New media art
New media art refers to artworks created with new media technologies, including digital art, computer graphics, computer animation, virtual art, Internet art, interactive art, video games, computer robotics, 3D printing, cyborg art and art as biotechnology. The term differentiates itself by its resulting cultural objects and social events, which can be seen in opposition to those deriving from old visual arts (i.e. traditional painting, sculpture, etc.). This concern with medium is a key feature of much contemporary art and indeed many art schools and major universities now offer majors in "New Genres" or "New Media" and a growing number of graduate programs have emerged internationally. New media art often involves interaction between artist and observer or between observers and the artwork, which responds to them. Yet, as several theorists and curators have noted, such forms of interaction, social exchange, participation, and transformation do not distinguish new media art but rather serve as a common ground that has parallels in other strands of contemporary art practice. Such insights emphasize the forms of cultural practice that arise concurrently with emerging technological platforms, and question the focus on technological media, per se.
New Media concerns are often derived from the telecommunications, mass media and digital electronic modes of delivering the artworks involve, with practices ranging from conceptual to virtual art, performance to installation.
This section needs additional citations for verification. (September 2015) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
The origins of new media art can be traced to the moving photographic inventions of the late 19th century such as the zoetrope (1834), the praxinoscope (1877) and Eadweard Muybridge's zoopraxiscope (1879). From the 1920s through the 1950s, various forms of kinetic and light art, from Thomas Wilfred's 'Lumia' (1919) and 'Clavilux' light organs to Jean Tinguely's self-destructing sculpture 'Homage to New York' (1960) can be seen as progenitors of new media art.
During the 1960s the development of then new technologies of video produced the new media art experiments of Nam June Paik, and Wolf Vostell with the installation 6 TV Dé-coll/age in 1963 at the Smolin Gallery in New York. A. Michael Noll, and multimedia performances of E.A.T., Fluxus and Happening. In 1983, Roy Ascott introduced the concept of "distributed authorship" in his worldwide telematic project La Plissure du Texte for Frank Popper's "Electra" at the Musée d'Art Moderne de la Ville de Paris. The development of computer graphics at the end of the 1980s and real time technologies then in the 1990s combined with the spreading of the Web and the Internet favored the emergence of new and various forms of interactive art by Ken Feingold, Lynn Hershman Leeson, David Rokeby, Ken Rinaldo, Perry Hoberman, Tamas Waliczky; telematic art by Roy Ascott, Paul Sermon, Michael Bielický; Internet art by Vuk Ćosić, Jodi; virtual and immersive art by Jeffrey Shaw, Maurice Benayoun, Monika Fleischmann, Wolfgang Strauss and large scale urban installation by Rafael Lozano-Hemmer. In Geneva, the Centre pour l'Image Contemporaine or CIC coproduced with Centre Georges Pompidou from Paris and the Museum Ludwig in Cologne the first internet video archive of new media art.
Simultaneously advances in biotechnology have also allowed artists like Eduardo Kac to begin exploring DNA and genetics as a new art medium.
Influences on new media art have been the theories developed around interaction, hypertext, databases, and networks. Important thinkers in this regard have been Vannevar Bush and Theodor Nelson, whereas comparable ideas can be found in the literary works of Jorge Luis Borges, Italo Calvino, and Julio Cortázar.
In the book New Media Art, Mark Tribe and Reena Jana named several themes that contemporary new media art addresses, including computer art, collaboration, identity, appropriation, open sourcing, telepresence, surveillance, corporate parody, as well as intervention and hacktivism. In the book Postdigitale, Maurizio Bolognini suggested that new media artists have one common denominator, which is a self-referential relationship with the new technologies, the result of finding oneself inside an epoch-making transformation determined by technological development. Nevertheless, new media art does not appear as a set of homogeneous practices, but as a complex field converging around three main elements: 1) the art system, 2) scientific and industrial research, and 3) political-cultural media activism. There are significant differences between scientist-artists, activist-artists and technological artists closer to the art system, who not only have different training and technocultures, but have different artistic production. This should be taken into account in examining the several themes addressed by new media art.
