Mystery! (also written MYSTERY!) is a television anthology series produced by WGBH Boston for PBS in the United States. The series was created as a police/crime drama spin-off to the already established PBS show Masterpiece Theater. From 1980-2006, Mystery! aired mostly British crime series purchased from or co-produced with the BBC or ITV and adapted from British mystery fiction. In 2002, due to pressure to include more American material, a series based on the novels of US mystery writer Tony Hillerman was produced, but the vast majority of Mystery! programming has always been and continues to be British literary adaptations co-produced with UK-based production companies.
In 2008 PBS combined Mystery! with its predecessor Masterpiece Theater under the umbrella title Masterpiece, which includes the sub-brands Masterpiece Classic, Masterpiece Mystery!, and Masterpiece Contemporary.
Edward Gorey, Derek Lamb, and the Mystery! opening sequence
Mystery! is noted for its animated opening and closing title sequences with original drawings created by cartoonist Edward Gorey and animated by Eugene Federenko, Derek Lamb, and Janet Perlman, with music by Normand Roger. A PBS veteran, animator Lamb had also created programming for series like Sesame Street, The Electric Company, and The American Dream Machine.
Gorey’s first pass at creating a storyboard of the opening was estimated to run 10 minutes. Since executive producer Joan Wilson was looking for a 75-second sequence, Gorey was eventually asked to hand over the drawings and allow animators to use his work as inspiration. Gorey, known for his eccentric and stubborn nature, recounted:
"When we first started talking about it, I gave them a scenario for the credits, but they said, 'Thank you, very much, dear, but this will take half an hour.' I told them it wouldn’t if they put in on at a reasonable rate of speed, but they didn’t seen to care for that idea very much. So Derek Lamb or somebody concocted the final scenario and I had very little to do with it."
The Lamb/Gorey sequence has changed multiple times since 1980. It followed a non-linear, Agatha Christie-esque series of animated tableaus. Some of the more famous scenes include a formal ball, a crowd of umbrella-toting funeral attendants, three investigators, a croquet game in the rain, and a moaning damsel in various scenes of distress. Over time, the sequence became more streamlined, quicker, and slightly more colorful. For the Hillerman episodes, the American flag was worked into this opening title sequence.
Today, the Masterpiece opening sequence is almost identical between each sub-brand—Classic, Mystery!, and Contemporary. However, each opening features fade ins and outs of popular characters from each series. The Mystery! version still features the Gorey/Lamb characters
Inception and early history
Mystery! was the second British anthology to come to WGBH Boston after Masterpiece Theatre. In 1979 Mobil Oil head of corporate affairs Herb Schmertz offered the idea of an all-British crime series show to WGBH manager Henry Becton. Mobil Oil was already the underwriter for Masterpiece Theater and had seen success with high-profile British series, including The Six Wives of Henry VIII and Elizabeth R. By 1979, WGBH was bringing in a diverse array of British programming, to the point that Mobil saw an advantage to creating a unique time slot for the crime/police drama genre.Mobil spent 2.3 million in 1979 and 3.2 million in 1980 toward the shows it sponsored on PBS, including for the kickoff of Mystery!. Not everyone was especially enthusiastic over the genre division between Masterpiece Theater and Mystery!. Then Masterpiece Theater host Alistair Cooke initially bemoaned the loss of the crime genre:
"I tell you one thing that makes life a little more difficult in choosing was since the arrival of Mystery. We’re not able to have the change of pace and tone that we had when we could have had Thomas Hardy and Balzac and then had Lord Peter Wimsey. You know that’s denied us know [sic], of course, because it goes to Mystery."
One of Mystery!'s early successes was Rumpole of the Bailey. Other noted successes include The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes starring Jeremy Brett in the title role, Inspector Morse with John Thaw, Brother Cadfael starring Derek Jacobi, and Prime Suspect starring Helen Mirren. Agatha Christie sleuths Hercule Poirot David Suchet and Miss Marple, starring at various times Joan Hickson, Geraldine McEwan and Julia McKenzie, have also featured.
