The Northern or Northwestern is a genre in various arts which tell stories set primarily in the later half of the 19th century in the north of North America, primarily in Canada but also in Alaska. It is similar to the Western genre but many elements are different, as appropriate to its setting. It is common for central character to be a Mountie instead of a cowboy or sheriff. Other common characters include fur trappers and traders, lumberjacks, prospectors, First Nations people, settlers and townsfolk.
International interest in the region and the genre was fuelled by the Klondike Gold Rush (1896–99) and subsequent works surrounding it, fiction and non-fiction. The genre was extremely popular in the inter-war years of the twentieth century. Northerns are still produced but popularity waned in the late 1950s.
Northerns are similar to westerns but are set in the frozen north of North America; that is, Canada or Alaska. Of the two, Canada was the most common setting, although many tropes could apply to both. Popular locations within Canada are the Yukon, the Barren Grounds, and area around Hudson Bay. Generic names used for this general setting included the "Far North", the "Northlands", the "North Woods", and the "Great Woods".
Common settings include boreal forests, isolated cabins, and mining towns. Snow featured to such an extent that Northern films were sometimes termed "snow pictures". Animals were a common feature too. Dogs and dog sleds were popularized by The Call of the Wild and White Fang. Scenes involving attacks by bears date back to The Klondyke Nugget.
Northerns often explore the 'Matter of Canada' (the national mythos of Canada, after the Matter of Rome). Common elements of which are the Black Donnelly murders (February 1880), the North-West Rebellion (1885), the Klondike Gold Rush (1896-99), the pursuit of Albert Johnson (January 1932), the October Crisis (October 1970), and persistent national anxiety about potential annexation by the United States.
The Western idea of lawlessness set in American towns was not a part of the Canadian Northern, though individual lawbreakers or uprisings by Canadians feature in works such as Quebec (1951), Riel (1979), and Northwest Mounted Police (1940). In Northerns and wider crime fiction, the general Canadian preference is for law enforcement to be performed by the state rather than vigilantes or private investigators. Likewise, Northerns rarely feature the heroic outlaws often found in Westerns. On the subject, David Skene-Melvin writes "Canada never had a Wild West because the Mounties got there first," while Margaret Atwood writes "No outlaws or lawless men for Canada; if one appears, the Mounties always get their man."
Law and order in Northerns set in Canada is most often represented by the Mounties, either the North-West Mounted Police or Royal Canadian Mounted Police depending on era. Like snow, Mounties are a common enough feature to become a synonym for the genre, with Northern films sometimes called "Mountie films". Their popularity was not confined to film; by 1930, 75 volumes of written Mountie fiction had been published, not including juvenile fiction and material published in magazines. Where a protagonist in a Western is often part of both civilization and the wild (whether native or criminal), Mounties in Northerns are entirely a part of civilization. The nature of fictional Mounties can vary depending on the nationality of the author. Mounties as written by British authors are often younger members of upper class British families serving the British Empire in the colonies. American-authored Mounties are often little different from US Marshalls and project the values of Westerns in that they place their individual sense of justice and conscience above their duty to the law. Canadian-authored Mounties represent, and are self-abnegating champions of, the Canadian establishment and its laws. Further, their authority does not come from either their social class or physical abilities; such a Mountie "upholds the law by moral rather than physical force". A common story outline for Northerns involving Mounties is a pursuit, confrontation and capture: the Mountie's pursuit of a fugitive takes place across the Canadian wilderness and may be resolved non-violently.
According to Pierre Berton "the French-Canadian was to the northerns what the Mexican was to the westerns — an exotic primitive, adaptable as a chameleon to play a hero or a heavy." French-Canadians were a ubiquitous element of the genre. As characters, French-Canadians are typically depicted as rustic and uneducated. These characters were usually divided into two broad types: the heroic, happy-go-lucky bon-vivant and the villainous, lecherous killer. Some later examples merged the two stereotypes into a charming, roguish anti-villain. Common visual elements were a tuque, a sash and a pipe. All were present in the first appearance in film, in A Woman's Way (1908). Female French-Canadian characters also followed the "tempestuous" stereotype of female Mexican characters. Mexican actress Lupe Vélez, in line with her identity as "The Mexican Spitfire", played the title character in Tiger Rose (1929) in this mode; as did Renée Adorée in The Eternal Struggle (1923) and Nikki Duval in Quebec (1951).
