Papilio Buddha (film)
|Directed by||Jayan K. Cherian|
|Produced by||Prakash Bare
|Written by||Jayan K. Cherian|
|Cinematography||M J Radhakrishnan|
|Edited by||Sujoy Joseph|
Papilio Buddha is a 2013 Indian feature film written and directed by Jayan K. Cherian. The film focuses on the atrocities committed against Dalits, women and the environment. It features Sreekumar, David Briggs and Saritha Sunil in the lead roles while Padmapriya, Prakash Bare and Thampy Antony play supporting roles. Kerala-based Environmentalist Kallen Pokkudan appears in another important role in the film which also cast 150 Adivasis. The film was completely shot from Wayanad in Kerala and the cinematography has been done by M J Radhakrishnan. The story deals with discrimination against landless Dalits and the politics of suppression of their struggle against the upper castes and other powerful elements locally.
The film unfolds in fictional space, in a Dalit settlement called Meppara. It explores the life of a group of displaced Dalits in the Western Ghats of India and probes the new identity politics based on Ambedkarism, gaining momentum among the Dalits in the region, in the milieu of an ongoing land struggle. A band of displaced untouchables in Western Ghats of India embrace Buddhism in order to escape from caste oppression. The on-screen happenings are from the perspective of a youth Sankaran, a Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) dropout, whose insecurity and reticence are in stark contrast to the deep-rooted faith and conviction of his father Kandal Kariyan.
Shankaran (Sreekumar), a young Dalit man, befriends a white gay American lepidopterist Jack (David Briggs), for whom he helps catch butterflies, including the rare and beautiful Papilio buddha, and it turns out the two men are romantically involved. While to the displeasure of Shankaran’s elderly father, homosexuality is of little consequence among this Dalit community.
Shankaran's father is a communist who feels let down by the failure to achieve equal rights. Meanwhile, Manju, a strong-minded woman who has a job as a rickshaw driver, struggles to avoid prejudice in a male-dominated career.
When Manjusree hits a lecherous union leader, and Shankaran is arrested for illegally catching butterflies, the events spark off two acts of violence which politicise and radicalise the community, some of whom are queer, who decide to shun the peaceful tactics proscribed by Mahatma Gandhi in favour of rebellion.
The film brings into focus, an example of the epic land struggles, which was fought in various regions of the state and across India, and the oppression of indigenous people by the powerful political and social establishments. It also maps environmental degradation and abuse of pristine mountain habitats by outside forces.
- S.P.Sreekumar as Shankaran
- David Briggs as Jack
- Saritha as Manjusree
- Kallen Pokkudan as Kandal Kariyan
- Thampi Antony as Ramdasji
- Padmapriya as Collector
- Prakash Bare as SP
The film marks the debut of Jayan K. Cherian as a feature filmmaker. A student of Iranian filmmaker Abbas Kiarostami, he had previously done several experimental films and short fictions including Shape of the Shapeless, Love in the Time of Foreclosure, Hidden Things, Soul of Solomon and Capturing the Signs of God.
Papilio Buddha is inspired by several events that happened in various Dalit communities in Kerala, including their struggle for land in places such as Chengara, Meppadi, and Muthanga, and its effect on the Dalit population. The director traveled all over Kerala and tried to integrate real life experiences of dalits, after talking to them. The film was shot from Muthanga in Wayanad district, Kerala. Principal photography for the film completed in 19 days.
The film was denied censor certification by the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC). The CBFC stated that the screening rights were denied as the film had visuals and dialogues denigrating iconic leaders including Mahatma Gandhi (In a scene from the film, a group of irate Dalits burn an effigy of Mahatma Gandhi as they oppose attempts by a mainstream political party to take up their cause by going on a fast.), E. M. S. Namboodiripad and Ayyankali apart from visuals of extreme violence and extreme torture of women by police. Jayan K. Cherian says that the ban on the public screening of the film is essentially fascistic in nature. Cherian says, "The Board has listed a number of reasons for denying the certification based on its archaic set of guidelines designed to give overwhelming dominance for the state. Most of the objections are about denigrating Gandhi, Ayyankali, Buddha et al. The perceived denigration seems to be coming from the realistic treatment of the climax scene - dalits' agitation and their confrontation with the police who use force to evict them."
The Censor Board had also taken exception to the language used in the film. Usage of extremely filthy language and expletives by numerous characters throughout the film, calling caste names such as 'Pulaya', 'Pulakalli' etc. in a derogatory manner, dialogues denigrating communal sections of the society etc. is what the Board noted. "The typical and realistic Malayalam used by the filmmaker for the characters in this film may be different from the usual commercial film language but calling it filthy is very subjective. The atrocities the dalit activists Sankaran and Manju go through in this film are reflections of social injustices happening in our society without exaggeration," explained Jayan.
In January 2013, the board decided to give certification to the film after the makers agreed to mute a controversial speech by Ambedkar in the movie. In the speech, Ambedkar implies that Gandhi was cheating Dalits by denying them an electoral constituency of their own during the Yervada jail fast in 1932. Prakash Bare says, "The Censor Board had cited nearly 30 instances. Finally, we agreed to mute the offending speech and also blurring in certain scenes. We agreed as it won't change the structure of the film."