Gene Shalit (1980): The first host of the show was NBC Today Show’s arts editor and film critic Gene Shalit. On the first night of airing, February 5, 1980, Shalit opened with the following introduction: “Good evening. We’re about to set out on a series of entertaining mysteries—15 weeks of suspenseful, sophisticated, crafty conundrums that are darkly diabolical or amusing adventures with introductions that suddenly seem alarmingly alliterative.”:10 Shalit stayed for one year and left in 1981.
Vincent Price (1981-1989): Mystery and horror icon Vincent Price took the reins in Mystery!’s second year. Price’s intros were famous for their haunted house gags, including walking through cobwebs and ducking under spiders and bats. He came to Boston twice a year to tape intros and outros for the show and crew members always described him as a delight. Actress Katherine Emory called Price “the sweetest scary man I ever met.":11 Price was in his seventies when he hosted the shows and eventually had to step down due to his failing health.
Diana Rigg (1989-2003): Actress Diana Rigg had the unique opportunity of introducing mysteries in which she was the star when the series Mother Love and later The Mrs Bradley Mysteries were aired. In addition to a well-decorated theater, film, and television career in England, Rigg appeared in many American projects and won a BAFTA Award for her work on Masterpiece Theater’s “Bleak House” miniseries. Likely due to its funding problems, beginning in 2004 Mystery! began airing without a host.
The show did not get a new host until the series was re-branded under the name Masterpiece. From 2008 to today, Masterpiece Mystery! is hosted by actor Alan Cumming.
Funding trouble: 1996-2007
In the summer of 1995, Mobil announced that it would stop funding Mystery! at the end of the season. Its underwritten series Masterpiece Theater and Mystery! had been losing audiences for some time. As executive producer Rebecca Eaton put it: "Many times, over the years, we've watched our best mini-series debut with a flourish . . . only to see the audience gently or not so gently erode over the weeks," Eaton said, citing last year's "Middlemarch" as an example.".
Although Mobil had been experiencing restructuring, cutting 1,250 employees, the company refused to blame its actions on cost cutting. The company announced that it would stay with Masterpiece Theater at least through 1999 though it didn’t leave as underwriter until 2004. After the ExxonMobil merger in 1999, the company reoriented its philanthropic mission to support public health and environmental causes, dropping its commitment to public television. PBS had avoided adding 30-second advertisements before programming blocks, despite underwriters’ requests for more robust representation on the channel. Mobil swore that the decision had nothing to do with PBS’s hesitancy in implementing 30-second advertising sports for its underwriters. Since 1980, Mobil had covered the entire cost of acquiring, repackaging and promoting British dramas for PBS, which had typically cost the company around $10 million a year. Without Mobil, Masterpiece Theater and Mystery! were left without consistent support until 2011.
As a result of Mobil's initial break from Mystery!, Eaton and her staff began looking for newer, more “relevant” stories to tell in both shows. They also looked to past successes for help. Prime Suspect had gained a strong following in the U.S. as well as England, so PBS re-ran Series 4 on Masterpiece Theater during the 1995-1996 season.
PBS shifted Mystery! in 2002 from its Thursday prime-time slot during the regular American TV season to Sunday nights in the summer. Mystery! continued as a summer series from 2002 to 2004 with shows like The Inspector Lynley Mysteries, Hetty Wainthropp Investigates and Foyle's War.
2008 format change
In 2008, the series was absorbed into Masterpiece (the former Masterpiece Theatre) and began using the banner Masterpiece Mystery! In addition, its theme music was changed. It now carries a signature theme based on its sister program's former theme.  This version is hosted by Alan Cumming.
