Close-up view of Narmer on the Narmer Palette
|Reign||c. 31st century BC(?) (1st Dynasty)|
|Predecessor||Ka (most likely) or Scorpion II|
|Burial||Chambers B17 and B18, Umm el-Qa'ab|
Narmer was an ancient Egyptian king of the Early Dynastic Period. Probably the successor to the Protodynastic kings Scorpion and/or Ka, some consider him the unifier of Egypt and founder of the First Dynasty, therefore the first king of a unified Egypt.
The identity of Narmer is the subject of ongoing debate, although mainstream Egyptological consensus identifies Narmer with the First Dynasty pharaoh Menes, who is also credited with the unification of Egypt, as the first pharaoh. This conclusion is based on the Narmer Palette which shows Narmer as the unifier of Egypt and the two necropolis seals from the necropolis of Abydos that show him as the first king of the First Dynasty.
The approximate date of Narmer/Menes is mostly estimated as close to the 31st or 32nd century BCE, although recent Egyptological literature comprises estimates of anywhere between the 34th and the 30th centuries BCE.
The famous Narmer Palette, discovered by James E. Quibell in 1898 in Hierakonpolis, shows Narmer displaying the insignia of both Upper and Lower Egypt, giving rise to the theory that he unified the two kingdoms. Since its discovery, it has been debated whether the Narmer Palette represents a historic event or was purely symbolic. In 1993, however, Günter Dreyer discovered in Abydos a year label of Narmer depicting the same event as that on the Narmer Palette which clearly shows that the Narmer Palette depicts an actual historic event.
The mainstream Egyptological consensus identifying Narmer with Menes is by no means universal. This has ramifications for the agreed history of ancient Egypt. Some Egyptologists hold that Menes is the same person as Hor-Aha and that he inherited an already-unified Egypt from Narmer; others hold that Narmer began the process of unification but either did not succeed or succeeded only partially, leaving it to Menes to complete. Arguments have been made that Narmer is Menes because of his appearance on a mud seal impression found in Abydos in conjunction with the gameboard hieroglyph for "mn", which appears to be a contemporary record of the otherwise unattested king.
Another possible theory is that Narmer was an immediate successor to the king who did manage to unify Egypt (perhaps the King Scorpion whose name was found on a macehead also discovered in Hierakonpolis), but he adopted symbols of unification that had already been in use for perhaps a generation.
Two necropolis mud sealings listing kings recently found in the tombs of Den and Qa'a (both in Abydos) show Narmer as the founder of the First Dynasty, who was then followed by Hor-Aha. The Qa'a sealing shows all eight kings of the First Dynasty in the correct sequence beginning with Narmer. Menes is not mentioned on either list of kings because at that time the name generally used on the monuments was the Horus name, while Menes was a personal name.
His wife is thought to have been Neithhotep (literally: "Neith is satisfied"), a princess of Lower Egypt. Inscriptions bearing her name were found in tombs belonging to Narmer's immediate successors Hor-Aha and Djer, implying that she was the mother of Hor-Aha.
Tomb and artifacts
Narmer is well attested throughout Egypt and southern Canaan. In Egypt his serekh has been found at 12 sites: three in Upper Egypt (Hierakonpolis, Naqada, and Abydos), seven in Lower Egypt (Tarkhan, Helwan, Zawyet el'Aryan, Tell Ibrahim Awad, Ezbet el-Tell, Minshat Abu Omar, and Kafr Hassan Dawood), and one each in the Eastern Desert (Wadi el-Qaash), and the Western Desert (Kharga Oasis).[a]
During Narmer's reign, Egypt had an active economic presence in southern Canaan. Pottery sherds have been discovered at several sites, both from pots made in Egypt and imported to Canaan and others made in the Egyptian style out of local materials. The latter discovery has led to the conclusion that Egypt's presence in Canaan was in the form of a colony rather than just the result of trade. While Egypt's presence in Canaan has been explained as the result of a military invasion, this view is not generally accepted. Fortifications at Tel es-Sakan dating to this period and almost entirely Egyptian in construction suggest a military presence, if not a military invasion.
