Permanent University Fund
|Sovereign wealth fund|
|Genre||Public Lands, Mineral Rights, Land Use Rights|
|Headquarters||Austin, Texas, United States of America|
Paul L. Foster, chairman
|Total assets||US$17.5 billion (2015) (does not include public land holdings)|
|Owner||State of Texas|
The Permanent University Fund (PUF) is a sovereign wealth fund created by the State of Texas to fund public higher education within the state. A portion of the returns from the PUF are annually directed towards the Available University Fund (AUF), which distributes the funds according to provisions set forth by the 1876 Texas Constitution, subsequent constitutional amendments, and the board of regents of the University of Texas System and the Texas A&M University System. The PUF provides extra funds, above monies from tax revenues, to the UT System and the Texas A&M System which collectively have approximately 50 percent of state public university students. The PUF does not provide any funding to other public Universities in the State of Texas.
The Permanent University Fund was established by the 1876 Constitution of the State of Texas. Initially, its assets included one-tenth of University of Texas at Austin lands bordering the railroads (UT Austin was granted 1 million acres (4,000 km2) in West Texas as compensation) as well as 1 million acres (4,000 km2) additional. In addition, the 1876 Constitution organized the University of Texas System, under which governance of Texas A&M University and UT Austin was placed. The original Constitution provided for preference in PUF investment in Texas and U.S. bonds. In 1883, Texas and Pacific Railroad returned 1 million acres (4,000 km2), deemed too worthless to survey, to the State Government, which turned the land over to the PUF. Initially, the little revenue PUF earned from its lands were from grazing leases.
The terms of the annexation of the Republic of Texas in 1845 meant that Texas kept its public lands. The 1894 discovery of oil in Corsicana, Texas and the 1901 discovery of oil at Spindletop in Beaumont, Texas, began a subsequent oil boom in Texas and the western U.S. In 1901, the Texas Legislature authorized UT Austin to "sell, lease and otherwise control" oil and mineral rights for PUF land. In late 1916, after a report was submitted to the Land Commission of the UT Board of Regents, the Board forbade the sale of any University lands, including those of the PUF. On 28 May 1923, the Santa Rita No. 1 oil well, in Reagan County discovered the first oil on PUF land; in the following decades, the PUF's revenue made UT Austin among the best-endowed in the nation. In 1924, the UT Regent Robert Story requested that the legislature direct oil rights revenue directly into the Available University Fund; the 29th legislature complied on 3 April 1925 by passing House Bill 246. The March 10, 1926, Texas Supreme Court case State ex rel Attorney General, v. Hatcher, decided against State Treasurer W. Gregory Hatcher, who refused to comply with Attorney General Dan Moody's demands that oil rights revenue be placed into the PUF rather than the AUF. The Texas Supreme Court concluded that the 1876 Constitution directed subterranean revenue to be "corpus of the estate" rather than UT Austin disposable income.
In 1928, State Attorney General Claude Pollard issued a legal opinion that the UT Board of Regents could issue bonds against the AUF, the account that holds the annual distributions of the PUF. In 1931, the legislature authorized UT Regent-requested bonds to improve UT Austin's buildings and campus in general. As the provision was repealed in 1932, it granted the only time ever that PUF principal was spent. The AUF's distributions were directed, in 1931, by the legislature such that 2/3 of the money would go to UT Austin and 1/3 to Texas A&M, and also extended to be available for purchase of equipment and building construction. In 1947, after World War II and during the education boom from the Servicemen's Readjustment Act of 1944, a constitutional amendment was passed that authorized the issuance of $15 million in AUF bonds, $10 million to the UT System and $5 million to the Texas A&M System.
1956 saw another amendment to the state constitution, this time setting the maximum bond issuance equal to the PUF's total asset value excluding land, as well as allowing Southwestern Medical School, Health Science Center at Houston, and M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, all of the UT System, access to AUF funds. In addition, the 1956 amendment guaranteed the 2/3 UT, 1/3 A&M AUF split that the Legislature had directed in 1931. In 1968, the PUF constitution was amended again to include a broader range of both corporate bonds and investments available to PUF, as well as applying a "prudent person" standard for some amendments.
The State Attorney General in 1978 issued an opinion that interest accruing in the PUF should be used to pay outstanding bonds and finance permanent educational improvements, per the PUF constitution. In 1984, the bond issuance capacity of the PUF was raised to 30% and the issuance of AUF funds was expanded to all existing University of Texas System and Texas A&M University System schools; another voter-approved amendment the same year authorized the creation of the Higher Education Assistance Fund, to help all public higher education institutions not covered by the PUF. As oil rights revenue was dropping from $262 million in 1981 to $57 million in 1995, the 1991 Texas Legislature reduced funding for the UT and Texas A&M University Systems by about one-quarter. This placed increased pressure for the PUF to make up much of the difference, even after the 1984 expansion of the PUF's list of beneficiaries. On 1 March 1996, the UT System Board of Regents authorized the nonprofit University of Texas Investment Management Company (UTIMCO) to manage UT System assets, including all of the PUF.
