There are many reasons that research is being done on the selective removal of memories. Potential patients for this research include patients suffering from psychiatric disorders such as post traumatic stress disorder, or substance use disorder, among others.
Memory erasure has been shown to be possible in some experimental conditions; some of the techniques currently being investigated are: drug-induced amnesia, selective memory suppression, destruction of neurons, interruption of memory, reconsolidation, and the disruption of specific molecular mechanisms.
- 1 Early history
- 2 Potential patients
- 3 Current research
- 4 Ethics
- 5 In fiction
- 6 References
Research focused on gaining a better understanding of what memories are has been going on for many years, in this way so has research in memory erasure. The basis for the recent history for memory erasure has been focused on determining how the brain actively keeps memories stored and retrieves them. There have been several instances where researchers found drugs that when applied to certain areas of the brain, usually the amygdala, have relative success in being able to erase some memories. As early as 2009 researchers were able to trace and destroy neurons involved in supporting the specific type of memory that they were trying to erase. This caused the erasure of the target memory.
Aside from the biotechnology approach to studying memory, research in psychiatry on how memories work has also been going on for several years. There has been some studies that show that some behavioral therapy can erase bad memories. Although there has been some evidence that psychodynamic therapy and other energy techniques can help with forgetting memories among other psychiatric issues there is no proven therapeutic approach for trying to erase bad memories.
There are several different types of possible patients that have the potential to draw great benefit from the selective memory erasure; these include people suffering from drug addiction, or posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). PTSD patients may include war veterans, people who witnessed horrific events, victims of violent crimes and many other possibly traumatic events. These potential patients have unwanted memories that can be absolutely devastating to their daily lives and cause them to not be able to function properly.
Along with patients suffering from these severe circumstances the idea of selective memory erasure is a very attractive idea for many. Thus making the practical use of this technology something that could be used by many people.
Different types of memories
There are three main types of memories: sensory memory, short-term memory, and long-term memory. Sensory memory in short is the ability to hold sensory information for a short period of time, for example looking at an object and being able to remember what it looked like moments after. Short-term memory is memory that allows a person to recall a short period of time; this can be a few seconds to a minute. Short-term memory allows people to remember what happened during that short time span without actually practicing the memory. Long-term memory has a much larger capacity than the prior two and actually stores information from both these types of memories to create a long lasting and large memory. Long-term memory is the largest target for research involving selective memory erasure.
Within long-term memory there are also different types of long-term memories. Implicit memory is one type of long-term memory that is generally described as the ability to remember how to use objects or specific movements of the body (e.g. using a hammer). Another type of long-term memory, explicit memory, refers to memories that can be consciously drawn upon by a person to remember. Explicit memory can be split into further subcategories, one being episodic memory, which is the memory of specific events and the information surrounding it, as well as semantic memory, which is the ability to remember factual information (e.g. what numbers mean).
A type of memory of main concern for memory erasure are emotional memories. These memories often involve several different aspects of information in them that can come from a variety of the different categories of memories mentioned above. These emotional memories are very powerful memories and can have very strong physiological effects on a person. An example of an emotional memory can be found in patients suffering from PTSD, for these patients a traumatic event has left a lasting emotional memory that can have powerful effects on a person even without them consciously retrieving the memory.
Drug-induced amnesia is the idea of selectively losing or inhibiting the creation of unwanted memories using drugs. Amnesia can be used as a treatment for patients who have experienced psychological trauma or for medical procedures where full anesthesia is not an option. Drug-induced amnesia is also a side-effect of other drugs like alcohol and rohypnol.
There are other drugs that also can cause their users to be put in an amnesic state, where they experience some type of amnesia because of their use. Examples of these drugs include Triazolam, Midazolam and Diazepam.
Disruption of molecular mechanisms
There is a growing amount of information that has shown that memory depends largely on the brain's synaptic plasticity, with a large part of this being dependent on its ability to maintain long-term potentiation (LTP). Studies on LTP have also started to indicate that there are several molecular mechanisms that may be at the basis of memory storage. Thus a more recent approach to erasing memories and the associations the brain makes with objects is disrupting specific molecular mechanisms in the brain that are actively keeping memories active.
Recovering methamphetamine (METH) addicts have reported that the sight of certain objects such as a lighter, gum or drug paraphernalia can cause massive cravings that can sometimes lead to a break in their mental strength and cause them to relapse. This indicates that long-term memories can be called upon by various different associations that were made with the memory without the conscious effort of the person. With an increasing belief that memories are largely supported by functional and structural plasticity deriving from F-actin polymerization in postsynaptic dendritic spines at excitatory synapses. Recent research has been done to target this F-actin polymerization by using direct actin depolymerization or a myosin II inhibitor to disrupt the polymerized F-actin associated with METH memory associations. The study indicated types of associations can be disrupted days to weeks after consolidation. Although the depolymerization techniques had no effect on food reward based associations or shock based associations the results demonstrate the idea that METH-associated memories' actin cytoskeleton is constantly changing making it uniquely sensitive to depolymerization during the maintenance phase. This is some of the first evidence showing that memories made with different associations are actively maintained using different molecular substrates. These results also show that the actin cytoskeleton may be a promising target for selective disruption of unwanted long-term memories.
