New York Rescue Workers Detoxification Project
|Headquarters||New York, NY|
The New York Rescue Workers Detoxification Project was founded in New York City in 2003 with the purpose of treating rescue workers for toxins inhaled from the smoke of the September 11 attacks. It has two clinics: Downtown Medical on Fulton Street, two blocks from the site of the World Trade Center, and another at Williston Park, Long Island. The project's co-founder and top fundraiser is the actor and Scientologist Tom Cruise. It uses the Purification Rundown, a "detoxification" program invented by L. Ron Hubbard as part of Scientology's Bridge to Total Freedom. This rundown has been criticized by many doctors as pseudoscientific and medically dangerous, although it has produced positive testimonials from some recipients. It was reported in October 2007 that 838 people had completed the program.
The project has been supported by some public officials, and received some public funding, but received criticism for its financial ties to the Church of Scientology, for exposing rescue workers to potential medical dangers, and for discouraging their use of orthodox medicine. Sources in the Fire Department told a reporter that several participants had joined Scientology, even disconnecting from their families.
Scientologists criticise EPA
Tom Cruise explained his motivation for setting up the project in a Scientology promotional video that leaked onto the internet in January 2008. The Environmental Protection Agency had stated after the World Trade Center attack that the air was safe to breathe. The video narration contradicted this, saying, "The devastation had spread an unprecedented combination of toxins through the air — and it was lethal." Cruise is seen dismissing the EPA's all-clear:
"Of course, as a Scientologist, you go, that's a lie. Outright lie. Liar. Fine. Finally you say, dammit, just go there and do it. Put it there, let's go, here's the money, let's go. Let's just get one person treated. I can't sleep another night."
In an appearance on CNN's Larry King Live, Cruise said that he founded the project out of concern that 9/11 survivors would suffer leukemia, parkinsonism, multiple sclerosis or cancer as a result of toxins in their fatty tissue. He advocated Hubbard's "research" as the only way to deal with these problems, claiming, "Doctors do not know how to diagnose chemical exposures [...] You go to a doctor and now he's going to put you on more and more drugs, steroids and things that are ineffective."
"Detoxification" in Scientology
The "detoxification" program was created by L. Ron Hubbard, who set out the procedure in Clear Body, Clear Mind, one of the canonical texts of Scientology. Known as the "Purification rundown" or "Purif," it is promoted through various groups affiliated with the Church of Scientology, including Narconon drug rehabilitation and the Second Chance Program. It claims to flush poisons from the body's fat stores using exercise, saunas, and high doses of vitamins, particularly niacin. Many medical experts have judged it to be unproven, ineffective and/or potentially dangerous. A report for the Department of Health in California described the mega-doses of vitamins as "hazardous" and "in some cases lethal." Scientology's own literature reports dehydration, electrolyte disturbances including hyponatremia (low sodium level) and hypokalemia (low potassium level), and heat-related illnesses as being frequent side-effects of the program. Testimonials from some participants credit it with improvements in physical and mental health, but several families blame the Rundown for the death of a relative.
The project's clients were required to attend this programme three hours each day, for between twenty-one and forty days. This was promoted as a way to treat memory loss, respiration problems, fatigue and other problems suffered by the Ground Zero workers.
Finances and organization
From 2003 to 2007, Downtown Medical received US$900,000 in public funding, including $630,000 from the City of New York. The project also received private funding, the biggest supporter being Tom Cruise. Other celebrity donors included Paul Newman, Paul McCartney, Adam Sandler, Leah Remini, Will Smith and Jada Pinkett Smith. By late 2004, these donations amounted to $2.3 million. The detoxification program has been offered for free to rescue workers, and also offered to other New York City residents, some of whom paid $5,000.
