The name, applied to team or individual scores of 111 or multiples thereof (known as double nelson, triple nelson, etc.) is thought to refer to a wicket. Longtime cricket historian and scorer, Bill "Bearders" Frindall once referred to it online as "one eye, one arm and one etcetera", implying that Nelson's alleged third lost body part was "something else", however this is equally mythical. In the 1939 film of Goodbye, Mr Chips a schoolboy refers to Nelson in these terms: "One arm, one eye, one destiny". Umpire David Shepherd during a radio interview to mark his retirement explained it as "One arm, one eye and one lump of sugar in his tea."
It is thought by the superstitious that bad things happen on that score, although an investigation by the magazine The Cricketer in the 1990s found that wickets are no more likely to fall on Nelson and indeed, the score at which most wickets fall is 0 (a duck). It may be considered unlucky because the number resembles a wicket without bails (a batsman is out if the bails are knocked off their wicket).
The equivalent superstitious number in Australian cricket is 87, or the "Devil's Number". Many, including commentators and journalists, think 87 is considered unlucky because it is thirteen shy of 100 however an alternative thought is it came to be known as the "Devil's Number" after Ian Johnson was dismissed for 87 while playing grade cricket and Keith Miller commented "That's funny, I once saw Bradman dismissed for 87". It turned out that Bradman had actually been dismissed for 89 and the MCG scorers hadn't updated his last two runs before his dismissal however the superstition remained. Statistics have shown that more Australian batsmen are in fact dismissed on the numbers surrounding 87.
On 11 November 2011, in a Test match between South Africa and Australia with the time at 11:11 and with South Africa requiring 111 runs to win, the majority of the crowd and umpire Ian Gould did Shepherd's leg raise Nelson for that minute with the scoreboard reading 11:11 11/11/11.
On 17 June 2018, at VOC ground in Rotterdam (Netherlands), VOC U11 played MOP (Vught) U11 in a 16 over match that ended in a very rare tie, both teams scoring 111.  On 8 May 2019, in the Women’s T20 Challenge in Jaipur, Trailblazers vs Velocity, Trailblazers were 111-2, needing 113 to win. Then they lost five wickets in seven balls for no runs, making the score 111-7. However, they went on to win.
- Booth, Lawrence. Arm-ball to Zooter: A Sideways Look at the Language of Cricket. Penguin Books. ISBN 978-0-14-051581-7.
- Paul Coupar and Mark Eklid (November 2005). "Shepherd's hop for the best". ESPN Cricinfo. Retrieved 2014-02-09.
- Kolo Toure and the Top 10 sporting superstitions. Retrieved 27 December 2013
- Wellington v Nelson 1873-74
- Nelson v Wellington 1891-92
- David Shepherd (2003-04-12). "David Shepherd's Umpire Guide - My Quirks". BBC Sport. Retrieved 2007-01-19.
- Geoff McClure (2007-11-20). "Why 87 is anything but Australian cricket's magic number". The Age. Retrieved 2009-06-30.
- The Nelson at 11:11 on 11/11/11
- VOC and MOP U11 teams tie at 111-111
- "Trailblazers v Velocity 2019". CricketArchive. Retrieved 9 October 2019.