Non-linearity can be seen as an important topic to new media art by artists developing interactive, generative, collaborative, immersive artworks like Jeffrey Shaw or Maurice Benayoun who explored the term as an approach to looking at varying forms of digital projects where the content relays on the user's experience. This is a key concept since people acquired the notion that they were conditioned to view everything in a linear and clear-cut fashion. Now, art is stepping out of that form and allowing for people to build their own experiences with the piece. Non-linearity describes a project that escape from the conventional linear narrative coming from novels, theater plays and movies. Non-linear art usually requires audience participation or at least, the fact that the "visitor" is taken into consideration by the representation, altering the displayed content. The participatory aspect of new media art, which for some artists has become integral, emerged from Allan Kaprow's Happenings and became with Internet, a significant component of contemporary art.
The inter-connectivity and interactivity of the internet, as well as the fight between corporate interests, governmental interests, and public interests that gave birth to the web today, fascinate and inspire a lot of current new media art.
Many new media art projects also work with themes like politics and social consciousness, allowing for social activism through the interactive nature of the media. New media art includes "explorations of code and user interface; interrogations of archives, databases, and networks; production via automated scraping, filtering, cloning, and recombinatory techniques; applications of user-generated content (UGC) layers; crowdsourcing ideas on social- media platforms; narrowcasting digital selves on "free" websites that claim copyright; and provocative performances that implicate audiences as participants".
One of the key themes in new media art is to create visual views of databases. Pioneers in this area include Lisa Strausfeld, Martin Wattenberg and Alberto Frigo. Database aesthetics holds at least two attractions to new media artists: formally, as a new variation on non-linear narratives; and politically as a means to subvert what is fast becoming a form of control and authority.
The emergence of 3D printing has introduced a new bridge to new media art, joining the virtual and the physical worlds. The rise of this technology has allowed artists to blend the computational base of new media art with the traditional physical form of sculpture. A pioneer in this field was artist Jonty Hurwitz who created the first known anamorphosis sculpture using this technique.
As the technologies used to deliver works of new media art such as film, tapes, web browsers, software and operating systems become obsolete, New Media art faces serious issues around the challenge to preserve artwork beyond the time of its contemporary production. Currently, research projects into New media art preservation are underway to improve the preservation and documentation of the fragile media arts heritage (see DOCAM - Documentation and Conservation of the Media Arts Heritage).
Methods of preservation exist, including the translation of a work from an obsolete medium into a related new medium, the digital archiving of media (see the Rhizome ArtBase, which holds over 2000 works, and the Internet Archive), and the use of emulators to preserve work dependent on obsolete software or operating system environments.
Around the mid-90s, the issue of storing works in digital form became a concern. Digital art such as moving images, multimedia, interactive programs, and computer-generated art has different properties than physical artwork such as oil paintings and sculptures. Unlike analog technologies, a digital file can be recopied onto a new medium without any deterioration of content. One of the problems with preserving digital art is that the formats continuously change over time. Former examples of transitions include that from 8-inch floppy disks to 5.25-inch floppies, 3-inch diskettes to CD-ROMs, and DVDs to flash drives. On the horizon is the obsolescence of flash drives and portable hard drives, as data is increasingly held in online cloud storage.
Museums and galleries thrive off of being able to accommodate the presentation and preservation of physical artwork. New media art challenges the original methods of the art world when it comes to documentation, its approach to collection and preservation. Technology continues to advance, and the nature and structure of art organizations and institutions will remain in jeopardy. The traditional roles of curators and artist are continually changing, and a shift to new collaborative models of production and presentation is needed.
In New Media programs, students are able to get acquainted with the newest forms of creation and communication. New Media students learn to identify what is or isn't "new" about certain technologies. Science and the market will always present new tools and platforms for artists and designers. Students learn how to sort through new emerging technological platforms and place them in a larger context of sensation, communication, production, and consumption.
When obtaining a bachelor's degree in New Media, students will primarily work through practice of building experiences that utilize new and old technologies and narrative. Through the construction of projects in various media, they acquire technical skills, practice vocabularies of critique and analysis, and gain familiarity with historical and contemporary precedents.
In the United States, many Bachelor's and Master's level programs exist with concentrations on Media Art, New Media, Media Design, Digital Media and Interactive Arts.
Leading art theorists and historians
Leading art theorists and historians in this field include Roy Ascott, Maurice Benayoun, Christine Buci-Glucksmann, Jack Burnham, Mario Costa, Edmond Couchot, Fred Forest, Oliver Grau, Margot Lovejoy, Dominique Moulon, Robert C. Morgan, Christiane Paul, Catherine Perret, Frank Popper, and Edward A. Shanken.
