Optima Lake

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Optima Lake
USACE Optima Lake and Dam.jpg
Optima Lake and Dam
Location Texas County, Oklahoma
Coordinates 36°39′57.39″N 101°8′12.44″W / 36.6659417°N 101.1367889°W / 36.6659417; -101.1367889Coordinates: 36°39′57.39″N 101°8′12.44″W / 36.6659417°N 101.1367889°W / 36.6659417; -101.1367889
Type reservoir
Basin countries United States

Optima Lake was built to be a reservoir in Texas County, Oklahoma. The site is located just north of Hardesty and east of Guymon in the Oklahoma Panhandle.

The earthen Optima Lake Dam (National ID # OK20510) was completed in 1978 by the United States Army Corps of Engineers, with a height of 120 feet, and a length at its crest of 16,875 feet.[1] Although designed to contain a maximum of 618,500 acre-feet of water, the lake never reached more than 5 percent of its capacity,[2] and remains effectively empty. Rapid declines in streamflow related to large-scale pumping from the High Plains Aquifer, also known as the Ogallala Aquifer, coincided with the completion of dam construction[2] to make this lake a dramatic example of unanticipated environmental impacts.[3]

The US Army Corps of Engineers website states (emphasis in original):

"Visitors should be aware that the lake's level can be very low. Depending on rainfall and evaporation rates, the lake may offer no water-based recreation and may not be suitable for swimming, fishing, boating or other activities. Visitors should come for the quiet natural setting--with or without water in the lake area." [4]

The lake surroundings offer few to no amenities since lake camping facilities and buildings were dismantled for public safety by the Corps of Engineers in 2010.


History[edit]

The project was originally included as part of the Flood Control Act of 1936, as modified by the Flood Control Act of 1950,[5] but planning and political wrangling delayed the start of construction until 1966.[6] The intent was for the reservoir to fill primarily from the flow of the Beaver River,[7] also known as the North Canadian River.[8] Normal flow on the Beaver River, from 1937 to 1966, averaged 32.2 cubic feet per second.[9] The river had occasional floods, including an October 1923 flood amounting to 109,000 acre-feet of water, and a September 1941 flood in which the Beaver’s flow increased to 44,200 cubic feet per second.[10] The river’s most recent flow of significance was in October of 1965 at 17,800 cubic feet per second.[11] In the end the project was authorized for flood control, drinking and irrigation water in the relatively dry Oklahoma panhandle, recreation and fish & wildlife conservation.[12]

During the 12 years of construction by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, flow of the Beaver dropped.[13] It was later recognized that, because the source of the Beaver was the underground Ogallala Aquifer, being the water table beneath far western Oklahoma and parts of seven other Western states, and because of increased pressure on said aquifer due to expanded irrigation and drinking water withdrawals, the river’s flow was being reduced to a trickle.[14]

The $46.1 million project was completed in 1978.[15] The dam was constructed as compacted earthfill embankment with gated outlet works and a 1,500-foot long uncontrolled saddle spillway.[16] The top of the dam is at 2821.0 feet of elevation above sea level.[17] The specs put the top of the maximum pool at 2814.2 feet, the top of the flood control pool is at 2779.0 feet, the top of the conservation pool at 2763.5 feet, and the top of the inactive pool at 2726.0 feet.[18] The conservation pool was designed to hold 117,500 acre-feet of water, with 76,200 acre-feet designated to be available as a water supply.[19] The flood pool capacity was designed for 229,500 acre-feet, while absolute maximum capacity of the lake was set at 618,500 acre feet.[20] During the first full year of operation in 1979, the Corps remained optimistic and declared, “The optimum visitation for the project is 600,000 annual visitors and will be reached in 2014.” [21]

But water flow in the Beaver, 1977–1987, averaged only 7 ft3/s, far less than the 32.2 ft3/s historical average.[22] In the mid-80’s, the Corps began to recognize that the reduced flow of the Beaver was permanent and the reservoir was not going to fill: the maximum lake level was achieved May 31, 1980 at an elevation of 2722.90 feet, whereas the very bottom of the conservation pool was intended to be 2726.00 feet.[23] The Corps closed the park in 1995 although the site remained open to the public.[24] With funding from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, about 161 decaying structures including picnic structures, campsites, restrooms, dump stations and numerous power poles, were demolished by September of 2010 for safety reasons.[25] As of 2014, the project was receiving 2000 to 5000 visitors annually.[26]

