Open outcry is a method of communication between professionals on a stock exchange or futures exchange typically on a trading floor. It involves shouting and the use of hand signals to transfer information primarily about buy and sell orders. The part of the trading floor where this takes place is called a pit.
In an open outcry auction, bids and offers must be made out in the open market, giving all participants a chance to compete for the order with the best price. New bids or offers would be made if better than previous pricing for efficient price discovery. Exchanges also value positions marked to these public market prices on a daily basis. In contrast, over-the-counter markets are where bids and offers are negotiated privately between principals.
Since the development of the stock exchange in the 17th century in Amsterdam, open outcry was the main method used to communicate among traders. This started changing in the latter half of the 20th century, first through the use of telephone trading, and then starting in the 1980s with electronic trading systems.
As of 2007[update], a few exchanges still had floor trading using open outcry. The supporters of electronic trading claim that they are faster, cheaper, more efficient for users, and less prone to manipulation by market makers and broker/dealers. However, many traders still advocate for the open outcry system on the basis that the physical contact allows traders to speculate as to a buyer/seller's motives or intentions and adjust their positions accordingly. As of 2010, most stocks and futures contracts were no longer traded using open outcry due to the lower cost of the aforementioned technological advances. As of 2017, open outcry in the United States was very limited, such as in a much more stream-lined form at the Chicago Board of Trade owned by the CME Group.
Floor trading is the meeting of traders or stockbrokers at a specific venue referred to as a trading floor or pit to buy and sell financial instruments using open outcry method to communicate with each other. These venues are typically stock exchanges or futures exchanges and transactions are executed by members of such an exchange using specific language or hand signals. During the 1980s and 1990s, phone and electronic trading replaced physical floor trading in most exchanges around the world.,
As of 2007, few exchanges still have floor trading. One example is the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), which still executes a small percentage of its trades on the floor. That means that the traders actually form a group around the post on the floor of the market for the specialist, someone that works for one of the NYSE member firms and handles the stock. As in an auction, there are shouts from those that want to sell and those that want to buy. The specialist facilitates in the match and centralizing the trades. On 24 January 2007, the NYSE went from being strictly an auction market to a hybrid market that encompassed both the auction method and an electronic trading method that immediately makes the trade electronically. A small group of extremely high-priced stocks isn't on this trading system and is still auctioned on the trading floor. Even though over 82 percent of the trades take place electronically, the action on the floor of the stock exchange still has its place. While electronic trading is faster and provides for anonymity, there is more opportunity to improve the price of a share if it goes to the floor. Investors maintain the right to select the method they want to use.[as of?]
The London Metal Exchange is the last open outcry exchange in Europe. It utilises short periods of face-to-face "ring trading" for price discovery, with further trades taking place electronically.
Conversion to electronic trading
- The London Stock Exchange moved to electronic trading in 1986.
- The Borsa Italiana, Italy's stock market, located in Milan, moved to electronic trading in 1994.
- The Bombay Stock Exchange, Mumbai, embraced electronic trading in 1995 by introducing the BSE Online Trading (BOLT) System on 14 March 1995.
- The Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE) adopted electronic trading on 7 June 1996.
- The Colombo Stock Exchange (CSE) adopted electronic trading (The Automated Trading System (ATS)) in 1997.
- The Toronto Stock Exchange (TSX) adopted electronic trading in 1997.
- The Korea Exchange (KRX) adopted electronic trading in 1997.
- International Petroleum Exchange (IPE) moved to electronic trading in 2005.
- Minneapolis Grain Exchange (MGEX) moved to electronic trading in 2008.
- New York Stock Exchange, 2006-2007, under John Thain
- New York Mercantile Exchange (Nymex), 2006.
Since the 1980s, Nymex had a virtual monopoly on 'open market' oil futures trading, but the electronically based IntercontinentalExchange (ICE) began trading oil contracts that were extremely similar to Nymex's in the early 2000s and Nymex began to lose market share almost immediately. The pit-traders at Nymex had been resisting the electronic move for decades, but the executives believed the exchange had to move to the electronic format, or it would cease to exist as a viable business. The executives introduced CME's Globex system into Nymex in 2006. In 2016, NYMEX ceased all open outcry trading, leaving only open outcry at its sister exchange the Chicago Board of Trade.
Traders usually flash the signals quickly across a room to make a sale or a purchase. Signals that occur with palms facing out and hands away from the body are an indication the gesturer wishes to sell. When traders face their palms in and hold their hands up, they are gesturing to buy.
Numbers one through five are gestured on one hand, and six through ten are gestured in the same way only held sideways at a 90-degree angle (index finger out sideways is six, two fingers is seven, and so on). Numbers gestured from the forehead are blocks of ten, and blocks of hundreds and thousands can also be displayed. The signals can otherwise be used to indicate months, specific trade or option combinations, or additional market information.
These rules may vary among exchanges or even among floors within the same exchange; however, the purpose of the gestures remains the same.
- https://www.nyse.com/pdfs/Next_Generation_Model.pdf Archived 17 October 2012 at the Wayback Machine NYSE Next Generation Model fact sheet, 2008
- "The Art of Hand Signals" (PDF). floor trading hand signals ( 455 KiB)
- ""Open outcry" is in retreat but futures and options trading-volumes surge". The Economist. 5 January 2017. ISSN 0013-0613.
- "Trading". TSX.com. Retrieved 7 August 2018.
- "딱딱이 없으면 주식거래 못했던 시절…전자시세판 등장은 '충격'이었다" (in Korean). Retrieved 14 April 2020.
- Stevenson, Rachel (8 March 2005). "Petroleum exchange silences open outcry". Independent, The (London). Retrieved 13 December 2008.
- Kelsey, Eric (October 2008). "Grain Exchange to Stop Open Outcry". Archived from the original on 16 July 2011. Retrieved 17 December 2008.
- Technology squeezes out real, live traders, Adam Shell, USA Today, 2007 7 11
- The Asylum, Leah McGrath Goodman, 2011, Harper Collins