According to tax filings, the project pays on some of its money to two bodies, related to the Church of Scientology, that promote the Purification Rundown. These are the Association for Better Living and Education (ABLE), which receives 5% of all contributions, and the Foundation for Advancements in Science and Education (FASE). The Executive Director of the Church of Scientology was involved in creating the Foundation and later described it as a "front group". In one year, $173,300 of Downtown Medical's income went to Dr. Steven Lager, a Scientologist. As of 2007[update], the director of the project was Jim Woodworth, a former drug addict who credits his recovery to the Purification Rundown. He was formerly the executive director of HealthMed, a Sacramento, California group which promotes Hubbard's approach to detoxification.
Endorsements and criticism
The project had a mixed response from public officials. Margarita López, a former member of New York City Council, endorsed the program and helped it to win public funding. Subsequently, she received nearly $115,000 in campaign contributions from Scientologists. Another councillor, Joseph Addabbo, Jr., also supported the project, telling reporters, "The project seems to work. I've seen it firsthand." Mayor Michael Bloomberg spoke out against Addabbo and López for their connections with the program, saying that Scientology is "not science, and we should only fund those programs that reputable scientists believe will stand the light of day."
Another supportive member of the City Council was Hiram Monserrate. Monserrate went through the program himself, and drafted official proclamations honoring both Tom Cruise and L. Ron Hubbard. Describing himself as a Christian, he distanced himself from Scientology but said he believes in the Purification Rundown. Another councillor (and chair of the Public Safety Committee), Peter Vallone, Jr. vocally criticized the detoxification project and argued that public money should not be spent on it. He accused Monserrate of crossing the line between "cult and state."
The project's publicity included favorable quotations from Senator Charles Schumer and from Michael Balboni, New York's deputy secretary for Public Security, though Schumer later withdrew his support and Balboni denied ever making the statement. Council speaker Christine C. Quinn denounced the program as meritless. U.S. Representative Carolyn B. Maloney wrote a letter supporting the project. Dr. Bob Hoffman of the New York City Poison Control Center warned that the Purification Rundown is potentially dangerous, calling it "hocus pocus." Mayor Doreen Ehrbar of Williston Park took part in the opening ceremony for the Long Island clinic.
Neither the police nor the fire department officially supported the project. The Uniformed Firefighters Association initially supported it, but withdrew when the connection to the Church of Scientology was revealed. Firefighter Union President Patrick Bahnken said his members' lives had benefited from the program, and that it had involved no religious rhetoric. Deputy Fire Commissioner Frank Gribbon of the FDNY told the New York Times, "while we are aware some members of the department have availed themselves of the program, we in no way endorse it." Officials at the department raised concerns that firefighters were giving up existing medications in order to take part. The department's deputy chief medical officer Dr. David Prezant said, "It's not our job to say you can't go. All we can do is say there's no proven evidence it works."
It was reported in October 2007 that 838 people had completed the program. The clinic displayed towels with colored stains, as evidence that toxic material had been sweated out in the saunas. According to its Director, Jim Woodworth, during the Purification Rundown firefighters had passed odd-colored bowel movements and sweated out mercury, aluminium and magnesium. The Fire Department's chief medical officer, Dr. Kerry Kelly, criticized the lack of objective evidence, saying, "I have trouble believing in these purple-stained towels."
An investigation by the New York Press asked a number of independent doctors about the evidence for the Purification Rundown. None of them endorsed the program's effectiveness and some explicitly described it as dangerous. Several said that no peer-reviewed research on the rundown had been published in any medical journal. Some apparently supportive studies have been published, but these lack control groups and have other scientific failings. According to Deputy Fire Commissioner Frank Gribbon, doctors investigating the program on behalf of the Fire Department concluded that it was not detoxifying. University of Georgia bioterrorism expert Cham Dallas also denied that the procedure could detoxify, saying "It sounds great and they mean well, but it just doesn't work."
