NFL Quarterback Club 98
|NFL Quarterback Club '98|
|Series||NFL Quarterback Club|
|Genre(s)||Sports, American football|
|Mode(s)||Single player, multiplayer|
NFL Quarterback Club '98 is a football video game, released in 1997. It was developed by Iguana Entertainment and published by Acclaim Entertainment under their Acclaim Sports banner for the Nintendo 64. It was the first football game announced for the Nintendo 64.
The game established an advantage over its competitors by being the first Nintendo 64 game with high resolution graphics and holding exclusive NFL licensing for the console. Despite this, reviews were mixed as the game drew criticism for its lengthy floating of the ball during passes and issues with the A.I.
There are two kinds of Simulation modes, Custom and Historic. Custom Simulation mode allows one to create one's own scenario, including both teams' scores, who possesses the ball, how much time is left, and where the team with possession of the ball is on the field. Historic Simulation mode contains fifty different scenarios, based on games that happened in history, and a certain task is to be accomplished, often to "change history" and win with the team that lost the game, but sometimes to replicate a team's victory.
Another feature found in the game allows one to create a player. The game allows one to enter information such as the player's position, name, jersey number, height, weight, dominant hand, skin color, and age. After filling out this information, the user is taken may customize the player's stats, such as accuracy and range (for kickers and quarterbacks), catching abilities, agility, speed, and strength (all for numerous players). After a player is created, he is put into Free Agency, where he must be signed by a team.
Players can also create a team, using color schemes of the 30 NFL teams found in the game. Teams' playbooks, stadiums, and initials (shown next to a team's score during gameplay) can be edited, and a team may contain up to 55 players. Players can be put onto any of the 30 teams already in the game, as well as Free Agents (including created players), and can be substituted into any position.
In addition to the 30 pro teams in the game, there were also four hidden teams, accessed by entering a cheat code. Two teams, AFC and NFC, are the Pro Bowl teams from 1997. The other two teams are based on Iguana Entertainment and Acclaim, the developer and publisher of the game respectively, and feature then-employees as members of the team. Iguana Entertainment and Acclaim's teams are the two best teams statistically in the game.
There is a season mode where players can select a team and play through their 1997 schedule. There is also a playoff mode where a player can select a team and try to guide them through the playoffs. Quarterback Club '98 also features a Quarterback Profile feature. This feature contains 30 quarterbacks, one from each team, and their college and pro football achievements in encyclopedic format.
Acclaim brought the NFL Quarterback series into the 64-bit age using technology they had been working on for several years for Turok: Dinosaur Hunter. With this, they were able to keep the game running at 30fps in high-resolution (640 x 480), something that hadn't yet been done in the U.S. They obtained the full NFL license, including all the teams, stadiums and rosters. Their competitor for the N64 that year, Electronic Arts' Madden Football 64 was not able to get the NFL license in time for the game's release as Acclaim had acquired all the licenses for that year, but the game did feature real player names as it did get a license from the league's players' association that year. As a result, NFL Quarterback Club 98 is the only football video game for the Nintendo 64 to be fully licensed by the NFL in 1997.
One month before the game's release, its play-by-play commentator Marv Albert pled guilty to a misdemeanor charge of sexual assault and battery. Though a morals clause in Albert's multigame contract with Acclaim allowed Acclaim to dissolve the relationship if Albert were ever convicted of a crime, Acclaim opted to ship the game with Albert's commentary intact. An Acclaim representative explained that the game had already gone into production by the start of Albert's trial and was in the final stage of manufacturing when he entered his guilty plea, and said if the game were successful enough to merit a second manufacturing run, the company would re-evaluate its position on the inclusion of Albert's commentary.