Rebecca Eaton reflected on the 2008 changes in an interview with Diane Rehm, citing Mobil’s departure, a competitive media landscape, and trouble branding Masterpiece Theater and Mystery! to new audiences. Eaton said:
“I realized that this ship of whom I was the captain was at risk of going down, and that I had to do something. And I truly did not know what to do and had no money to do anything anyway. But we got a grant from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting and PBS which we were pretty much allowed to do anything with…we spent it on doing some research into how people perceived Masterpiece. And discovered that they used to watch it, they loved it, they regarded it very highly. They weren't watching it so much anymore. They thought it was too hard to find…And a lot of people were put off by the title. They thought, oh it sounds like it will be very challenging. It sounds like homework.…We didn't change the content because we realized whenever anybody, particularly younger viewers watched it, watched Madame Bovary or Sense and Sensibility or Bleak House, they loved it. It was just sort of getting past the rather forbidding title of Masterpiece Theater and the confusing anthology nature.”
Mystery! in popular culture
- Mystery! was parodied by Sesame Street's "Mysterious Theatre" sketches in the early 1990s, hosted by Vincent Twice (whose name was always said twice), a pastiche of Vincent Price.
- The 1990s Mystery! opening was parodied on a 1998 episode of fellow WGBH program Arthur entitled "Binky Rules."
List of series presented on Mystery!
- The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes with Jeremy Brett broadcast as:
- The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes: 1984–85 (7), 1985–86 (6)
- The Return of Sherlock Holmes: 1986–87 (7), 1988–89 (6)
- The Casebook of Sherlock Holmes: 1991–92 (6)
- Sherlock Holmes: The Master Blackmailer: 1992–93 (1)
- Sherlock Holmes: The Last Vampire: 1993–94 (1)
- Sherlock Holmes: The Eligible Bachelor: 1993-1994 (1)
- The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes: 1995–96 (6)
- Agatha Christie Stories: 1982–83 (4), 1984–85 (6)
- Agatha Christie's Marple with Geraldine McEwan, and Julia McKenzie: 2005 (4), 2006 (4), 2007 (4), 2009 (4), 2010 (3)
- Agatha Christie's Miss Marple with Joan Hickson: 1985–86 (2), 1986–87 (2), 1987–88 (3), 1988–89 (2)
- Agatha Christie's Partners in Crime with James Warwick and Francesca Annis: 1984–85 (5), 1985–86 (5)
- Agatha Christie's Poirot with David Suchet: 1989–90 (10), 1990–91 (9), 1991–92 (8), 1992–93 (6), 1993–94 (6), 1994–95 (4), 1995–96 (1), 1996–97 (1), 1998–99 (3), 1999–2000 (1), 2009 (2), 2010 (3), 2013 (5)
- Agatha Christie's The Secret Adversary with Francesca Annis and James Warwick: 1986–87 (1)
- Brat Farrar with Mark Greenstreet: 1986–87 (1)
- Breathless with Catherine Steadman, Zoe Boyle, Natasha Little, Jack Davenport, Iain Glen: 2014 (6)
- Cadfael with Derek Jacobi: 1994–95 (4), 1996–97 (1), 1998–99 (5), 1999–2000 (5)
- Campion with Peter Davison: 1989–90 (4)
- Case Histories with Jason Isaacs: 2011 (3)
- Cause Célèbre with Helen Mirren: 1988–89 (1)
- Chandler and Company: 1995–96 (4)