The term New Media Art is generally applied to disciplines such as:
- Artistic computer game modification
- ASCII art
- Bio Art
- Computer art
- Critical making
- Digital art
- Digital poetry
- Tradigital art
- Electronic art
- Experimental musical instrument building
- Evolutionary art
- Fax art
- Generative art
- Glitch art
- Information art
- Interactive art
- Kinetic art
- Light art
- Motion graphics
- Net art
- Performance art
- Radio art
- Robotic art
- Software art
- Sound art
- Systems art
- Telematic art
- Video art
- Video games
- Virtual art
- Andrea Ackerman
- Miguel Álvarez-Fernández
- Carlos Amorales
- Cory Arcangel
- Deborah Aschheim
- Roy Ascott
- Maurice Benayoun
- Wafaa Bilal
- Jeremy Blake
- Maurizio Bolognini
- Oleg Buryan
- Micha Cárdenas
- Janet Cardiff
- Brody Condon
- Petra Cortright
- Vuk Ćosić
- Beatriz da Costa
- Andrea Crespo
- Critical Art Ensemble
- Nick Crowe
- Sharon Daniel
- Liu Dao
- Char Davies
- Ronald Davis
- Heiko Daxl
- R. Luke DuBois
- Electronic Disturbance Theater
- Arthur Elsenaar
- David Em
- Ursula Endlicher
- Ken Feingold
- Anna Frants
- Mary Flanagan
- Floating Point Unit
- Peter Foldes
- Fred Forest
- Ingeborg Fülepp
- Rick Gibson
- Ken Goldberg
- Guillermo Gómez-Peña
- Phil Hansen
- Lynn Hershman
- Garnet Hertz
- Sam Heydt
- Perry Hoberman
- Tiffany Holmes
- Marc Horowitz
- G.H. Hovagimyan
- Jonty Hurwitz
- Ryoji Ikeda
- Toshio Iwai
- Eduardo Kac
- Allan Kaprow
- Mario Klingemann
- Knowbotic Research
- Aaron Koblin
- Myron Krueger
- Ryota Kuwakubo
- LaBeouf, Rönkkö & Turner
- Antoinette LaFarge
- Roy LaGrone
- Steve Lambert
- Marc Lee
- Golan Levin
- Olia Lialina
- Lin Hsin Hsin
- Marita Liulia
- Teddy Lo
- Rafael Lozano-Hemmer
- Garrett Lynch
- John Maeda
- Judy Malloy
- Sergio Maltagliati
- Michael Mandiberg
- Miltos Manetas
- Lev Manovich
- Cathy Marshall
- Eva and Franco Mattes
- Yucef Merhi
- Elle Mehrmand
- Bjørn Melhus
- Eric Millikin
- Christian Moeller
- Francesco Monico
- Manfred Mohr
- Joshua Mosley
- Leonel Moura
- Michael Naimark
- Mark Napier (artist)
- Joseph Nechvatal
- Kingsley Ng
- Carsten Nicolai
- Mendi & Keith Obadike
- Erwin Olaf
- Marisa Olson
- Anuska Oosterhuis
- Joseph Stanislaus Ostoja-Kotkowski
- Randall Packer
- Nam June Paik
- Zaven Paré
- Chiara Passa
- Eric Paulos
- Simon Penny
- Maja Petrić
- Dani Ploeger
- Jim Pomeroy
- Sabrina Raaf
- Melinda Rackham
- Ken Rinaldo
- David Rokeby
- Gustavo Romano
- Jason Salavon
- Daan Samson
- Antoine Schmitt
- Lillian Schwartz
- Paul Sermon
- Marie Sester
- Jeffrey Shaw
- Laila Shereen Sakr
- Alexei Shulgin
- Scott Snibbe
- Jonas Staal
- Stelarc (Stelios Arkadiou)
- System D-128
- Thomson & Craighead
- Elena Tejada-Herrera
- Kenneth Tin-Kin Hung
- Timo Toots
- Ryan Trecartin
- Amalia Ulman
- Camille Utterback
- Bill Viola
- VNS Matrix
- Wolf Vostell
- Tamás Waliczky
- Lee Walton
- Noah Wardrip-Fruin
- Martin Wattenberg
- Gillian Wearing
- Lee Wells
- Pedro Zaz
- Australian Network for Art and Technology
- Center for Art and Media Karlsruhe
- Centre pour l'Image Contemporaine
- Eyebeam Art and Technology Center
- Foundation for Art and Creative Technology
- Los Angeles Center for Digital Art (LACDA)
- Netherlands Media Art Institute
- NTT InterCommunication Center
- Rhizome (organization)
- School for Poetic Computation (SFPC)
- School of the Art Institute of Chicago
- Squeaky Wheel: Film and Media Arts Center
- V2 Institute for the Unstable Media
- Werkleitz Gesellschaft
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to New media art.|
- Aspect magazine
- Curatorial Resource for Upstart Media Bliss
- Culture jamming
- Digital art
- Digital media
- Digital puppetry
- Documentation and Conservation of the Media Arts Heritage
- Electronic art
- Electronic Language International Festival
- Expanded Cinema
- Experiments in Art and Technology
- Glitch art
- Interactive film
- Interactive media
- LA Freewaves
- New Epoch Notation Painting
- New media art festivals
- New media artist
- New media art journals
- New media art preservation
- Perpetual Art Machine
- Remix culture
This article includes a list of references, but its sources remain unclear because it has insufficient inline citations. (August 2009) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
- "Web Design & New Media". academyart.edu.
