Mobile phones on aircraft
||The examples and perspective in this article deal primarily with the United States and do not represent a worldwide view of the subject. (March 2014)|
In the U.S., Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regulations prohibit the use of mobile phones aboard aircraft in flight. Contrary to popular misconception, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) does not actually prohibit the use of personal electronic devices (including cell phones) on aircraft. Paragraph (b)(5) of 14 CFR 91.21 leaves it up to the airlines to determine if devices can be used in flight, allowing use of "Any other portable electronic device that the operator of the aircraft has determined will not cause interference with the navigation or communication system of the aircraft on which it is to be used." In Europe, regulations and technology have allowed the limited introduction of the use of passenger mobile phones on some commercial flights, and elsewhere in the world many airlines are moving towards allowing mobile phone use in flight. Many airlines still do not allow the use of mobile phones on aircraft. Those that do often ban the use of mobile phones during take-off and landing.
On the one hand many passengers are pressing the airlines and government to allow and deregulate mobile phone use, while some airlines, under the pressure of competition, are also pushing for deregulation or seeking new technology which could solve the present problems. On the other hand, official aviation agencies and safety boards are resisting any relaxation of the present safety rules unless and until it can be conclusively shown that it would be safe to do so. There are both technical and social factors which make the issues more complex than a simple discussion of safety versus hazard.
- 1 The debate on safety
- 2 The debate on other issues
- 3 Current status
- 4 Technical discussion
- 5 See also
- 6 References
- 7 External links
The debate on safety
In the United States, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) restricts cell phone usage on aircraft in order to prevent disruption to cellular towers on the ground. As mentioned above, the FAA allows the in-flight use of wireless devices but only after the airline has determined that the device will not interfere with aircraft communication or navigation.
One report asserts correlations between the use of mobile phones and other portable electronic devices in flight, and various problems with avionics. Another study concluded that some "portable electronic devices" used in the cabin can exceed the aircraft manufacturer's permissible emission levels for safety with regard to some avionics, while they were unsuccessful in duplicating any of the errors suspected to be caused by PED use in controlled lab conditions.
Since these regulations were originally imposed by various international aviation agencies, ultra-low-power devices, such as picocells, have been developed. Reasons for this include improved security, reduction of interference, reduced health risks and to allow safe in-flight use of mobile phones. Many airline companies have now added such equipment to their aircraft. More are expected to do so in the coming years.
Electromagnetic interference to aircraft systems is the most common argument offered for banning mobile phones (and other passenger electronic devices) on planes. Theoretically, active radio transmitters such as mobile phones, walkie–talkies, portable computers or gaming devices may interfere with the aircraft. Non-transmitting electronic devices also emit electromagnetic radiation, although typically at a lower power level, and could also theoretically affect the aircraft electronics. Collectively, any of these may be referred to as portable electronic devices (PEDs).
A NASA publication details the fifty most recent reports to the Aviation Safety Reporting System (ASRS) regarding "avionics problems that may result from the influence of passenger electronic devices." The nature of these reports varies widely. Some merely describe passengers' interactions with flight crews when asked to stop using an electronic device. Other reports amount to crews reporting an anomaly experienced at the same time a passenger was witnessed using a mobile phone. A few reports state that interference to aircraft systems was observed to appear and disappear as that particular suspect device was turned on and off. One entry in the ASRS, designated ACN: 440557, reports a clear link where a passenger's DVD player induced a 30-degree error in the display of the aircraft's heading, each time the player was switched on. However, this report dates back to 1999 and involves a Boeing 727, an old type of aircraft that is no longer in use by airlines today.
...our research has found that these items can interrupt the normal operation of key cockpit instruments, especially Global Positioning System (GPS) receivers, which are increasingly vital to safe landings. Two different studies by NASA further support the idea that passengers' electronic devices dangerously produce interference in a way that reduces the safety margins for critical avionics systems.
There is no smoking gun to this story: there is no definitive instance of an air accident known to have been caused by a passenger's use of an electronic device. Nonetheless, although it is impossible to say that such use has contributed to air accidents in the past, the data also make it impossible to rule it out completely. More importantly, the data support a conclusion that continued use of portable RF-emitting devices such as cell phones will, in all likelihood, someday cause an accident by interfering with critical cockpit instruments such as GPS receivers. This much is certain: there exists a greater potential for problems than was previously believed.