A 1988 constitutional amendment eliminated all investment restrictions related to the PUF for the UT Board of Directors in favor of adopting the "prudent person" standard for all investments, which was subsequently amended in 1999 to the "prudent investor" standard for investments. Another 1999 statewide vote adopted an amendment that made further changes to the PUF. The first was that distributions to the AUF would equal both realized (income return) and unrealized (capital gains) PUF assets. The second directed payments to PUF expenses come from PUF assets; the third directed the establishment of an investment and return policy that would preserve both a stable AUF distribution and the real value of the investments.
In 2001, PUF annual distribution to the AUF was changed from 4.50% to 4.75%. On 7 February 2008, after months of study, the UT Board of Regents authorized an increase in AUF annual transfers, from 4.75% of the PUF value to 5.00%, citing recent PUF growth of more than 10% per year and unrest over the large annual increases in tuition at UT Austin. The Texas A&M System chancellor lauded the increased distribution, which now matched other Texas A&M endowment distributions.
In 1900, the Permanent University Fund earned approximately $40,000, mostly from grazing leases; by 1925, income had increased to $2,000 per day (about $700,000 per year), and by 1943 was just under $1 million per year. In the late 1950s, the PUF earned about $8,513,000 per year and was valued above $283,642,000; in 1990, the PUF was valued at $3,541,314,800 and earned $266,119,000 in income. Currently, PUF land assets deliver proceeds through oil, gas, sulfur, and water royalties, rentals on mineral leases, and gains on fiduciary investments. Grazing leases and other surface rights income are distributed to the AUF.
As of December 2008 figures, the PUF holds approximately $8.8 billion in investments and 2,100,000 acres (8,500 km2) of land located in 21 counties, mostly in West Texas. Each year, five percent of the PUF's value is transferred to the AUF, which then distributes the money. The PUF exclusively serves institutions in the University of Texas System, which receives two-thirds of its proceeds, and the Texas A&M System, which receives the remaining one-third. As of 2008, the University of Texas System received the fifth-largest endowment in the nation, and the Texas A&M System received the tenth-largest. At one time, the PUF was the chief source of income for The University of Texas at Austin, but today its revenues account for less than twenty percent of the university's annual budgets. Of the 2007-08 year's $1 billion core academic budget of UT Austin, the AUF's funding accounted for $143 million.
The PUF's land assets are managed by the University of Texas System Administration. The PUF's fiduciary assets are managed by the University of Texas/Texas A&M Investment Management Company (UTIMCO), a nonprofit group formed to manage various assets of the UT and Texas A&M Systems and governed by a volunteer Board of Directors. The Board is composed of three members of the UT System Board of Regents, four members selected by the UT System Board of Regents, and two members selected by the Texas A&M University System Board of Regents. Of these, at least three of the members appointed by the UT System Regents and one appointed by the Texas A&M System Regents must be investment professionals. Additionally, the UT System chancellor is normally one of that system's seven representatives on the UTIMCO board. In addition, UTIMCO has a Chief Executive Officer and Chief Investment Officer appointed by the Board and a President appointed by the CEO and Board; all employees of UTIMCO except the nine-member Board of Directors receive a salary and are eligible for annual bonuses.
Robert Rowling, UTIMCO Chairman
In February 2009, UTIMCO drew criticism from the state's legislative and executive branches for awarding bonuses to employees despite the global financial crisis of 2008–2009. Robert Rowling, chairman of UTIMCO and vice chairman of the UT Austin Board of Regents, insisted that the bonuses he authorized were for the fiscal year ending 31 July 2008, in which the PUF net fiduciary assets decreased by 3.26%, or $383 million, as compared to nearly 14% for the Dow Jones Industrial Average. The Chairman of the Board of Regents defended Rowling, stating that the contracts obligated bonus payment and the large amounts, $1.05 million for the UTIMCO CEO and $2.3 million for other employees combined, were fairly inflexible.
Governor Rick Perry and Lieutenant Governor David Dewhurst criticized "[W]e can’t imagine how such compensation is justified considering that in the same month this meeting was held, reports surfaced that UTIMCO’s earnings for the year had dropped an estimated 23 percent." Perry's spokeswoman attacked the contracts, stating, "The compensation structure ought to incorporate the health of the fund, whereby incentives are not immediately paid out if the fund is in the red." State Senator Kevin Eltife criticized CEO Bruce Zimmerman's bonus. "Most people out there on the street are scared to death and we just paid you a million-dollar bonus [...] If there's that much money floating around, maybe there's too much." After heated interrogation by the State Senate Finance Committee, Rowling resigned from both his chairmanship of UTIMCO and vice chairmanship of UT Austin's Board of Regents.