- Charters and Caldicott: 1985–86 (1)
- Dalgliesh with Roy Marsden and Martin Shaw: 1985–86 (1), 1986–87 (2), 1987–88 (1), 1989–90 (1), 1991–92 (1), 1993–94 (1), 1995–96 (1), 1996–97 (1), 1998–99 (1), 1999–2000 (1), 2000–01 (1), 2004 (1), 2005 (1), 2006 (1)
- A Dark-Adapted Eye with Helena Bonham Carter: 1994–95 (1)
- The Dark Angel with Peter O'Toole: 1990–91 (1)
- Death Comes to Pemberley with Matthew Rhys and Anna Maxwell Martin: 2014 (3)
- Dead Gorgeous with Helen McCrory and Fay Ripley: 2003 (1), 2005 (1)
- Deep Secrets with Colin Salmon: 1997–98 (1)
- Die Kinder (The Children) with Miranda Richardson: 1990–91 (1)
- Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde with David Hemmings: 1981–82 (1)
- Dying Day: 1982–83 (1)
- Endeavour with Shaun Evans: 2012 (1), 2013 (4), 2014 (4)
- The Escape Artist with David Tennant: 2014 (3)
- Father Brown with Kenneth More: 1982–83 (4)
- Forgotten with Paul McGann: 2001–02 (1)
- Foyle's War with Michael Kitchen: 2004 (6), 2005 (4), 2007 (4), 2008 (3), 2009 (2), 2010 (3), 2013 (3)
- Gallowglass with Michael Sheen and Paul Rhys: 1995–96 (1)
- Game, Set, and Match with Ian Holm: 1988–89 (1)
- Grantchester with James Norton and Robson Green: 2015 (6)
- Heat of the Sun with Trevor Eve: 1998–99 (5)
- Hetty Wainthropp Investigates with Patricia Routledge: 1997–98 (1), 1998–99 (1), 1999–2000 (6), 2000–01 (16), 2003 (3)
- Inspector Alleyn Mysteries with Simon Williams and Patrick Malahide: 1991–92 (1), 1993–94 (3), 1994–95 (2)
- Inspector Lewis with Kevin Whately and Laurence Fox: 2006 (1), 2007 (3), 2008 (3), 2009 (3), 2010 (3), 2011 (3), 2012 (3), 2013 (3), 2014 (3)
- The Inspector Lynley Mysteries with Nathaniel Parker and Sharon Small: 2001–02 (2), 2003 (4), 2004 (4), 2005 (8), 2006 (4), 2007 (6), 2008 (6)
- Inspector Morse with John Thaw: 1987–88 (3), 1988–89 (3), 1989–90 (3), 1990–91 (3), 1991–92 (3), 1992–93 (3), 1993–94 (4), 1994–95 (3), 1995–96 (2), 1996–97 (2), 1998–99 (3), 1999–2000 (2), 2000–01 (2), 2001–02 (3), 2004 (2), 2005 (2), 2006 (2)
- Into the Blue with John Thaw: 1997–98 (1), 1998–99 (1)
- Jericho with Robert Lindsay: 2006 (4), 2007 (2)
- Lady Audley's Secret with Lucy Graham: 1999–2000 (1), 2000–01 (1)
- The Lady Vanishes with Tuppence Middleton: 2013 (1)
- The Life and Crimes of William Palmer with Keith Allen: 1998–99 (1)
- The Limbo Connection: 1982–83 (1)
- Lord Peter Wimsey with Edward Petherbridge: 1987–88 (3)
- Malice Aforethought with Hywel Bennett: 1981–82 (1)
- Malice Aforethought with Ben Miller: 2005 (1), 2006 (1)
- The Man from the Pru with Jonathan Pryce: 1990–91 (1)
- Maigret with Michael Gambon: 1992–93 (6), 1994–95 (6)
- Melissa with Peter Barkworth: 1982–83 (1)
- Miss Morison's Ghosts with Wendy Hiller: 1982–83 (1)
- The Mrs. Bradley Mysteries with Diana Rigg: 2003 (4)
- Mother Love with Diana Rigg: 1990–91 (1)
- Murder Rooms: The Dark Beginnings of Sherlock Holmes with Ian Richardson: 1999–2000 (2), 2000–01 (2), 2001–02 (4)
- My Cousin Rachel with Christopher Guard and Geraldine Chaplin: 1985–86 (1)
- Oliver's Travels with Alan Bates: 1996–97 (1), 1998–99 (1)
- Praying Mantis with Jonathan Pryce: 1984–85 (1)
- Prime Suspect with Helen Mirren: 1991–92 (1), 1992–93 (1), 1993–94 (1)