Selective memory suppression
Selective memory suppression is the idea that someone can consciously block an unwanted memory. There are many different therapeutic techniques or training that has been done to test this idea with some success. Many of these techniques focus on blocking the retrieval of a memory using different suppression techniques to slowly teach the brain to suppress the memory. Although some of these techniques have been useful for some people it has not been shown to be a clear cut solution to forgetting memories. Because these memories are not truly erased but merely suppressed the question of how permanent the solution is and what actually happens to the memories can be troubling for some.
Selective memory suppression is also something that can occur without a person being consciously aware of suppressing the creation and retrieval of unwanted memories. When this occurs without the person knowing it is usually referred to as memory inhibition; the memory itself is called a repressed memory.
Interruption of memory reconsolidation
One of the ways scientists have attempted to erase these memories through suppression is by interrupting the reconsolidation of a memory. Memory consolidation of a memory is when a person recalls a memory, usually a fearful one, it becomes susceptible to alteration, and then gets stored again. This has led many researchers to believe that this time period is the best time for memories to be altered or erased. Studies have shown that through behavioral training results showed that they were able to erase memories by tampering with memories during the reconsolidation phase.
Destruction of neurons
With evidence showing that different memories excite different neurons or system of neurons in the brain the technique of destroying select neurons in the brain to erase specific memories is also being researched. Studies have started to investigate the possibility of using distinct toxins along with biotechnology that allows the researchers to see which areas of the brain are being used during the reward learning process of making a memory to destroy target neurons. In a paper published in 2009, authors showed that neurons in the lateral amygdala that had a higher level of cyclic adenosine monophosphate response element-binding protein (CREB) were activated primarily over other neurons by fear memory expression. This indicated to them that these neurons were directly involved in the making of the memory trace for that fear memory. They then proceeded to train mice using auditory fear training to produce a fear memory. They proceeded to check which of the neurons were overexpressing CREB and then, using a inducible diphtheria-toxin strategy, they destroyed those neurons, resulting in persistent and strong memory erasure of the fear memory.
Due to the lack of understanding of the brain this technique of destroying neurons may have a much larger effect on the patient than just the removal of the intended memories. Due to this complex nature of the brain treatment that would stun the neurons instead of destroying them could be another approach that could be taken.
Emotional Freedom Techniques
Emotional Freedom Techniques (EFT) are self-help techniques that do not involve any medication. They are designed to help erase traumatic memories or help relieve the user of any emotional angst they may have. There is no quality evidence for the effectiveness of EFT beyond placebo.
As with most new technologies the idea of being able to erase memories comes with many ethical questions. One ethical question that arises is the idea that although there are some extremely painful memories that some people (for example PTSD patients) would like to be rid of, not all unpleasant memories are bad. The ability to soften or erase memories could have drastic effects on how society functions. The ability to remember unpleasant effects from one's past has a huge impact on the future actions they may take. Remembering and learning from past mistakes is crucial in the emotional development of a person and helps to ensure they do not repeat previous errors. The ability to erase memory could also have a massive impact on the law. When it comes to determining the outcome of a trial, the ability to modify memory could have a massive impact on the judicial system. Another ethical question that arises is to how the government will use this technology and what restrictions would need to be put in place. Some worry that if soldiers can go into battle knowing that the memories created during that time period can simply be erased they may not uphold military morale and standards.
Memory erasure has also been a common topic of interest in science fiction and other fiction. Several notable comics, TV shows and movies feature mindwipes, including Telefon, Total Recall, Men in Black, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, The Bourne Identity, and Dollhouse. Novels that feature memory erasure include The Invincible by Stanisław Lem and some of the Harry Potter novels (including Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets) by J. K. Rowling, also The Giver by Lois Lowry deals with this subject. Several works by Philip K. Dick are about mindwipes, including "Paycheck" and "We Can Remember It for You Wholesale" (inspiration for Total Recall).
- Young, Erica J.; Aceti, Massimiliano; Griggs, Erica M.; Fuchs, Rita A.; Zigmond, Zachary; Rumbaugh, Gavin; Miller, Courtney A. (2013). "Selective, Retrieval-Independent Disruption of Methamphetamine-Associated Memory by Actin Depolymerization". Biological Psychiatry. 75 (2): 96–104. doi:10.1016/j.biopsych.2013.07.036.