A common anachronism in Northerns was the tyranny and absolute power of the Hudson's Bay Company and its officers, even into the modern period. This was repeated not just in fiction but by reviewers and critics too. The concept of La Longue Traverse, or the Journey of Death, comes from The Call of the North (1914) and was popular in later films. In this, the Hudson's Bay Company executes convicts by forcing them into the wilderness without equipment or supplies. In 1921, the Hudson's Bay Company successfully sued the Famous Players-Lasky Corporation for the villainous portrayal of their Company in the latters' remake The Call of the North.
Besides being set in Canadian Prairies, the stories often contrast the American frontier with the Canadian frontier in several ways. In films such as Pony Soldier and Saskatchewan the North-West Mounted Police display reason, compassion and a sense of fair play in their dealings with Aboriginal people (First Nations) as opposed to hotheaded American visitors (often criminals), lawmen or the American Army who seem to prefer extermination with violence.
David Skene-Melvin classes the "second period" of Canadian crime literature (1880–1920), as "the heyday of the 'Northern' and the literary exploration of Canada's remote and romantic frontiers." He refers to Joseph Edmund Collins as an important figure in this period because, despite his work being of low quality, he was the first Canadian author to address some aspects of the 'Matter of Canada' in his novels, such as The Story of Louis Riel: The Rebel Chief (1885) and Annette, the Métis Spy (1886). Northerns continued to be written after 1920 but Canadian authors largely moved to other genres after World War 1 as they moved away from a frontier and colonial ethos.
The Klondike Gold Rush during the 1890s in Canada and Alaska brought a lot of wider, international attention to the far north of North America. Adventure novels from veterans of the gold rush—such as Jack London's The Call of the Wild (1903), Rex Beach's The Spoilers (1906) and Robert W. Service's The Trail of Ninety-Eight (1909)—became best sellers. These inspired more adventure fiction which grew in popularity throughout the first half of the twentieth century. The genre was extremely popular in the inter-war years, with a "Mountie craze" hitting its peak during the mid-1920s.
A large amount of Northern fiction is the work of non-Canadians. Nevertheless, Skene-Melvin writes "Just as the Western is widely regarded as emblematic of American culture, it can be argued that the Northern is the only truly indigenous Canadian art form, even if most of its exponents have been foreigners."
One of the earliest international examples of the genre is the British play The Klondyke Nugget, which was first performed in 1898. Its author, Samuel Franklin Cody initially wrote it as a Western but changed the location to capitalize on the contemporary gold rush.
Charlie Chaplin's 1925 film The Gold Rush is a comedy that parodies some of the cliches of the Northern genre. The Looney Tunes character Blacque Jacque Shellacque, who first appeared in the 1959 short Bonanza Bunny, is another parody.
While the Hollywood Western began to change in the post-World War 2 era and the Western myth was eventually debunked, Hollywood Northerns remained unchanged until they stopped being produced in the late 1950s and the underlying mythology was never examined.
Examples of Northerns
Folklore of Canada (Canadian oral stories)
- Chasse-galerie, the enchanted canoe that flies over the water of the river like a bird
- Johnny Chinook, the Canadian cowboy and rancher of Alberta
- Big Joe Mufferaw, woodsman Paul Bunyan of Canada.
