The McCabe–Thiele method is considered to be the simplest and perhaps most instructive method for the analysis of binary distillation. It uses the fact that the composition at each theoretical tray (or equilibrium stage) is completely determined by the mole fraction of one of the two components and is based on the assumption of constant molar overflow which requires that:
The method was first published by Warren L. McCabe and Ernest W. Thiele in 1925. At that time, both McCabe and Thiele were at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). Thiele completed his D.Sc. program at MIT and graduated in that same year. McCabe, with an M.S. degree from the University of Michigan (U of M), was serving a faculty appointment at MIT and subsequently returned to the U of M to obtain his doctorate in 1928.
Construction and use of the McCabe–Thiele diagram
||This section's tone or style may not reflect the encyclopedic tone used on Wikipedia. (February 2014) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)|
Before starting the construction and use of a McCabe–Thiele diagram for the distillation of a binary feed, the vapor–liquid equilibrium (VLE) data must be obtained for the lower-boiling component of the feed.
The first step is to draw equal sized vertical and horizontal axes of a graph. The horizontal axis will be for the mole fraction (denoted by x) of the lower-boiling feed component in the liquid phase. The vertical axis will be for the mole fraction (denoted by y) of the lower-boiling feed component in the vapor phase.
The next step is to draw a straight line from the origin of the graph to the point where x and y both equal 1.0, which is the x = y line in Figure 1. This 45 degree line is used simply as a graphical aid for drawing the remaining lines. Then draw the equilibrium line using the VLE data points of the lower boiling component, representing the equilibrium vapor phase compositions for each value of liquid phase composition. Also draw vertical lines from the horizontal axis up to the x = y line for the feed and for the desired compositions of the top distillate product and the corresponding bottoms product (shown in red in Figure 1).
The next step is to draw the operating line for the rectifying section (the section above the feed inlet) of the distillation column, (shown in green in Figure 1). Starting at the intersection of the distillate composition line and the x = y line, draw the rectifying operating line at a downward slope (Δy/Δx) of L / (D + L) where L is the molar flow rate of reflux and D is the molar flow rate of the distillate product. For example, in Figure 1, assuming the molar flow rate of the reflux L is 1000 moles per hour and the molar flow rate of the distillate D is 590 moles per hour, then the downward slope of the rectifying operating line is 1000 / (590 + 1000) = 0.63 which means that the y-coordinate of any point on the line decreases 0.63 units for each unit that the x-coordinate decreases.
The next step is to draw the blue q-line (seen in Figure 1) from the x = y line so that it intersects the rectifying operating line.
The parameter q is the mole fraction of liquid in the feed and the slope of the q-line is q / (q – 1). For example, if the feed is a saturated liquid it has no vapor, thus q = 1 and the slope of the q-line is infinite which means the line is vertical. As another example, if the feed is all saturated vapor, q = 0 and the slope of the q-line is 0 which means that the line is horizontal.
Some example q-line slopes are presented in Figure 2. As can be seen now, the typical McCabe-Thiele diagram in Figure 1 uses a q-line representing a partially vaporized feed.
Next, as shown in Figure 1, draw the purple operating line for the stripping section of the distillation column (i.e., the section below the feed inlet). Starting at the intersection of the red bottoms composition line and the x = y line, draw the stripping section operating line up to the point where the blue q-line intersects the green operating line of the rectifying section operating line.
Finally, as exemplified in Figure 1, draw the steps between operating lines and the equilibrium line and then count them. Those steps represent the theoretical plates (or equilibrium stages). The required number of theoretical plates is 6 for the binary distillation depicted in Figure 1.
Note that using colored lines is not required and only used here to make the methodology easier to describe.
In continuous distillation with varying reflux ratio, the mole fraction of the lighter component in the top part of the distillation column will decrease as the reflux ratio decreases. Each new reflux ratio will alter the slope of the rectifying section operating line.
When the assumption of constant molar overflow is not valid, the operating lines will not be straight. Using mass and enthalpy balances in addition to vapor-liquid equilibrium data and enthalpy-concentration data, operating lines can be constructed based on Ponchon–Savarit's method.
If the mixture can form an azeotrope, its vapor-liquid equilibrium line will cross the x = y line, preventing further separation no matter the number of theoretical plates.
- McCabe, W. L. & Smith, J. C. (1976). Unit Operations of Chemical Engineering (3rd ed.). McGraw-Hill. ISBN 0-07-044825-6.
- Perry, Robert H. & Green, Don W. (1984). Perry's Chemical Engineers' Handbook (6th ed.). McGraw-Hill. ISBN 0-07-049479-7.
- Beychok, Milton (May 1951). "Algebraic Solution of McCabe-Thiele Diagram". Chemical Engineering Progress.
- W.L. McCabe & E.W. Thiele (June 1925). "Graphical Design Of Fractionating Columns" (PDF). Industrial and Engineering Chemistry. 17: 605–611. doi:10.1021/ie50186a023.
- Jonathan H. Worstell (March 2009), Ernest W. Thiele: His Impact on Chemical Engineering
- Ralph E. Fadum (1984), Warren Lee McCabe in Memorial Tributes: National Academy of Engineering, Volume 2.
- King, C. Judson (1971). Separation Processes. McGraw-Hill. ISBN 0-07-034610-0.
- More detailed information on how to draw a McCabe-Thiele Diagram
- Detailed discussion of McCabe-Thiele method by Tore Haug-Warberg, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Norway
- McCabe-Thiele Diagram generator