The extent of Egyptian activity in southern Canaan is shown by the discovery of 33 serekhs on pottery sherds at sites in Canaan dating from the Protodynastic Period to the beginning of the First Dynasty. Thirteen of these belong to Narmer, and came from six different sites: Tel Arad, En Besor (Ein HaBesor), Tel es-Sakan, Nahal Tillah (Halif Terrace), Tel Erani, and Lod. An additional serekh from Lod is attributed to Narmer's probable predecessor, Ka. Significantly only one is attributable to Narmer's successors, to Hor Aha, his immediate successor. The remainder of the serekhs either have no name on them or have a name not attributable to any known pharaoh. Narmer's serekh, along with those of other Predynastic and Early Dynastic kings, has been found at the Wadi 'Ameyra in the southern Sinai, where inscriptions commemorate Egyptian mining expeditions to the area.
During the summer of 1994, excavators from the Nahal Tillah expedition, in southern Israel, discovered an incised ceramic sherd with the serekh sign of Narmer. The sherd was found on a large circular platform, possibly the foundations of a storage silo on the Halif Terrace. Dated to c. 3000 BCE, mineralogical studies of the sherd conclude that it is a fragment of a wine jar which had been imported from the Nile valley to Canaan.
Gallery of images
Alabaster statue of a baboon divinity with the name of the pharaoh Narmer inscribed on its base, on display at the Ägyptisches Museum Berlin.
- Wilkinsonn 1999, p. 67.
- Lloyd 1994, p. 7
- Edwards 1971, p. 13
- Cervelló-Autuori 2003, p. 174
- Heagy 2014, pp. 59–92
- Dee et al. (2013): "recent estimates range from 3400 to 2900 BCE", based on: J. Mellaart, 1979, Egyptian and Near Eastern chronology: a dilemma?. Antiquity 53, 6–1; J. von Beckerath, 1997, Chronologie des Pharaonischen Agypten. Mainz, Germany: Verlag Philipp von Zabern; KA Kitchen, 2000, Regnal and genealogical data of ancient Egypt (absolute chronology I). In The synchronisation of civilisations in the Eastern Mediterranean in the Second illennium BC I (ed. Bietak M), pp. 39–52. Vienna, Austria: Austrian Academy of Sciences; R. Krauss and DA Warburton, 2006, 'Conclusions' in: Ancient Egyptian Chronology (eds Hornung E, Krauss R, Warburton DA), pp. 473–489. Leiden, The Netherlands: Brill; D Wengrow, 2006, The archaeology of Early Egypt. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
- Quibell 1898, pp. 81–84, pl. XII–XIII.
- Gardiner 1961, p. 403–4. Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; name "FOOTNOTEGardiner1961403.E2.80.934" defined multiple times with different content (see the help page).
- Edwards 1961, pp. 41–43.
- Baines 1995, p. 117.
- O'Connor 2011.
- Dreyer 2000, pp. 6–7.
- Midant-Reynes 2000, pp. 243–50.
- Gardiner 1961, pp. 404–5.
- Schulman 1991–92, p. 85.
- Cervelló-Autuori 2005, pp. 31–37.
- Seidlmayer 2010, p. 25.
- Tyldesley 2006, p. 26–29.
- Dreyer 1999, pp. 110–11.
- Hassan 2000, p. 39.
- Ciałowicz 2011, p. 63.
- Porat 1986–87, p. 119.
- Yadin 1955, pp. 1-16.
- Campagno 2008, pp. 695–96.
- Porat 1986–87, p. 109.
- de Miroschedji 2008, p. 2028–29.
- Anđelković 2011, p. 31.
- Jiménez-Serrano 2007, pp. 372–73, Table 9.
- Jiménez-Serrano 2007, p. 370, Table 8.
- Tallet & Laisney 2012, pp. 383–389.
- Levy et al. 1995, pp. 26–35.
- Anđelković 1995, p. 72.
- Anđelković, B (1995), The Relations Between Early Bronze Age I Canaanites and Upper Egyptians, Belgrade: Faculty of Philosophy, Center for achaeological Research, ISBN 86-80269-17-4.
- ——— (2011), "Political Organization of Egypt in the Predynastic Period", in Teeter, E, Before the Pyramids, Chicago: Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago, ISBN 978-1-885923-82-0.
- Baines, J (1995), "Origins of Egyptian Kingship", in O’Connor, D; Silverman, DP, Ancient Egyptian Kingship, Leiden, New York, Cologne: EJ Brill, pp. 95–156, ISBN 90-04-10041-5.
- Braun, E (2011), "Early Interaction Between Peoples of the Nile Valley and the Southern Levant", in Teeter, E, Before the Pyramids, Chicago: Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago, ISBN 978-1-885923-82-0.
