Murder of Zahra Baker

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Zahra Baker
Zahra Clare Baker

(1999-11-16)16 November 1999
Died24 September 2010(2010-09-24) (aged 10)
Known forMurder victim

Zahra Clare Baker (16 November 1999 – 24 September 2010) was an Australian schoolgirl who was reported missing on 9 October 2010. Only 10 years old at the time of her death, her dismembered remains were found in November 2010. Because of the crime's gruesome nature and the series of events leading up to her death, Zahra's murder received worldwide media coverage.[1]

In September 2011, the victim's stepmother, Elisa Baker, pleaded guilty to murdering Zahra, and was sentenced to 18 years in prison. In 2013, she was given an additional 10 years for drug-related charges. While Baker told investigators that Zahra's father Adam Baker was involved in the crime, he was not charged, and the District Attorney has said that the state had no evidence linking anyone but Elisa Baker to the murder.[2]


Zahra Baker was born on 16 November 1999, to Emily Dietrich and Adam Baker, who both lived in Wagga Wagga. Dietrich, who had postpartum depression after Zahra's birth, gave up custody to Adam. Adam took Zahra and moved with his parents to Giru, Queensland, in 2004 to work for a sugar mill. Zahra, who was diagnosed with bone cancer in 2005, later suffered a bout of lung cancer as well. As a result, she had the lower part of one leg amputated and had to wear hearing aids.

Adam Baker reportedly met Elisa Fairchild (originally from western North Carolina) online on an IMVU website. Elisa Fairchild visited Adam Baker in Queensland and they were soon married. Elisa had been previously married six times and was still married at the time she married Adam Baker. Zahra's cancer went into remission in 2008, shortly before she moved to the United States from Australia with her father and new stepmother.[1]

North Carolina, U.S.A.[edit]

After moving to North Carolina, the Bakers settled in Hickory where Zahra attended public school until she started being homeschooled. It is not known, though, if she was ever actually homeschooled. It is suspected Zahra was taken out of public school because reports of child abuse were made to the school, implicating Elisa. Many neighbors of Zahra's claimed that Elisa was physically and mentally abusive, and neglected the child. Two teachers visited Zahra's home, after Zahra came to school with a black eye in a public school in Hudson while she was in the fourth grade.[1] Child Protective Services from both Caldwell County and Catawba County visited the various residences of Zahra multiple times before Zahra died. The Bakers had moved a few times in both those counties before settling in Hickory.[3] Reports of Elisa's abusive behavior have been investigated by the Department of Social Services in regards to Elisa's own biological children dating from as far back as 1999.[4] Elisa has a daughter from a previous boyfriend, and a son and a daughter from a previous marriage.[5]

911 call[edit]

Elisa made a 911 call at 5:30AM on 9 October 2010 to report a fire in the back of the family residence in Hickory. The police arrived to find a ransom note and the smell of gasoline coming from Adam's company truck, a Chevrolet Tahoe.[6] In a second 911 phone call made to report Zahra missing at 2PM the same day, Adam Baker explained that during a fire in their backyard a $1 million ransom note was found on his company truck the night before, addressed to Adam's boss and landlord, Mark Coffey. Adam explained that they called 911 earlier that day about the fire and implied that whoever started the fire, may have done so to distract the family in order to take Zahra. Adam explained the purported kidnapper mistakenly confused Zahra for Mark Coffey's daughter. Mr. Coffey's daughter was unharmed and with her family, Adam stated. Adam said the last time he saw his daughter was at 2:30AM. Apparently, Adam Baker left for work early in the morning and did not return until after Zahra went to sleep.[1]


Arrests and charges[edit]

Reportedly, Elisa failed a polygraph test she had taken early in the investigation. She was asked if she had hurt Zahra, if she knew of anyone who had harmed Zahra, and if she knew who wrote the ransom note.[4] On 10 October 2010, search and rescue dogs were sent to search the Bakers' house and cars. The dogs gave positive alerts to the scent of human remains on both of the Bakers' cars, the Chevrolet Tahoe and a sedan. The police took swabs of what they thought might be blood from the car. Elisa Baker was also arrested for various crimes unrelated to the death of Zahra, including communicating threats, writing bad checks, larceny, and driving with a revoked license.[7] Baker, who was jailed, was next charged with obstruction of justice after admitting that she wrote the ransom note, which led the police astray.[8]

Bond hearing[edit]