- Louis Riel
- The Spell of the Yukon by Robert W. Service, including "The Shooting of Dan McGrew" and "The Cremation of Sam McGee"
- North-West Stories (May 1925–Summer 1937), became North-West Romances (Fall 1937–Spring 1953)
- Complete Northwest Magazine (September 1935–April 1940)
- Real Northwest Stories
- The Story of Louis Riel: The Rebel Chief (1885), by Joseph Edmund Collins
- Annette, the Métis Spy (1886), by Joseph Edmund Collins
- The Devil's Playground (1894), by John Mackie
- Klondike Kit Library (May 1898 – March 1899, series of 19 dime novels), by William Wallace Cook
- The Sky Pilot (1899), by Ralph Connor
- The Call of the Wild (1903), by Jack London
- The Hound from the North (1904), by Ridgwell Cullum
- White Fang (1906), by Jack London
- The Spoilers (1906) by Rex Beach
- The Trail of Ninety-Eight (1909) by Robert W. Service
- Corporal Cameron of the North West Mounted Police (1912), by Ralph Connor
- Yukon Trail (1917), by William MacLeod Raine
- Renfrew of the Royal Mounted (10 books, 17 short stories; from 1922) by Laurie York Erskine
- The Alaskan (1923), by James Oliver Curwood
- The Snow Patrol (1925) by Harry Sinclair Drago
- Gone North (1930), by Charles Alden Seltzer
- Susannah of the Mounties (1936), by Muriel Denison
- Barren Land Showdown (1940) by Luke Short
- Mrs. Mike (1947) by Benedict Freedman and Nancy Freedman
- Torture Trail (1965) by Max Brand, based on "Torturous Trek" (published in Western Story Magazine, August-September 1932)
- Corporal Cavannagh (1982) by Ian Anderson, first of the Scarlet Riders series of seven books
- Works of James B. Hendryx, George Marsh, Robert Ormond Case, William Byron Mowery, Philip H. Godsell, and Dan Cushman.
- Rugged Alaska Stories (1950), by Frank Richardson Pierce
- Best Mounted Police Stories (1978), edited by Dick Harrison
- The Northerners (1990), edited by Bill Pronzini and Martin H. Greenberg
- Stories of the Far North (1998), edited by Jon Tuska
- Scarlet Riders (1998), edited by Don Hutchison
- Renfrew of the Royal Mounted (presented by the author Laurie York Erskine)
- Challenge of the Yukon (1939-1955) featuring Sergeant Preston
- The Mystery Trooper (1931)
- Clancy of the Mounted (1933)
- The Mysterious Pilot (1938)
- King of the Royal Mounted (1940)
- Perils of the Royal Mounted (1942)
- King of the Mounties (1942)
- The Royal Mounted Rides Again (1945)
- Dangers of the Canadian Mounted (1948)
- Canadian Mounties vs Atomic Invaders (1953)
- Gunfighters of the Northwest (1954)
- Perils of the Wilderness (1956)
- Renfrew of the Royal Mounted (1953)
- Sergeant Preston of the Yukon (1955–1958)
- R.C.M.P. (1959–1960)
- Klondike (1960–1961)
- Dudley Do-Right (1961–1970, animated), a spoof of melodrama and silent films using the genre
- The Forest Rangers (1963–1965)
- Klondike Kat (1963–1968, animated)
- Adventures in Rainbow Country (1970–1971)
- Red Serge (1986–1987)
- Bordertown (1989–1991)
- Northern Exposure (1990–1995)
- North of 60 (1992–1997)
- Due South (1994–1999)
- When Calls the Heart (2014—)
- An Klondike (2015–17)
- A Woman's Way (1908)
- The Snowbird (1916)
- 'Blue Blazes' Rawden (1918)
- The Call of the North (1918)
- The Spoilers (1914)
- The Law of the Great Northwest (1918)
- The Law of the North (1918)
- The Mints of Hell (1919)
- The Call of the North (1921)
- Flower of the North (1921)
- Cameron of the Royal Mounted (1921)
- God's Country and the Law (1921)
- The Sky Pilot (1921)
- Belle of Alaska (1922)
- The Frozen North (1922)
- The Man from Glengarry (1922)
- Nanook of the North (1922)
