Perjury trap

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

A perjury trap is a form of prosecutorial misconduct in which a prosecutor calls a witness to testify, typically before a grand jury, with the intent of coercing the witness into perjury (intentional deceit under oath).[1] Most often a perjury trap is employed because the prosecutor is unable to prosecute the defendant on other charges.

As an example, suppose that a person committed a crime for which they were never prosecuted, but the statute of limitations on that crime has expired. A prosecutor could set a perjury trap for them by calling them as a witness before a grand jury in a case about a different crime, and ask them about the expired crime. If the witness lies about the expired crime, that would be perjury—a new crime, which could then be prosecuted.[2] Prosecution for perjury elicited in this manner violates due process of law, since the investigatory powers of the grand jury are exploited to reach beyond their legal limits.[1] It has been argued by legal scholars whether it constitutes a form of entrapment.[2]

Claims of a perjury trap are common when perjury charges result from testimony before a grand jury, but are rarely proven.[3] No US federal court has ever accepted a motion to dismiss because of claimed perjury trap.[2] The defense is extremely difficult, because the question that elicited the perjured testimony must be immaterial to the case in which it was asked, and courts construe very broadly what questions count as material to a case.[2]

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b Gershman, Bennett L. (1981). "The "Perjury Trap"". University of Pennsylvania Law Review. 129 (624).
  2. ^ a b c d McLain, Billy Joe (March 2010). "Debunking the Perjury-Trap Myth". Texas Law Review. 88 (4) – via Questia. (subscription required)
  3. ^ "1756. Perjury Cases -- Special Problems And Defenses -- Perjury Trap". Department of Justice. Retrieved January 26, 2018.