Otto Heinrich Warburg
|Died||1 August 1970 (aged 86)|
|Alma mater||University of Berlin|
University of Heidelberg
|Known for||Pathogenesis of cancer|
Warburg effect (oncology)
Warburg effect (plant physiology)
|Awards||Iron Cross 1st class (1918)|
Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine (1931)
Pour le Mérite (Civil Class) (1952)
Paul Ehrlich and Ludwig Darmstaedter Prize (1962)
Foreign Member of the Royal Society
|Institutions||Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Biology|
|Doctoral advisor||Emil Fischer|
Ludolf von Krehl
Otto Heinrich Warburg (German pronunciation: [ˈɔto ˈvaːɐ̯bʊʁk] (listen), //; 8 October 1883 – 1 August 1970), son of physicist Emil Warburg, was a German physiologist, medical doctor, and Nobel laureate. He served as an officer in the elite Uhlan (cavalry regiment) during the First World War, and was awarded the Iron Cross (1st Class) for bravery. He was the sole recipient of the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 1931. In total, he was nominated for the award 47 times over the course of his career.
Otto Heinrich Warburg was born in Freiburg im Breisgau in 1883, close to the Swiss border. Otto's mother was the daughter of a Protestant family of bankers and civil servants from Baden. His father, Emil Warburg, had converted to Protestantism as an adult, although Emil's parents were Orthodox Jews. Emil was a member of the illustrious Warburg family of Altona. Emil was also president of the Physikalische Reichsanstalt, Wirklicher Geheimer Oberregierungsrat (True Senior Privy Counselor).
Otto Warburg studied chemistry under Emil Fischer, and earned his doctorate in chemistry in Berlin in 1906. He then studied under Ludolf von Krehl and earned the degree of doctor of medicine in Heidelberg in 1911.
Between 1908 and 1914, Warburg was affiliated with the Naples Marine Biological Station, (in Naples, Italy), where he conducted research. In later years, he would return for visits, and maintained a lifelong friendship with the family of the station's director, Anton Dohrn.
A lifelong equestrian, he served as an officer in the elite Uhlans (cavalry) on the front during the First World War, where he won the Iron Cross. Warburg later credited this experience with affording him invaluable insights into "real life" outside the confines of academia. Toward the end of the war, when the outcome was unmistakable, Albert Einstein, who had been a friend of Warburg's father Emil, wrote to Warburg at the behest of friends, asking him to leave the army and return to academia, since it would be a tragedy for the world to lose his talents. Einstein and Warburg later became friends, and Einstein's work in physics had a great influence on Warburg's biochemical research.
Scientific work and Nobel Prize
While working at the Marine Biological Station, Warburg performed research on oxygen consumption in sea urchin eggs after fertilization and showed that upon fertilization the rate of respiration increases as much as sixfold. His experiments also showed that iron is essential for the development of the larval stage.
In 1918, Warburg was appointed professor at the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Biology in Berlin-Dahlem (part of the Kaiser-Wilhelm-Gesellschaft). By 1931 he was named director of the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Cell Physiology, which had been founded the previous year by a donation of the Rockefeller Foundation to the Kaiser Wilhelm Gesellschaft (since renamed the Max Planck Society).
Warburg investigated the metabolism of tumors and the respiration of cells, particularly cancer cells, and in 1931 was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology for his "discovery of the nature and mode of action of the respiratory enzyme". In particular, he discovered that animal tumors produce large quantities of lactic acid. The award came after receiving 46 nominations over a period of nine years beginning in 1923, 13 of which were submitted in 1931, the year he won the prize.
Nobel Laureate George Wald, having completed his Ph.D. in zoology at Columbia University, received an award from the U.S. National Research Council to study with Warburg. During his time with Warburg, 1932–1933, Wald discovered vitamin A in the retina.
Survival under the Nazis
When the Nazis came to power, people of Jewish descent were forced from their professional positions, although the Nazis made exceptions. Warburg had a Protestant mother and a father with Jewish heritage (who had converted to Protestantism). According to the Reichsbürgergesetz from 1935 (cf. Nuremberg Laws) Warburg, as a "half-Jew" was labeled a Halbjude or Mischling.
