Patch Adams (film)
Theatrical release poster
|Directed by||Tom Shadyac|
|Produced by||Mike Farrell
Marsha Garces Williams
|Screenplay by||Steve Oedekerk|
|Based on||Gesundheit: Good Health Is a Laughing Matter
by Patch Adams and Maureen Mylander
Philip Seymour Hoffman
|Music by||Marc Shaiman|
|Cinematography||Phedon Papamichael Jr.|
|Edited by||Don Zimmerman|
Bungalow 78 Productions
|Distributed by||Universal Pictures|
|Box office||$202.3 million|
Patch Adams is a 1998 semi-biographical comedy-drama film starring Robin Williams, Monica Potter, Philip Seymour Hoffman and Bob Gunton. Directed by Tom Shadyac, it is based on the life story of Dr. Hunter "Patch" Adams and his book, Gesundheit: Good Health is a Laughing Matter, by Adams and Maureen Mylander. Despite being poorly received by critics and Dr. Adams himself, the film was a box-office success, grossing over twice its budget in the United States alone.
A suicidal Hunter "Patch" Adams (Robin Williams) commits himself into a mental institution. Once there, he finds that using humor, as opposed to the indifferent sessions provided by their doctor, to help his fellow patients gives him a purpose in life. Because of this he wants to become a medical doctor and two years later enrolls at the Medical College of Virginia (now known as VCU School of Medicine) as the oldest first year student. He questions the school's soulless approach to medical care and clashes with the school's Dean Walcott (Bob Gunton), who believes that doctors must treat patients as patients and not bond with them as people. Because of this and incidents such as setting up a giant pair of legs during an obstetric conference, he is expelled from the medical school, although he is later reinstated due to his methods actually helping patients improve. Adams encourages medical students to work closely with nurses, learn interviewing skills early, and argues that death should be treated with dignity and sometimes even humor.
Adams begins a friendship with fellow student Carin Fisher (Monica Potter), and develops his idea for a medical clinic built around his philosophy of treating patients using humor and compassion. With the help of Arthur Mendelson (Harold Gould), a wealthy man who was a patient whom Patch met while in the mental hospital, he purchases 105 acres (425,000 m²) in West Virginia to construct the future Gesundheit! Institute. Together with Carin, medical student Truman Schiff (Daniel London), and some old friends, he renovates an old cottage into a clinic. When they get the clinic running, they treat patients without medical insurance and perform comedy sketches for them.
Carin and Patch's friendship soon turns into romance. When she tells him that she had been molested as a child, Patch comforts her and reassures her that she can overcome her pain by helping others. Encouraged, Carin wants to help a disturbed patient, Lawrence "Larry" Silver (Douglas Roberts). However, Larry murders Carin then kills himself. Patch is devastated and guilt-ridden by Carin's death, and begins to question the goodness in humanity. Standing on a cliff, he contemplates suicide once again and questions God about what happened. He then sees a butterfly which reminds him of Carin's telling him earlier how she always wished she was a caterpillar that could someday transform itself and fly away. The butterfly lands on his medical bag and on his shirt before flying away. This reminds Patch of Carin and revives his spirits, and he decides to continue his work in her honor.
He is expelled from medical school a second time for running a clinic and practicing medicine without a license and because of complaints that he has made his patients uncomfortable (which is obviously not true). He files a grievance with the state medical board at the advice of his former medical school roommate, uptight Mitch Roman (Philip Seymour Hoffman). Patch is able to convince the board that he did his best to help the people that came to him, and as a doctor it is his responsibility to treat the spirit as well as the body. The board accepts Patch's methods and decides to allow him to graduate. He receives a standing ovation from the packed hearing room.
At graduation, Patch receives his diploma and bows to the professors and the audience, revealing that he is not wearing any pants under his gown.
- Robin Williams as Dr. Hunter "Patch" Adams, initially a mental patient, who wishes to change the way doctors think and treat their patients.
- Daniel London as Truman Schiff, Patch's best friend and most loyal follower, in medical school.
- Philip Seymour Hoffman as Mitch Roman, Patch's uptight roommate, who initially clashes with Patch, but later joins his cause.
- Monica Potter as Carin Fisher, a serious medical student, who is later touched by Patch's passion.
- Bob Gunton as Dean Walcott, rigid dean of the Medical School, who locks horns with Patch right from the start.
- Frances Lee McCain as Judy, a nurse at the hospital
- Irma P. Hall as Joletta, a nurse at the hospital
- Josef Sommer as Dr. Eaton, professor at Medical School, who does appreciate Patch's efforts.
- Harold Gould as Arthur Mendelson, wealthy mathematician who is in the mental hospital, and initially coins Patch's nickname.
- Harve Presnell as Dean Anderson, head of the Medical School; more tolerant of Patch than is Walcott.
- Michael Jeter as Rudy
- Barry Shabaka Henley as Emmet
- Harry Groener as Dr. Prack, humorless doctor at the mental hospital. Colleague of Dean Walcott.
- Richard Kiley as Dr. Titan, chair of the State Medical Board
- Ryan Hurst as Neil
- Peter Coyote as Bill Davis, dying, ill-tempered patient in the hospital, who eventually bonds with Patch, and accepts his fate with dignity.
- Alan Tudyk as Everton
- Dot Marie Jones as Miss Meat
- Douglas Roberts as Lawrence "Larry" Silver
- Norman Alden as Truck Driver
- James Greene as Bile
- Greg Sestero as Jaime
- Ralph Peduto as Organizer
The film was shot in three locations: Treasure Island, California (near San Francisco), Asheville (North Carolina), and the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. A diner in Point Richmond (a district in Richmond, California) served as the University Diner. Several interior classroom scenes were filmed on the campus of UC Berkeley.