- Chan, Jason C. K.; Lapaglia, Jessica A. (2013). "Impairing existing declarative memory in humans by disrupting reconsolidation". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 110 (23): 9309–13. doi:10.1073/pnas.1218472110. PMC . PMID 23690586.
- Han, Jin-Hee; Kushner, Steven A. K; Yiu, Adelaide P.; Hsiang, Hwa-Lin; Buch, Thorsten; Waisman, Ari; Bontempi, Bruno; Neve, Rachael L.; Frankland, Paul W.; Josselyn, Sheena A. (2009). "Selective Erasure of a Fear Memory". Science. 323 (5920): 1492–6. doi:10.1126/science.1164139. PMID 19286560.
- Agren, Thomas; Engman, Jonas; Frick, Andreas; Björkstrand, Johannes; Larsson, Elna-Marie; Furmark, Tomas; Fredrikson, Mats (2012). "Disruption of Reconsolidation Erases a Fear Memory Trace in the Human Amygdala". Science. 337 (6101): 1550–2. doi:10.1126/science.1223006. PMID 22997340. Lay summary – Psychology Today (October 7, 2012).
- Feinstein, D (2008). "Energy Psychology: A Review of the Preliminary Evidence". Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training. 45 (2): 199–213. doi:10.1037/0033-3184.108.40.206. PMID 22122417.
- Foa, Edna B.; Gillihan, Seth J.; Bryant, Richard A. (2013). "Challenges and Successes in Dissemination of Evidence-Based Treatments for Posttraumatic Stress: Lessons Learned from Prolonged Exposure Therapy for PTSD". Psychological Science in the Public Interest. 14 (2): 65–111. doi:10.1177/1529100612468841. Lay summary – Association for Psychological Science (April 11, 2013).
- Caplan, Arthur (June 18, 2013). "Deleting Memories". MIT Technology Review. Retrieved 27 November 2013.
- "Long-Term Memory". PositScience. Posit Science.
- LeDoux, Joseph (2007). "Emotional mempory". Scholarpedia. 2 (7): 1806. doi:10.4249/scholarpedia.1806.
- "Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)". National Institute of Mental Health. National Institutes of Health.
- Drug-induced amnesia
- Jain, K K. "Drug-Induced Memory Disturbance". Neurology Medlink. Retrieved 27 November 2013.
- Martin, S. J.; Grimwood, P. D.; Morris, R. G. M. (2000). "Synaptic Plasticity and Memory: An Evaluation of the Hypothesis". Annual Review of Neuroscience. 23 (1): 649–711. doi:10.1146/annurev.neuro.23.1.649. PMID 10845078.
- Abel, Ted; Lattal, K.Matthew (2001). "Molecular mechanisms of memory acquisition, consolidation and retrieval". Current Opinion in Neurobiology. 11 (2): 180–7. doi:10.1016/S0959-4388(00)00194-X. PMID 11301237.
- Roth, Tania L.; Roth, Eric D.; Sweatt, J. David (2010). "Epigenetic regulation of genes in learning and memory". Essays in Biochemistry. 48 (1): 263–74. doi:10.1042/bse0480263. PMID 20822498.
- Trei, Lisa (January 8, 2004). "Psychologists offer proof of brain's ability to suppress memories". Stanford Report. Retrieved 27 November 2013.
- Anderson, Michael C.; Levy, Benjamin J. (2009). "Suppressing Unwanted Memories". Current Directions in Psychological Science. 18 (4): 189–94. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8721.2009.01634.x.
- Bjork, R.A. (1989). "Retrieval inhibition as an adaptive mechanism in human memory" (PDF). Varieties of memory and consciousness: 309–330.
- Tronson, Natalie C.; Taylor, Jane R. (2007). "Molecular mechanisms of memory reconsolidation". Nature Reviews Neuroscience. 8 (4): 262–75. doi:10.1038/nrn2090. PMID 17342174.
- Bardin, Jon (September 20, 2012). "Researchers erase fear memories in people through behavior alone". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 27 November 2013.
- Byrne, John. "Introduction to Neurons and Neuronal Networks". Neuroscience Online. Retrieved 27 November 2013.
- Iverson, Margot (22 November 1999). "Killing Pain by Killing Neurons". Science.
- Chopra, Deepak. "The Gold Standard for EFT".
- Liao, Matthew; Sandberg, Anders; Savulescu, Julian (November 3, 2008). "Should We Be Erasing Memories?". Practical Ethics. Retrieved 27 November 2013.
- May, Kate. "9 classic movies about memory manipulation, and how they inspired real neuroscience". TED Blog. Wordpress.com.