Warburg was also at risk due to his relationship with Jacob Heiss, with whom he lived and worked. Beginning around 1918, Heiss served variously as Warburg's personal aid, secretary, and administrative assistant. The couple lived together in an elegant villa in Dahlem, in Berlin.
Warburg was banned from teaching, but allowed to carry on his research. In 1941, Warburg briefly lost his post for making remarks critical of the Nazi regime, but in a few weeks was able to resume his research following a personal order from Hitler's Chancellery. Hermann Göring also arranged for him to be classified as one-quarter Jewish. In September 1942, Warburg made an official request for equal status ("Gleichstellung") with German Aryans, which was granted.
Warburg disagreed with the Nazi regime, and refused to acknowledge the Nazi salute, to the point of provoking retaliation from its officers. Authors have speculated on why he stayed in Germany under the Reich. Apple suggests that, like many others, he did not imagine how bad things could get. His own egotism may have led him to underestimate the potential threat posed by the Nazis. Others have suggested that Warburg was so totally devoted to his work that he was prepared not only to stay in Germany but to tolerate the treatment of his Jewish colleagues and relatives by the Nazis. An anecdote from Birgit Vennesland, who became a director at Warburg's institute in West Berlin in 1968, is suggestive. She said that Warburg's advice for an acquaintance who was experiencing emotional difficulties was "Tell him not to think about anything but science - think about absolutely nothing else - only science."
In 1943 Warburg relocated his laboratory to the village of Liebenburg on the outskirts of Berlin to avoid ongoing air raids. The Rockefeller Foundation reportedly offered to continue funding his work if he emigrated. After the war ended, Warburg inquiried about the prospect of moving to the United States, but was turned down.
Nomination for a second Nobel Prize
In 1944, Warburg was nominated for a second Nobel Prize in Physiology by Albert Szent-Györgyi, for his work on nicotinamide, the mechanism and enzymes involved in fermentation, and the discovery of flavin (in yellow enzymes). Some sources report that he was selected to receive the award that year, but was prevented from receiving it by Adolf Hitler's regime, which had issued a decree in 1937 that forbade Germans from accepting Nobel Prizes. According to the Nobel Foundation, this rumor is not true; although he was considered a worthy candidate, he was not selected for the prize at that time.
Three scientists who worked in Warburg's lab, including Sir Hans Adolf Krebs, went on to win the Nobel Prize in future years. Among other discoveries, Krebs is credited with the identification of the citric acid cycle (or Szentgyörgyi-Krebs cycle).
Warburg's combined work in plant physiology, cell metabolism, and oncology made him an integral figure in the later development of systems biology. He worked with Dean Burk on the quantum yield of photosynthesis.
Warburg hypothesized that cancer growth is caused by tumor cells generating energy (as, e.g., adenosine triphosphate/ATP) mainly by anaerobic breakdown of glucose (known as fermentation, or anaerobic respiration). This is in contrast to healthy cells, which generate energy mainly from oxidative breakdown of pyruvate. Pyruvate is an end product of glycolysis and is oxidized within the mitochondria. Hence, according to Warburg, cancer should be interpreted as a mitochondrial dysfunction.
Cancer, above all other diseases, has countless secondary causes. But, even for cancer, there is only one prime cause. Summarized in a few words, the prime cause of cancer is the replacement of the respiration of oxygen in normal body cells by a fermentation of sugar.— Otto H. Warburg, 
Warburg continued to develop the hypothesis experimentally and gave several prominent lectures outlining the theory and the data.
Today, mutations in oncogenes and tumor suppressor genes are thought to be responsible for malignant transformation, and the metabolic changes Warburg thought of as causative are now considered to be a result of these mutations.