The film has several major departures from Adams' real history. One is that the character of Carin is fictional, but is analogous to a real life friend of Adams (a man) who was murdered under similar circumstances. Another difference is the then 47-year-old Robin Williams portrays Adams as enrolling in medical school very late in his life, his older age even being brought up in dialogue. In reality, Adams started medical school immediately and his educational progress was quite normal for a physician: He graduated high school at 18, college at 22, and medical school at 26.
Box office performance
The film was released on December 25, 1998 in the United States and Canada and grossed $25.2 million in 2,712 theaters its opening weekend, ranking #1 at the box office. After its first weekend, it was the #2 film for four weeks. The film grossed US$202,292,902 worldwide — $135,026,902 in the United States and Canada and $67,266,000 in other territories.
The film received negative reviews by critics. Review aggregator Metacritic reported that the film averaged a rating of 25%, and currently has a score of 22% on Rotten Tomatoes based on 64 reviews with the consensus reading, "Syrupy performances and directing make this dramedy all too obvious." Noted Chicago Sun-Times film critic Roger Ebert gave the film one and a half stars out of four and wrote, "'Patch Adams' made me want to spray the screen with Lysol. This movie is shameless. It's not merely a tearjerker. It extracts tears individually by liposuction, without anesthesia." Robert K. Elder of the Chicago Tribune called Monica Potter "the best thing about the otherwise dopey Patch Adams."
It received "Two Thumbs Down" on the television series Siskel & Ebert, with particular criticism towards the character of Patch, whom they viewed as "overbearing", "obnoxious" and "sanctimonious" as well as noting that they would never trust a doctor who acted like Adams does. Gene Siskel said 'I would rather turn my head and cough than see another moment of Patch Adams again'. He later singled it out as the worst film of 1998; it was the last film he gave a "Worst of" to before his death in 1999.
Marc Shaiman's score was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Original Score. The film was also nominated two Golden Globe Awards, for Best Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy and Best Actor – Motion Picture Musical or Comedy (Robin Williams).
Reaction of the real Patch Adams
The real Patch Adams has been openly critical of the film, saying that it sacrificed much of his message in order to make a selling film. He also said that out of all aspects of his life and activism, the film portrayed him merely as a funny doctor. At a Conference of World Affairs, he told film critic Roger Ebert, "I hate that movie."
During a speech in 2010 at the Mayo Clinic, Patch Adams said, "The film promised to build our hospital. None of the profits from the film ever came to us, and so, basically 40 years into this work, we are still trying to build our hospital."
Adams' thoughts on Williams
Furthermore, Adams stated,
"[Robin Williams] made $21 million for four months of pretending to be me, in a very simplistic version, and did not give $10 to my free hospital. Patch Adams, the person, would have, if I had Robin's money, given all $21 million to a free hospital in a country where 80 million cannot get care."
After Williams' death in 2014, Adams said,
"The terrible news of the passing of Robin Williams reached me here in the Peruvian Amazon late Monday night with tremendous sadness. Surrounded by over 100 friends and clowns on our annual clown trip, we mourn this tragic loss and continue to treasure his comic genius. Robin Williams was a wonderful, kind and generous man. One important thing I remember about his personality is that he was unassuming—he never acted as if he was powerful or famous. Instead, he was always tender and welcoming, willing to help others with a smile or a joke. Robin was a brilliant comedian—there is no doubt. He was a compassionate, caring human being. While watching him work on the set of the film based on my life—Patch Adams–I saw that whenever there was a stressful moment, Robin would tap into his improvisation style to lighten the mood of cast and crew. Also, I would like to point out, Robin would be especially kind toward my children when they would visit the set. Contrary to how many people may view him, he actually seemed to me to be an introvert. When he invited me and my family into his home, he valued peace and quiet, a chance to breathe—a chance to get away from the fame that his talent has brought him. While early in life, he turned to drug use and alcohol to escape, he replaced the addiction with moments of solitude to help cope with the stress that fame brought. This world is not kind to people who become famous, and the fame he had garnered was a nightmare. While saddened, we are left with the consequences of his death. I’m enormously grateful for his wonderful performance of my early life, which has allowed the Gesundheit Institute to continue and expand our work. We extend our blessings to his family and friends in this moment of sadness. Thank you for all you’ve given this world Robin, thank you my friend."
- Patch Adams Movie Reviews, Pictures - Rotten Tomatoes
- "IMDB trivia".
- "Patch Adams (1998) - Weekend Box Office Results". Box Office Mojo. Retrieved 2008-02-08.
- "Patch Adams (1998)". Box Office Mojo. Retrieved 2008-02-09.
- Patch Adams - MetaCritic. Retrieved 2009-06-06.
- "Patch Adams". Rotten Tomatoes. Retrieved 2012-07-07.
- "Patch Adams". Chicago Sun-Times.
- Elder, Robert K. (February 2, 2001). "Monica Potter Almost Redeems `Head Over Heels'". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved January 13, 2014.
- chalomirof63 (2011-02-17). "SISKEL & EBERT: "PATCH ADAMS" (1998)". YouTube. Retrieved 2012-07-07.
- "Real Patch Adams - Movie True Story". Chasingthefrog.com. Retrieved 2012-07-07.
- Video on YouTube
- Interview with Patch Adams on Repubblica.it
- "Celebrity Involvement at St. Jude". Stjude.org. Retrieved 2012-07-07.
|Wikiquote has quotations related to: Patch Adams (film)|