- Campagno, M (2008), "Ethnicity and Changing Relationships between Egyptians and South Levantines during the Early Dynastic Period", in Midant-Reynes; Tristant, Y, Egypt at its Origins 2, Leuven: Peeters, ISBN 978-90-429-1994-5.
- Cervelló-Autuori, Josep (2003), "Narmer, Menes and the seals from Abydos", Egyptology at the dawn of the twenty-first century: proceedings of the Eighth International Congress of Egyptologists, 2000 2, Cairo: The American University in Cairo Press.
- Cervelló-Autuori, Josep (2005), "Was King Narmer Menes?", Archéo-Nil 15.
- Ciałowicz, KM (2011), "The Predynastic/Early Dynastic Period at Tell el-Farkha", in Teeter, E, Before the Pyramids, Chicago: Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago, pp. 55–64, ISBN 978-1-885923-82-0.
- Dodson, Aidan; Hilton, Dyan (2004), The Complete Royal Families of Ancient Egypt, Thames & Hudson, ISBN 0-500-05128-3.
- Dreyer, G (1999), "Abydos, Umm el-Qa'ab", in Bard, KA; Shubert, SB, Encyclopedia of the Archaeology of Ancient Egypt, New York: Routledge, ISBN 0-415-18589-0.
- ——— (2000), "Egypt's Earliest Event", Egyptian Archaeology 16
- Edwards, IES (1971), "The early dynastic period in Egypt", The Cambridge Ancient History 1, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- Edwards, WB (1961). Archaic Egypt: Culture and Civilization in Egypt Five Thousand Years Ago. London: Penguin Books..
- Gardiner, Alan (1961), Egypt of the Pharaohs, Oxford University Press.
- Hassan, FA (2000), "Kafr Hassan Dawood", Egyptian Archaeology 16: 37–39.
- Heagy, Thomas (2014), "Who was Menes?", Archeo-Nil 24: 59–92
- Jiménez-Serrano (2007), Los Primeros Reyes y la Unificación de Egipto [The first kings and the unification of Egypt] (in Spanish), Jaen, ES: Universidad de Jaen, ISBN 978-84-8439-357-3.
- Kinnaer, Jacques (2004), "What is Really Known About the Narmer Palette?", KMT: A Modern Journal of Ancient Egypt.
- Lloyd, Alan B (1994) , Herodotus: Book II, Leiden: EJ Brill, ISBN 90-04-04179-6.
- Levy, TE; van den Brink, ECM; Goren, Y; Alon, D (1995), "New Light on King Narmer and the Protodynastic Egyptian Presence in Canaan", The Biblical Archaeologist 58 (1): 26–35, doi:10.2307/3210465.
- Midant-Reynes, B (2000), The Prehistory of Egypt.
- de Miroschedji, P (2004), "Sakan, Tell Es-", in Stern, E; Geva, H; Paris, A, The new Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land, Supplementary Volume 5.
- O'Connor, David (2011), "The Narmer Palette: A New Interpretation", in Teeter, E, Before the Pyramids, Chicago: Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago, ISBN 978-1-885923-82-0.
- Porat, N (1986–87), "Local Industry of Egyptian Pottery in Southern Palestine during the Early Bronze Period", Bulletin of the Egyptological Seminar 8.
- Quibell, JE (1898). "Slate Palette from Hierakonpolis". Zeitschrift für ägyptische Sprache und Altertumskunde 36..
- Schulman, AR (1991–92), "Narmer and the Unification: A Revisionist View", Buletin of the Egyptological Seminar 11.
- Seidlmayer, S (2010), "The Rise of the Egyptian State to the Second Dynasty", in Schulz, R; Seidel, M, Egypt: The World of the Pharaohs.
- Shaw, Ian (2000), The Oxford History of Ancient Egypt, Oxford University Press.
- Talllet, P; Laisney, D (2012), "Iry-Hor et Narmer au Sud-Sinaï: Un complément à la chronology des expéditions minères égyptiennes", Bulletin de l'Institut français d'archéologie orientale 112.
- Tyldesley, Joyce (2006), Chronicle of the Queens of Egypt, London: Thames & Hudson.
- Wilkinson, TAH (1999), Early Dynastic Egypt, London, New York: Routlege.
- Yadin, Y (1955), "The Earliest record of Egypt Military Penetration into Asia?", Israel Exploration Journal 5 (1).