A recent reevaluation of the data from nuclear/cytoplasm transfer experiments, where nuclei from cancer cells are placed in normal cytoplasm and where nuclei from normal cells are placed in cancer cytoplasm, support the role of metabolism in cancer and the mitochondria in aiding tumor suppression. Still, as evident from the references therein, this promising phenomenon still fails to explain the origin of cancer as Warburg originally proposed. While Warburg's hypothesis certainly inspired the scientific community to further investigate the field of cancer metabolism, his tendency to oversimplify perhaps prevented him from accepting the vastly complex role and interactions between both the mitochondria and nucleus, or more generally, metabolism and mutations.
This section needs additional citations for verification. (November 2015)
Otto Warburg edited and had much of his original work published in The Metabolism of Tumours (tr. 1931) and wrote New Methods of Cell Physiology (1962). An unabashed anglophile, Otto Warburg was thrilled when Oxford University awarded him an honorary doctorate. He was awarded the Order Pour le Mérite in 1952 and was known to tell other universities not to bother with honorary doctorates. He would ask officials to mail him medals he had been awarded so as to avoid a ceremony that would separate him from his beloved laboratory.
Seemingly utterly convinced of the accuracy of his conclusions, Warburg expressed dismay at the "continual discovery of cancer agents and cancer viruses" that he expected to "hinder necessary preventive measures and thereby become responsible for cancer cases".
When Josef Issels was tried and convicted for promoting the Issels treatment, an ineffective regimen claimed to treat cancer, Warburg offered to testify on Issels' behalf at his appeal to the German Supreme Court. All of Issels' convictions were overturned.
Warburg resided in the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute with his companion of 50 years, Jacob Heiss, the secretary and manager of the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute. Warburg pursued his research until the age of 86. He left his entire estate to Heiss.
The Otto Warburg Medal
The Otto Warburg Medal is intended to commemorate Warburg's outstanding achievements. It has been awarded by the German Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology (Gesellschaft für Biochemie und Molekularbiologie) since 1963. The prize honors and encourages pioneering achievements in fundamental biochemical and molecular biological research. The Otto Warburg Medal is regarded as the highest award in Germany for biochemists and molecular biologists. It has been endowed with prize money, sponsored by the publishing company Elsevier/BBA.
- Über die Rolle des Eisens in der Atmung des Seeigeleis nebst Bemerkungen über einige durch Eisen beschleunigte Oxydationen m. Abb. (Sitzungsber. Heidelberger Akad. Wiss. math.-nat. Kl B Heidelberg, 1911) (Trans: On the rôle of Iron in the Breathing of the Sea Urchin Egg and Comments about some Oxidations accelerated by Iron. Proceedings of the Heidelberg Academy of Sciences Heidelberg 1911.)
- Schwermetalle als Wirkungsgruppe von Fermenten (Berlin, 1946.) (Trans: Heavy metal prosthetic groups and enzyme action)
- Ideen zur Fermentchemie der Tumoren (Abh. der Deutschen Akad. der Wissenschaften zu Berlin. Math-naturwissenschaft. Kl 1947, Berlin 1947) (Trans: Theses on the enzymatic chemistry of Tumors, Proceedings of the German Academy of Sciences in Berlin, mathematical-scientific ?, Berlin 1947)
- Wasserstoffübertragende Fermente (Berlin, Saenger 1948) (Trans: Hydrogen-transferring Enzymes)
- Weiterentwicklung der zellphysiologischen Methoden: angewandt auf Krebs, Photosynthese und Wirkungsweise der Röntgenstrahlung: Arbeiten aus den Jahren 1945-1961, (Thieme, Stuttgart 1962) (Trans: Further Developments of Methods in Cellular Physiology applied to Cancer, Photosynthesis and the Effects of X-ray Radiation) Texts in German and English
- Nobel Lectures, Physiology or Medicine 1922-1941, Amsterdam: Elsevier Publishing Company, 1965
- Chernow, Ron (1993), The Warburgs: The Twentieth-Century Odyssey of a Remarkable Jewish Family, New York, NY: Random House, ISBN 978-0-679-41823-8
- Govindjee, Kärin Nickelsen (2011). The maximum quantum yield controversy. Otto Warburg and the 'Midwest-Gang' (Paperback). Institut Für Philosophie. ISBN 978-3-95234-219-0.