In 2007, James Dahlgren and colleagues published a small-sample pilot study assessing the project. Dahlgren is a doctor who promotes the Purification Rundown as a method of detoxification. The study claimed to find evidence both of elevated levels of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and polychlorinated dibenzofurans (PCDFs) in the rescue workers and improvement during the regime. Two scientists from Cambridge Environmental, Inc. published a thorough critique of the study. They questioned the premise that WTC rescue workers needed detoxification, citing studies that had found that their blood concentration of toxins was no greater than normal.
"[W]ith few exceptions, people’s body burdens of PCBs and other 'dioxin-like compounds' are determined almost exclusively by the food we eat, not by the air we breathe. Firefighters may occasionally receive on-the-job exposures to PCBs and PCDFs, but these would be from having fought PCB-containing electrical transformer fires, not from 9/11."
The paper argues that the project never properly tested its outcomes and concludes that application of the "potentially dangerous" Purification Rundown to the health problems of 9/11 workers is "unconscionable".
Many of the participants spoke favorably of the program and reported improved physical and mental health. Others said they were just taking advantage of the free saunas. One Fire Department lieutenant was quoted describing colleagues as desperate for help with the distress they felt in the aftermath of the attacks, to the point that they would try anything. Fire Department officials raised concerns about the project, saying that firefighters were being required to give up inhalers, pills and other orthodox medication. Two weeks into the program, one firefighter passed out and was taken to an emergency room with severe asthma, later saying that he had been asked to stop using his inhaler. According to the clinic's associate medical director, Dr. Kawabena Nyamekye, participants were being helped off medication at their own insistence, not at the request of Downtown Medical. A former worker at Downtown Medical told reporters that staff were discouraged from calling for an ambulance even in an emergency, and that one of them had been required to break off contact with her boyfriend because he had left Scientology. A spokesman responded that the clinic had "a clear policy of calling 911 when needed."
- DeSio, John (May 31, 2007). "The Rundown on Scientology’s Purification Rundown: What Scientologists aren't telling you about their detox program (and how much it’s costing you)". New York Press.
- Schaffer, Amanda (October 21, 2004). "Poisons, Begone! The dubious science behind the Scientologists' detoxification program for 9/11 rescue workers". Slate (Washington Post). Retrieved January 29, 2009.
- O'Donnell, Michelle (October 4, 2003). "Scientologist's Treatments Lure Firefighters". New York Times. p. 1. Retrieved January 30, 2009.
- Whitely, Margaret (June 18, 2004). "Tom Cruise Opens Rescue Workers Detox Clinic". The Illustrated News (online edition) (Anton Newspapers).
- Sappell, Joel; Robert W. Welkos (June 27, 1990). "Church Seeks Influence in Schools, Business, Science". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved January 21, 2009.
- Doward, Jamie (March 27, 2005). "Scientologists will 'purify' drug addicts - for £15,000". The Observer (Guardian News & Media). Retrieved February 21, 2009.
- Carey, Art (October 7, 2007). "Clinic's results make 9/11 responders believe. Critics aside, they say Scientology's detox center cures ills". The Philadelphia Inquirer.
- Crouch, Edmund A. C.; Laura C. Green (October 2007). "Comment on "Persistent organic pollutants in 9/11 world trade center rescue workers: Reduction following detoxification" by James Dahlgren, Marie Cecchini, Harpreet Takhar, and Olaf Paepke [Chemosphere 69/8 (2007) 1320–1325]". Chemosphere 69 (8): 1330–1332. doi:10.1016/j.chemosphere.2007.05.098. PMID 17692360.
- Friedman, Roger (December 22, 2006). "Tom Cruise Can't Put Out These Fires". Fox 411 (Fox). Retrieved February 2, 2009.
- "Tom Cruise's 9/11 clean-up". Boston Globe. January 18, 2008. Retrieved February 3, 2009.
- "Tom in Ground Zero tantrum". New York Post. January 18, 2008.
- "Interview With Tom Cruise". Larry King Live. November 28, 2003. CNN.
- Bouma, Gary D. (2006). Australian Soul: Religion and Spirituality in the 21st Century. Cambridge University Press. p. 9. ISBN 0-521-67389-5.
