Murder of Alexander Montgomerie
Murder of Alexander Montgomerie, 10th Earl of Eglinton
Section of the Earl of Eglinton's coach door with details of the murder
10 February 1723
|Died||25 October 1769 (aged 46)|
Burnhouse beach, Ardrossan
|Cause of death||Blood loss due to bullet wound|
|Resting place||Montgomerie family vault, Kilwinning Abbey|
|Occupation||Landowner and Scottish peer|
|Parent(s)||Alexander Montgomerie, 9th Earl of Eglinton and Susanna Montgomery, Countess of Eglinton|
Murdered by Mungo Campbell
Alexander Montgomerie (10 February 1723 – 25 October 1769) was the 10th Earl of Eglinton. Alexander was mortally wounded on the beach near his stables at Parkhouse on his own estate of Ardrossan by an excise officer or Gaudger (Scots) named Mungo Campbell on 24 October 1769 following a dispute about poaching and the latter's right to bear arms on the earl's grounds.
- 1 Alexander Montgomerie
- 2 Mungo Campbell
- 3 The murder
- 4 The Trial and sentence
- 5 Subsequent events
- 6 Micro-history
- 7 See also
- 8 References
- 9 External links
Alexander, one of twenty siblings, was the eldest son of the 9th Earl of Eglinton and Susanna Montgomery, Countess of Eglinton the earl's third wife and a renowned society beauty. Alexander planned and built the conservation village of Eaglesham in 1769 around the basic plan of a capital 'A' (for Alexander). The Earl introduced the young James Boswell to the joys of London society in the early 1760s, and figures prominently in Boswells London Journal, 1762-63. He was the Grand Master Mason of the Grand Lodge of Scotland from 1750-51. He was married to Jane (or Jean) Montgomerie, daughter of John Maxwell and widow of James Montgomerie of Lainshaw, the brother of Boswell's wife Margaret. They had no offspring.
Alexander was a great agricultural innovator and although this ultimately led to improvements that were of great benefit they were initially very unpopular with many of the tenants.
Mungo was the son of a Provost of Ayr, born in 1712, and one of twenty-four children. An uncle, also Mungo Campbell, paid for him to have a good education but died when the Mungo was about eighteen years of age. He joined the Scots Greys regiment, then commanded by his relation, General Campbell, and served in two campaigns. After the battle of Dettingen, at which he took part, he had an opportunity of being appointed quartermaster, however he could not raise the required sum of money and it went to another. He left the army and went back to Scotland in 1745, where Lord Loudoun, a relation, was in command of the loyal Highlanders and Mungo fought with him. After the battle of Culloden, Lord Loudoun arranged for him to be appointed in 1746 as an excise officer In Newmilns, then Stewarton, afterwards Irvine and finally Saltcoats.
Alexander Bartleymore, an Englishman, was a favourite servant of Lord Eglinton, and like many in the locality had dealings with contraband goods. Mungo, in the course of his duties, had come across Alexander Bartleymore on the seashore with a cart containing eighty gallons of rum, which he duly seized as contraband. However, the cart itself was not impounded, because it was the property of the earl. Bartleymore was held in the Irvine Tolbooth and only escaped deportation to the colonies through the influence of his master. He held a grudge from that day forward and was determined to get his revenge when the opportunity presented itself.
Another crucial element in the story is that Mungo, in the course of duties, was crossing part of Lord Eglinton's estate on a road when a hare started up and ran through the dyke. He 'automatically' shot it with the gun he was carrying, and the earl happened to hear the gunshot. Being committed to the prevention of poaching and the preservation of game, the earl sent a servant to bring Mungo to talk with him. At his meeting with the earl, Mungo apologised for his behaviour, which he explained as having been due to the suddenness of the hare's appearance.