NFL Quarterback Club '98 received mixed reviews. Critics esteemed it for being the first Nintendo 64 game with high-resolution graphics, in many cases noting how this enabled a high level of detail on the players.[b] IGN elaborated, "Players have realtime shadows, noticeable breath in frigid weather, and detailed uniforms and helmets." Next Generation said the high resolution "effectively takes away that nasty N64 blur we've all become accustomed to". However, critics widely opined the game's good visuals are outweighed by gameplay issues, specifically that the A.I. is easily exploited and often unrealistic, and passes float in the air for an inordinate length of time, even bullet passes.[c] GameSpot explained the problem: "Because of this hang time, defenders have way too much time to close in. The ball often drops down in the middle of about three defenders that shouldn't have been there, and one wide receiver that should have been wide open. As the ball reaches the players, they all jump up to catch it, in what looks like synchronized volleyball. What's more amusing is that somehow the receiver still makes the catch. This happens so often that it seems like it was done on purpose to compensate for the game engine's shortcomings."
Several critics also remarked that the audio is dry and sparse, and overall fails to provide an NFL atmosphere as compelling as other football video games of the time.[d] They particularly said that Marv Albert's voice-overs were interesting solely for his then-recent sex scandals, as his actual commentary is remarkably dull.[e] Even the game's visuals were not exempt from criticism, as many cited poor animation and odd player models with disproportionate arms.[f] However, IGN instead praised the animation as fluid and realistic, and said the game's flaws are overall too minor to prevent the game from being recommended. The inclusion of full NFL licensing was widely praised.[g]
Next Generation stated that "In the end, serious football fans may want to stick with Quarterback Club 64 [sic] for its realism, but the slow play is likely to drive gamers crazy." Electronic Gaming Monthly's four reviewers instead argued that problems such as the poor AI and slow passes would inevitably irritate football devotees, while casual players were more likely to overlook these flaws and therefore enjoy the game. GameSpot similarly concluded, "To be fair, some gamers will enjoy Quarterback Club despite its shortcomings - but only if they don't know or care about realistic football." GamePro called it "Probably the most disappointing sports game of the year", remarking that while it had enough good qualities to satisfy hardcore football fans, there was no reason to prefer it over its competitor, Madden Football 64. They gave it a 4.5 out of 5 for graphics but a 3.0 for both control and sound, and a 2.5 for fun factor.
The game was nominated for the "Best Nintendo 64 Game" award at the CNET Gamecenter Awards for 1997, which went to Diddy Kong Racing. It was also a finalist for the Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences' 1997 "Sports Game of the Year" and "Outstanding Achievement in Software Engineering" awards, both of which went to International Superstar Soccer 64 and GoldenEye 007.
Despite the mixed reviews, NFL Quarterback Club 98 beat competitor Madden Football 64 in sales; according to figures compiled through November 1997 from The NPD Group, NFL Quarterback Club 98 came in second for video game sales while Madden Football 64 came in ninth.
- "Gaming Gossip". Electronic Gaming Monthly. No. 93. Ziff Davis. April 1997. p. 28.
- "NFL Quarterback Club '98 (Preview)". Electronic Gaming Monthly. No. 96. Ziff Davis. July 1997. p. 110.
- Johnny Ballgame (November 1997). "NFL Quarterback Club '98 (Preview)". GamePro. No. 110. IDG Entertainment. p. 162. Retrieved August 6, 2020.
... it's the first high-resolution game for the N64 ...
- "Inside Scoop". GamePro. No. 104. IDG Entertainment. May 1997. p. 24. Retrieved August 6, 2020.
- Electric Playground Network - EPN (January 26, 2016). "Electric Playground: Season 1, Episode 8". YouTube. Google. Archived from the original on 2021-12-21. Retrieved August 22, 2018. Event occurs at 8:52-12:18.
- Casamassina, Matt (October 24, 1997). "Madden 64". IGN. Ziff Davis. Retrieved September 13, 2018.
Football fanatics, however, will be very disappointed to know that Madden 64 doesn't feature the full NFL license, so real team names, team colors and team stadiums are not present. This means that you could be stuck playing the Chicago Bulldozers instead of the mighty Bears -- and they might be purple. Acclaim grabbed all the NFL licensing rights for its NFL QB Club '98 early and EA was left playing catch up. However, EA did manage to get ahold of the NFLPA (NFL Players Association) so real player names are present in the game.