In late October 2010, a Catawba County judge raised Elisa's bond from $40,000 to $65,000 at a bond hearing, believing that Elisa was a flight risk. Amber Fairchild, Elisa's daughter, testified at the hearing and said her mother told her she was thinking of leaving North Carolina the day before she was arrested. Amber Fairchild also said her mother was involved in an online relationship with a man from England who had sent her thousands of dollars. The prosecutor said that Elisa failed to show up at other court dates for other charges which included traffic violations and communicating threats, thus thwarting Elisa's attorney's attempt to lower her bond.[9]


Elisa Baker's aunt, Buzzie Winkler, told reporters that Elisa told her Zahra died after being sick for two weeks, and both parents dismembered her and hid the remains. Elisa's aunt said, "She'd been sick two weeks before she died; when they found her, I guess they didn't know what to do. They just went wild." However, Elisa reportedly said Adam dismembered Zahra Baker alone after she died, and they both hid her remains. Elisa also told police that Zahra died on 24 September, yet she was not reported missing until 9 October.[10]

Allegedly, Eric Gein, crime memorabilia dealer and owner of Serial Killers Ink, used an assumed name to write to Elisa in jail. She twice wrote back to him, sharing some information. According to a letter written to Eric Gein, Elisa admitted, "We really didn't kill her, but what he did after the fact is kinda horrifying... (It) makes me scared of him."[11]

Reportedly, Elisa told her attorney Lisa Dubs that Zahra's prosthetic leg was left in a dumpster that she and Adam had disposed of at Fox Ridge Apartments in Hickory. Dubs informed police of the possible evidence. [4]

A prosthetic leg was found in late October off a road in Caldwell County a few miles from a former residence of Elisa's. The Hickory police department were able to match the serial number of the prosthetic leg from Zahra's medical records they obtained from Australia, in order to confirm that it was definitely Zahra's leg.[8][12]

In November 2010, Elisa Baker started leading police to different areas in Catawba County and Caldwell County to find Zahra's scattered remains. Numerous bones of Zahra were found, but Zahra's head was not found until some years later.[12] Allegedly, Elisa had told police she threw Zahra's mattress in a dumpster, and police confirmed the mattress fitting the description was found in a landfill.[13] Elisa Baker also led the police to another dumpster, behind a grocery store in Hudson, where she and Adam dumped a car cover and bed cover, which was used to hide and transport Zahra. Elisa also told police they would find Zahra's body parts in the drain trap of the bathtub and that plastic gloves that she used would be found in her bathroom.[4]

Elisa's MySpace page[edit]

A review of Elisa Baker's now-defunct MySpace page revealed she called herself "GothicFairy6668". Her page portrayed skulls and bones as Living Dead Girl by Rob Zombie was played. She listed "Never, neverland" as her hometown, Queensland, Australia, as her state and country and wrote that she was a college graduate and a proud parent. The page had photos of Zahra on it and in one photo, Zahra was wearing all black and the title read "The Dark Child!!!lol". Her "mood" on the page was listed as "crazy" on the last day she signed in, 8 October 2010, one day before Zahra was reported missing.[14]

Elisa's past marriages[edit]

Reportedly, Elisa Baker was married seven times. At times she was married to two or three men concurrently, having failed to divorce before remarrying. Prior to marrying Adam Baker, Elisa had married three men within three years.[15] In January 2011 it was reported that Elisa Baker was charged with bigamy after it was confirmed that she was still married to Aaron Young when she wed Adam Baker. Elisa had introduced Aaron Young to Adam, claiming he was her brother, not an ex-husband.[16]

Elisa kept in frequent contact with her previous husband, Aaron Young, and they both visited an website on 22 September, two days before the day on which Elisa claimed Zahra died. The IMVU website featured "chainsaw massacre role-playing". Police investigated the claim of a woman who used the same social networking site as the Bakers that she had had a conversation with one or both of the Bakers about "doing a murder with chainsaws."[17]

Accusations against two men related to Elisa Baker's previous husband, Aaron Young, alleged that Zahra was raped and may have been hit on the head, causing her death. The two cousins, James Young and Timothy "Sammy" Young were both investigated by the police for the allegations. Both men passed polygraph tests and were not charged. Sammy Young was alleged to have had a sexual relationship with Elisa and the two had taken illicit drugs together.[17]

Murder charge[edit]