- Shanken, Edward A. "Artists in Industry and the Academy: Collaborative Research, Interdisciplinary Scholarship, and the Creation and Interpretation of Hybrid Forms" (PDF). Leonardo 38:5 (2005). pp. 415–18.
- "Contemporary Art and New Media: Toward a Hybrid Discourse?". Contemporary Art and New Media: Toward a Hybrid Discourse?.
- "Media Art Net - Vostell, Wolf: German View from the Black Room Cycle". medienkunstnetz.de.
- "Media Art Net - Vostell, Wolf: Television Décollage". medienkunstnetz.de.
- "La Plissure du Texte". 1904.cc. Archived from the original on 2015-04-02.
- "Nouveaux Media - New Media - Neue Medien". www.newmedia-art.org.
- Andreas Broeckmann, "Image, Process, Performance, Machine: Aspects of an Aesthetics of the Machinic", in Oliver Grau (ed.) (2007), Media Art Histories, Cambridge: MIT Press, ISBN 0-262-07279-3, pp. 204-205.
- Mark Tribe, Reena Jana (2007), New Media Art, Introduction, Rome: Taschen, ISBN 978-3-8228-2537-2
- Maurizio Bolognini (2008), Postdigitale (in Italian), Rome: Carocci Editore, ISBN 978-88-430-4739-0
- Catricalà, Valentino (2015). Media Art. Toward a new Definition of Arts in the Age of Technology. Gli Ori. ISBN 978- 88-7336-564-8.
- See also Maurizio Bolognini, "From interactivity to democracy. Towards a post-digital generative art", Artmedia X Proceedings. Paris, 2010.
- Dale Hudson and Patricia R. Zimmermann. (2015). Thinking Through Digital Media Transnational Environments and Locative Places. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. P. 1. ISBN 978-1137433626
- Bulajic, Viktorija Vesna (2007). Database aesthetics: art in the age of information overflow. University of Minnesota Press.
- Moulon, Dominique (2013). Contemporary new media art. Nouvelles éditions Scala.
- "Digital Rosetta Stone" (PDF). ercim.org.
- Rinehart, Richard. "Preserving the Rhizome ArtBase (report)". rhizome.org. Archived from the original on 2005-01-16.
- Rose, Frank (2016-10-21). "The Mission to Save Vanishing Internet Art". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2016-11-14.
- "Longevity of Electronic Art". besser.tsoa.nyu.edu. Retrieved 2017-12-07.
- New media in the white cube and beyond : curatorial models for digital art. Paul, Christiane. Berkeley: University of California Press. 2008. ISBN 9780520255975. OCLC 225871513.
- "The School of Art and Design - University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign". illinois.edu.
- "New Media Programs in the United States — Dr. Edgar Huang". www.iupui.edu.
- Wardrip-Fruin, Noah and Nick Montfort, ed. (2003). The New Media Reader. The MIT Press. ISBN 0-262-23227-8.