The following are all available beneficiaries, as of 2018, of the Available University Fund, which distributes the annual dividends and returns of the Permanent University Fund. The Texas Constitution (Article 7, Section 18) stipulates that most current institutions under the University of Texas System and Texas A&M System are eligible to receive PUF profits through the AUF, and that a two-third vote of each house in the State Legislature is necessary to create a new institution as part of either system, which would then be automatically eligible for funds.
Other Texas public universities—notably all institutions in the University of Houston System, the University of North Texas System, the Texas State System, the Texas Tech System, and some UT System and Texas A&M System institutions—are prohibited by law from sharing the income from this endowment, but in 1984 a second fund was created to one day serve those schools: the Higher Education Fund (also known as the Higher Education Assistance Fund), a much smaller fund. Addition of the other university systems or individual institutions to the Permanent University Fund would require an amendment to the Texas Constitution or a two-thirds vote in the legislature.
The most recently added institution to the list of allowed institutions is the University of Texas Rio Grande Valley, which was founded in 2013 with the merger of the University of Texas–Pan American and University of Texas at Brownsville and began full operation in 2015. The predecessor schools were not eligible for PUF allocations, but the law that created UTRGV made the new institution PUF-eligible, and was passed by the required two-thirds vote of both legislative chambers.
- Sovereign wealth fund
- List of U.S. colleges and universities by endowment
- The Government Pension Fund of Norway
- Alaska Permanent Fund
- Earmark (finance)
- Permanent School Fund
- "2015 Annual Report" (PDF). University of Texas Investment Management Company. Retrieved September 15, 2016.
- "Amendments to the Texas Constitution Since 1876" (pdf). Texas Legislative Council (Research division). April 2008. Retrieved 2009-02-08.
- "Texas Annexation Questions and Answers". Texas State Library & Archives Commission. 2006-06-19. Retrieved 2009-02-08.
- "PUF Timeline - Home". The University of Texas Investment Management Company. 2008. Retrieved 2009-02-08.
- Block, Lourenda (2000). "Permanent University Fund: Investing in the Future of Texas". TxTell (University of Texas at Austin). Archived from the original on 2009-02-04. Retrieved 2009-02-14.
- Brown, Dee (1994). The American West. Simon & Schuster. p. 158. ISBN 978-0-684-80441-5. Retrieved 2009-02-08.
- Texas Supreme Court (1926-03-10). "State v. Hatcher, 281 S.W. 192 (Tex., 1926)". Fastcase. Retrieved 2009-02-14.[permanent dead link]
- "Permanent University Fund (PUF) / Higher Education Assistance Fund (HEAF) Overview" (PDF). Texas Senate. March 2008. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2009-02-24. Retrieved 2009-02-08.
- Hacker, Holly (2008-02-08). "UT System increases endowment spending to help ease tuition burden". Dallas Morning News. Retrieved 2009-02-14.
- "Permanent University Fund". Handbook of Texas Online. 2008-01-18. Retrieved 2009-02-11.
- TxTell. "Permanent University Fund: Investing in the Future of Texas". University of Texas at Austin. Archived from the original on 2009-02-04. Retrieved 2011-03-19.
- Deloitte & Touche (2010-10-09). "Financial Statements and Independent Auditors' Report, Permanent University Fund" (PDF). UTIMCO. Retrieved 2011-03-19.
- Beck, Catie and Jessica Sondgeroth. (2009-02-05). "UTIMCO board awards $1 million bonus for CEO". News 8 Austin. Retrieved 2009-02-08.
- "Texas Constitution, Article 7. Education". Texas Constitution and Statutes. Retrieved 2009-02-08.
- "2008 NACUBO Endowment Study" (PDF). National Association of College and University Business Officers. 2009-01-27. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2010-12-29. Retrieved 2009-02-09.
- "Tuition Policy Advisory Committee - Tuition-Related Questions and Answers" (PDF). University of Texas at Austin. 2007. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2009-02-05. Retrieved 2009-02-11.
- Haurwitz, Ralph K. M. (2009-02-07). "Chairman of UT regents defends bonuses for investment staff". Austin American-Statesman. Retrieved 2009-02-11.[dead link]
- "2017 Annual Report" (PDF). University of Texas/Texas A&M Investment Management Company. Retrieved May 4, 2018.
- "Zimmerman Appoints Cathy Iberg President of UTIMCO". University of Texas Investment Management Company. 2008-10-02. Retrieved 2009-02-09.
- "Employment Opportunities". University of Texas Investment Management Corporation. 2008. Retrieved 2009-02-09.
- Associated Press (2009-02-05). "UTIMCO bonuses draw criticism". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on February 14, 2009. Retrieved 2009-02-11.
- Lavergne, Mark (Lone Star Review) (2009-02-11). "Regent resigns in UTIMCO controversy". East Texas Review. Retrieved 2009-02-11.[dead link]