- Issels MD, Josef (1981), Mein Kampf gegen den Krebs: Erinnerungen eines Arztes, C. Bertelsmann, ISBN 978-3-570-04736-1
- Krebs, Hans Adolf (1981), Otto Warburg: Cell Physiologist, Biochemist, and Eccentric, Oxford University Press, ISBN 978-0-19-858171-0
- Liljestrand, Göran; Bernhard, Carl Gustaf (1972), "The Prize in Physiology or Medicine", in Nobel Foundation; Odelberg, W. (Coordinating Ed.) (eds.), Nobel: The Man and His Prizes (3rd ed.), New York, NY: American Elsevier Publishing Company, Inc, pp. 139–278, ISBN 978-0-444-00117-7
- Medawar, Jean; Pyke, David (2012). Hitler's Gift: The True Story of the Scientists Expelled by the Nazi Regime (Paperback). New York: Arcade Publishing. ISBN 978-1-61145-709-4.
- Werner, Petra (1991), Ein Genie Irrt Seltener, Berlin: Akademie Verlag, ISBN 978-3-05-501282-2
- Werner, Petra (1988), Otto Warburg : Von der Zellphysiologie zur Krebsforschung : Biografie, Verlag Neues Leben, ISBN 978-3-355-00789-4
- NobelPrize.org, The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 1931 accessed April 20, 2007
- Krebs, H. A. (1972). "Otto Heinrich Warburg 1883-1970". Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society. 18: 628–699. doi:10.1098/rsbm.1972.0023. PMID 11615754.
- "Nomination Database - Physiology or Medicine". Nobelprize.org. Retrieved 2011-06-04.
- Weisz, GM (2015). "Dr. Otto heinrich warburg-survivor of ethical storms". Rambam Maimonides Med J. 6 (1): e0008. doi:10.5041/RMMJ.10183. PMC 4327324. PMID 25717390.
- Warburg, Otto (June 1964). "Prefatory Chapter". Annual Review of Biochemistry. 33 (1): 1–15. doi:10.1146/annurev.bi.33.070164.000245. ISSN 0066-4154. PMID 14268832. Retrieved 17 January 2022.
- Parks, Scott K.; Mueller-Klieser, Wolfgang; Pouysségur, Jacques (2020). "Lactate and Acidity in the Cancer Microenvironment". Annual Review of Cancer Biology. 4: 141–158. doi:10.1146/annurev-cancerbio-030419-033556.
- Medawar & Pyke. Page 184.
- Reinhard Rürup, unter Mitwirkung von Michael Schüring: Schicksale und Karrieren: Gedenkbuch für die von den Nationalsozialisten aus der Kaiser Wilhelm Gesellschaft vertriebenen Forscherinnen und Forscher. Wallstein 2008, S. 83f. ISBN 978-3-89244-797-9
- Apple, Sam (2022). Ravenous : a Jewish scientist in Nazi Germany and the search for the cancer-diet connection. [S.l.]: Liveright Publishing Corp. ISBN 978-1-324-09201-8.
- Otto, Angela M. (8 March 2016). "Warburg effect(s)—a biographical sketch of Otto Warburg and his impacts on tumor metabolism". Cancer & Metabolism. 4 (1): 5. doi:10.1186/s40170-016-0145-9. ISSN 2049-3002. PMC 4784299. PMID 26962452. S2CID 23503461.
- Johnston, Christopher (4 June 2021). "The WWII-era scientist who revolutionized cancer research—despite the Nazis". The Hub. Johns Hopkins University. Retrieved 17 January 2022.
- Mnookin, Seth (6 June 2021). "How Did a Gay Scientist of Jewish Descent Thrive Under the Nazis?". The New York Times. Retrieved 17 January 2022.
- "Otto Warburg: the Jewish doctor and the Nazi war on cancer". HistoryExtra. October 8, 2021. Retrieved 17 January 2022.
- Medawar & Pyke. Page 185.
- Vennesland, Birgit (1 June 1981). "Recollections and Small Confessions". Annual Review of Plant Physiology. 32 (1): 1–21. doi:10.1146/annurev.pp.32.060181.000245. ISSN 0066-4294. Retrieved 17 January 2022.