- Maurice Benayoun, The Dump, 207 Hypotheses for Committing Art, bilingual (English/French) Fyp éditions, France, July 2011, ISBN 978-2-916571-64-5
- Timothy Murray, Derrick de Kerckhove, Oliver Grau, Kristine Stiles, Jean-Baptiste Barrière, Dominique Moulon, Jean-Pierre Balpe, Maurice Benayoun Open Art, Nouvelles éditions Scala, 2011, French version, ISBN 978-2-35988-046-5
- Vannevar Bush (1945). "As We May Think" online at As We May Think – The Atlantic Monthly
- Roy Ascott (2003). Telematic Embrace: Visionary Theories of Art, Technology, and Consciousness (Ed.) Edward A. Shanken. Berkeley: University of California Press. ISBN 978-0-520-21803-1
- Barreto, Ricardo and Perissinotto, Paula “the_culture_of_immanence”, in Internet Art. Ricardo Barreto e Paula Perissinotto (orgs.). São Paulo, IMESP, 2002. ISBN 85-7060-038-0.
- Jorge Luis Borges (1941). "The Garden of Forking Paths." Editorial Sur.
- Nicolas Bourriaud, (1997) Relational Aesthetics, Dijon: Les Presses du Réel, 2002, orig. 1997
- Christine Buci-Glucksmann, "L’art à l’époque virtuel", in Frontières esthétiques de l’art, Arts 8, Paris: L’Harmattan, 2004
- Christine Buci-Glucksmann, La folie du voir: Une esthétique du virtuel, Galilée, 2002
- Valentino Catricalà, Media Art. Towards a New Definition of Arts in the Age of Technology. Siena: Gli Ori, 2015
- Sarah Cook & Beryl Graham, Rethinking Curating: Art After New Media, Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 2010. ISBN 978-0-262-01388-8.
- Sarah Cook & Beryl Graham, "Curating New Media", Art Monthly 261, November 2002. online at Art Monthly
- Sarah Cook, Verina Gfader, Beryl Graham & Axel Lapp, A Brief History of Curating New Media Art - Conversations with Curators, Berlin: The Green Box, 2010. ISBN 978-3-941644-20-5.
- Sarah Cook, Verina Gfader, Beryl Graham & Axel Lapp, A Brief History of Working with New Media Art - Conversations with Artists, Berlin: The Green Box, 2010. ISBN 978-3-941644-21-2.
- Fleischmann, Monika and Reinhard, Ulrike (eds.). Digital Transformations - Media Art as at the Interface between Art, Science, Economy and Society online at netzspannung.org, 2004, ISBN 3-934013-38-4
- Monika Fleischmann / Wolfgang Strauss (eds.) (2001). Proceedings of »CAST01//Living in Mixed Realities« Intl. Conf. On Communication of Art, Science and Technology, Fraunhofer IMK 2001, 401. ISSN 1618-1379 (Print), ISSN 1618-1387 (Internet).
- Gatti, Gianna Maria. (2010) The Technological Herbarium. Avinus Press, Berlin, 2010 (edited, translated from the Italian, and with a preface by Alan N. Shapiro). online at alan-shapiro.com
- Charlie Gere, (2002) Digital Culture, Reaktion ISBN 978-1-86189-143-3
- Charlie Gere, (2006) White Heat, Cold Logic: Early British Computer Art, co-edited with Paul Brown, Catherine Mason and Nicholas Lambert, MIT Press/Leonardo Books
- Graham, Philip Mitchell, New Epoch Art, InterACTA: Journal of the Art Teachers Association of Victoria, Published by ACTA, Parkville, Victoria, No 4, 1990, ISSN 0159-9135, Cited In APAIS. This database is available on the, Informit Online Internet Service or on CD-ROM, or on Australian Public Affairs - Full Text
- Oliver Grau (2003). Virtual Art: From Illusion to Immersion (Leonardo Book Series). Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press/Leonardo Books. ISBN 0-262-07241-6.
- Oliver Grau (2007). (Ed.) MediaArtHistories. Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press/Leonardo Books. ISBN 0-262-07279-3.
- Mark Hansen, (2004) New Philosophy for New Media (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press)
- Dick Higgins, ‘Intermedia’ (1966), reprinted in Donna De Salvo (ed.), Open Systems Rethinking Art c. 1970, London: Tate Publishing, 2005
- Lopes, Dominic McIver. (2009). A Philosophy of Computer Art. London: Routledge
- Lev Manovich (2001). The Language of New Media Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press/Leonardo Books. ISBN 0-262-63255-1
- Lev Manovich, Ten Key Texts on Digital Art: 1970-2000 Leonardo - Volume 35, Number 5, October 2002, pp. 567–569
- Christiane Paul, Challenges for a Ubiquitous Museum: Presenting and Preserving New Media
- Lev Manovich (2003. "New Media from Borges to HTML", The New Media Reader. MIT Press.