- Quiet as a Nun with Maria Aitken: 1982–83 (1)
- The Racing Game with Mike Gwilym: 1980–81 (3), 1981–82 (3)
- Rebecca with Jeremy Brett and Joanna David: 1980–81 (1)
- Reilly, Ace of Spies with Sam Neill: 1983–84
- Rumpole of the Bailey with Leo McKern: 1980–81 (4), 1981–82 (6), 1984–85 (6) 1987–88 (6), 1989–90 (6), 1992–93 (6), 1994–95 (7)
- The Sally Lockhart Mysteries: The Shadow in the North with Billie Piper: 2008 (1)
- The Sculptress with Caroline Goodall: 1997–98 (2)
- Second Sight with Clive Owen: 1999–2000 (1), 2000–01 (4), 2001–02 (2)
- Sergeant Cribb with Alan Dobie: 1980–81 (3), 1981–82 (5), 1982–83 (5)
- Shades of Darkness with John Duttine: 1983–84 (7)
- She Fell Among Thieves: 1980–81 (1)
- Sherlock with Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman: 2010 (3), 2012 (6), 2014 (3)
- Silk with Maxine Peake: 2013 (3)
- Sweeney Todd: 1982–83 (1)
- Touching Evil with Robson Green: 1998–99, 1999–2000 (6), 2000–01 (4), 2001–02 (6)
- Trial by Fire with Juliet Stevenson: 2000–01 (1)
- An Unsuitable Job for a Woman with Helen Baxendale: 1999–2000 (4)
- Wallander with Kenneth Branagh: 2009, (3) 2010 (3), 2012 (3)
- We, the Accused: 1982–83 (1)
- The Woman in White: 1984–85 (1)
- The Wyvern Mystery with Derek Jacobi: 2000–01 (1)
- Zen with Rufus Sewell: 2011 (3)
American Mystery! Specials
- Lenburg, Jeff (June 1, 2006). Who's Who in Animated Cartoons: An International Guide to Film and Television's Award-Winning and Legendary Animators. Applause Books. pp. 283–284. ISBN 978-1-55783-671-7.
- Miller, Ron (1996). MYSTERY!: A Celebration, San Francisco, CA: WGBH Educational Foundation, 1996. ISBN 0-912333-89-8.
- Hilmes, Michele. Network Nations: A Transnational History of British and American Broadcasting. New York: Routledge, 2012).
- Fraser, C. Gerald (May 9, 1980). Mobil asks PBS to reconsider showing film about Saudi Princess. New York Times, A10.
- Knox, Simone. “Masterpiece Theatre and British Drama Imports on US Television: Discourses of Tension.” Critical Studies in Television 7, no. 1 (2012): 32.
- "Bouchercon World Mystery Convention : Anthony Awards Nominees". Bouchercon.info. October 2, 2003. Retrieved March 14, 2012.
- Jensen, Elizabeth (December 10, 2007). "‘Masterpiece Theater,’ Now in 3 Flavors: Classic, Mystery, Contemporary". Nytimes.com. Retrieved January 22, 2008.
- Eaton, Rebecca (2013). Making Masterpiece: 25 Years Behind the Scenes at Masterpiece Theatre and Mystery! at PBS, Viking Adult.
- Hilmes, Michele (2012). Network Nations: A Transnational History of British and American Broadcasting. Routledge.
- Knox, Simone (2012). “Masterpiece Theatre and British Drama Imports on US Television: Discourses of Tension.” Critical Studies in Television 7:1 (29-48).
- Miller, Ron (1996). MYSTERY!: A Celebration, WGBH Educational Foundation, 1996. ISBN 0-912333-89-8.
- Neves, Sheron (2013). “Running a Brothel from Inside a Monastery: Drama Co-Productions at the BBC and the Trade Relationship with America from the 1970s to the 1990s,” PhD dissertation, University of London-Birkbeck.
- Weissmann, Elke (2012). Transnational Television Drama: Special Relations and Mutual Influence Between the US and the UK. Palgrave Macmillan.