During the first year the clinic was open, Bircher-Benner came down with jaundice, and he claimed he became well again by eating raw apples. From this observation, he experimented with the health effects raw foods have on the body, and from this he promoted muesli, a dish based on raw oats, fruits, and nuts.[2] Bircher-Benner expanded on his nutritional research and opened a sanatorium called "Vital Force" in 1897. He believed raw fruits and vegetables held the most nutritional value, cooked and commercially processed foods held even less, and meat held the least nutritional value. Eventually, Bircher-Benner gave up meat entirely and became a vegetarian. Other scientists of the time did not respond well to what Bircher-Benner referred to as his "new food science," but the general public caught on to his ideas to the point where he had to expand his sanatorium practice.[1][3] His nutritional habits and eating patterns steadily grew in popularity until he died on January 24, 1939 in Zürich at the age of 71.[4]

Nutrition[edit]

At his sanatorium in Zürich, a balanced diet of raw vegetables and fruit was used as a means to heal patients, contrary to the beliefs commonly held at the end of the 19th century.[2] Bircher-Benner believed raw foods were more nutritious because they contain direct energy from the sun.[5] He encouraged people of good health to eat approximately 50% raw foods on a daily basis, and for those with poor health to eat 100% raw foods. Bircher-Benner's sisters, Alice Bircher and Berta Brupbacher-Bircher, created many recipes using raw foods to help a diet of raw foods seem more appealing. Because of this help from his sisters, his sanatorium gained enormous popularity and he expanded the size of his clinic.[1][4]

Bircher-Benner changed the eating habits of the late 19th century. Instead of much meat and white bread, he postulated eating fruit, vegetables and nuts. His ideas included not only controlled nutrition, but also spartan physical discipline. At his Zürich sanatorium off Bircher-Benner-Platz, the patients had to follow a somewhat monastic daily schedule including early bedtime (21:00, or 9:00pm), physical training and active gardening work. Each meal began with a small dish of muesli, developed by Dr. Bircher-Benner, followed by mostly raw vegetables and a dessert. Patients were not allowed to consume alcohol, coffee, chocolate, or tobacco while they were being treated. Bircher-Benner also recommended his patients to sun bathe, take cold showers, and use a medicinal bath developed by American physician John Harvey Kellogg.[1] His theory of life was based on harmony between people and nature, a key component of a German lifestyle reform movement, and the reason he named his clinic "Vital Force."[2]

Criticism[edit]

Bircher-Benner held pseudoscientific ideas about nutrition, including vitalism. He believed that all people including babies should eat only raw food.[6] Bircher-Benner developed the idea that cooking deprived foods of their nutritional content and destroyed their "vital substance". He believed that cooked foods leave decay in the digestive tract, that may cause autointoxication.[6]

Bircher-Benner's ideas about nutrition were in opposition to science and he was dismissed as a quack by the medical community.[7] A review for Bircher-Benner's cookbook Health-Giving Dishes commented that it contained "a mixture of physiological half-truths and fantasies" and concluded that the number of people capable of eating solely raw fruits and vegetables as Bircher-Benner encouraged is limited because only few humans can live as herbivores.[3] Thomas Mann, a well-known novelist, visited the sanatorium and described it as a "health jail."[1] Despite disapproval from others, Bircher-Benner's ideas caught the public's eye and his sanatorium stayed in business until some time after his passing.[7]

Legacy[edit]

Bircher-Benner's work was not recognized by other scientists until the discovery of vitamins in fruits and vegetables in the 1930s.[1] Shortly after his death, a second sanatorium was opened and named "People's Sanatorium for a Lifestyle Based on Nature," and was run according to Bircher-Benner's ideas. In 1939, the Vital Force clinic was renamed the "Bircher-Benner Clinic" in his memory.[2] In the late 20th century, after closure of the sanatorium, it was briefly a student hostel. It has since been purchased by Zürich Financial Services, and is named the Zürich Development Center. It is used for executive training, and also houses an extensive private art collection.[citation needed]

Selected publications[edit]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b c d e f "Maximilian Oskar Bircher-Benner". CooksInfo.com. Retrieved 2015-10-09.
  2. ^ a b c d "Biography of Max Bircher-Benner – Zurich Development Center". www.zurichdevelopmentcenter.com. Retrieved 2015-10-09.
  3. ^ a b "Notes on Books". The British Medical Journal. 1 (3864): 157. 1925-01-26. JSTOR 25343029.
  4. ^ a b "Dr. M. Bircher-Benner". The British Medical Journal. 1 (4075): 307. 1939-02-11. JSTOR 20302420.
  5. ^ Thuringer, Joseph M. (1927-09-01). Books Abroad. Board of Regents of the University of Oklahoma. p. 44.
  6. ^ a b Gratzer, Walter. (2005). Terrors of the Table: The Curious History of Nutrition. Oxford University Press. pp. 197-198. ISBN 0-19-280661-0
  7. ^ a b Fitzgerald, Matt. (2015). Diet Cults: The Surprising Fallacy at the Core of Nutrition Fads and a Guide to Healthy Eating for the Rest of US. Pegasus. p. 43. ISBN 978-1605988290 "There was, of course, no evidence that the life force that Bircher-Benner deemed all-important actually existed. His peers in the mainstream medical establishment dismissed the life-force concept as unscientific and branded Bircher-Benner a quack."

External links[edit]