A 2000 study by the British Civil Aviation Authority found that a mobile phone, when used near the cockpit or other avionics equipment location, will exceed safety levels for older equipment (compliant with 1984 standards). Such equipment is still in use, even in new aircraft. Therefore, the report concludes, the current policy, which restricts the use of mobile phones on all aircraft while the engines are running, should remain in force.
Critics of the ban doubt that small battery-powered devices would have any significant influence on a commercial jetliner's shielded electronic systems. Safety researchers Tekla S. Perry and Linda Geppert point out that shielding and other protections degrade with increasing age, cycles of use, and even some maintenance procedures, as is also true of the shielding in PEDs, including mobile phones.
Several reports argue both sides of the issue in the same article; on the one hand they highlight the lack of definite evidence of mobile phones causing significant interference, while on the other hand they point out that caution in maintaining restrictions on using mobile phones and other PEDs in flight is the safer course to take.
The debate on other issues
Competition for airlines' in-flight phone service
Skeptics of the ban have suggested that the airlines support the ban because they do not want passengers to have an alternative to the in-flight phone service such as GTE's Airfone. Andy Plews a spokesman for UAL's United Airlines was quoted as saying "We don't believe it's a good safety issue"..."We'd like people to use the air phones." Such services are much more expensive than mobile phone services and provide slow data rates at a similarly high price. In general the airlines have had little success in selling these services and the in-flight phone equipment has disappeared from most U.S. domestic flights.
In flight technology
On October 31, 2013 the FAA issued a press release entitled "FAA to Allow Airlines to Expand Use of Personal Electronics" in which it announced that "airlines can safely expand passenger use of Portable Electronic Devices (PEDs) during all phases of flight." This new policy does not include cell phone use in flight, because, as the press release states, "The FAA did not consider changing the regulations regarding the use of cell phones for voice communications during flight because the issue is under the jurisdiction of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC)."
This FAA press release was quickly followed up by an FCC press release entitled "Chairman Wheeler Statement on In-Flight Mobile Services Proposal" in which FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler states, "modern technologies can deliver mobile services in the air safely and reliably, and the time is right to review our outdated and restrictive rules." This has led to media speculation that the use of cell phones for voice communication on board an aircraft in flight will soon be allowed.
Some airlines have installed technologies to allow phones to be connected within the airplane as it flies. Such systems were tested on scheduled flights from 2006 and in 2008 several airlines started to allow in-flight use of mobile phones. Some airlines that are installing the equipment are also considering the issue of "phone-free zones" and "quiet time" on long flights.
Status of specific regions and individual airlines
- Emirates Airline
- European services
Since 26 August 2014 Qantas permits mobile phones (and other portable electronic devices weighing less than 1 kg) to be switched on during the entire flight, if the devices are in flight mode while on board the aircraft. Jetstar (owned by Qantas) adopted the same arrangements on 30 August 2014.
On 30 August 2006 the Irish airline Ryanair announced that it would introduce a facility to allow passengers to use their mobile phones in-flight. This service started on 19 February 2009 with 20 of their Dublin based aircraft.
- Turkish Airlines
- Mobile phones on corporate jets
- United Kingdom
On 18 October 2007 the Office of Communications published proposals for the technical and authorisational approach that would be adopted to allow this for European GSM users on the 1800 MHz band on UK registered aircraft. and on 26 March 2008 Ofcom approved the use of mobile phone-supporting picocells aboard aircraft in the United Kingdom. Airline companies will have to first equip the aircraft with picocells and apply for licences.
Regulations and practice in the United States
To prevent disruption to the cellular phone network from the effects of fast-moving cell phones at altitude (see Technical discussion, below), the FCC has banned the use of mobile phones on all aircraft in flight. The FCC did, however, allocate spectrum in the 450 MHz and 800 MHz frequency bands for use by equipment designed and tested as "safe for air-to-ground service" and these systems use far more widely separated ground stations than standard cellular systems. In the 450 MHz band co-channel assignments are at least 497 miles apart and in the 800 MHz band only specific sites were authorized by the FCC. The 450 MHz service is limited to "general aviation" users, usually corporate jets, while the 800 MHz spectrum can be used by airliners as well as for general aviation. The 450 MHz spectrum is named AGRAS while the name of the 800 MHz service is under review following an auction of the spectrum in 2006.