- The Call of the Wild (1923)
- The Eternal Struggle (1923)
- The Spoilers (1923)
- Gold Madness (1923)
- The Grub-Stake (1923)
- Where the North Begins (1923)
- Lure of the Yukon (1924)
- Yukon Jake (1924)
- The Ancient Highway (1925)
- The Gold Rush (1925)
- The Flame of the Yukon (1926)
- The Lodge in the Wilderness (1926)
- The Michigan Kid (1928)
- Tiger Rose (1929)
- Men of the North (1930)
- O'Malley Rides Alone (1930)
- The Spoilers (1930)
- Mounted Fury (1931)
- Riders of the North (1931)
- The River's End (1931)
- Honor of the Mounted (1932)
- Mason of the Mounted (1932)
- McKenna of the Mounted (1932)
- Courage of the North (1934)
- The Fighting Trooper (1934)
- The Trail Beyond (1934)
- Undercover Men (1934)
- Border Brigands (1935)
- The Call of the Wild (1935)
- Code of the Mounted (1935)
- Fighting Shadows (1935)
- His Fighting Blood (1935)
- Northern Frontier (1935)
- The Red Blood of Courage (1935)
- Silent Code (1935)
- Timber Terrors (1935)
- Trails of the Wild (1935)
- Wilderness Mail (1935)
- Caryl of the Mountains (1936)
- The Country Beyond (1936)
- King of the Royal Mounted (1936)
- O'Malley of the Mounted (1936)
- Phantom Patrol (1936)
- Rose Marie (1936)
- Secret Patrol (1936)
- Skull and Crown (1936)
- God's Country and the Woman (1937)
- Renfrew of the Royal Mounted (1937)
- Death Goes North (1938)
- Heart of the North (1938)
- On the Great White Trail (1938)
- Blue Montana Skies (1939)
- Fighting Mad (1939)
- North of the Yukon (1939)
- Outpost of the Mounties (1939)
- Susannah of the Mounties (1939)
- Yukon Flight (1939)
- Danger Ahead (1940)
- Murder on the Yukon (1940)
- North West Mounted Police (1940)
- River's End (1940)
- Sky Bandits (1940)
- 49th Parallel (1941)
- The Royal Mounted Patrol (1941)
- North of the Rockies (1942)
- Northwest Rangers (1942)
- Pierre of the Plains (1942)
- The Spoilers (1942)
- Law of the Northwest (1943)
- Northern Pursuit (1943)
- Riders of the Northwest Mounted (1943)
- Northwest Trail (1945)
- Neath Canadian Skies (1946)
- North of the Border (1946)
- Road to Utopia (1946)
- Bush Pilot (1947)
- Where the North Begins (1947)
- Northwest Stampede (1948)
- Mrs. Mike (1949)
- Trail of the Mounties (1949)
- Trail of the Yukon (1949)
- Wolf Hunters (1949)
- Call of the Klondike (1950)
- The Cariboo Trail (1950)
- North of the Great Divide (1950)
- Snow Dog (1950)
- Northwest Territory (1951)
- Quebec (1951)
- Yukon Manhunt (1951)
- Blue Canadian Rockies (1952)
- Border Saddlemates (1952)
- Lost in Alaska (1952)
- Pony Soldier (1952)
- The Wild North (1952)
- Yukon Gold (1952)
- Fangs of the Arctic (1953)
- Fort Vengeance (1953)
- Northern Patrol (1953)
- The Far Country (1954)
- Rose Marie (1954)
- Saskatchewan (1954)
- Yukon Vengeance (1954)
- The Spoilers (1955)
- Bonanza Bunny (1959)
- North to Alaska (1960)
- The Canadians (1961)
- The Trap (1966)
- The Call of the Wild (1972)
- Challenge to Be Free (1972)
- Alien Thunder (1974)
- Red Coat (1975)
- The Call of the Wild (1976)
- Death Hunt (1981)
- Silence of the North (1981)
- The Grey Fox (1982)
- Jesuit Joe (1991)
- White Fang (1991)
- Shadow of the Wolf (1992)
- White Fang 2: Myth of the White Wolf (1994)
- Balto (1995)
- Alaska (1996)
- Dudley Do-Right (1999)
- Balto II: Wolf Quest (2002)
- Snow Dogs (2002)
- The Snow Walker (2003)
- Balto III: Wings of Change (2004)
- Gunless (2010)
- The Mountie (2011)
- Searchers (2016)
- Beverly, Edward Joseph (2008). "Preface". Chasing the Sun: A Reader's Guide to Novels Set in the American West. Sunstone Press. p. 11. ISBN 9780865346031.