- Liljestrand & Bernhard 1972, "The Prize in Physiology or Medicine", p. 210
- "Nomination Database - Physiology or Medicine". Nobelprize.org. 1944. Retrieved 2011-06-04.
- "Otto Warburg". Encyclopædia Britannica Online. 2007. Archived from the original on 2007-12-19. Retrieved 2007-11-12.
- Chernow 539-541.
- A Systems Approach to Biology, by Jeremy Gunawardena, Department of Systems Biology, Harvard Medical School, lecture 1, September 2011 retrieved 5 May 2012
- Brand, R. A. (2010). "Biographical Sketch: Otto Heinrich Warburg, PhD, MD". Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research. 468 (11): 2831–2832. doi:10.1007/s11999-010-1533-z. PMC 2947689. PMID 20737302.
- Warburg, O. (1956). "On the Origin of Cancer Cells". Science. 123 (3191): 309–314. Bibcode:1956Sci...123..309W. doi:10.1126/science.123.3191.309. PMID 13298683.
- Bertram, JS (December 2000). "The molecular biology of cancer". Molecular Aspects of Medicine. 21 (6): 167–223. doi:10.1016/s0098-2997(00)00007-8. PMID 11173079. S2CID 24155688.
- Seyfried, Thomas N.; Flores, Roberto E.; Poff, Angela M.; D’Agostino, Dominic P. (March 2014). "Cancer as a metabolic disease: implications for novel therapeutics". Carcinogenesis. 35 (3): 515–527. doi:10.1093/carcin/bgt480. ISSN 0143-3334. PMC 3941741. PMID 24343361.
- Seyfried, Thomas T.N. (July 2015). "Cancer as a mitochondrial metabolic disease". Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology. 3: 43. doi:10.3389/fcell.2015.00043. PMC 4493566. PMID 26217661 – via PMC.
- Krebs, H. A. (1972). "Otto Heinrich Warburg, 1883-1970". Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society. Royal Society (Great Britain). 18: 629–699. ISSN 0080-4606. PMID 11615754.
- Frezza, Christian (March 2014). "The role of mitochondria in the oncogenic signal transduction". The International Journal of Biochemistry & Cell Biology. 48: 11–17. doi:10.1016/j.biocel.2013.12.013. ISSN 1878-5875. PMID 24397955.
- Zhou, Zhengqiu; Ibekwe, Elochukwu; Chornenkyy, Yevgen (2018-01-17). "Metabolic Alterations in Cancer Cells and the Emerging Role of Oncometabolites as Drivers of Neoplastic Change". Antioxidants. 7 (1): 16. doi:10.3390/antiox7010016. ISSN 2076-3921. PMC 5789326. PMID 29342092.
- Andréasson, Claes; Ott, Martin; Büttner, Sabrina (4 October 2019). "Mitochondria orchestrate proteostatic and metabolic stress responses". EMBO Reports. 20 (10): e47865. doi:10.15252/embr.201947865. ISSN 1469-3178. PMC 6776902. PMID 31531937.
- Brown, Jamelle A.; Sammy, Melissa J.; Ballinger, Scott W. (September 2020). "An evolutionary, or "Mitocentric" perspective on cellular function and disease". Redox Biology. 36: 101568. doi:10.1016/j.redox.2020.101568. ISSN 2213-2317. PMC 7281786. PMID 32512469.
- Max Planck > Quotes > Quotable Quote. goodreads.com
- van Wijk, Roeland (2014). Light in Shaping Life: Biophotons in Biology and Medicine. p. 86. ISBN 978-90-818843-2-7.
- Weisz, G. M. (2015). "suffered a broken femur, complicated by deep vein thrombosis, and in 1970, Otto Heinrich Warburg died from a pulmonary embolism; from Google (otto warburg died) result 3". Rambam Maimonides Medical Journal. 6 (1): e0008. doi:10.5041/RMMJ.10183. PMC 4327324. PMID 25717390.
- "The Otto Warburg Medal". elsevier.com. Retrieved 2014-07-03.