Newfoundland National Convention
|This article needs additional citations for verification. (March 2008)|
The Newfoundland National Convention of 1946 was a forum established to decide the constitutional future of Newfoundland.
On 11 December 1945 the British Government announced that there would be an election to a National Convention, which would debate constitutional options and make a recommendation as to which options would appear on a ballot in a national referendum. British Prime Minister Clement Attlee wanted to ensure that people from St John's did not dominate the seats, so he recommended that delegates would be elected in the former electoral districts and that each delegate would have to have been a resident of the district. Nominations to the National Convention were held on May 31, 1946 and on June 21, 1946, Newfoundlanders elected 45 delegates. Only two females offered themselves as candidates, but neither succeeded in winning a seat. Lester Burry, of Labrador had secured a seat, the first time that Labrador had elected representation.
Convening the National Convention
The National Convention was convened on September 11, 1946. Judge Cyril J. Fox, a Supreme Court of Newfoundland Justice, chaired the proceedings until his untimely death. He was succeeded as Chairman by Convention Member Gordon Bradley for most of the rest of the Convention's life, but after Bradley's resignation the lawyer J.B. McEvoy served in the chair. The Commissioner of Home Affairs issued pay cheques to delegates: $15 a day, with a travelling stipend of $10 per day.
Not only were observers allowed in the gallery but the general public could listen to the debates on radio stations VOCM, VOAR and the state-run Broadcasting Corporation of Newfoundland station, VONF.
Some delegates who were critical of the Commission of Government used the opportunity to demand Commissioners justify to the Convention some of their policies. However, Governor MacDonald would explain that delegates were not the Government of Newfoundland, but were convened to debate the constitutional options which would appear on a ballot in a forthcoming referendum.
National Convention Proceedings
Many delegates believed Newfoundland should return to Responsible Government and Self-Determination; delegates sympathetic to Confederation with Canada were in a minority in the National Convention. On October 28, 1946, Joseph R. Smallwood moved that a delegation be sent to Ottawa to discuss Terms of Union with Canada. More motions and amendments were passed in the days following, when on October 30 Kenneth M. Brown, the delegate from Bonavista South, collapsed on the floor of the chamber. Tragedy struck again when on November 16, Judge Fox suffered a heart attack and died suddenly. Smallwood's motion revealed that confederation with Canada had only a minority of support in the Convention, but it was now on the agenda and the confederates used the radio broadcasts of the Convention to tell the people of Newfoundland and Labrador of the financial advantages that joining Canada would bring. The Convention adjourned on December 13 for the Christmas break, but the widespread feeling that Smallwood and the confederates had the upper hand encouraged St. John’s businessman F. M. O'Leary and others to form the Responsible Government League. The RGL was dedicated to the resumption of the former (1933) constitution for the Dominion.
The London Delegation
In 1946, the National Convention dispatched the London Delegation to seek guarantees of continued assistance if Newfoundland were to resume Responsible Government. The British government favoured Newfoundland joining Canada, so it did not offer any promises of continued financial aid.
The members (with their districts) were:
- F.G. Bradley (Bonavista South)
- Peter John Cashin (St. John's City West)
- Malcolm Mercer Hollett (Grand Falls)
- Chesley Crosbie (St. John's City West)
- Albert Butt (St. John's West Extern)
- Pierce Fudge (Humber)
- William Keough (St. George's)
The Ottawa Delegation
On June 19, 1947, the National Convention dispatched the Ottawa Delegation to negotiate the Terms of Union for Confederation between Newfoundland and Canada. While the British government had offered nothing, the Canadian Government wanted Newfoundland as a province so they were prepared to negotiate support for the new province. There was a limit to that however as it was not possible to offer Newfoundland any special deal that was not allowed other provinces under the British North America Act.
The Ottawa Delegation was supposed to return to Newfoundland after one week. But the negotiations spanned on longer than that. Each delegate received a travelling subsidy of $25 per day. The members (with their districts) were:
- T.G.W. Ashbourne (Twillingate)
- F.G. Bradley (Bonavista South)
- Charles Ballam (Humber)
- Lester Burry (Labrador)
- P.W. Crummey (Bay de Verde)
- Joey Smallwood (Bonavista Centre)
Interestingly, at least half of the Ottawa Delegates belonged to the Orange Lodge: Joseph Smallwood, P.W. Crummey and F.G. Bradley were Orangemen; and two of them had been grand-masters: P.W. Crummey and F.G. Bradley.
Newfoundland - Canadian negotiations were largely a one-way affair, because any union between the two dominions was dictated by the provisions of the British North America Act (BNA), under which Canada had come into being in 1867.
P.W. Crummey had the hardest portfolio. Because the economy of his district was almost exclusively fishery-oriented, he was assigned to negotiate maritime issues. Crummey quickly discovered that after Confederation, Newfoundland would lose control of the Grand Banks because the BNA designated fisheries as under federal jurisdiction. Crummey also sensed that the federal negotiators intended to draw out the negotiations.
Economic Union Party
A National Delegate named Robert Brown Job suggested economic union with the United States. Another National Delegate named Chesley Crosbie subsequently created the Economic Union Party On April 11, 1947, D.I. Jackman moved that a delegation be sent to Washington, DC to seek terms of union but his motion was not passed by the assembly. Thus, union with the United States was effectively taken off the table.
The Confederation Debate
A motion to place Confederation with Canada on the ballot was defeated 29 to 16. Joey Smallwood felt slighted by what he called 'Twenty-Nine Dictators'. Smallwood and his Confederates took the matter public. Newfoundland's Governor, Gordon Macdonald would announce on March 11, 1948 that Confederation with Canada would be on a national referendum ballot along with Dominion government and the Commission.
On June 3, 1948, the first of two Newfoundland referendums was held on the advice of the Convention. Voters had three options:
- A return to dominion status
- Commission of Government, the status quo
- Confederation with Canada
The option for responsible government (Dominion status) won a plurality, but not an absolute majority. The Governor and Commissioners called for a second National Referendum, one between Confederation and Dominion status. Anti-Confederates wanted the second National Referendum options limited to "Responsible Government" and "Commission of Government", believing that if Responsible Government won, it would be in a position to negotiate better terms with Canada.
On July 22, 1948 A second National Referendum was held. In the second referendum only two options appeared:
- Dominion status
The Confederation option won by a narrow margin, and Newfoundland became Canada's tenth province the following year. A topic which still raises debate.
- The Newfoundland National Convention, 1946-1948 Heritage Newfoundland
- Commission of Government 1934-1949
- NL premier orders removal of all Canadian flags from provincial buildings
- Jeff Webb, "Newfoundland's National Convention, 1946-48" MA Thesis, Memorial University of Newfoundland
- "Falling into the Canadian Lap: The Confederation of Newfoundland and Canada, 1945-1949" (PDF). Royal Commission on Renewing and Strengthening Our Place in Canada.
- "Job's Papers Reveal His Family's Commitment to Province". From the files of The Gazette July 11, 1996. Memorial University of Newfoundland. November 2000. Retrieved 14 August 2010.