A spending controversy erupted In 2009, when the Corps wanted to use $1.2 million of economic stimulus money to replace rotting guardrails on each side of the paved road across the top of the Optima Dam used by approximately 15 cars a day.[27] Public criticism caused the Corps to instead gate and padlock the road at a cost of $1000.[28] Per the Corps’ September 2010 Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report on Optima Lake, the Corps continues to spend approximately $160,000/year for annual inspections of dam structures, detailed inspections at 5-year intervals, and repairs as budgets allow.[29] That same report indicates the existing dam structures (gate tower, stilling basin, uncontrolled spillway and outlet works) remain in operational condition.[30]

The overall project included the Optima National Wildlife Refuge, run by the US Fish and Wildlife Service, being initially 2,605 acres along Coldwater Creek-- which has its confluence with the Beaver .2 miles upstream from the dam--[31] and the Optima Wildlife Management Area, public hunting lands managed by the Oklahoma Department of Wildlife Conservation, initially 2,141 acres along the Beaver.[32] However, the decreased size of the lake itself has led to Optima National Wildlife Refuge being increased to 4,334 acres, and the area managed by Oklahoma, including licensed Corps lands above and below the dam, increasing to 8,062 acres.[33]

Notes[edit]

  1. ^ http://ce-npdp-serv2.stanford.edu/DamDirectory/DamDetail.jsp?npdp_id=OK20510
  2. ^ a b Wahl, K & R. L. Tortorelli, 1996. "Changes in flow in the Beaver-North Canadian River Basin Upstream from Canton Lake, Western Oklahoma", USGS WRI 96-4304
  3. ^ Logan Layden, “If you Want to Build a New Lake in Oklahoma, Forget History,” March 28, 2013, StateImpact Oklahoma"StateImpact Okahoma website". Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  4. ^ U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Optima Lake website
  5. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  6. ^ M.J. Alexander, “Pictures from the Missing Lake,” Slice Magazine"Slice Magazine website accessdate=2015-06-01". 
  7. ^ Logan Layden, “If you Want to Build a New Lake in Oklahoma, Forget History,” March 28, 2013, StateImpact Oklahoma"StateImpact Okahoma website". Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  8. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  9. ^ Logan Layden, “If you Want to Build a New Lake in Oklahoma, Forget History,” March 28, 2013, StateImpact Oklahoma"StateImpact Okahoma website". Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  10. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  11. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  12. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  13. ^ Logan Layden, “If you Want to Build a New Lake in Oklahoma, Forget History,” March 28, 2013, StateImpact Oklahoma"StateImpact Okahoma website". Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  14. ^ Logan Layden, “If you Want to Build a New Lake in Oklahoma, Forget History,” March 28, 2013, StateImpact Oklahoma"StateImpact Okahoma website". Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  15. ^ M.J. Alexander, “Pictures from the Missing Lake,” Slice Magazine"Slice Magazine website". Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  16. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  17. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  18. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  19. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  20. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  21. ^ M.J. Alexander, “Pictures from the Missing Lake,” Slice Magazine"Slice Magazine website". Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  22. ^ Logan Layden, “If you Want to Build a New Lake in Oklahoma, Forget History,” March 28, 2013, StateImpact Oklahoma"StateImpact Okahoma website". Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  23. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  24. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  25. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  26. ^ M.J. Alexander, “Pictures from the Missing Lake,” Slice Magazine"Slice Magazine website". Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  27. ^ Amy Lester, “Stimulus Project Scrapped; Questions Remain Why it was Ever Approved,” News 9"News 9 Website website". Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  28. ^ Amy Lester, “Stimulus Project Scrapped; Questions Remain Why it was Ever Approved,” News 9"News 9 Website website". Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  29. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  30. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  31. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  32. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 
  33. ^ Section 216 Initial Appraisal Report, Optima Lake, September 2010, US Army Corp of Engineers"US Army Corp of Engineers, Tulsa District, website" (PDF). Retrieved 2015-06-01. 

References[edit]

  • R. Lowitt, 2002. "Optima Dam: A Failed Effort to Irrigate the Oklahoma Panhandle", Agricultural History, 76(2):260-72

External links[edit]