- Rothstein, Mikael (2007). "Scientology, scripture and sacred tradition". In James R. Lewis, Olav Hammer. The invention of sacred tradition. Cambridge University Press. p. 21. ISBN 978-0-521-86479-4. OCLC 154706390.
- Sommer, Mark (February 1, 2005). "Addiction specialists criticize detoxification program". Buffalo News.
- Carey, Art (October 7, 2007). "Clinic's results make 9/11 responders believe". The Philadelphia Enquirer. Archived from the original on October 24, 2007.
- Sommer, Mark (August 6, 2005). "Schumer backs off support for program". Buffalo News.
- Roberton, Craig (December 28, 1981). "Narconon". St. Petersburg Times. pp. 1B. Retrieved February 21, 2009.
- Al-Zaki, Taleb; B. Tilman Jolly (January 1997). "Severe Hyponatremia After Purification". Annals of Emergency Medicine (Mosby) 29 (1): 194–195. doi:10.1016/S0196-0644(97)70335-4. PMID 8998113.
- Dougherty, Geoff (March 28, 1999). "Store selling Scientology vitamin regimen raises concerns". St. Petersburg Times. Retrieved February 14, 2009.
- Gittrich, Greg (December 13, 2003). "Bravest taking the Cruise cure". New York Daily News. Archived from the original on December 16, 2003. Retrieved February 22, 2009.
- Dunleavy, Steve (June 12, 2007). "Cruise's Clinic OK". New York Post.
- Gilmore, Heather (August 15, 2004). "Scientology ‘Detox’ Furor: clinic draws client raves and researcher jeers". New York Post.
- Bonawitz, Amy (April 20, 2007). "Tom Cruise Raises Money For 9/11 Detox". CBSNews.com (CBS Interactive). Retrieved March 4, 2011.
- Schindler, Paul (August 5, 2005). "Margarita Lopez stays mum through Scientology flap". Downtown Express 18 (11). Retrieved January 29, 2009.
- Seifman, David (April 20, 2007). "Crui$e is 'Detox' of De Town". New York Post.
- Jose, Katharine (April 22, 2008). "Mad-Dog Councilman Champions No Man's Land". The New York Observer. Retrieved September 26, 2009.
- "Monserrate Defends Detox Program". The New York Observer. April 21, 2007. Retrieved September 26, 2009.
- Seifman, David (April 18, 2007). "City Proclamation Sparks L. Ron Hubbub". New York Post (NYP Holdings). Retrieved September 27, 2009.
- Seifman, David (April 19, 2007). "Mike Thumps Tom: blasts city honor for Scientology's Sept. 11 'Detox'". New York Post.
- AP and Post Wire Services (April 19, 2007). "Crui$ing for Cash". New York Post.
- de Vries, Lloyd (April 6, 2007). "Cruise To Host Gala For 9/11 Detox: Report". CBSNews.com (CBS Interactive). Retrieved March 5, 2011.
- Friedman, Roger (April 19, 2007). "FDNY Hierarchy Furious With Tom Cruise Over Scientology Detox for 9/11 Workers". Fox News. Archived from the original on February 3, 2009. Retrieved February 22, 2009.
- Walls, Jeannette (May 2, 2006). "Garofalo gushes over Scientology-linked project". MSNBC.com. Retrieved January 29, 2009.
- Dahlgren, James; Marie Cecchini; Harpreet Takhar; Olaf Paepke (October 2007). "Persistent organic pollutants in 9/11 world trade center rescue workers: Reduction following detoxification". Chemosphere 69 (8): 1320–1325. doi:10.1016/j.chemosphere.2006.05.127. PMID 17234251.
- O'Donnell, Michelle (October 4, 2003). "NYC Clinic has Scientology ties". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. p. 4.
- Friedman, Stefan C. (August 4, 2005). "Scientology Clinic Bad Medicine: Ex-Worker". New York Post.
- Official sites