- Mondloch, Kate. Screens: Viewing Media Installation Art. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2010. ISBN 978-0-8166-6522-8
- Dominique Moulon, Tim Murray, Kristine Stiles, Derrick de Kerckhove, Oliver Grau Open Art, Maurice Benayoun, Nouvelles editions Scala, 2011, ISBN 978-2-35988-046-5
- Paul, Christiane (2003). Digital Art (World of Art series). London: Thames & Hudson. ISBN 0-500-20367-9.
- Robert C. Morgan, Commentaries on the New Media Arts Pasadena, CA: Umbrella Associates,1992
- Janet Murray (2003). "Inventing the Medium", The New Media Reader. MIT Press.
- Frank Popper (2007) From Technological to Virtual Art, MIT Press/Leonardo Books
- Frank Popper (1997) Art of the Electronic Age, Thames & Hudson
- Edward A. Shanken "Selected Writings on Art and Technology"
- Edward A. Shanken Art and Electronic Media. London: Phaidon, 2009. ISBN 978-0-7148-4782-5
- Mark Tribe and Reena Jana. New Media Art[permanent dead link]
- Rainer Usselmann, (2003) (PDF) "The Dilemma of Media Art: Cybernetic Serendipity at the ICA London", Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press/Leonardo Journal - Volume 36, Number 5, pp. 389–396
- Rainer Usselmann, (2002) "About Interface: Actualisation and Totality", University of Southampton
- Wands, Bruce (2006). Art of the Digital Age, London: Thames & Hudson. ISBN 0-500-23817-0.
- Whitelaw, Mitchell (2004). Metacreation: Art and Artificial Life Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press. ISBN 0-262-73176-2.
- Steve Dietz, Collecting New Media Art: Just Like Anything Else, Only Different
- Anne-Cécile Worms, (2008) Arts Numériques: Tendances, Artistes, Lieux et Festivals M21 Editions 2008 ISBN 2-916260-33-1.
- Youngblood, Gene (1970). Expanded Cinema. New York. E.P. Dutton & Company.
- (in Spanish) Juan Martín Prada, Prácticas artísticas e Internet en la época de las redes sociales, Editorial AKAL, Madrid, 2012, ISBN 978-84-460-3517-6
- New Media Faculty, (2011). "New Media", University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
- Hiekel, Jörn Peter (2009). Vernetzungen: Neue Musik im Spannungsfeld von Wissenschaft und Technik. Institut für Neue Musik und Musikerziehung Darmstadt.
- Bailey, Chris & Hazel Gardiner. (2010). Revisualizing Visual Culture. Surrey, UK: Ashgate Publishing.
- Jana, Reena and Mark Tribe. (2009). New Media Art. New York: Taschen.
- Dale Hudson and Patricia R. Zimmermann. (2009). “Taking Things Apart: Migratory Archives, Locative Media, and Micropublics.” Afterimage vol. 36 no. 4 (January/February), pp. 14–19.
- artists-with-/ Moss, Ceci. (2008). Thoughts on “New Media Artists v. Artists with Computers”. Rhizome
- Nechvatal, Joseph. (2013). Whither Art? David Joselit's Digital Art Problem. "Hyperallergic: Sensitive to Art & its Discontents."
- Joselit, David. (2012). After Art. Princeton: Princeton University Press. ISBN 9780691150444.
- Guertin, C. (2012). Digital prohibition: Piracy and authorship in new media art. London: Continuum International Pub. Group. ISBN 9781441106100.
- Catricalà, Valentino (2013). "Come l’avanguardia inventò il futuro. L’Optofono di Raoul Hausman, la 'visione elettromeccanica' di Lissitzky e le forme dell’energia", in "Imago. Rivista di studi sul cinema e i media", n. 7-8. (pp. 277–294). ISSN 2038-5536 
- Dale Hudson and Patricia R. Zimmermann. (2015). Thinking Through Digital Media Transnational Environments and Locative Places. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN 978-1137433626 companion website with links to projects
- Janez Strehovec (2016). Text as Ride. Electronic Literature and New Media Art. Morgentown: West Virginia University Press (Computing Literature book series)-