The small estate of Montfode was involved in the case of the murder of the 10th Earl of Eglinton by Mungo Campbell. John Brown, tide-officer or tide-waiter (a customs officer who boarded and inspected incoming ships) at Saltcoats gave evidence that on the day of the earl's death, Tuesday 24 October 1769, he was on duty and walking with Mungo Campbell "They passed through the grounds of Montfodd, and thereafter crossed a burn, which is the march between the between Montfodd and the earl of Eglintoun's property, and went through lord Eglintoun's ground towards the sea." Mungo had permission from Dr. Hunter to shoot on the lands of Montfode, as well as preserve game and prosecute poachers, however he had no such permission from the Earl of Eglinton. On this day they were hunting for woodcock in the glen of the Montfode Burn and after crossing the Montfode Burn they walked briefly through the Earl of Eglinton's property before reaching the beach.
Travelling in his carriage on the way to Fairlie with four servants following him on horsesback, Alexander was told that two men, one with a gun, had been seen crossing his land. Bartleymore stated that Mungo Campbell was one of the two suspected poachers and the earl decided to investigate, leaving his carriage and proceeding down the beach on horseback. Upon catching up with Mungo the earl demanded that he hand over the gun he was carrying, which he refused, saying that he would rather die. The earl then ordered his fowling-piece to be brought from the carriage, saying that he was as good a shot as Mungo. The earl continued to walk towards Mungo who retreated, walking backwards, however he stumbled on a stone, fell on his back, and the earl moved quickly to grab his gun, at which point Mungo fired at Lord Eglinton, who was mortally wounded in the bowels. Mungo threw his gun away and tried to wrest the earl's gun from his servant, however he failed and was attacked by the earl's servants who upon being asked to desist by Lord Eglinton, was tied up and taken to Irvine by cart, then to Ayr, later to Glasgow, and finally to Edinburgh. The mortally wounded Lord Eglinton reportedly said to Mungo that he would not have shot him.
Lord Eglinton was carried to his carriage and taken to Eglinton Castle, where despite the best available medical attention, he died ten hours later at about one o’clock on the following morning of Wednesday 25 October, having put his affairs in order The preserved door panel contradicts the stated course of events by stating that the earl was instantly shot upon leaving his carriage.
A contemporary newspaper report first recorded the incident as actually being a duel over a woman in which the Earl had been worsted. Indeed, when in London (from 1760 to 1763 at the least) he stayed in Queen Street, Mayfair and according to Boswell, he kept a mistress, a Ms. or Mrs. Brown, who, in 1763, "had lived with him seven or eight years".
The Trial and sentence
Some legal argument took place regarding jurisdiction in this case as the incident took place on the beach between high and low water marks. Murder at sea lay within the jurisdiction of the Lord High Admiral of Scotland. The earl that day was attended by several servants, namely John Milliken, John Hazel, John Cooper, James Hutcheson, and Alexander Bartleymore, all of whom gave evidence as witnesses.
After due legal process, Mungo was sentenced to be taken to the tolbooth in Edinburgh, fed on bread and water only, and on 11 April 1770 taken to the Grassmarket where he was to be hanged between 2 and 4pm, after which his body was to be taken for dissection by Dr Alexander Munro.
Mungo Campbell hanged himself with a silk scarf provided by his friends and thereby cheated the hangman, however the populace, expecting a public hanging, dug up his body and abused it. Mungo's friends took possession of his corpse and buried it at sea. He was found to have left the following note -
The effect upon the earldom and family
Dying without an heir, the earl was succeeded by his brother, Archibald Montgomerie, 11th Earl of Eglinton. The carriage door, inscribed with the details of the tragedy, was retained by the Montgomerie family until the great sale of Eglinton Castle's contents in the 1920s.
Lady Susanna, his mother, never quite recovered from the sight of her dying son being carried into Eglinton Castle and wrote I shall endeavour to bear my suffering with as little trouble to my fellow creatures as possible. Millar records that after the murder, by Mungo Campbell, she retired from the position which she held in society.
A ghost story
Alexander was engaged to Jean or Jane, a daughter of the Maxwell family of Pollok House in Eastwood parish near Glasgow and had been a regular visitor in the months before his wedding. At the hour of his mortal wounding at Ardrossan a servant at Pollock House was surprised to see Alexander walking up the stairs to the room reserved for his visits. The servant prepared a meal, however the earl was nowhere to found and it was some time later that the awful news reached the Maxwell family.