Some book reviewers, however, contend that the one thing all Western settings have in common is aridity, and wouldn't consider novels set in Missouri or along the Pacific Coast or in the other non-arid regions to be Western fiction. Some include stories set in Canada and Alaska; others differentiate these as 'Northerns.'
- Pronzini, Bill (2017). "The Bull Moose and Other Scourges of the Frozen North". Six-Gun in Cheek. Courier Dover. ISBN 9780486820347.
Northerns—tales set in the rough-and-tumble frontier days of Alaska, the Yukon, the Canadian Barrens, the Hudsons's Bay region—were a popular adjunct to the Western story during the first half of this century.
- Solomon, Matthew (2015). The Gold Rush. Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN 9781137516114.
Chaplin's decision to have The Gold Rush take place during the 1897–8 Klondike Gold Rush placed it squarely within the well established Northern genre, which spanned theatre, literature and film, encompassing stories about trappers, adventurers, lumberjacks, miners, Mounties, Eskimos, and others-even animals-in the Far North.
- Hutchison, Don (1998). "Introduction: Scarlet Fiction". The Scarlet Riders. Mosaic Press. ISBN 9780889626478.
- Harrison, Dick (1978). "Introduction". Best Mounted Police Stories. University of Alberta. ISBN 9780888640543.
- Skene-Melvin, David (2014). "Canadian Crime Writing in English". In Sloniowski, Jeannette; Rose, Marilyn. Detecting Canada. Wilfrid Laurier University Press. ISBN 9781554589289.
- Atwood, Margaret (1972). Survival: A Thematic Guide to Canadian Literature.
- "Canada". International Encyclopedia of Men and Masculinities. Routledge. 2007. ISBN 9781134317066.
'Mounties' (RCMP officers) have been widely mythologized and lampooned in Anglophone popular culture, from the dozens of early Hollywood Mountie films or 'Northerns' (McGuire of the Mounted, Rose Marie) and popular television series Sergeant Preston of the Yukon and Due South, to the cinematic spoof Dudley Do-Right [...]
- Berton, Pierre (1997). "Hollywood's Canada". In Cameron, Elspeth. Canadian Culture. Canadian Scholars’ Press. ISBN 9781551300900.
- Berton, Pierre (1975). Hollywood's Canada: the Americanization of our National Image. McClelland and Stewart. ISBN 9780771012235.
- MacLulich, Thomas Donald (1988). Between Europe and America: The Canadian Tradition in Fiction. ECW Press. ISBN 9780920763957.
- Drew, Bernard Alger (1990). Lawmen in Scarlet: An Annotated Guide to Royal Canadian Mounted Police in Print and Performance. Scarecrow Press. ISBN 9780810823303.
- Dawson, Michael (1998). The Mountie from Dime Novel to Disney. Between The Lines. ISBN 9781896357164.
- Strange, Carolyn; Loo, Tina Merrill (2004). True Crime, True North: The Golden Age of Canadian Pulp Magazines. Raincoast Books. ISBN 9781551926896.
- MacKenzie, Scott; Westerståhl Stenport, Anna (2015). Films on Ice: Cinemas of the Arctic. Edinburgh University Press. ISBN 9780748694174.
- Baker, Richard G. (24 Jun 2015). "'Nothing But Hill and Hollow': The Canadian Border as American Frontier in the Hollywood Northern". Comparative American Studies. 13 (1–2).
- "Looking for Dudley Do-Right" at Pulp and Dagger Fiction
- Northern Romances Editorial at Pulp and Dagger Fiction
- "Romancing the Redcoat: A Canadian Hero Lost in Hollywood" at Canuxploitation
- The RCMP in Popular Culture
- The Mountie Films at B-Westerns
- NORTH WEST MOUNTED POLICE Canadian Mounties in Literature
- Hollywood's View of Canada (list of films)
- The Force in the North - Myths at Virtual Museum Canada