Since no cause of death could be determined, Zahra's death was ruled an "undetermined violent homicide".[12] Allegedly, Elisa told the police that both she and Adam Baker disposed of Zahra's remains, but according to cell phone towers, Elisa was in the area where Zahra's remains were found. But Adam was not.[18] Investigators believe that Elisa Baker killed and dismembered Zahra on 24 September 2010 and disposed of her remains the following day.[19] Elisa Baker was indicted by a grand jury, for second degree murder with aggravating circumstances, on 22 February 2011 in Catawba County. The five aggravating circumstances were cited as:

  • Elisa Baker had a history of physical, verbal and psychological abuse of the child.
  • She secreted the child from her family, before and after the crime.
  • She desecrated Zahra’s body to hinder the murder investigation and prosecution.
  • Zahra was young and physically infirm/handicapped.
  • Elisa Baker took advantage of a position of trust.[20]

Elisa would have a first degree murder charge if she had not led law enforcement to Zahra's remains.[1] Adam has denied any involvement in Zahra's death and the police have not found any credible evidence to suggest that he had any involvement in her death or to charge him with murder.[21] Elisa's bond was increased by $200,000 because of the murder charge, making the total bond $307,700.[22]

Identity theft charges[edit]

In April 2011 Adam Baker was charged with identity theft and obtaining property under false pretenses. It was claimed that Adam Baker used the identity of a man by the name of James Starbuck and his social security number to get power connected to his apartment. James Starbuck is the husband of Elisa's daughter, Brittany Starbuck. Adam was previously charged with passing worthless checks, communicating threats, assault with a deadly weapon and failure to return property.[23][24] With these new charges, Adam was ordered not to leave North Carolina without notifying the district attorney's office. He also was ordered to wear an electronic monitoring device on his ankle and was ordered to meet with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement once a week. Adam was hoping to return to Australia shortly.[25]

Elisa Baker was also charged with identity theft and obtaining property under false pretenses in February 2011. It was reported that Elisa had used her daughter, Brittany Starbuck's personal information to obtain telephone and utility service at one of the family residences in Caldwell County in March 2010. She pleaded not guilty to the four counts of identity theft in May 2011.[26] [27]

Drug charges[edit]

In May 2011, Elisa Baker was indicted with seven drug counts for the time period of May 2006 through October 2010. Elisa, who had used different addresses in both Catawba and Caldwell County of North Carolina, had distributed Oxycodone, Hydrocodone and Alprazolam, all prescription drugs for pain and anxiety. Elisa was charged with possessing, distributing and conspiring to distribute prescription drugs. These new federal drug charges combined with the previous unrelated charges brings the total to over twenty.[28] On June 2, 2011, Elisa pleaded not guilty to all seven federal drug charges. She is facing up to 20 years in prison for each drug charge.[29]

Change of venue[edit]

Because of all the publicity surrounding this case, Elisa Baker's attorney, Scott Reilly requested a change of venue for the trial, which was supposed to occur in Catawba County. On August 1, 2011, a change of venue for the trial was agreed upon by Superior Court Judge Timothy Kincaid. Judge Kincaid said the location of the trial would be decided on 12 September 2011.[30]


  • July 2010 – Zahra along with her parents moved from a trailer park in Caldwell County, North Carolina.[31]
  • August 2010 – Zahra was enrolled in a Hudson elementary school, but never attended. Elisa Baker notified the school that Zahra would be home schooled.[31]
  • 22 September 2010 – Workers at a Hickory, North Carolina furniture store claimed they saw Zahra in the store while she was there with Elisa. This is the last time anyone claimed to have seen Zahra, other than her parents, before her remains were found.[31]
  • 24 September 2010 – Investigators believe Zahra Baker died on this day.[19]
  • 25 September 2010 – Investigators believe Zahra was disposed of on this day.[19]
  • 9 October 2010 – Two 911 calls were placed: one at 5:30am to report a fire and another call around 2pm to report Zahra missing.[6]
  • 10 October 2010 – Elisa Baker was arrested for various charges unrelated to Zahra.[31]
  • 27 October 2010 – Zahra Baker's prosthetic leg was found.[31]
  • 21 February 2011 – Elisa Baker was indicted for second-degree murder.[22]
  • 21 February 2013 – The Hickory Police Department confirm that a skull found in April 2012 belongs to Zahra Baker.[32]

See also[edit]