The FAA in 14 C.F.R § 91.21 prohibits the use of portable electronic devices, including mobile phones, for all commercial flights and for those private flights being made under instrument flight rules (IFR). It does allow that the airline (or, for privately operated aircraft, the pilot) can make an exception to this rule if the operator deems that device safe. This effectively gives the airline, or the private pilot, the final word as to what devices may safely be used aboard an aircraft as far as the FAA is concerned although the FCC restriction still applies.
- Note that for aircraft operated by an airline the pilot is not considered the "operator" and cannot legally allow exceptions to the airline's restrictions although the pilot may dictate additional restrictions.
On February 11, 2014, the House Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure approved the Prohibiting In-Flight Voice Communications on Mobile Wireless Devices Act. The bill would forbid airline passengers from talking on mobile phones during a flight. In September 2014, bipartisan group of lawmakers opposed the FCC ending ban on mobile phones aboard, citing safety as one of the main concerns.
Regulatory status in Europe
|This section requires expansion. (January 2015)|
A few U.S. airlines have announced plans to install new technology on aircraft which would allow mobile phones to be used on aircraft, pending approval by the FCC and the FAA. This method is similar to that used in some cars on the German ICE train. The aircraft would carry a device known as a picocell. A picocell acts as a miniature base station (like a cellphone tower) communicating with cellphones within the aircraft and relaying the signals to either satellites or a terrestrial-based system. The picocell will be designed and maintained for full compatibility with the aircraft avionics. Communication between the picocell and the rest of the telephone network will be on separate frequencies that do not interfere with either the cellular system or the aircraft's avionics, similarly to the on–board proprietary phone systems already aboard many commercial aircraft. Since the picocell's antennas within the aircraft would be very close to the passengers and inside the aircraft's metal shell both the picocell's and the cell phones' output power could be reduced to very low levels, which would reduce the risk of interference. Such systems have been tested on a few flights within the United States under a waiver from the FCC.
ARINC and Telenor have formed a joint venture company to offer such a service aboard commercial aircraft. The cell phone calls are routed via satellite to the ground network and an on-board EMI screening system prevents the cell phones from attempting to contact ground-based networks.
These systems are comparatively easy to implement for customers in most of the world where GSM phones operating on one of just two bands are the norm. The multitude of incompatible mobile phone systems in the United States and some other countries makes the situation more difficult — it is not clear if the onboard repeaters will be compatible with all of the different cell-phone protocols (TDMA, GSM, CDMA, iDen) and their respective providers.
The U.S. Federal Communications Commission (FCC) currently prohibits the use of mobile phones aboard any aircraft in flight. The reason given is that cell phone systems depend on channel reuse (Frequency (or channel) reuse allows for a dramatic increase in the number of customers that can be served (capacity) within a geographic area on a limited amount of radio spectrum (limited number of radio channels)), and operating a phone at an altitude may violate the fundamental assumptions that allow channel reuse to work.
- "FCC 47 Part 22.925". www.ecfr.gov. Retrieved 2014-08-28. Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; name "FCC_Cellban01" defined multiple times with different content (see the help page).
- 14 Code of Federal Regulations 91.21 . Retrieved August 21, 2009.
- Qatar Flies First B787 with Inflight Connectivity Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; name "OnAirAirfax" defined multiple times with different content (see the help page).
- Sherr, Lynn; Chris Kilmer (2007-12-07). "Cell Phones Are Dangerous in Flight: Myth, or Fact?". ABC News. Retrieved 2010-06-18.
- "In flight phone-free zone may end". CNN. October 3, 2004. Retrieved January 10, 2013.
- Cauley, Leslie (2005-06-16). "Cingular backs air cell ban". USA Today. Retrieved 2010-05-12.
- "Wireless Devices on Airplanes". fcc.gov. Retrieved 2012-01-19.
- "22.925 Prohibition on airborne operation of cellular telephones.". Code of Federal Regulations, Title 47. National Archives and Records Administration. Retrieved 2012-01-19.