The film was denied a screening at the 17th International Film Festival of Kerala (IFFK) which created much controversies. The film was not included in the nine Malayalam films selected for screening in the festival in two different categories. Jayan K. Cherian kicked off the controversy by stating that he was shocked by the decision of the jury headed by director Sibi Malayil. "Private screening, especially at the film festivals, needed no censor certificates. The jury had almost taken a decision in the film's favour, but it was averted at the last moment for political reasons," he said.
A preview of the film was held in Thiruvananthapuram in September 2012. The screening brought a number of Dalit Human Rights Movement (DHRM) activists to the theatre hall. "The film has not shown even one-hundredth of the torture borne by us. And now they won’t even allow our film to be screened," says Thathu, a dalit who saw the film. About the denigrating remarks about Mahatma Gandhi, the director said, "Gandhi has a saintly image created through our educational system and the media. When we brought out a counter-narrative to the official one, there is no space for us. Then how can it be a democracy?"
Initially banned in India and subsequently certified for theatrical distribution, Papilio Buddha had a world premiere on 19 March 2013 at the 27th London Lesbian & Gay Film Festival organised by the British Film Institute. It was the only Indian film to be selected for the festival. The film was an inaugural film in three festivals — International Film Festival Thrissur, Chittur Panchajanayam International Film Festival and Jamia Milia Malayalam Film Festival. The film has been screened at Montreal World Film Festival, Trinidad and Tobago Film Festival and Athens International Film and Video Film Festival in 2013. The film was the only Indian film selected to be screened in the Panorama Section at the 64th Berlin International Film Festival.
Malayalam writer Deedi Damodaran included Papilio Buddha among the five films that she feels were fair in portraying the gender issue in a feature published by The Hindu. She said, "Our society is not yet ready to face the statements this film makes. The film deals with gender and Dalit issues in a raw manner, and I feel these are causes that are inseparable. Papilio Buddha chooses not to beat about the bush. It is bold and clear and relevant. No wonder the state was worried by the revelations made so loudly and unapologetically."
Although the makers of the film vehemently opposes any negative remarks about Gandhi, a writeup on the film by Alex Davidson for the British Film Institute notes:
- To western eyes, this community may be unfamiliar, and the scorn shown towards Gandhi's teachings (principally his advocacy of hunger strikes) may shock those whose image of the leader is influenced by Ben Kingsley’s Oscar-winning performance in Richard Attenborough’s 1982 biopic.
The film won Jayan K. Cherian a Special Jury Award for direction at the 2012 Kerala State Film Awards while Saritha received a Special Jury Mention for her performance in the film. It won the second prize for Best Narrative Feature Film at the Athens International Film and Video Festival. At the 2013 Oaxaca FilmFest of Mexico, Papilio Buddha won two major awards. M. J.Radhakrishnan was conferred with the Best Cinematographer award and Manu Perunna won the Best Art Director award.
- "Director Jayan Cherian's Interview". Manorama. Retrieved 2011-10-26.
- "The Butterfly effect"
- "Ban on Papilio Buddha is fascism"
- "Makers of 'Papilio Buddha' move censor tribunal"
- "Papilio Buddha director terms CBFC a draconian institution "
- "Papilio Buddha gets censor certification"
- "This time, Papilio Buddha out of IFFK"
- "Screening the reality"
- "Festival gem: Papilio Buddha". British Film Institute. Retrieved 29 May 2013.
- "Unfettered feature". The Hindu. 25 February 2013. Retrieved 29 May 2013.
- "Filmes brasileños y lo último de Gondry estarán en Berlín" (in Spanish). El Universal. 20 December 2013. Retrieved 20 December 2013.
- "Identity Crisis". Indian Express. 18 March 2013. Retrieved 29 May 2013.
- "Four new Malayalam releases today (Mar 15)". Sify.com. 15 March 2013. Retrieved 29 May 2013.
- Rasmi Binoy ( 7 March 2013)."In a positive light". The Hindu. 25 February 2013. Retrieved 29 May 2013.
- "Athens International Film Fest Winners Announced". Athens International Film and Video Festival. Retrieved 29 May 2013.
- Radhika C Pillai (4 October 2013). "Pappilio Buddha bags two awards". The Times of India. Retrieved 2 November 2013.
- Papilio Buddha at the Internet Movie Database
- K. Satchidanandan (30 November 2012). "To break a butterfly on a wheel". Tehelka.
- "Indian Censor Board Restricts Papilio Buddha, A Gandhi Critic Movie". Global Voices. 12 March 2013.
- S. Anandan (9 September 2012). "Papilio Buddha director terms CBFC a draconian institution". The Hindu.
- Divya Trivedi (1 October 2012). "The Butterfly effect". The Hindu.
- Anuj Kumar (4 October 2012). "The counter narrative". The Hindu.
- S. R. Praveen (3 September 2012). "Censorship regime archaic, says film-maker". The Hindu.
- "Film censorship has no place in a democracy: Director Cherian". Micro Finance Monitor (New York). 1 September 2012.
- "Censor board’s rejection of film on Kerala Dalits triggers debate". Micro Finance Monitor (New York). 1 September 2012.