- "QBC Tackles Madden". Electronic Gaming Monthly. No. 104. Ziff Davis. March 1998. p. 28.
- "E3 Unleashed!". GamePro. No. 106. IDG Entertainment. July 1997. p. 63.
- "Sega and Bandai: A Merger Collapses". Next Generation. No. 32. Imagine Media. August 1997. pp. 16–17.
- "Marv Albert Sexual Assault Trial: Albert Receives a 12-Month Suspended Sentence". Court TV Online. October 24, 1998. Archived from the original on May 30, 2006.
- "Tidbits...". Electronic Gaming Monthly. No. 101. Ziff Davis. December 1997. p. 26.
- "NFL Quarterback Club 98 for Nintendo 64". GameRankings. CBS Interactive. Archived from the original on December 5, 2019.
- Lombardi, Doug (December 5, 1997). "[NFL] Quarterback Club 98". Gamecenter. CNET. Archived from the original on August 23, 2000. Retrieved October 27, 2021.
- "NFL Quarterback Club 98". Consoles + (in French). No. 72. January 1998. p. 132. Retrieved August 6, 2020.
- Edge staff (December 25, 1997). "NFL Quarterback Club '98". Edge. No. 53. Future Publishing. p. 110. Retrieved August 6, 2020.
- EGM staff (December 1997). "Review Crew: NFL QB Club '98". Electronic Gaming Monthly. No. 101. Ziff Davis. p. 192.
- Reiner, Andrew; Storm, Jon; Anderson, Paul (December 1997). "NFL Quarterback Club 98". Game Informer. No. 56. FuncoLand. Archived from the original on September 8, 1999. Retrieved August 6, 2020.
- Joe Kidd; The Rookie (October 1997). "[HFN] Quarterback Club '98". GameFan. Vol. 5, no. 10. Metropolis Media. p. 124. Retrieved November 1, 2020.
- Lumpy (November 1997). "NFL Quarterback Club '98 Review". GameRevolution. CraveOnline. Archived from the original on February 5, 2004. Retrieved August 6, 2020.
- Lerhman, Darren (November 5, 1997). "NFL Quarterback Club 98 Review [date mislabeled as "April 28, 2000"]". GameSpot. CBS Interactive. Archived from the original on September 29, 2007. Retrieved August 6, 2020.
- Hoople, Andrew (March 1998). "NFL Quarterback Club 98". Hyper. No. 53. Next Media Pty Ltd. pp. 42–43.
- Casamassina, Matt (October 24, 1997). "NFL Quarterback Club '98". IGN. Ziff Davis. Retrieved August 6, 2020.
- Tucker, Tim (January 1998). "Madden 64 vs. NFL Quarterback Club '98". N64 Magazine. No. 10. Future plc. pp. 49, 51–52.
- "QBC 64 [sic]". Next Generation. No. 37. Imagine Media. January 1998. p. 146. Retrieved August 6, 2020.
- "NFL Quarterback Club '98". Nintendo Power. Vol. 102. Nintendo of America. November 1997. p. 92. Retrieved August 6, 2020.
- Johnny Ballgame (December 1997). "NFL Quarterback Club '98". GamePro. No. 111. IDG Entertainment. p. 194. Archived from the original on March 4, 2004. Retrieved August 7, 2020.
- Gamecenter staff (January 28, 1998). "The Gamecenter Awards for 1997! (Nintendo 64, Part 2)". Gamecenter. CNET. Archived from the original on September 30, 2000. Retrieved October 27, 2021.
- "The Award - Updates". Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences. Archived from the original on June 15, 1998. Retrieved November 3, 2021.
- "The Award - Winners". Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences. Archived from the original on June 15, 1998. Retrieved November 3, 2021.