Cellular telephones installed in or carried aboard airplanes, balloons or any other type of aircraft must not be operated while such aircraft are airborne (not touching the ground).
- "Interference from Electronic Devices". Aero (Boeing) (10). March 2000. Retrieved 2010-06-18.
- NASA ASRS Database Report Set Passenger Electronic Devices (PDF)
- NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System Case Number 440557 (June 1999) ASRS Case 440557
- IEEE Spectrum (March 2006). "Unsafe At Any Airspeed?"
- Civil Aviation Authority (May 2, 2000). Interference Levels In Aircraft at Radio Frequencies used by Portable Telephones (PDF)
- BBC News (July 20, 1999). "Can Mobile Phones Bring Down Planes?"
- "Mobile phone interference with plane instruments: Myth or reality?". EDN network. September 11, 2012. Retrieved November 29, 2014.
- "Airlines ban mobile phones – but why?". ZDNet UK. October 6, 1999. Retrieved January 10, 2013.
- "FAA to Allow Airlines to Expand Use of Personal Electronics" (Press release). Federal Aviation Administration. October 31, 2013. Retrieved November 11, 2013.
- "Chairman Wheeler Statement on In-Flight Mobile Services Proposal" (Press release). Federal Communications Commission. November 21, 2013. Retrieved November 22, 2013.
- Wall Street Journal (November 22, 2013) U.S. to Consider Cellphone Use on Planes
- "Emirates offers first mobile phone service onboard A380 Aircraft" (Press release). Emirates. October 4, 2012. Retrieved January 10, 2013.
- Boynton, Christine (May 29, 2012). "Virgin Atlantic to offer AeroMobile connectivity". Air Transport World. Retrieved January 10, 2013.
- "Inflight Communications". Qantas. Retrieved May 17, 2015.
- "Qantas, Virgin Australia allow gate-to-gate gadgets". Australian Business Traveller. Retrieved May 17, 2015.
- "Jetstar to allow gate-to-gate iPads, Kindles, smartphones". Australian Business Traveller. Retrieved May 17, 2015.
- "RTÉ Business: Ryanair signs OnAir deal for in-flight mobiles". Rte.ie. 2006-08-30. Retrieved 2010-06-18.
- "News : Launch of Europe's 1st Fleet Wide Inflight Mobile Phone Service". Ryanair.com. 2006-11-06. Retrieved 2010-06-18.
- "IFExpress Special Edition". Airfax.com. 2009-03-31. Retrieved 2010-06-18.
- "Mobile Communications onboard Aircraft – Consultation on the introduction of mobile services on aircraft" (PDF). Office of Communications. October 18, 2007.[dead link]
- "Mobile phone use backed on planes". BBC News. October 18, 2007. Retrieved January 10, 2013.
- "Approval for mobiles on aircraft". BBC News. 2008-03-26. Retrieved 2008-10-07.
- Enabling mobile phone use on aircraft, Office of Communications, 2008-03-26, retrieved 2013-06-15
- 14 Code of Federal Regulations 91.21 . Retrieved August 21, 2009.
- Martin, Aaron. "Committee approves bill that would ban in-flight calls". Ripon Advance. 2014-02-13. (Retrieved 2014-02-14).
- Krasny, Ros. "U.S. lawmakers urge continued ban on in-flight cellphone calls". Reuters. Retrieved 22 September 2014.
- Isidore, Chris; Senior, /Money (2004-12-09). "Cell phone calls in flight?". CNN. Retrieved 2010-05-12.
- Isidore, Chris; Senior, /Money (2004-12-14). "FCC eyes in-flight cell phones, Web". CNN. Retrieved 2010-05-12.
- "mobile phones on planes . AeroMobile". Aeromobile.net. Retrieved 2010-06-18.
- 47 C.F.R. § 22.925 Prohibition on airborne operation of cellular telephones.. Retrieved August 21, 2009.
- Study: Up To 15 Phones Are Left On During Every Flight
- Study: In-flight cell calls pose risk to planes
- 'Hello? I'm on the plane': Ryanair passengers will be able to use mobiles on board – at a price
- 47 CFR § 22.925: Prohibition on airborne operation of cellular telephones