  1. ^ a b c d e Lagan, Bernard (May 23, 2011). "What happened to Zahra Baker?".
  2. ^ Wright, Gary L. (January 30, 2012). "Adam Baker deported; takes Zahra's remains". Charlotte Observer. Retrieved 6 December 2020.
  3. ^ Overton, Rod (Feb 21, 2011). "NC agencies questioned about how the Zahra Baker case was handled".
  4. ^ a b c d Baker, Jordan-Ashley (Dec 1, 2010). "Source: Zahra was raped". Observer News Enterprise.
  5. ^ Weiss, Mitch (Feb 4, 2011). "Elisa Baker's 'life of deception' revealed". Archived from the original on February 7, 2011. Retrieved July 28, 2011.
  6. ^ a b "Police Release 911 Tapes in Missing NC Girl Case". Oct 19, 2010. Archived from the original on 2011-09-18.
  7. ^ De Nies, Yunji (Oct 11, 2010). "Zahra Baker Case: Police Doubt $1M Ransom Note in Disabled Girl's Disappearance".
  8. ^ a b Ferran, Lee (Oct 27, 2010). "Zahra Baker's Case: Prosthetic leg Discovered".
  9. ^ Black, Caroline (Oct 21, 2010). "Zahra Clare Baker Update: Stepmother Elisa Baker Deemed Flight Risk, Bail Increased".
  10. ^ Breen, Tom (Jan 5, 2011). "Stepmother's aunt: Zahra died of natural causes". Archived from the original on 2012-03-23.
  11. ^ Lohr, David (Nov 2, 2010). "Exclusive: Notes Say Zahra's Dad Did 'Horrifying' Act". Archived from the original on 2011-07-29.
  12. ^ a b c Goldman, Russell (Feb 21, 2011). "Police Never Found Zahra Baker's Head; Stepmom Charged with Murder".
  13. ^ "Zahra Baker Was Murdered And Dismembered". Nov 16, 2010. Archived from the original on 2012-10-12.
  14. ^ Rivenbark, Jeff (Oct 12, 2010). "MySpace page yanked down for stepmother in missing girl case".
  15. ^ "Elisa Baker married seven times, including overlapping marriages". Winston-Salem Journal. Feb 4, 2011. Archived from the original on 2013-01-27. Retrieved 2011-07-26.
  16. ^ Lohr, David (Jan 19, 2011). "Slain NC Girl's Stepmother Charged With Bigamy". Archived from the original on 2011-02-23.
  17. ^ a b Wright, Gary (Jan 5, 2011). "Stepmother: Zahra Baker's dad cut up her body". Charlotte Observer.
  18. ^ Fogarty, Morgan (Jan 5, 2011). "Elisa Baker Phone Records Tell a Different Story".
  19. ^ a b c "Zahra Baker's father must notify DA's office if he leaves NC". May 4, 2011. Archived from the original on May 6, 2011. Retrieved September 4, 2011.
  20. ^ "Ex-Lawyer: Baker Plea Deal Avoids Death Penalty". Archived from the original on 2012-03-23. Retrieved 2021-11-01.
  21. ^ Hopper, Jessica (Feb 22, 2011). "Zahra Baker's Father Calls Murder Charge Against Wife 'Justice'".
  22. ^ a b Sells, Jessica (Feb 23, 2011). "Elisa Baker arraigned in stepdaughter's murder". Archived from the original on February 23, 2011. Retrieved July 23, 2011.
  23. ^ Moxley, Jennifer (Apr 14, 2011). "Adam Baker faces new charges, can't leave U.S."
  24. ^ Toulson, Andy (April 14, 2011). "Adam baker arrested for identity theft". Townsville Bulletin.
  25. ^ Newell Williamson, Sarah (May 4, 2011). "Adam Baker must notify DA's office if he leaves state". Archived from the original on October 9, 2011.
  26. ^ "Elisa Baker faces identity theft, property charges". Feb 28, 2011.[dead link]
  27. ^ Berky, Rad (May 4, 2011). "Elisa Baker pleads not guilty to ID theft charges". Archived from the original on 2012-03-23.
  28. ^ Ordonez, Franco (May 19, 2011). "Drug charges added against Elisa Baker".
  29. ^ "Elisa Baker Pleads Not Guilty To Drug Charges". June 2, 2011. Archived from the original on February 9, 2013.
  30. ^ Mitchell, Peter (August 2, 2011). "US judge moves trial of Zahra Baker's mum". Sydney Morning Herald.
  31. ^ a b c d e "Zahra Baker Timeline". Oct 17, 2010.[dead link]
  32. ^ "Police: Skull found in 2012 belongs to murdered Hickory girl". 21 February 2013.

Further reading[edit]