Montaillou (book)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Montaillou
Montaillou.jpg
Author Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie
Original title Montaillou, village occitan de 1294 à 1324
Translator Barbara Bray
Subject Catharism, history from below, Montaillou
Genre History, Nonfiction
Published 1975
Published in English
1978

Montaillou (French: Montaillou, village occitan de 1294 à 1324) is a book by the French historian Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie, first published in 1975. It was first translated into English in 1978 by Barbara Bray, and has been subtitled The Promised Land of Error and Cathars and Catholics in a French Village.

Montaillou was Ladurie's "most important and popular work".[1] Ladurie used the inquisitorial records of Jacques Fournier to reconstruct the lives of the inhabitants of Montaillou in the Ariège (at the time, the county of Foix).[2] The work was part of the historical anthropology of the Annales school.

Summary[edit]

Montaillou examines the lives and beliefs of the villagers of Montaillou, a small village in the Pyrenees with only around 250 inhabitants, at the beginning of the fourteenth century. It is largely based on the Fournier Register, a set of records from the Inquisition which investigated and attempted to suppress the spread of Catharism in the Ariège from 1318 to 1325.

The work is in two parts. The first explores the physical world of the inhabitants of Montaillou, telling the stories of Pierre and Bernard Clergue, two of the most powerful men in Montaillou, and the shepherd Pierre Maury. The second explores the beliefs of the residents of Montaillou: what Annales historians called their mentalité.

Historiography[edit]

Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie is most associated with the Annales School of French historiography, and in the English-speaking world he is one of the best-known Annales historians.[3]

Montaillou has been described as a work of history from below.[4] In its use of records of interrogations as its primary source, it has also been seen as having links with oral history.[5]

Montaillou is unusual for its use of a single source, the inquisition register, for so much of the work.[6]

Montaillou has been considered a precursor to microhistory.[7]

Reception[edit]

Montaillou was much more successful than either Ladurie or his publishers had anticipated, selling more than 250,000 copies and being translated into multiple languages.[8] It received praise from professional historians and the general public alike.[9] When the book was published, it was widely described as a masterpiece of social history.[10] It has been described as a landmark in the genre of history from below.[11]

Reviewers considered that Montaillou was "by far one of the finest historical works of the decade",[12] and one of the most remarkable works of French history ever.[13]

However, despite its influence, Ladurie's history has been criticised by many reviewers. Ladurie's use of the Fournier Register has been challenged as being insufficiently critical.[14] Reviewers such as Cynthia Hay have written about the challenges of using oral evidence, especially oral evidence given many years after the event in question, as a source, despite Ladurie's rejection of the idea that the evidence might not be reliable.[15] David Herlihy has also criticised the translations of the Register given in Montaillou, which he said were often paraphrased, sometimes misleadingly, rather than direct translations.[16]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Huges-Warrington, Marnie (2000). Fifty Key Thinkers on History. London: Routledge. p. 197. 
  2. ^ "Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie, Montaillou". 
  3. ^ Herlihy, David (1979). "Review: Ladurie, Montaillou". Social History. 4 (3): 517. 
  4. ^ Sharpe, Jim (1991). "History from Below". In Burke, Peter. New Perspectives on Historical Writing. Cambridge: Polity Press. p. 29. 
  5. ^ Hay, Cynthia (1979). "Review: Ladurie, Montaillou". Oral History. 7 (2): 71. 
  6. ^ "Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie, Montaillou: Language and Sources". 
  7. ^ Tristano, Richard M. (1996). "Microhistory and Holy Family Parish: Some Historical Considerations". U.S. Catholic Historian. 14 (3): 26. 
  8. ^ "Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie, une vie avec l'histoire". 
  9. ^ Hay, Cynthia (1979). "Review: Ladurie, Montaillou". Oral History. 7 (2): 70. 
  10. ^ Herlihy, David (1979). "Review: Ladurie, Montaillou". Social History. 4 (3): 518. 
  11. ^ Sharpe, Jim (1991). "History from Below". In Burke, Peter. New Perspectives on Historical Writing. Cambridge: Polity Press. p. 29. 
  12. ^ Shriver, George H. (1980). "Review: Sumption, The Albigensian Crusade and Ladurie, Montaillou". Church History. 49 (1): 82. 
  13. ^ Constant, Jean-Marie (1975). "Un Village Désormais Célèbre: Montaillou". Revue d'histoire économique et sociale. 53 (4): 559. 
  14. ^ Sherwood, Jessie (2012). "The Inquisitor as Archivist, or Surprise, Fear, and Ruthless Efficiency in the Archives". The American Archivist. 75 (1): 77. 
  15. ^ Hay, Cynthia (1979). "Review: Ladurie, Montaillou". Oral History. 7 (2): 70–71. 
  16. ^ Herlihy, David (1979). "Review: Ladurie, Montaillou". Social History. 4 (3): 518.