Immediate aftermath of trial
Wilson records that "This sad affair , which took place on the grounds between Saltcoats and Ardrossan, was long the topic of discourse in town and country, .."
The Countess Susanna was further devastated by the attitude of many of the Montgomerie estates tenants who had more sympathy for Mungo Campbell than for the earl, and saw his death as a punishment imposed by heaven, due to the misimprovements of his life and the still more irritating improvement of his estates, his changes of old customs, his interference with old tenants. Mungo himself had been well liked in all the places that he had resided as an Excise officer, namely Newmilns, Stewarton, Saltcoats and Irvine.
In 1770 "A Dialogue of the Dead : Betwixt Lord Eglinton and Mungo Campbell. was published. This argues the rights of the common man over those of the aristocracy without coming to any form of reconciliation.
John Service records a semi-fictional version in his book "The Memorables of Robin Cummell."
Mr Reid of Bonshaws' collection of historical artifacts is said to have included the stirrups from the horse that the 10th Earl of Eglinton was riding when he was shot and killed by Mungo Campbell.
North Ayrshire Council commemorated the incident in 2014 with a plaque on the Montfode Burn bridge and a 'QR' linking to web-based information about Mungo Campbell and Alexander Montgomerie.
- James Boswell.info Accessed : 2012-07-08
- McClure, Page 169
- Information for Mungo Campbell, Page 2
- Robertson (1889), Page 324
- Information for Mungo Campbell, Page 3
- The Newgate Calendar Retrieved : 2012-07-08
- Information for Mungo Campbell, Page 6
- Trial of Mungo Campbell, Page 50
- Trial of Mungo Campbell, Page 7
- Trial of Mungo Campbell, Page 60
- Trial of Mungo Campbell, Pages 48 & 49
- Trial of Mungo Campbell, Page 72
- Service, Page 100
- Trial of Mungo Campbell, Page 15
- The Trial of Mungo Campbell, Page 37
- Trial of Mungo Campbell, Page 67.
- Tarlton Law Library. Accessed : 2012-07-08
- Catalogue of the Superior Furnishings within Eglinton Castle. Dowell's Ltd. 1 December 1925
- Cousins, Page 56
- Millar, Page 14
- Blair, Page 82
- Wilson, Page 95
- Aiton, Page 77
- Fullarton, Page 169
- Cuthbertson, Page 155
- A Dialogue of the Dead, Pages 5-20
- Service, Pages 95-101
- Service, Pages 81-83
- Aiton, William (1811). General View of The Agriculture of the County of Ayr; observations on the means of its improvement; drawn up for the consideration of the Board of Agriculture, and Internal Improvements, with Beautiful Engravings. Glasgow.
- Blair, Anna (1983). Tales of Ayrshire. London : Shepeard - Walwyn. ISBN 0-85683-068-2.
- Cuthbertson, David Cuningham (1945). Autumn in Kyle and the Charm of Cunninghame. London : Jenkins.
- A Dialogue of the Dead : Betwixt Lord Eglinton and Mungo Campbell. MDCCLXX. London : J. Murray.
- Information for Mungo Campbell for the alleged murder of the late Alexander Earl of Eglinton. 1770.
- Millar, A. H. (1885). The Castles and Mansions of Ayrshire. Glasgow : Grimsay Press. ISBN 1-84530-019-X.
- Robertson, William (1889). Historical Tales and Legends of Ayrshire. London: Hamilton, Adams and Co.
- Service, John (1887). The Life & Recollections of Doctor Duguid of Kilwinning. Pub. Young J. Pentland.
- Service, John (1913). The Memorables of Robin Cummell. Paisley : Alexander Gardner.
- The Trial of Mungo Campbell for the Murder of Alexander Earl of Eglinton. 1770. London : D. Wilson & G. Nicol.
- Wilson, M. (1875). The Ayrshire Hermit. Kilmarnock : Alfred Chas. Jonas.